I am a big fan of this place. The food is excellent, not over priced at all and the staff is friendly and attentive. I come here every time I'm in Puerto Rico. This time I made it a point to get a Airbnb next to this restaurant and so far I've been there three times in 4 days. I'll be baaack! read more

While having a delicious "Miami Vice" at the lobby bar inside the Marriott Resort, the cool bartender told me to check out Cayo Caribe if I liked fresh fish. He said it was about a 10 minute walk and that I would not be disappointed.. Bet! The next day, while she was working, I took my little walk to Cayo Caribe and I'm sure glad that I did! It's a cool indoor/outdoor restaurant, with a nice sized bar and island decor. I ordered the Red Snapper and the server promptly came over with two for me to pick from before they cooked it to my liking. I chose grilled over fried. It took a little while for them to prepare it but it was well worth the wait. That snapper was freakin delicious!! So much so, I convinced her the next day to check out Cayo Caribe instead of Sushi. We started off with a couple drinks and calamari. She chose the grilled red snapper and I chose fried snapper this time. Honestly, mine was fried a bit too long, so I regreted not going with grilled again :( Cayo Caribe is must go for anyone that's visiting PR and loves fish. I thorougly enjoyed myself but definitely go for the grilled..lol! read more

See all

The food was okay, there was an overwhelming fish smell inside. We ate outside, the drinks were okay, not super well balanced. We got a few things to share as a group, the calamari was rubbery and not good, but it was removed from the bill. We had the skirt steak mofongo, chicken and beef empanadas. These were good. read more

See all

Our server Gustavo was attentive and on point! Our rice and beans with breaded chicken cutlet was delicious! The bacalaito appetizer was perfect too! Very nice ambiance for a Monday evening! Definitely worth visiting again! read more

I walked in almost at noon on a Tuesday and was surprised to find the restaurant nearly empty, especially since the place next door was buzzing. I'll admit, the ambiance made me hesitate for a moment and wonder if that said something about the food. Turns out, I had nothing to worry about. I ordered the red snapper, and it was genuinely excellent. The sauce was the kind you don't forget: deep, flavorful, and perfectly paired with the fish. The fish was beautifully cooked - crispy on the outside while maintaining moisture. No overcooked meat here. Even the rice stood out, which says a lot. Everything worked together in a way that felt thoughtful and memorable. Despite having limited time on my Puerto Rico trip, this is one of those meals I'd actually come back for, maybe even order the exact same dish again. The flavors really stayed with me, and I already want to take them home. read more

See all

Absolutely amazing service, and a great happy hour. Good outdoor space. The veggie paella was good, the snapper was good, and truly the risotto was surprisingly some of the best I have had anywhere. My niece ordered a kids cheeseburger that I tried as well. It's a huge burger for kids but it was good. I rated 4 stars because none of us like the mofongo. read more

See all

We came to Cayo Caribe in San Juan with our toddler and my husband's coworker for dinner. The restaurant had a nice casual vibe, and we were excited to try a mix of dishes. We started with several appetizers : queso frito, bacalaitos, and croquetas de bacalao. They were all enjoyable, especially the croquetas de bacalao which were crisp and flavorful. For the entrées, we ordered two red snappers -- one fillet and one whole fish. The whole fish was good and well-seasoned, but the fillet was disappointing. It lacked seasoning and was a bit dry. The service was okay, but it could have been more attentive. I also ordered two sides, though only one came out, which was a little frustrating. Overall, it was a mixed experience. Not terrible, but not great either. read more

Cayo Caribe - croquetas de bacalao and queso frito - Seafood Near Me - San Juan, Puerto Rico

See all

3 stars for the service being absolutely fantastic!!! The vibes are immaculate. I'm sure the other food is good but the vegan/vegetarian options are a bust (terrible). My server was amazing. I was in the area for an appointment and I usually get aguacate relleno de vegetales at Bebo's Cafe which I love, so thought it would be decent here. It was so bad lol. For $15 (including tax) I reveived a half of a Mexican avacado, on top of unseasoned watery mashed potatoes, with frozen broccoli and carrots steamed over the avacado. Thank God I got it con ajillo (with garlic sauce) because there was not a drop of seasoning on it. It was so not flavorful. Never again. Next time I'll try a fritura or something and get a d read more

