Some of our food was good, some not so good. Service is spotty. Won't go back. Stay away from the onion rings. Gross!

Love the authentic ambiance, great atmosphere and waterside location. Our dishes could have been great but suffered an excessive amount of butter. I felt the need to tilt the plate to drain it off. My grouper was fresh and perfectly done. If not floating in butter, I would have enjoyed it much more. read more

Always get the best service and amazing food! We make the drive from Longboat Key at least twice every time we vacation in Florida! read more

Casey Key Fish House - Pompano with garlic herb sauce. Very delicious. - Seafood Near Me - Osprey, Florida

This was once one of our favorite places to eat. Not anymore. Both the food and the service was terrible. Our waitress was snippy and barely civil. She dropped our food off without even making eye contact. She didn't ask us if we had everything we needed. She didn't come back to check on us, our drinks were empty and never refilled. We ordered conch fritters which were burned beyond even being edible. Our fish was good but the fries were undercooked. We are pretty laid back people and we really next to never complain but are doing so now out of utter disappointment. Maybe this just isn't the place to be during snowbird season. We won't be back. read more

Excellent place for fresh fish. Great views and laid back vibe. Much easier to get in than Pops and some others in the area.

Pulled up in our boat and the dockmaster immediately helped us out. Ordered crab cakes, too much filler, wouldn't suggest them. But honestly I'm used to Maryland Crabcakes. My husband had fish and chips. Our server Linda was excellent and efficient. Bottle of beer only $3.50. Great place, I would come again read more

Love this place! Have been going here for many years and have received amazing food and great service.

Overhyped and overrated. Average food, although their daily specials are a notch above their regular menu foods. Fab service though the help is not especially friendly. 3 stars is a generous rating. read more

We've been patrons of Casey Key Fish House for nearly 20 years. The quality and service are consistent. Obviously it's very crowded in season but still not impossible to get into. My favorite dish is their Almond Encrusted Snapper. You can arrive by boat or car, which is fun. read more

Really like it here. The fish is always fresh and the location is great, especially if you can get seated outside. Definitely prefer dinner to lunch... much healthier options. A must visit for a real FL experience. read more

Delectable food and gorgeous views! I had the almond snapper which cost $21.00 and was worth every penny. It came with vegetables, rice and garlic bread. Unless you're starving, this dish could satisfy 2 people. If I'm ever in the area, I will make another trip out here. read more

Casey Key Fish House - Almond snapper pan seared - Seafood Near Me - Osprey, Florida

See all

My son gave me $150 gift certificate for my birthday. We invited four friends to join us for dinner. The noise was painful. People talking at such volume we had to leave. And the food - mediocre at best. The experience was embarrassing. Good bye Casey Key! read more

Shannon or Sharon can't remember her exact name. Young girl tall with brown hair totally was out of it. She was our waitress, totally screwed our order up, food was touristy fish food. Waitress was probably the worst part of our experience though. She kept forgetting about us, I don't how with a rather large group of us. Also screwed the bill up go figure. This place is not what it used to be. I will definitely take my friends and family else where for a good local florida meal. read more

Terrible customer service!!!!! If I could give zero stars I would! I had planned to join my family at this restaurant at 4:00 pm Wednesday afternoon. Unfortunately I was not ALLOWED to get a table because my entire party wasn't present (they were running 15 minutes late). I was told to sit outside until they arrived. Curiously, there were only a few tables occupied in the restaurant, most were empty. I sat down outside to wait where there was no one waiting to be seated. Within a couple minutes the "hostess" put up a sign that read "please seat yourself" so I got up and tried to enter the restaurant to seat myself, but was immediately stopped by the "hostess" and told I could not go in! When I questioned her about the logic, she angerly told me it was their policy! I now realize if I had waited until she walked away from her "please seat yourself" sign, I could have selected my seat while my party was parking their car! Because of her disrespectfull demeanor and lack of customer service attitude, we left and will not go back! Ridiculous! There are too many other good places to eat where they appreciate their customers! If I had been treated with respect, I would have handled this differently, but the hostess was apparently having a bad day! read more

