Delicious food! Great wait staff! Great place to eat after a day on Green Lake! Great place for families with kids to eat!

Very disappointed. My son-in-law placed an order using my phone number. He asked for the order to be delivered. We waited and waited. After almost an hour, I called back to see what the holdup was. At this time I was told they don't deliver (they previously did). I complained to the manager that the person should have told my son-in-law that they no longer deliver. Scvording to the manager they did. According to my son-in-law the phone cut out shortly on the call, & he asked what the person had said. He said he definitely wasn't told they don't deliver. So we waited over an hour to get our order. It was far from hot & it was exactly like you'd expect it to be after sitting in a warming area all that time after it was made. Not sure what happened, but I certainly believe my son-in-law should have at least been compensated for part of the order. Christianos-you did not put your customer first this time, by any means. Guess I'll start checking out other local pizza places. Definitely did not feel like my/our business was valued. read more

Fresh, fresh, fresh! We're NEVER disappointed!! Always our go when we're in town. Everything we've tried has been excellent read more

Christianos Pizza - Personal Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Green Lake, Wisconsin

Came here while on a short vacation with the family on Green Lake. Christianos was highly recommended to us by locals. The recommendations did not disappoint. We arrived at the restaurant and there were only a few tables taken. We sat at a booth and the server took our order promptly. We had local craft beers that started the dinner right. We ordered a cup of soup for my son and a salad to share with the table. Both were solid. We ordered a thin pizza with sausage and mushroom. The crust was nice and thin and crispy. The sauce was perfect. A clean tomato flavor without a ton of sugar. The cheese was also of quality. Overall a really good pizza. Definitely will return if in the area. read more

Best service ever! Great food and great people. The delivery was amazing even though it wasn't available Stella delivered it, fast and the pizza was hotter thank you so much!!!! read more

Christianos Pizza - @christianos - Pizza Near Me - Green Lake, Wisconsin

Italian isn't usually my go to as I'm Italian and pretty critical. This point highly exceeded my expectations! Everything tasted fresh and with real quality ingredients. Creamy pesto Alfredo with chicken and shrimp as well as traditional Alfredo were truly perfect in every way. Lasagna and meatballs were on point leaving you smiling with the after tastes! read more

Christianos Pizza - a plate of food on a table - Pizza Near Me - Green Lake, Wisconsin

Nice Christmas decor. Menu has a fair number of options and fairly good pizza. Service was fairly good (and we were a group of 14, including five young kids). read more

Looking for a light dinner before ice fishing and was told that Christianos was the place to be. Close to where we were staying this place was definitely convenient. Ella was our server and she was helpful as well as delightful. We ordered up a couple of beers to start and Ella ran us through the selection and made some recommendations. From there we ordered starter salads and a pepperoni and sausage pizza. The pizza was hot and crispy and had plenty of flavor. The beer was cold as well. Thank you Christianos! read more

See all

Was OK. I have had better pizza. Service was quick and polite. Very roomy and accommodating.

None of their food is good overall. Even their pizza is subpar. Tonight we ordered to subs fir delivery. They had no onions or cucumbers or anything but the cheap meat and thickly sliced tomatoes on it. Asked for Provolone on the Italian Sub. They lied and sd "sure we've got it." Instead it had cheap quality Salami with those cheap Kraft sliced cheeses that comes between individually wrapped in plastic wraps. The sub bread was drenched in the oil. I didnt want mayo, asked for mustard. They said they only had Dijon. What restaurant doesn't have Mayo or Dijon for their Italian subs. Horrible. Not recommended in the least. read more

The garlic bread is to die for delicious! All the pizza our large party of 15 ordered was terrific! We had gluten free, vegetarian, sausage and pepperoni! Our server was friendly and helpful. We were seated immediately read more

Since the covid outbreak I've been ordering delivery for many meals. Out of the dozen places I've ordered from Christianos is by far the friendliest out of all of them. They deliver farther than anyone around and seem to be happy to have your business. The food is excellent, that's without saying, but I'm impressed how this place has met the demands of customers since the outbreak. Ty Christianos delivery! read more

