Really enjoyed the pep pizza with hot honey drizzle. Patio in warmer temps is super nice. After the meal you can enjoy a nice walk in adjacent park. Reasonably priced. read more

The Chatty Pizzeria is located in Bay Village, across the street from Huntington Beach. We spent a few hours at the beach and then went across the street to the pizzeria since they open at 4pm. We enjoyed our food. The pizza is very good. Our server was nice and attentive. The ambiance is so lovey. It's a great experience. We will be back for sure. read more

See all

Overall the food, service, and ambience was good. Unfortunately it was a rainy day when we went, but I would love to be able to sit outside and enjoy the outside ambience. read more

See all

The last 2 pizzas have been burned black. When the cook pulled the pizza out of the oven he would have to been blind not to notice. Likewise the girl checking the box contents did not notice the blackened crust and contents. How such a poor product could pass as good is beyond comprehension. Quality control has declined significantly at the restaurant to the point that I am done patronizing the establishment. read more

It's me again, visiting on another pizza week. Haha! For starters, they've added more seating! They have entire room in the back/side now! We came in on a Wednesday evening at dinner time and there was no wait at all. We were seated at a high top by the kitchen area, which I thought was fun seeing all the employees making pizzas. The employees also seemed happy, like they enjoyed each others company. So that was really nice to see too. I remember loving the cheesy bread so much last time, but it wasn't as good as I remembered. Still good though! And our waitress was nice enough to heat up our sauce for us ! We got the pizza week pizza and salad. Both were delicious. The pizza was way better than I remember it being, which was a wonderful delight! They also have some nice wines on the menu, like Quilt, which is what got. Mmmm Our server was TOP NOTCH. She was very personable and warm. She acted like we've been friends for years! I just really loved her. She really made our experience that much better. read more

Chatty's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bay Village, Ohio

See all

Best location for pizza in Bay Village. Wonderful atmosphere - just be certain you can tolerate very lively children from babies to pre-teens if you go early. Sweet Heat pizza was excellent. Partners plain NY Style while tasty needed a good mopping of grease toppings. Rey nice service always. The 1.00 charge for rocks in my tequila holds back the fifth star. I thought that only happened in Europe and the desert. read more

Chatty's Pizzeria - Tequila receipt - Pizza Near Me - Bay Village, Ohio

I had the lovely experience coming here for the first time during one of the BayArts outdoor concerts, they had nice seating, both indoors and outdoors (front and back of building) we sat outside and got three pizzas which were all very very delicious, I love that the pepperonis were the little ones, the sauce was really good and you can definitely taste the freshness of the dough (it had that really rich pizza oven taste) Our server was very kind, super attentive and when it was just sprinkling not even raining he was very ready to help us move all our stuff to an indoor table. All in all, I wish I had come and tried this pizza earlier. I've lived near this little spot of years and years and I'm so happy to have found a new delicious dining place! read more

See all

Cute place right by Huntington Beach! Came here with a group of 5 Friday early evening right after some beach time, and it was a great way to end the day. We were able to be seated immediately. The cheesy garlic bread starter was delicious and the Mediterranean Veggie pizza and Cacio e Pepe pizzas were solid as well. Would recommend checking this place out if you're in the area! read more

This place came highly recommended so we decided to check it out with a friend visiting from out of town. It was a Saturday night and very busy. It was a 45 minute wait when we walked up but we were offered a small table inside immediately for some reason. So, that was nice. The atmosphere inside was fine. A cute mural and just one other table was set up. We started with meatballs and a burrata salad, they were brought out pretty quickly and were both pretty good. Our pizza took over an hour to make and we were watching all the pizzas come out of oven so it was a little disheartening when the pizza from the back that came out more charred than the others was ours. We did say something to our waitress about it but she just shrugged and basically told us we would have to wait at the end of the queue if we wanted it remade. So, we took our burnt pizza. I guess it was fine but the leftover slices I had for lunch today just tasted like ash. So, meh. And the service was really not great. In fact, the restaurant called my phone while we were seated because they hadn't removed us from the list and when my friend got up to let the hostess know our waitress became visibly upset. If she had been checking on us during our hour wait, we could have told her but I guess she was busy watching our movements from afar. Too bad she never noticed our empty drinking glasses either... I guess this is a good neighborhood place but I am pretty sure we will visit other neighborhoods for our pizza moving forward. read more

See all

It was our first time here and our server on the back patio was friendly and informative. Nice decor, relaxing atmosphere, clean and you could hear the band playing behind the restaurant which was a bonus. Pizzas were really good, quality with right amount of toppings. We got a grandmas and a New York style. They came out at a reasonable pace, were light with the perfect amount of chew, great for summer. read more

Chatty's Pizzeria - New York style pepperoni and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Bay Village, Ohio