Cayo Caribe - Aguacate relleno de vegetales - Seafood Near Me - San Juan, Puerto Rico

I had intention to eat next door bc it was recommended but they didn't open on time. I got tired of waiting so I came here. The pictures of crab meat looked good on yelp so I got the same. It did not disappoint. Service was great! I also got a mango mojito and it was so stronggggg. I sat at the bar and they had sports games on. read more

Cayo Caribe - Seafood Near Me - San Juan, Puerto Rico

10/10 I got dropped off and immediately seated. I ordered the fried snapper where I got to pick my own snapper and it was amazing. It was a bit salty but overall the good and service was really good! Miguel was a great waiter and kept the good and drinks going. We also had passion fruit mojitos which were absolutely delicious. Sitting at outside was perfect! I will definitely visit when I come back to the island! read more

Came here with a group of five and maybe it was because we were in a group it was not the best experience. The place itself was loud, there were tables outside, but they didn't want to seat us out there, so we sat in doors. Did I mention it was loud? In any case it took a very long time for someone to take our orders and the much longer for the food to arrive. I ordered a veggie arepa and the crab empanada. It was at best ok. The crab was definitely the better of the two. They also refused to split the check into more than two parts or take separate credit cards. This seems typical for the area, though horrifically inconvenient if say, you're traveling with a work group. I also ordered a margarita and instead of salting the rim it tasted like they poured salt into the drink, even after I scraped all the salt off the rim. I would have said something if the waiter even came back to check on us, but he didn't. I don't know that I'll be back here. Between the food that was at best ok, the really mediocre drink and similar service there are better places around. read more

EXCELLENT service but food was just okay. I was so hungry and really wanted to pig out. The environment feels very corporate.

Came here for lunch before we embarked on our cruise. Cute place inside, definitely not good for larger groups. I believe they had patio seating directly across from the restaurant that could accommodate larger groups. Food was amazing. Hot and fresh. Came out quickly. Staff were friendly as well. read more

Cayo Caribe - Seafood Near Me - San Juan, Puerto Rico

See all

My family and a coworker picked this place after a long day of work. I was visiting PR for work and the local team recommended by i go here for dinner. We were able to sit down quickly after arrival and had time to view the menu. The appetizers were delicious and my wife and I shared the red snapper. I would suggest going with the whole snapper instead of the fillet. The fillet is a little on the dry side but adding some sauce always helps. The staff wasn't super attentive but they did check on us after the food came out. read more

See all

Been coming to this place for years. Food is always fresh and delicious. Service is always GREAT! We had the most amazing server on my visit today. Brenda was so fun, bubbly, very polite and hospitable! Everything from her was 10 out of 10. Can't miss with this great local spot! read more

Came here to say the 1st night in OSJ. Wait wasn't too bad and one of the few restaurants open on Monday. Appetizer: got the fried cheese Mains: we got the mofongo shrimp and conch Dessert: Oreo pudding Service was pretty good, food came in a reasonable time, waiter checked on us. We didn't enjoy the cheese it was dried out and tasted like dried tofu. The mofongo is where we went wrong, it was dry and crumbly, and extremely garlicky. The shrimp Was the only saving grace. Wish this wasn't our first meal since it dissuaded us from trying this dish somewhere else. The dessert was basic but was the best thing we probably ate here read more

See all

This spot was recommended by our hotel and was just a 7-minute walk away, super easy to get to. When we arrived, we were told there'd be about a 25-minute wait. We were fine with that, and right as we were being seated, they let us know the food would take another 45 minutes. Our waitress was really sweet--she brought our drinks quickly, and we placed our order right away. Surprisingly, the food came out in just 25 minutes. The snapper was fresh and tasty. Overall, it's a nice place if you're into seafood. Just be prepared for a bit of a wait! read more