Always good I have done the GF crust pizza and the cauliflower crust pizzas both awesome love the salads as well! The only negative for me is they only serve beer and wine for cocktails. I guess it's not a big deal but on a date night I want I little something different read more

We had Madeline as a server last night, she was such a pleasure. She was able to answer every question we had about the menu, and about the gluten free options. I got the shrimp primavera with gluten free noodles. They also have gluten free pizza crusts. We will definitely be returning. read more

Got here around 5pm on a Saturday and were seated immediately. Our waitress took our order right away...pizza was very good! The only fault I found was the acoustics are terrible; if you have any hearing issues you'll have trouble making conversation. We were done by 6pm and people were waiting, and that's a good sign read more

Obviously really good pizza otherwise I wouldn't have given it 5 stars. Easy access from Green Lake Campground. read more

Christianos Pizza - Awesome pizza - Pizza Near Me - Green Lake, Wisconsin

Pizza has some decent flavor and toppings aren't minimal however they need to rethink their delivery area. Sometimes pushing boundaries causes a soggy crust and cold pizza upon delivery and when it's a $30 pizza after delivery and tip charges - I'd rather be told "sorry but your out of our area" rather than "it will be 45 minutes" and then receive a cold and soggy pizza over an hour later. Hesitated to order, chose to make the call, wish I'd have tried their pizza in house first as this has caused a bad taste for their pizza sadly read more

The pizza from Christianos Pizza is absolutely awesome! Plus, the delivery drivers are quick and efficient and our food always arrives piping hot! read more

Excellent food and environment! great service from Harmony! Would most definitely eat here again!

Wonderful place. Lovely ambiance, amazing food. So friendly. Kitchen staff does lovely work getting food out quickly and insanely high quality! Love love love this place. Highly recommend to anyone visiting the area read more

Food and service are always good. Highly recommend their meatballs as an app or sandwich.

Pizza was delicious, salads were delightful and Harmony the server made the night with her fun personality. She was a fantastic server. Thank you for the experience. First time here will come back again. read more

Happy Days are Here Again! Much to my wonderment, I spied a *gasp* craft beer list on the table during my most recent visit to the restaurant. Therefore, eighty-one years after the repeal of the Volstead Act, Christiano's ode to prohibition is finally over and you can finally order a beer or a glass of wine to go with your meal. That development combined with a marked improvement to their pizza crust has placed this eatery firmly in four-star territory in the eyes (and taste buds) of this grizzled pizza-hound. First things first, bravo to Christianos for compiling an impressive menu of craft beers. In the past, the absence of 'any' wine or beers options detracted from the dining experience at this establishment. The general manager definitely put some thought into their beer list - it is not the typical Miller High Life / Bud Light type of fare you usually see from area restaurants. I loved the Nut Brown Ale from Ashland's South Shore Brewery - it complemented the meal and made a special occasion (my dad's 80th birthday) even more memorable. I posted a picture of the beer list, since that information is currently not available online. Second, Christiano's did a tremendous job improving the quality of their pizza crust. A great pizza is a balancing act between the crust, sauce and toppings. Each component should complement the other. If one component fails, the pizza as a whole suffers. In the past, the crust has been the weak link, but not last night. Golden brown on the exterior and no soggy spots in the center of the pie with great chew and flavor, the kitchen did a superb job nailing this component. As in prior visits, the properly seasoned sauce tasted fresh with the acidity of the tomatoes being balanced out with a hint of sweetness. While I would have preferred a little more concentrated tomato flavor, I felt the red sauce complimented the other components. With over 30 topping options, Christianos provides all the traditional favorites. It is still a little disappointing not to see cheese options like feta or chevre or specialty Italian meats like Prosciutto Ham. Nonetheless, it is not difficult to construct a pie that needs the needs of your group. I'm a fan of the flavorful sausage and the vegetable topping are all fresh and generously applied. I also enjoyed the quantity and fresh quality of the cheese. While best known for their pizzas, the menu boasts a wide variety of pastas, sandwiches and salads. There also offer gelato and cannoli as dessert options. In addition, if you have the kiddos in tow, there are plenty of kid-friendly options on the menu. I have always experienced stellar service during any of my visits to the restaurant and last night was no exception. Roberta helped ensure last night's birthday festivities went off without a hitch. She performed all the duties of a great server (prompt order taking, explaining menu options, keeping us properly hydrated, maintaining proper flow of the meal, clearing dirty dishes, checking on our satisfaction with each course, etc.) with an infectious cheerfulness. Seated near the open kitchen, the noise level made it difficult at times to carry on a conversation. That was really the only negative of a truly wonderful evening. Therefore, if you are looking for a casual dining option after spending a day gallivanting around the Green Lake area, you cannot go wrong giving Christiano's a shot. read more