See all

We stopped in during a trip to see the Rock and roll Hall of Fame, and our hostess greeting us with a warm smile. She's from SC originally, so she asked where we are from (our accents gave us away). We loved chatting with her, and she left us in the hands of an efficient, courteous server who got us taken care of quickly. The pizza was epic! Great crust, cooked perfectly, and excellent salad. Cute place in a great location! read more

Visited Chatty's during Cleveland Pizza week, and loved that they offered both regular and gluten free pizza crust! While I didn't care for the pizza that was on the pizza week menu, the drinks were delicious and the atmosphere was so fun. We went back 2 weeks later and ordered off the menu and the pizza was DELICIOUS!!! I was so happy we gave them a second chance, and can't wait to go back during the summer and sit outside with our pizza!!!! read more

See all

Great atmosphere, average food and service I really wanted to like this place more. It has a great outdoor patio and kid friendly with outdoor areas to play. Everyone's food coming out looked delicious but overall our meal and service underwhelmed. We went on a Saturday night and had to wait about a half an hour. The wait was quick because there is a lot to look at with the arts area next door. They call you when your table is ready. We were seated outside on the patio. Ordered a small salad, meatball sandwich and pizza. The salad came out and was very spicy. After waiting about 10 to 15 minutes our waiter came back. I asked if the salad was supposed to be like that she said no. I said we could not eat it because it was too spicy. She did not offer to remake or pick another option. The meatball sub had little cheese and lots of pesto. The pizza had good crust but overall was bland. The patio is also dog friendly and the table next to ours had a dog that would aggressively bark at other dogs that walked by. We enjoyed ourselves since the weather was nice but feel the experience could have been better. read more

See all

Food was really good. We got the pizza, sweet meats. Was a nice balance of flavors and the spicy honey really elevated this one. Server Hunter was really trying to be on it. Was super busy and he did a good job. Ambiance was a really cool vibe. We set in the newer constructed garage area. Was a nice day so was a beautiful outside sitting area. With how popular it seemed and busy I don't know what further renovations could be done to make getting people seated and fed faster. Only miss for the experience was wrongly quoted waited time. Quoted 20-25 and waited a hour. Would have went somewhere else if knew was going to be an hour. read more

Great service, amazing atmosphere, unbelievable pizza. Get the NY crust! The tomato basil pie is the one.

Yum! I was lucky enough to have two of the best pizzas in Cleveland I have had in a WHILE the past few weeks and Chatty's was one of them. My husband and I were in the area and put a pick up order in. We were lucky with our timing beating the dinner rush and the staff could not have been more welcoming and knowledgable. They explained their menu and were super helpful!!! After a quick 25 minutes our order was ready and took it over to Huntington beach. The location of this place is even as wonderful as the pizza. The pizza roll was soooo delicious as well was the pizza. It was airy and yummy and so good! Recommended to all my family after going! read more

Chatty's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bay Village, Ohio

See all

Lactose intolerant or vegan pizza lovers enjoy! Chatty's is so good! Delicious pizza! I really appreciate that they have a vegan cheese option. Even before the vegan cheese option, I willingly suffered to eat this great pizza. I can't tell the difference with the regular mozzarella or the vegan tbh. It's about time that pizza joints in Cleveland have an option for the lactarded. Thank you & will continue ordering frequently!! read more

We were pleasantly surprised that they had a special menu yesterday that included Prime Rib and Chicken Marsala. We are trying to avoid carbs and we thoroughly enjoyed the Prime Rib. Service was excellent. My only suggestion is to include these special menu items/days on the website. I only heard about this special menu by word of mouth. read more

Food was great. The meatballs were truly the best I've had. The sauce is slightly spicy but only enough to give it some good flavor. It was seasoned well. You can add burrata cheese which we did. Truly decadent. The gluten free crust was pretty decent. If you get the NY crust, it is very hard to cut with a knife so prepare to just dive in! The sauce used on the pizza is complex and has many layers of flavor to it. My boyfriend loved the pizza so much he nearly ordered another to take home. Service was friendly and attentive. Definitely a younger serving crowd. Ambiance was impressive. Well thought out design for the patio and the planters were a beautiful touch. Only qualms were that it took a very long time to get our pizzas out, wait times, and some of the tables and fencing are unsturdy. read more

See all

We rented one of their igloos for a date night out and we had so much fun! Our daughter is immune compromised right now so this was the perfect way to get out but stay safe. The igloo was very warm and cozy and decorated with lights. We ordered the burrata salad, butternut squash soup and the BFF pizza. The food was all so delicious and we were stuffed by the end! We also enjoyed a bottle of wine that was on special. I can't wait to come back again! They had 3 igloos all together and we went early on a Tuesday so basically were the only people outside. A great date night out with my husband! read more

See all

Great food lovely service and the location is great. Have a great park day with the family and then get really good