Peel and eat shrimp was a great way to start our meal. I had the Asian ahi tuna dish with noodles and it was perfect, although portion size is large. Lobster mac & cheese special was our favorite, with its light seafood sauce and plenty of lobster. It's definitely an island dive with moderately-priced menu choices. read more

What a great view. All outside heat isn't an issue though. Well shaded and beautiful breeze coming in off the water. Got a fried grouper sandwich and it is out of this world good. Not the fake indonisian strain of grouper (aka Hadock) this was a genuine red grouper sandwich and it was awesome! Ed was my server, and he did an awesome job. Wish I lived closer. Thank you Casey Key Fish House, you made my day!!! Also very affordable. read more

Grease. Tourists. Traffic. Parking. If you must have a meal on the Intercoastal Waterway, and if you must go where the great unwashed go, head on over. We've given it a couple tries, and it's always the same... greasy oily fried fish sometimes served on bread with very predictable and typical sides and condiments. Everyone who wants to try to be someone (in what category, we cannot figure out) shows up here, and some people come back annually each time they come to Florida. But it certainly is not for the food. There's not enough parking, so some people need to drop their companions off at the front door and then maneuver their car all around in order to go park across the road in a gravel parking lot on the other side of the street. Not only that it's located on the other side of a one-lane bridge. The wait to get over the bridge for a meal can be so long at mealtimes that you really need to bring a snack to tide yourself over. In order to go home the wait to get over the bridge is sometimes so long that you need to re park your car, and go back inside to use the restroom again. Not kidding. Only go here if you've got a full day just to drive there and back. read more

Cool atmosphere, but if you don't like fish or are a vegetarian, not so much to choose from on the menu.

Neutral. Tiki Bar on the water seems to be a popular local hang out for an older crowd. Bartenders were quick with service. Restaurant staff was efficient but hospitality and menu selections were average at best. Not bad, but not planning on returning. read more

Was excited to sit waterfront but arrived and waited a hour to get three easy drinks and never received our simple dip and crackers appetizer. Suggestion for the staff, pay attention to customers and not your phones. read more

Very good - we've been back for the past 5 years and continue to return. They always seem overwhelmed but the food is great and a very fair price. The Tuna is always great, the almond snapper is a safe bet. Tonight we tried the clams and garlic sauce. I will probably not get a garlic sauce dish from here again - but only because it was a strong garlic. The clam chowder is second place to captain Curts. Tonight was a date night, so no kiddos but it's one of the least expensive kid menus in town. :) read more

We enjoyed our meal at Casey Key Fish House. It's on the water (bay, I think not ocean) and has a very casual, fun vibe. It is a popular place and very crowded. We got there at 5:30 and were seated around 6 o'clock.They have a good selection of everything. I got a yellow tail special that was pan seared with a sauce. I don't typically like sauce on my fish but it was still pretty good. I would definitely recommend this restaurant. read more

Great shrimp scampi but I cannot believe my party waited an hour to be eating ice during our meal. Unorganized customer service.

My husband and I have been to Casey Key Fish House several times since moving to Florida last summer. Don't let the casual dining deter you, their food is excellent. The Fish Tacos are one of our favorites. Their key lime pie is to die for...so creamy and delicious. This place gets packed especially during season, so come early or be prepared for a wait. If you do have to wait, enjoy the many birds that hang out on the docks. It is in a gorgeous location. read more

One of the best kept secrets of the area! My wife and I had snapper and wahoo, both specials. The quality and preparation was excellent. Tiki bar is great for drinks before or after dinner. We also found out there is a water taxi operating off the restaurant docks that will pickup on siesta key and other local areas. We will definitely try it on our next trip. read more