Cayo Caribe - Seafood Near Me - San Juan, Puerto Rico

See all

The food here is delicious. This was my first time trying yucafongo and it did not miss! Seasoned to perfection. Wonderful service and great ambiance. read more

Cayo Caribe - Sangria - Seafood Near Me - San Juan, Puerto Rico

See all

This was our first real meal in Puerto Rico. We visited San Juan our first day and this restaurant came recommended by Maria and her team at the visitor center. There were three of us so we ordered 1. Shrimp risotto - my coworker seemed to enjoy this. She offered for me to sample but it had cheese. 2. Paella - this was my meal. Honestly the rice was delicious and flavorful. However, the fish was dry, calamari was very rubbery and almost got stuck in my throat, and the musssel and clam shells were both empty. 3. Whole snapper - my sister picked out her own and it was delicious. The fish with seasoned well and was fresh. She also ordered fries and rice and beans with her meal, but only received the fries but honestly, the meal didn't anything beyond the fish. 4. We all ordered nonalcoholic piña colada drinks and enjoyed each of them. Overall, my recommendation would be to order the red snapper and share it at the table and skip the paella. read more

See all

We stopped in to get dinner and it was a good spot. The service was really excellent and the food was good. I had the churrasco with tostones. It was cooked at a perfect temperature. My grandson had the chicken Alfredo and he enjoyed his meal. A friend of ours ordered the mofongo stuffed with jueyes, it was a large portion and really good. Overall, it was really good and we will probably visit again. read more

See all

From the airport straight to Cayo Caribe for a first-time magical experience. To start, no reservations were made so we walked up and were seated in less than 5 minutes. The hostess wasn't as friendly but our waitress was and her welcoming attitude made the experience worth the while. Drinks: The Cayo Margarita is a must but opt out from the mango and go with the passion fruit. My mango drink wasn't as tasty and after taking a sip of my boyfriend's drink, I was sold on the passion fruit being the BEST there is! It offered just enough rum and fresh passion fruit flavor. It was good to the last sip! Appetizer: We started with the Arepas Menu name: Arepas de camarones, carrucho, pulpo, mixta (pulpo y carrucho), jueyes, spicy crab Translates to: Arepas: Shrimp, crabmeat, octopus, mixed (octopus and crabmeat), spicy crab Cost: less than $10 Shareable: yes, but you would want your own. This was SO divine! The arepa was crispy on the outside and soft and buttery on the inside. And while it was topped with shrimp, octopus, and crab, it was not wet but maintained a smooth consistency. The seafood inside was fresh and perfectly prepared! This dish gets a perfect 10! Main dish: Menu name: Surtido de Antojos (Sorullitos de maíz, bolitas de queso, carne frita, chicharrones de pollo y pescado) Translates to: Sampler (Corn sticks, cheese balls, fried pork. fried chicken strips & crunchy chicken bites) Cost: $20 Shareable: ABSOLUTELY Favorites: EVERYTHING! There was so much culinary greatness on the plate that it was hard to say that one item stood out more than the other. The corn sticks were sweet and offered a break in between from the salty flavor of the fried chicken and cheese balls-yet they all worked perfectly together. We thoroughly enjoyed this meal. This dish went above and beyond so it gets 10, 10, 10! Might I add that the venue was so vibrant, the music was lively, and it was perfect for our day date. You can also consider taking the family there or gathering with friends-it welcomes all. Overall, this first stop on the PR flavor train did not disappoint. read more

See all

Hostess at the front was very friendly and the server was also. However, my husband and I were rushed. Every time we put a plate or cup down the young lady who cleans the table was right there to pick it up. At first we thought we were thinking too much into it until we started to deliberately place things to see if it was so. The food was ok nothing to brag about. read more

Cayo Caribe was overall a 7/10 for us. The flavors were good, but my chicken and my husband's steak both came out dry, even though they were seasoned well. The rest of the dishes we ordered were just okay. The service was a little slow, and it took some time for our food to arrive, although the staff was friendly. A standout for us was the avocado salad. They topped it with a generous amount of perfectly sliced avocado, beautifully fanned out across the entire top. It must have been a big avocado because it covered the whole salad -- fresh, creamy, and absolutely delicious. But the true showstopper -- the dish that stole the whole night -- was the empanadas. I am an empanada snob, and these were honestly some of the best I've ever had in my life. The dough was flaky, moist, and flavorful, and both the beef and chicken fillings were incredible. I would return solely for these empanadas! read more