After hearing all of the reviews, I ventured out to Chatty's on a Friday night. It was crazy busy. A table was a 1 hour and 45 minute wait and take was over 2 hours. Needless to say I didn't stay. So I tried again this Friday. I felt like an old timer, but got there at 4:30pm and low and behold it was pretty empty. We ordered Chatty's pizza on grandma crust and the tomato basil on the NYC. Tomato basil pizza was pretty basic and the dough lacked flavor. Very minimal sauce and very few tomato slices made die a bland pizza The Chatty's on the grandma crust tasted a lot better. I think it also would have been food an an NYC. read more

See all

Really tasty pizzas and salads. The crust has a great chew. The atmosphere is so quaint as well. Prices are fair for the quality of the ingredients. read more

Chatty's is definitely worth finding tucked away as it is on the south side of Huntington Beach. Great little Mom & Pop joint with awesome pizza made with care and the best ingredients. read more

This is my favorite place anymore! I can't get over how kind the servers are every time we have gone, the food is phenomenal, and you can't beat the atmosphere. Great price for a group of us all to eat, and options for all tastes. Good spot for out of towners so you can take them to Huntington right after. Our server was particularly great at explaining the menu and that their "grandma style" is light and not heavy as you may expect from a thick square slice. She was correct in this description and it was so satisfying! read more

Chatty's Pizzeria - Pesto mushroom NY style, sweet meat grandma style per server recc. - Pizza Near Me - Bay Village, Ohio

Food was decent but terrible service did not let us sit in the shaded area and let us get rained on I strongly advise not coming here

The food was so good! My family LOVES pizza, so we are always up for trying a new place. The convenience of this being right at Huntington Beach really ended our day at the beach on a high note. We ordered a pizza with burrata on top of it and another with hot honey. It was an adventurous choice that turned out so great! My child is autistic and has a limited diet. Our server was very helpful in ensuring we could order food made to their taste. This enabled the entire family to have an enjoyable experience. If you're ever in the area, pizza at Chatty's is a must! read more

See all

After my sister and brother-in-law moved to Bay Village last year, I had been wanting to try Chatty's. They had been a few times and highly recommended it. They took me here on my most recent trip to CLE. Even thought it was summer, we were unfortunately not able to sit outside due to a thunderstorm. But luckily, we were sat inside after a 10-15 min wait. We ordered the House salad to share and it was very good! It was the perfect amount to split between three people. They opted for the Tomato Basil (NYC style) pizza while I went for the Grandma's style of a classic cheese pizza. The Grandma's style can best be described as Detroit style pizza-- more dough than anything else. I actually ended up preferring the NYC style pizza. The grandma's is just really doughy, even though I asked for extra sauce. I also ordered a glass of Angeline Cabernet which was very good! Service is really not that great here. Very bare minimum service and they don't check in on you for quite some time once you have your food. They also are not the friendliest. Given the familial vibe of Chatty's, I was expecting more. All told, I would give it another shot. Will be great to dine out on the patio sometime next summer! read more

See all

NEW NEW NEW well kinda new, u know why they put a gate up around the cemetery right?? Don't say it... bc they're dying to get in here. Opens at 4 people line up for the pie & subs. We came at 4 on sat. No problemo. The old Vento by Huntington Beach. Cool cool old place. New venture by some Symon alums. Good luck break a leg etc etc. Wonderful! Great NY style pie serves 8. Added pepp and the burrata cheese $18. I don't know what to do with the extra cheese but hey it works. See pic. Me & the bro had a great time. Got the Willamette (damnit) Pinot $9.50 and it's best wine I've had in some time. Bud light $4 and a couple IPA for the bro. Great waiter. I'm glad I left the house. So hey the fun part is most locals know the place is haunted. The girl she sits right there said a ghost hunter. She was left here when this was a train station. Hey believe what u want but I love it. Don't follow me home tho god bless America. I almost wonder if the ghost hunter was real ya know and I hope she pay for her meatballs. 5 stars the pizza is great and it's hot and new. I give everyone 5 stars it looks like but hey u can't say I'm not a lot a laughs. Enjoy! read more