We found the Fish House on Yelp after getting off I-75 for gas. Hands down some of the freshest fish I've ever eaten (and that says a lot being from Long Island). The service was as great as the view. All around a great place to have lunch. read more

Casey Key Fish House - Seafood Near Me - Osprey, Florida

Another one of our favorites! Great atmosphere and great food! The Fish Tacos were very tasty! Nice flavor combinations! The sides were just so-so. The rest of my group got fish sandwiches. They were excellent! read more

Casey Key Fish House - The Fish Tacos were very good! They were a special for lunch the day we went. Very nice combination! The rice was just so-so. - Seafood Near Me - Osprey, Florida

Amazing location, feel and food.. Never order off the menu.. Specials only.! Standard menu is fried this, fried that, blackened grouper...etc... But the daily specials are amazing every time.. Grilled calamari salad has had us coming back for over 10 yrs. read more

Casey Key Fish House - Seafood Near Me - Osprey, Florida

Excellent food and service; fun atmosphere. A taste of authentic Florida. We made a lunch of clams, peel and eat, crab cakes followed by key lime pie. Sitting right by the water on a sunny day. Heaven! read more

Casey Key Fish House - Garlic peel and eat shrimp - Seafood Near Me - Osprey, Florida

See all

Great service and their food is delicious. Our favs so far are tuna and pan seared grouper. Not crazy about their drinks but that's not as important to me. Visit the tiki bar, better drinks and yes they are real. read more

Excellent. (Period. Point blank) Aside from the parking situation this place is everything you could ask for in Florida hot spot off of the beaten path. read more

To sum it up - Terrible atmosphere, limited drink selections, nice waitress, food was quite good. I had the lobster Mac & Cheese and it was quite delicious! However, for the prices you wouldn't expect such a divey restaurant. They also didn't have any top shelf alcohol options like Grey Goose. I'd highly recommend doing take out at this place, but if you're looking for a more upscale place for the price you pay, I'd look elsewhere. read more

Alex ROCKS! Best service! Best bartender! She made our night so special and her smile definitely adds to the atmosphere. You can tell she is an asset to this laid back place and I can only hope she is here on our next visit read more

Shannon was a great waitress! She was superb, competent , happy, relaxing, attentive, playful and fun!!!! She even fixed the fan so it cooled us down. I had the wahoo fish at Shannon's recommendation and it was excellent, Casey's is a come as you are restaurant with great good. read more

The food was very good and I definitely recommend the fish and chips that is what I ordered and it's was the best fish and chips.

I like the ambiance of this place but the food was mediocre. I had almond crusted red snapper with potatoes and green beans. The sauce was a very rich butter sauce. The food was just okay. I was hoping for more. read more

My family ate at Casey Key Fish House in June. I have a service dog for medical reasons which we notified the staff about upon arrival. They said ha due o that fact we had to eat outside, which might I add is against federal law for them to do that. Even worse, they said I was not allowed to walk through the restaurant and had me walk around on the boat dock to reach my table, once again, this is against federal law. When our food arrived it was cold a did not taste very good. When we got up to leave I was once again told my service animal could not enter the restaurant and had to go on the boat dock once again. My family and I shall not return here and I do not recommend anyone else goes here either. read more

So there are 2 venues at this establishment. The restaurant which is on the water and then the tiki bar on the opposite side of the property that is also on the water and has its own sand beach. The food is served only at the restaurant and is average. The tiki bar is the bomb, great service, great entertainment, dance floor in the sand. You can sit on chairs on the beach with toes in the sand watching boats up and down the inter coastal. The tiki bar is a fun time, with a broad age group. A great way to spend a afternoon, good times!!!! read more

Love this place and atmosphere! The food was great and so was our server Manny. I especially like the fact you are greeted with a smile by everyone and feel very welcome. It's nice to have a place where you can actually relax from all the craziness going on. This place is a breath of fresh air! read more

Best seafood ever! The staff is excellent! Absolutely no complaints. It is right on the water so the views are gorgeous if you go around sunset. read more