Christianos Pizza - The new craft beer menu. Well done, Christianos, well done. - Pizza Near Me - Green Lake, Wisconsin

We always order delivery from this establishment and the service is great! The food is wonderful and I highly recommend it. When Covid finally calms down we will very likely dine inside but not before as Covid precautions are not followed in the dining area. So one star taken away for that. read more

My family worked with Ryan to plan a rehearsal dinner near Green Lake, WI for my niece. We had a large group at this destination wedding with over 60 people. Their private event space is cozy with a separate entrance from the regular restaurant.Ryan was accommodating and easy to work with. He and his team worked with us so we could stay on budget. The result was really a nice time with plenty of food and time to do all we wanted to do with mixing, networking, toasting and having a wonderful plentiful buffet. The pizza was great and so much of it (we got to take some back to resort). The only little thing is the echo in the room which he said they will be working on. Thanks Ryan and Christinos for a great time. read more

See all

I picked this pizza up coming from Milwaukee on my way to Montello. Had only been to the restaurant once before a long time ago. We generally don't pick up the pizza "to go" because it's another 30 minutes to our house. With that said, I ate a couple pieces in the car with one hand tightly on the wheel - never took my eyes off the road. Good crust, plenty of toppings and not too spicy. Closed the lid and put the seat warmer on. When I got home, the pizza was still very, very good. Will definitely go back. Was extremely cost effective for the quality. Nice work!! read more

Sent pizzas to both of my stores for lunch, to thank staff for all their hard work. I picked one up for dinner on the way home. Everyone raved how good they were. A combo, a meatlovers and a bbq chicken. read more

We ordered food for carry out at Christiano's. The Greek salad was very good along with the house dressing. Our entrees included 2 orders of the lasagna. The food was very tasty if the portion size was easily enough for two meals. In addition, a large portion of garlic bread -4 big pieces were provided. Great value and very good food. read more

Christianos Pizza - Greek salad - Pizza Near Me - Green Lake, Wisconsin

See all

Recently dined in at Christiano's for a birthday dinner with our son. Of course had to order the pizza, while the others ordered seafood alfredo, chicken alfredo and lasagna. I have to say the seafood alfredo is wonderful and their garlic bread served with the entree is so delicious. Wished they served Wine or Beer but understand the choice not too. read more

Both our meals came with a huge salad and good garlic bread. The garlic bread was maybe a little too crunchy. My girlfriend's Shrimp and Scallop pasta was swimming in butter but had little flavor. I also had to add salt and pepper to my Chicken Alfredo. The cheese cake desert was great, but very small and expensive. Altogether it was too pricey for what we got. We might have made a mistake to get non pizza menu items rather than pizza from a pizza places. So I have to review their pizza some other time. read more

I really like the pizza at Christianos! Its thin crust with a nice vibrant tomato sauce, and just the right amount of flavorful mozzarella cheese. If you've had Marty's pizza in Waukesha/Delafield/Brookfield or pizza from the North Lake Inn (in North Lake) the flavor and heft to the pizza is almost identical. What is really critical for me is their Italian Sausage. This is where most pizza places fail. Christianos does it right. I've also tried their lasagna, which was good but overpriced ($12 if I recall correctly). The dining room is ok. It's very clean which I appreciate. My two main complaints: They arent open on Sundays They dont serve beer or wine. I have heard this is because they have Christian fundamentalist owners. Hence the name of the Restaurant. read more

