Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    5.0 (4 reviews)
    InexpensivePizza
    Open 5:00 am - 11:00 pm

    Casey's Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 1

    9 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Despite being a gas station, Casey has some of the pizza in town! And the prices are great to.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 8,734 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Peel Wood Fired Pizza

    Peel Wood Fired Pizza

    4.2
    (546 reviews)
    3.9 mi
    $$

    The food was great. The girl who showed us to our table was a bit sullen because we didn't want a…read morehigh top, but Victor, our server, more than made up for it. He was really friendly and started a conversation about where we were traveling from and where we were going. He also gave good service, keeping my husband's ice tea glass filled. We had a large Italian chopped salad and a half and half pizza. Half was the cheese formaggio pizza and the other half was the trio of meat pizza. It was very good. For dessert we had their house baed chocolate chip cookies. Victor warmed them up before he served them so the chips were gooey. Sooo goood. It was a very enjoyable evening.

    What an incredible lunch special, for the low price of $18. You get to choose one item each from…read moretwo sections. The variety of choices allows you to create the perfect lunch. When I saw they had hot honey and pepperoni paired together on a 8" pizza, I instantly knew that was one of my choices. The fresh mozzarella and ricotta cheeses paired with the hot honey and pepperoni exploded with flavor. My only disappointment was the inner crust. The outer rim crust was very crispy, but the inner was soft and limp due to the excessive grease from the flavorful pepperoni. I guess that is something I just need to deal with for a tasty lunch pizza. My other choice was, the Apple Gorgonzola Salad. Wow. Double Wow! This has to be the best salad I have ever had. It was a delightful mix of, spinach, granny smith apple, gorgonzola, sun-dried cranberries, candied pecans, all topped with a delicious maple cider vinaigrette. I will be back for the large version and a glass of Pino Grigio as a dinner. As my usual, I sat at the bar. My adult beverage of choice, was a Peel Summer Lager. I may be going back to fill my growler, for the upcoming holiday weekend. The restaurant has a contemporary feel, but the acoustics make it a loud environment. I didn't mind the laughter and loud conversations, it was the yelling and crying toddlers that made me cringe. Service was friendly and attentive. I enjoyed watching the bartenders use their mixologist skills preparing all the cocktails. It pleased me to see they offer "hooks under the bar". That's a small detail that makes me smile.

    Photos
    Peel Wood Fired Pizza
    The best garlic cream sauce, kind of like a sister to Alfredo?
    The best garlic cream sauce, kind of like a sister to Alfredo?
    Blood Orange Wheat Beer

    See all

    Blood Orange Wheat Beer
    Roma's Pizza

    Roma's Pizza

    4.4
    (143 reviews)
    10.9 mi
    $$

    A friend and I came here one evening to enjoy some pizza. She told me it was her favorite pizza…read moreplace! Parking was easy, with a large parking lot outside the restaurant. Family-owned, Roma's was a delightful experience. After being seated, we were greeted by a friendly server and ordered our beverages. Browsing the menu, I ordered a Bosco Stick and a medium pizza. The Bosco Stick was warm and filled with gooey cheese. It reminded me so much of the Bosco Sticks I would eat as a child. The meat sauce was a great addition to use as a dip and wasn't too meaty. I ordered a medium pizza with extra cheese, jalapeños, and mushrooms. It was so good! The pizza came out about 25 minutes after ordering and satiated my pizza craving! Roma's is nothing fancy, however, it is a comfortable environment with delicious and affordable food. Next time I am in town, I will have to come back!

    It was one of those nights and I was craving, pizza. I wanted something different than the joints…read morenear my home. So, I made the drive to B-Town and did carry-out from Roma's I placed my order on-line, which was extremely easy. I ordered a Sausage & Onion Pizza and a Small House Salad with House Dressing. I even paid for it on line and put a tip on the carry-out. When I arrived, instead of going inside, I decided to try the Drive-Thru Pick-up. They have designated lanes to take you to the back of the restaurant. That's where you'll see associates running back-n-forth from the kitchen to cars delivering the pizzas. Once it was my turn, the young lady asked my name and went into retrieve my order. When she brought it out, she had me sign the credit card slip. To my surprise, it had an additional space for another tip. I don't think so, I left it blank. I already tipped when I ordered on-line. My salad and pizza hit the spot. My pizza was still a good temperature for eating after the 15 minute drive home. I love their cheese.

    Photos
    Dining area
    Dining area
    Pepperoni and sausage pizza
    Pepperoni and sausage pizza
    Hours of Operation

    See all

    Hours of Operation
    Rosati's Pizza

    Rosati's Pizza

    3.5
    (33 reviews)
    4.4 mi

    We ordered carry out for a quick lunch. The order was ready at the promised time with attention to…read morethe special requests. Staff were friendly, knowledgeable, efficient. The waiting area was comfortable and cool on a 95° day. The salad was crisp and the toppings were fresh making a salad that was visually appealing and delicious. Something that hit the spot were the toasted ravioli, a Midwest delight, and this one was a perfect dish.

    About a year ago, on my way back from Shilo, IL I stopped by Rosati's. They offer a large slice of…read morepizza and a Drink for $5.00. It was after 1 pm and there were only 2 slices of cheese pizza in the case. The person at the counter said there were more pizzas in the oven and they would be up soon. It was worth the wait. The pepperoni pizza was hot and delicious even after traveling the 25 min. home. I told me wife about the deal and the experience..both being positive. Then, on two separate occasions, we went out of our way, while traveling, only to be disappointed because the deal is from 11 to 3:00. Today's experience...we arrived at 1:50 pm. We were excited because we were finally going to get the $5 deal. We went in the door and there was 1 slice of cheese pizza. I asked if more pizza was coming out. The gal behind the counter said no because it was a slow day and the pizza would go to waste. ( The lunch special was supposed to be valid for another 70 min. Any other restaurant will try to accomodate their patrons for lunch special up to and including 2:59.) There's counter person was not concerned about disappointing customers or even trying to show some empathy. We asked about ordering a pizza..."for here or to go"...."here"..."you have to order that in dining room". We discussed it while sitting and both felt that the person at the front counter need some customer relation training. Another person was working the dining area. She was very friendly. We placed our order for a 14" Classic Combo. It was ready in a reasonable amount of time. Our opinion, as we discussed it at length, is Rosati's has the best thin crust of all the pizza places we've eaten. Their sauce is a little tomato forward. They seem to care about the amount of toppings on the pizza. We did feel that the pie was light on the sausage. There was an ample amount of the other toppings including pepperoni. We noted the pepperoni tasted closer to bacon than the classic savory pepperoni flavor. And there was plenty of melty stringing cheese!!. I am really getting discouraged at the amount of money restaurants are charging for soft drinks. A 20oz soft drink costs the restaurant 5 to 15 cents for syrup and CO² and they charge the customer $3.75 to, in Rosati's cases $4.00. Ambiance...it's large and uses cold materials. Looks like a semi sports bar. Prices...on the higher end for pizza Wait staff...hit or miss... one good-one not so much. Food quality...(pizza) very good Lunch special...if you can get it, it's a great deal. The all important!! The left-over pizza is very good, cold straight from the refrigerator

    Photos
    Rosati's Pizza
    Rosati's Pizza
    Rosati's Pizza

    See all

    Casey's - pizza - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...