Came here to say to celebrate my wife's birthday. We got an…read moreoutdoor table so we could enjoy the view. My wife ordered a Caesar salad and the Tropical Mahi Mahi. She enjoyed everything! I ordered my usual coconut shrimp with Brussels sprouts and whipped sweet potatoes. Yummy! We topped this off with a piece of carrot cake. This cake is on another level. WOW! Service is as always -excellent. The best thing is they take reservations and you can enjoy the view of the intercostal waterway.

Been in Florida for 25 years. This is one of my best. If not the best restaurant I've ever been in…read moreBartender is a great serve is a great and most of all the manager is fantastic. It seems like he greets every guest. It is always moving around and make sure things are the way they're supposed to be running nice and smooth. Al Goslowski

Nice location on the water. The service was great, very attentive. The food was mediocre which…read morewas a surprise. I wouldn't go back. .

What a find! We spent the day at the beach and finished with the scenic drive on Casey Key Road…read more(the mansions we passed, oh my). Happy to pull in the packed parking lot of the Fish House and find a spot along with a view of the Bay. We started with the mahi fish dip - only ok. But it turns out at 2:50 on a Friday afternoon I could still order the daily lunch special - grouper with hearts of palm, rice and pea pods. Wow! Absolutely amazing. Seriously the favorite meal on my mini vacation. Service was friendly, and prices were reasonable for quality and ambiance. Don't forget the key lime pie. Hubby and I each got our own and I'm glad that was the case. I could have eaten two slices:) We will be back to Casey Key Fish House.

Tuna nachos absolutely the best! Seafood pasta with the…read moregarlic butter sauce ‍ The water views and sunsets are so pretty here! We've been coming back here for YEARS!

Food was excellent,Service was perfect and the Ambiance was perfect. My neighbors told me about…read moreDockside two weeks ago, so my wife and I decided to Make a road trip and see for ourselves, and it is everything he told . It's the perfect DOCKSIDE Dining and I believe that all the people I met must feel the same way. Was a very nice visit

The owner is very friendly and eager to pair you with a lobster of almost any size. We come here a…read morefew times a year so my wife can get a large lobster. They prepare the whole thing onsite. They cook it to perfection. There is no dining inside but that's ok. There's a bar next door that allows you to eat the meal inside so you have access to drinks and such. We will be coming here many more times.

Their fish is fresh, they have a great variety, and it is healthy for you…read more The owner, Susanne, is extremely helpful and caring.

Always good food and consistent. Quick seating with the waitlist option…read more Our waiter was very attentive.

Love everything about Pop's...especially their famous Pop's Punch! Go often. Always take family,…read morefriends and guests there.

The most insane meal ever. If you are in siesta key, run to here…read more Food amazing. Service amazing. The seafood was the freshest I've ever had.

Super food and service at this great little joint! We had a grouper Reuben- tops! Scallops-nicely…read moreseasoned and grilled. Very attentive wait staff. Small indoor space but comfortable. We sat outside facing their parking lot but we didn't mind. We'll return! Highly recommend.

A huge shout-out and heartfelt thank you to Evie's on the Bay - The Point Restaurant for hosting…read moreour mom's Celebration of Life on February 28th. A very special thank you to Julie Asher, the Event Coordinator, who truly went above and beyond to make the day absolutely perfect. Your kindness, attention to detail, and support meant so much to our family. Between the breathtaking view, the beautiful weather, and the delicious food, we truly could not have asked for a more perfect day to honor and remember our mom. Thank you for helping us create such a meaningful and memorable celebration.

Had a very nice lunch at the point. First time there and got a seat overlooking the water. Service…read moreoutstanding and food was excellent. Will be back!

Lovely Mom&Pop Non-Chain Seafood restaurant. Best Crab Cake I've ever had! "All Crab No Cake" It's…read morea tiny building, but a fantastic restaurant. A tier above the rest Vanessa did a superb job, brought our dog iced water without us even asking. Will be back for more and will tell friends!

This assuming location has incredibly fresh seafood prepared well. I had a stone crab and corn…read morechowder special that was sweet and full of crab, and had fish with their tropical salsa. The sides are well-cooked, but nothing fancy. The key lime pie lives up to the hype. Drink menu is beer and wine only, and service was pleasant and our server knew the menu, too. A great place for people who love Florida seafood.

Anniversary night out...food was great, ambiance was nice, service was GREAT but for one…read moredetail...we reserved inside and were seated outside in a COLD New Year's Eve!!! Heater wasn't working too great and not only us humans but the food got cold very soon after being served! Asked to be seated inside but no available tables although we had reserved weeks in advance...asked for the heater to be pointed at us and the young man said he would but never returned and of course I wouldn't ask the young lady serving us! Bottom line, NICE 49th anniversary but COLD dining experience.

I don't really like to write reviews unless I'm wowed. We had lobster at another place that had a a…read morecasual bar next door. We then decided to go somewhere by the water for a better quality drink before we headed home. This came up on google so we gave it a shot. The view and ambience were amazing but OMG! The food and drinks were honestly the worst I've ever had in MY LIFE. This is a lot coming from foodies who love to travel as well. Good thing we live in the FL because this would have made us never want to come back. The chicken Nachos were bizarre (blocks on chicken) on dry nachos and scattered slices of cheese. The drink (can't recall the name but maybe Tentacolota) was like something from a dumpster. It's just tasted like sour milk with no liquor. I am shocked that the local bar we left made better drinks at $6 a pop than this place. I would only return if I want to sit by the water but not if I'm craving a drink.

What a terrific addition to Sarasota. Owned by Km and Captain/ Chef Rich , they carry the freshest…read moreseafood in the area. I bought Tile fish and Mangrove Snapper, what a treat. Kim will lead you in the right direction if you are undecided what fish to choose and how to fix it. She is always willing to help. The interior is your typical fish marketplace with seafood to go. They carry numerous types of Crab including Blue Crab. Now I don't have to travel to downtown Sarasota Farmers Market to get fresh fish more than one day a week.

Spent my entire adult life eating Maryland steamed crabs (I'm from PA). The crabs at this place…read morewhere every bit as good as any Maryland crab that I have eaten. The owners are very nice couple and very friendly. I will be a repeat customer.