Chatty's Pizzeria - don't ask - Pizza Near Me - Bay Village, Ohio

See all

I have been eyeing this place since I first signed up my son at BayArts and we finally got a chance to try it today. As much as I really wanted to give this place 5 stars because the food was honestly delicious, the service ruined it. When we arrived they were busy but nothing too crazy. We were told 30 minute wait so we got on the waitlist, we were seated in about 15-20 minutes. We got served water/drinks immediately and waitress started off good. We got in our order of meatballs, pretzel and our pizza. Appetizers came pretty quickly and pretzel was pretty good as it was served with their pizza sauce, meatballs were probably 4 out of 5. After that, our waitress barely came around, it took 50 minutes to get our one pizza out and at no point did anyone come and check in on us, no explanation on why our pizza took so long, no water/drink refills and we couldn't even get our waitresses attention to ask about our pizza. After about 40 minutes we finally got her attention and she told us just a couple more minutes for our pizza, which was more like 10 minutes. Once it finally arrived, it was truly delicious...we got the New York style with pepperoni and bacon. I loved the thin, crispy crust...it had a hint of sweetness to it that made it that much better. They seemed pretty well staffed in both kitchen and restaurant so not sure why it took so long and why we never got drink refills. The place itself is super cute, nestled within the metro parks and offer both a nice indoor/outdoor experience. We went on a Tuesday so we assumed it would be a bit quicker. Added touch for pet owners, you can bring your dog if you sit outside, they do have dog bowls out for our furry friends. Honestly if it wasn't for the long wait on our pizza and zero drink refills, I would give this place a 5. read more

See all

Delicious pizza in Bay Village!! Loved coming here after work for some great wine & all different options of pizza. I personally loved the "grandma style" crust. Extremely crunchy and filling with every bite. The staff was extremely knowledgeable about their wines and pizza offerings. It was great to get out and experience the hustle and bustle of Chatty's. Looking forward to coming back and trying the BLT pizza, grandma style of course. read more

Chatty's Pizzeria - Veggie pizza on top, grandma style on the bottom - Pizza Near Me - Bay Village, Ohio

See all

Great food, good service. The place is really quaint since it's part of an older building in the Bay Arts section of Huntington Woods. They fill up pretty quickly with patrons so carry out is something we do a bunch to avoid the crowds. read more

Highly recommended folks!! We placed a pickup order for Chatty's Pizzeria. We didn't expect it to be through the Metroparks when we drove there so that was interesting. They have a really nice eating area for date night too. We may have to take advantage of the wonderful atmosphere for our next trip. We ordered the Sweet Meats specialty pizza on their Grandma Style Crust. The crust is different but very good. It's kinda like a Ciabatta crust. Get there! read more

Chatty's Pizzeria - Sweet Meats pizza on Grandma Style crust - Pizza Near Me - Bay Village, Ohio

See all

Upon the recommendation of a west side local, my friend and I went to Chatty's Pizzeria recently. We were going on a Friday evening in the summer, so I called ahead and put my name on the wait list. The wait was less than an hour. When we arrived, I was immediately dazzled by the vibe of the place. The restaurant is located right behind a large grassy area and across the street from the very picturesque Huntington Beach. The front and side patios were bustling with people and good vibes. Think warm summer air, fireflies, string lights. The menu includes vegan options (hooray!) - specifically, you can sub vegan cheese (Follow Your Heart brand mozzarella) on any of the vegetarian pizzas. I was informed that all the crusts except the cauliflower crust is vegan. I got the vegetable pizza, and my friend tried the tomato basil pizza. We were both really impressed by the pizza and the overall atmosphere. This place is clearly a locals' favorite! Perfect for a summer evening, and easy to walk to the beach afterwards. read more

Chatty's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bay Village, Ohio

We are FOR SURE pizza snobs. This pizza was good. Crust was airy and light - not heavy (grandma crust) Wanted to mention - they have bourbon here. Namely Buffalo Trace - which was exceptional Wee don't live nearby, but if we did, we would come back read more

Good pizza but extremely slow we were seated outside and definitely off of the waitresses path.Drinks were empty never saw the waitress for a long time only she showed up when our pizza arrived haven't been back since about a year ago probably not gonna go back. Follow up, received a follow up message from the owner of Chattys pizza he sounded passionate about the restaurant I will go back give it another try, the pizza is good and has a good beer selection anyway he said they have been working hard to provide a good dining experience it's rare to get feedback from a restaurant it was appreciated read more

Went for a walk along the lake and ran into a couple of local guys who suggested Chatty's when we mentioned grabbing a pizza on the way back to our motel. Ordered the Pesto, mushroom pizza and glass of wine. Both were exceptional and I wish we lived in the area so we could go back for other flavors of pizza. read more

Chatty's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bay Village, Ohio

See all

Chatty's Pizza is excellent! Service is top notch and the ambiance is perfect.. there is plenty of parking and reserved spots for picking up. read more

Great pizza and service in a nice setting. Always happy with our food and drinks.............

I've ordered from there about 7 times and never had a bad experience. There is a long wait because it's quality food. The menu is somewhat limited because they focus on doing quality not quantity. If you want quantity of choices go to the Cheesecake Factory. Love how one reviewer ordered thick crust and then complained it was too thick? Idiots. If you like Dominos or 95% of franchise pizza places then you don't know shit about pizza. This place is Aces and I'm only talking about the food. The locations is perfect but I'm going there for food, not a scenic view. Keep up the good work read more