Great Erie pub with a variety of food! I love it because of nostalgia. It's an Erie staple that has…read moregreat bar food and atmosphere!

Plymouth Tavern might have the cheapest drinks in town, but apparently the service comes with…read morejealous mean girl behavior included for free. A bartender named Anastasia spent more time policing where girls were sitting and acting territorial over the boys, than actually doing her job professionally. My friends and I were ignored on multiple occasions while watching her happily serve everyone else around us, then tonight got told we "couldn't be" in a room with our own friends. We literally walked in for two seconds to say hi, not even intending to order drinks through her and got treated like we were committing a felony. The craziest part was watching a grown bartender run around talking about customers instead of actually bartending. If the energy spent gossiping and targeting certain people went into actual service, maybe this place would have something besides $2 drinks going for it. Never been somewhere that felt so unnecessarily immature, and uncomfortable. There are plenty of bars in Erie where the staff acts like adults. This just isn't one of them.

Good food. Best wing in town. Like getting a pitcher of beer. Clean bar. Good service. Comfortable…read moreseating

we were there on Jan12, 2025. Great service and food. The bartender/ service guy was spectacular…read moreand the cook prepared great food.

I LOVE their Mac and cheese! The waiter that took care of us was SO nice! Our food came out…read moreimmediately, and it was sooo delicious! I would recommend this to everyon!

I really try to avoid leaving bad reviews, but the burger I had tonight was so disappointing and…read morethat seems on theme with others who have left similar reviews. The burger was extremely dry and overcooked. Others have written that these patties may be from Sysco, or flash frozen - that all tracks. There's no flavor, the and the meat was crumbling apart when I bit into it. I hope that they can improve.

food can be overpriced. I ordered a grilled chicken sandwich, no brioche bin, had American cheese…read moremelted, not very appealing. added a small salad (good sized), says $15 on menu price. salad was 4.50. $19.50-?! $15 for chicken sandwich (not even correct items served!) sides included fries/tater tots, coleslaw, (small amount) I ordered none of the sides?! $15 for grill chicken sandwich?! I can't eat healthy. husband ordered cranberry walnut spinach salad with feta cheese..,,,greater value.....$16. salad from now on. had to ask the music level turned down. always so loud. left disappointed?!

If you haven't tried the buffalo chicken tots you've missed out! Service was spot on as well…read more. music playing great Christmas atmosphere.

I absolutely love this place. The drinks are fantastic and unique. The service is phenomenal and…read morefriendly. The ambiance is perfectly quaint and relaxing. My wife and I try to make there every Friday that we can for and end of the week tradition which is more about getting a good drink.

Love the ambience and the good selection of their drinks here (it is quite pricey, but it is well…read moreworth the experience) . The schoolhouse is a great place to grab a drink and hangout with your friends. Though, there are limited selections of food/snack items offered.

Dog friendly place--their outdoor patio has plenty of shades, so it's a lot better than other…read moreplaces we checked (a lot of other places have outdoor patios but somehow not providing any shades, which won't work in the heat). The older female server is extremely friendly. Our dog somehow puked and she cleaned it without making a big deal of it, which we really appreciated. Food is good except that I am not sure why chicken wings would be "market price". I've never seen chicken wings being of market price.

Jen was awesome. Walleye and perch were spot on tonight, great spot!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!read more

Stopped here for lunch on Wednesday afternoon. I started with the tortilla soup and it was very…read moreaverage. There wasn't a lot of chicken or anything else in it - it was mostly a semi-thick broth surrounded by lots of tortilla chips. My husband ordered the Reuben and was so so disappointed. The corned beef was tender, but he was appalled when he removed the bread to find a layer of corned beef folded in half to cover half of the sandwich. There wasn't much corned beef at all. Cole slaw also tasted like bland cabbage. :(( Not sure we would return.

Great service at bar Very honest menu suggestions…read more Had a some good shrimp taco's as well as good steak salad. Beer selection was fair. Good vibe