Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    1.7 (3 reviews)
    Open 4:00 am - 12:00 AM (Next day)

    Casey's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Mr. B.
    0
    146
    37

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jon C.
    2
    10
    0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 1,757 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Mother Tucker's Pizza - Amazing how far and wide customers have come from

    Mother Tucker's Pizza

    4.8(21 reviews)
    54.4 mi

    I always drive by and see the signs from the interstate when I'm heading to the lake from Kansas…read moreCity. We were finally driving by at a time that made sense to stop and eat, so we had our first meal here and it won't be the last. Friendly service. Good pizza. Good atmosphere. I was not expecting to order from the counter right when we walked in, but luckily we had already scoped out the menu. We ordered two pizzas and cheese curds. Hopefully the cheese curds are a permanent addition to the menu. They're delicious. And they have the good ranch dressing for dipping. We ordered the all meat pizza on cauliflower crust for the gluten-free diner, and we ordered bbq chicken on regular crust. I know the crust is kind of the main attraction here, but we all actually preferred the cauliflower crust over the regular crust. The regular crust has a nice chew, but we just really enjoyed the cauliflower. The bbq pizza is very sauce heavy and felt a little out of balance to me, but overall we all enjoyed our meal and the service and the break from driving. We will definitely be back. Oh, it's also super affordable whether you're here for pizza, drinks, or the buffet.

    The pizza's okay little plan but it's fine. Could use better crust on the pizza and cheese or…read morepeppers could come with it but haven't gotten any with mine yet don't know about the customer service never saw or met any of them

    Photos
    Mother Tucker's Pizza - Customer corner!

    Customer corner!

    Mother Tucker's Pizza - Cheese Curds and Toasted Ravs

    Cheese Curds and Toasted Ravs

    Mother Tucker's Pizza - Plenty of outdoor seating with views of the golf course.

    See all

    Plenty of outdoor seating with views of the golf course.

    Mr Gilberti's Place Chicago Pizza - The large deep dish pizza with meatballs as a topping

    Mr Gilberti's Place Chicago Pizza

    4.2(503 reviews)
    31.8 mi
    $$

    What a surprise this place turned out to be. We were staying at the Cliffs at Long Creek and wanted…read moreto find a restaurant instead of going to Big Cedar. Unless you want to drive to Branson there's not too many other choices closer. So we decided to give Mr. Gilbert's place a try. It was about 7:30 PM when we arrived. Parking was a nightmare because the lot was entirely filled and they actually had a man in the parking lot helping people to find a place to park. We eventually did find a place to park and entered the restaurant. It was packed. We were greeted warmly and asked if we had a reservation. We did not have a reservation but we're seated immediately in the back dining area. Our drink orders were taken immediately and we were warned that if we were ordering a deep dish pizza that it would take anywhere from 45 minutes to an hour. We were good with that. We ordered the MR. GILBERTI'S SPECIALTY which was a deep dish pizza with Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Black Olives, Mushrooms, Marinated Green Peppers & Red Onions. SMALL 28.50 * MEDIUM 34.25 * LARGE 40.95. This is not your typical thick bread Chicago style pizza that you're accustomed to. Instead this was a crust which is more dense and approaching a cracker like consistency around the edges. It seems that the cheese is laid down first with the rest of the toppings layered on top and the sauce is the last thing that goes on. It's like an upside down pizza. However if you think about it, it's brilliant because the sauce doesn't make the crust get soggy on the bottom since it is on the top. My wife and I both agreed that it was one of the best tasting pizzas that we'd ever had. And a small was plenty for the two of us. For dessert we ordered the strawberry cream cake which was made in the house by a culinary school graduate who just also happened to be the owner. The strawberry cake layers were separated by a cheesecake filling. It was to-the-moon delicious. This is one of those rare restaurant finds. It's the kind of place you just might drive by without giving it a second thought. But I'll tell you, we are so glad that we took a chance because the pizza was fantastic. It is a very casual ambience but the staff was extremely friendly we felt like we were amongst friends. This will definitely be on our repeat visit list next time we come into this area.

    Based on my last couple of visits - I haven't been back to this place in a while. This visit, the…read morefood was back to being good - BUT, this place is pricing their stuff to the moon for what you get. A large meat pizza: $43.25. And let me tell you, the pizza is only a 14"....not that deep. I don't mind paying...but this is so out of line compared to what you get. Even a straight pepperoni or sausage pizza..you're paying plenty for what you get. Good taste...but dang have they continued to raise the prices. Salad for 2: $20.75 and the salad is smaller than it ever used to be. Toppings aren't as plentiful as they used to be. And the dressing...the salad didn't have squat. And I paid 2.50 more to get a couple of sides of more dressing....and they're coming in the small plastic ramekin. Gee, give me a break with the nickel and dime junk...when you're already charging $21 for the salad. I have always loved this place. And I can pay whatever....but out of principle...I won't for this place anymore. Sad...as I'm from Chicago and love what this place offered in the past. But now...I suggest Pizza by the Chef in Hollister. Want a meat pizza...Hercules at that place is awesome.

    Photos
    Mr Gilberti's Place Chicago Pizza - Inside of the restaurant

    Inside of the restaurant

    Mr Gilberti's Place Chicago Pizza - All Meal Specialty pizza

    All Meal Specialty pizza

    Mr Gilberti's Place Chicago Pizza - Total skimp on deep dish ingredients.

    See all

    Total skimp on deep dish ingredients.

    Pizza House - Cheeseburger bacon pizza. Ready good!

    Pizza House

    4.3(209 reviews)
    16.7 mi
    $

    This is THE BEST pizza in the UNIVERSE. No exaggeration…read more Order it all, you won't be disappointed. Special props to the side salad with cheese and French dressing and as many crumbled club crackers as you can pile on. It's the perfect bright, tangy, sweet, acidic (thanks to the fresh diced tomatoes), and crispy palate-preparer for the gloriously decadent pizza that's headed your way. The pizza. What can I say about the pizza. Crispy? Yes. Creamy? Thanks to the standard generous cheese treatment, absolutely. Perfectly sauced? They should teach every other pizza joint the right sauce approach, because it's somehow perfect every time. Toppings? Only the most impeccable quality, you can't go wrong, though my favorite is the mushroom, hands down. Please go here, life is too short to not experience this pizza. You deserve it.

    overpriced and rude staff…read more Went here with some coworkers after a long shift, figured we'd grab some pizza. Ordered 4 large pizzas to split between all of us -- ended up paying a ridiculous amount for what we got. The pizzas were paper-thin, barely any toppings. Since the food and value were so disappointing, we didn't leave a tip. As we were walking out, one of the male employees yelled across the store, "No tip? F*** off, don't ever come back." Completely unprofessional and uncalled for. We came in as paying customers and left feeling disrespected over something that should've just been a normal business interaction. Won't be back, and I'd think twice before going here with a group. Portions don't match the price, and the customer service backs it up when you call them out on it.

    Photos
    Pizza House
    Pizza House - This is all they was left of the 13 inch 4 meat pizza!

    This is all they was left of the 13 inch 4 meat pizza!

    Pizza House - Store front

    See all

    Store front

    Casey's - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...