Very unfortunate experience here with a super incompetent staff. The manager of old man tells us we'll be waiting 15 minutes to get seated for our party of six.. after a 30 minute wait him and the Mayor D are arguing on who's gonna give us the bad news to tell us that they don't want to see this because it'll take over an hour to get our table. Serve served.. completely incompetent and unorganized rude energy from the beginning.. They were literally arguing back-and-forth, just letting us wait. Definitely not some way you want to take your family. read more

Im honestly shocked to see this low rating. Everything here was utterly five stars. I came for lunch at about 2 pm. I guess service wasn't super fast. But it was very typical for an island, and the server was very friendly, spoke perfect English, and was patient with my broken Spanish (I usually try to speak Spanish as I need the practice). He knew I wasn't a great Spanish speaker but unlike most people he indulged me and didn't switch to English unless I was rally confused. I sat at the outside bar, which I love. They also had tables outside and inside bar and tables. My type of layout for sure! Ok the food. My order: empanadilla de carne, empanadilla de pollo, chicharrones de pescado, y un taquito de "crazy shrimp". (Small empanada with beef, small empanada with chicken, fried fish bites, and a small crazy shrimp taco.) The empanadas were flawless. I could eat them every day for the rest of my life. He gave me some pica de aguacate (avacado hot sauce), and it was delicious (note, nothing here is actually hot if you're used to Mexican or Asian food, but it's still yummy). Now here is where the surprises start. I don't really like sea food. I order it sometimes especially if near the water. I especially don't like shell fish. The crazy shrimp taco.. I figured "crazy" meant it was spicy. Nope, it was covered in crab! Had a little sauce that tasted like reduced soy sauce. Verdict? Freaking delicious! I couldn't believe it as I kept eating it. I asked what type of crab it was. He told me two types but the only one I remember is jueyes. Never heard of them. But it was great; Mild and sweet. Shrimp was crispy fried and it was served in a flower tortilla. The fish bites were also delicious! Fresh, crispy, and seasoned. Not sure what kind of fish, but I would guess grouper. Mild, white, and perfectly seasoned. Came with some mayo type dipping sauce. Total bill was $30 for 4 plates of food. Small like apps or tapas but still a great deal imo. Two empanadas, a taco, a whole plate full of fish bites I could not finish, Crowd was great. Everyone smiled. I got several "buen provechos" from other patrons. This is what I want when I come to Puerto Rico. So far, Ashford (Condado) has been so much better than Loíza or McLaren (Ocean Park) as far as food goes. I cannot recommend Cayo Caribe enough. Just be patient, relax, enjoy your vacation, drink a margarita and the food will arrive soon. If you come with the island attitude, you will have an amazing time at Cayo Caribe. read more

Wow! Talk about fresh fish and a quick fry. This awesome restaurant allows you to pick your own fresh snapper and they'll fry it up in a matter of minutes. The service was solid and the interior of the restaurant was cool with a little wine cellar. I would definitely recommend and come again! read more

The food and service and ambience is stellar if you are looking for authentic puertorriquena food not fancy but down home deliciousness. Highly recommend. read more

Cayo Caribe - Seafood Near Me - San Juan, Puerto Rico

See all

We were walking around the area and stumbled into this place. The place has plenty of space inside and the atmosphere was nice. We just ordered appetizers that was a platter that included fried chicken, fried pork, chicken tenders, risotto fritters, and corn fritter sticks, and empanadas, and a four platter of tacos. The fried chicken was cooked perfect and the flavor was not bad. The fried pork was cooked prefect with great flavor and very tender. The empanadas beef inside was tender and the dough was nice and flaky. The tacos were huge with plenty of meat inside and the sauces were tasty. The drinks were a good compliment to the meals. We didn't have any dessert. The service was not bad, the place was pretty busy inside. read more