I've ordered from here 4 times and 3 of those times have not been delivered on time. Today my food was ordered at 10:00am and was supposed to be delivered at 12:00. My food was over 20 minutes late. I called and asked to be reimbursed for it, I only get a 30 minute lunch break so when they do show up I won't even be able to eat it. I was told they wouldn't give me a refund but they could cancel the order and they can't guarantee delivery times. If they have a delivery at 11:45 at Alliance and the ppl there don't let them in, they can't help it. I've been told by 2 different ppl that Green Lake Christianos doesn't deliver to Ripon; so explain to me the excuse! I wasn't offered a coupon or a free item with a future order (I don't think I will order from here again tho). Very unhappy customer!!!! I do NOT recommend! read more

Food is decent, some things better than others. Best place for pizza in Green Lake. Lots of other menu options. To go orders seem to ALWAYS get messed up, even when repeating it over and over to make sure they get it right. Staff is nice, service is okay. read more

Christiano's has some really good pizza, which I like, but my family LOVES! Their cheesy garlic bread is also a great app. I haven't heard great things about the pasta, but why get anything other than the pizza anyway. They also have some mean gelato at their little shop on the other side of the parking lot. read more

Christianos Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Green Lake, Wisconsin

The food was great. The service...well...if you don't mind helping train the staff, you'll be fine. We went because they have gluten-free pizza crust...which they were out of the day we were there. The server offered me gluten-free pasta...for a $2 up-charge. (I guess the pizza crust also has an up-charge.) My group suggested she waive that, since they were out of the pizza crust. Instead of saying "Let me talk to my manager and see what I can do for you," she said WE should talk to the owner. Way to provide great service!! {sarcasm font} Then later, when we ordered a round of gelato, which arrived melty and messy, I had to ask her to clear the dinner dishes off the table. Who wants to eat dessert while looking at piled up plates of food? This gal was just not trained to be a good server. If you can get past that, you'll enjoy the food. :) read more

This is your standard, unpretentious pizza. Can't expect a ton from a lake town pizza joint, but you can certainly do a heck of a lot worse. We got three thin crust pies, everyone seemed to enjoy it, but there is just not a lot to it... read more

Very nice place. Very friendly staff. Good service. I can't review anything except the pizza because that's all we had. My review of the pizza is a big Not Good. We had pieces with absolutely no cheese on some slices and doughy tasting. Big disappointment. When we showed the server the cheese less pizza he joked and said the cooks must have dazed out. That's ok though, I don't think cheese would have helped that much anyways read more

Where do I start...we had a VERY large call in order. The young lady on the phone was crazy nice and absolutely amazing at taking multiple orders and providing us individual totals. We had 14 pizzas and some apps and when she said it would be ready in 30 minutes, we chuckled. We arrived 10 minutes after placing the order, knowing we were early and ordered a drink. One sip of beer and they came out with our order! Not only was it ready early, but they had all the boxes marked with the order on the outside! They were super friendly, order was correct and the pizza was spectacular! We were all very extremely happy that we ordered from them! Thanks for being awesome! read more

A group of 7 of us came here for lunch. We'd been to one of the other Christianos locations last time we were in town, so decided to give this one a try. They did not disappoint! Delicious pizza, a varied menu with something for even the pickiest eater, and fantastic local beers on tap! The $8.95 lunch special of a personal pizza and drink can't be beat! I removed one star for service. Our waters were never refilled, and we sat for 20 minutes waiting for the check to be brought. Every time our server came in our direction, she would visit another table and pass right by us despite us trying to flag her down. We finally just found another employee to bring our bill. Other than that, a great experience! read more

Excellent gourmet pizza, several local craft brews on tap. Prices are good. Place is immaculate and staff is knowledgeable and professional. As a traveler, I get around. This is one of my favorite restaurants. If you're looking for corporate food this ain't it. Very original and a meal you'll definitely enjoy. The location on yelp is incorrect. It is east of that location a mile or two and right on 23. read more