See all

2nd time I went there where I noticed the wait staff is not the most honest. We ordered a salad to share 2 entrees and empanadillas. We were charged for 2 salads, the entrees were not great and the empanadillas came out wrong and after we were done eating. Brenda the waitress did nothing to make her mistake right and did not apologize for ordering us extra food. It felt a little scammy but I also saw the other male server weighing the red snapper with the plate they must be pretty desperate for tips there. I will never eat at a table there again. The Bar is where you get the best service. The only good service I received at a table was from Jessica. read more

Cayo Caribe - Empanadilla , the best things to eat at this place. All the fish is frozen here besides the red snapper. - Seafood Near Me - San Juan, Puerto Rico

Service was great, food tasted SO fresh. Really good seafood. I got local vibes at this place! Would recommend read more

Cayo Caribe - Oysters - Seafood Near Me - San Juan, Puerto Rico

See all

Really enjoyed Cayo Caribe. Service was 10/10, we arrived less than an hour before closing and we seated within 15 minutes. The staff quickly took our order and dishes arrived soon after. We also ended up staying 30 minutes past closing and staff didn't blink an eye. May be more common in PR but really appreciated their positivity and friendliness. The shrimp turnover was stellar. Favorite items on the sample platter were corn fritters, fried pork, and chicken bites. Oysters were just ok, surprising considering it's a seafood restaurant on the coast. Entrees we ordered seafood Mofongo with a side of tostones. The seafood tasted fresh and flavorful, the Mofongo was great! I'm a big fan of plantain and this dish didn't disappoint. The restaurant is located under/next to the hospital so doesn't look like much outside but has a really nice vibe nice inside. Main area has bar and tables with small wine bar further inside. I'd recommend for a dinner before a night out or even a date. read more

See all

I would 100% come back here! The seafood was so fresh and of good quality. The tostones here are SOO good. First time trying mofongo and we loved it. The garlic sauce they put on top really set it off! Service was quick and they got us sat down really quickly! Even on a busy night. The appetizer was amazing and was recommended by our server! Very clean place. Music was fun!! read more

See all

The service was great - the conch empanadas were so delicious....and I can't say enough about the whole fried snapper - I will definitely return and highly recommend - BIG shout out to Natalia and the new trainee for their service and smile..... read more

Cayo Caribe - Conch Empanadas - Seafood Near Me - San Juan, Puerto Rico

See all

Wry nice meal on the patio. Server was very helpful with our choices. Large menu with lots of options. Next time I think I'll try the snapper. read more

Super fun vibe for a night out in San Juan! It feels very much like a bar vibe inside but the food here is amazing. I had some of the best fish tacos of my life here! Super crispy, flavorful, and fresh. Came here with a large group of friends and they were able to accommodate us very easily. They have a really varied menu with some traditional Puerto Rican dishes but also modern dishes too, so there's something for everyone here. Lots of excellent seafood options too. Service was also excellent. Our waiter recommended ordering sangria to pair with my meal and it was a great choice :) we didn't have any issues with food or speed despite having such a large group! read more

Cayo Caribe - sangria - Seafood Near Me - San Juan, Puerto Rico

See all

The drinks must be amazing--but the empanadas were greasy and the grouper was frozen, or maybe worse, refrozen, with that "are you really hungry enough to risk it?" after taste. I mean it's hard to make grouper gross. There's a great Argentinian place right down the block and better Puerto Rican food, well, everywhere. read more

Really enjoyed the lunch I had here. Highly recommend the shrimp mafongo. The empanadas were also drlicious! read more

See all

Service was terrible. Went in at 8:40. They directed me to the bar. Waited, no one came. We left. Don't bother, go where service is a priority. read more

Local food was DELICIOUS And service was great Loved eating here. Loved that the locals eat here too read more

Cayo Caribe - Fried red snapper 1.4lbs - Seafood Near Me - San Juan, Puerto Rico

Popped in here for some fresh seafood and it did not disappoint. Ceviche, oysters and sampler appetizer were all great. Would absolutely recommend checking them out read more