The pizza is in my opinion the best in Erie. It has a real New York feel. They have a nice variety on the menu and and are very customer oriented. read more

Tastes just like New York City pizza--crispy, cheesy, and packed with flavor! Crazy Oven is a must for any pizza fan. Friendly staff and clean environment. read more

Pizza was good just needs a bit more sauce, Wings completely disappointed, got home opening container looked over cooked oily burnt (pic #1), called girl was nice saying they could replace them, drove all the way back replaced the looked good but time got home sauce had soaked in appearance of wings (pic#2) wasn't pleasing again but the were edible. Nice quiet family environment. read more

See all

Pretty decent food for what it is: beach food. Won't fault them for delays, because this is 2021. Our waitress was very pleasant and open about the delay. The appetizers and sides were better than expected and the pizza was fairly good. Not great, but better than the concession stand. All of the food is way better than the popular place next door. Speaking of, I have no idea what the owner might be like, but we completely understand why he'd be angry. I'd say 80% of the cars that pulled in between Noon and 1pm were filled with people that got out, looked at the "Crazy Oven parking only" signs, then proceeded to walk over and step over or limbo under the yellow plastic chain dividing the lots. Even more egregious were the trashy illiterates that parked right in front of the door. Based on years of getting nasty food at the popular spot next door, I was a bit biased. Watching the behavior of their customers Sunday, my normally passive demeanor starting inching toward disgusted and angry... by watching people get out of their vehicle! read more

Crazy Oven - At least 3 of these vehicles were Sara's customers. Rude. - Pizza Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

Ordered the deep dish pizza and it's delicious. We like Chicago style and this reminds of us the famous Malnati's pizzeria but it's in our back yard. Will be back for more... read more

Deeeeelicious pizza! We ordered the New York style pizza with pepperoni and sausage. The toppings, sauce, cheese, and crust were allll incredible!!! We also ordered pepperoni balls. We weren't impressed with those. But the pizza more than made up for the disappointing pepperoni balls!! read more

There was more honey mustard dressing than chicken, ham, and Swiss cheese. What little chicken there was tasted off. The honey mustard was ridiculous it shot everywhere there had to be a cup of it on the pitiful wrap. No condiments like ketchup for the overcooked French fries or Parmesan cheese or red peppers. I would not feed their food to my worst enemy. read more

Crazy Oven - Chicken cordon bleu wrap with at least 1 cup of honey mustard! - Pizza Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

See all

We used to frequent this place when they were Stevo's. The main difference for us with the new restaurant (aside from the bar, and since we don't drink, that part doesn't matter), is that the fries are different...still good, but not the way they used to be, and now the ketchup and ranch dressing each come out of a store bought bottle rather than being homemade like they used to be. The pizza is still good, the pepperoni balls are still good, plus we tried the pepperoni roll recently for the first time and it was good as well. We will still frequent this place, but they were better as Stevo's. Sadly, they kept the same odd winter hours as Stevo's did, which makes it weird when you want to go for lunch and they don't open until 4 pm. read more

I just recently had there pizza and wasn't as good as I remember it from I guess before Covid. I've tried ordering a few times but they never pick up the phone, maybe the hours changed I don't know. When I picked up my pizza I was just standing there awhile, she finally said I'll be with you in a few, then a guy came out several minutes later and waited on me. I might give em another try cuz I used to like them read more

Went in for a spiked slushy and a few slices of pizza. Both of which were great. Very fair prices for being by the beach.

BEWARE, they allow customers in without a mask, the cooks in the kitchen do not wear masks! When I spoke to the manager, he rolled his eyes as if I was bothering him. STAY AWAY!! Cooks DO NOT WEAR MASKS!!! read more

Pizza wasn't too bad despite reviews! Could have been served hotter. Nice atmosphere and fun place to crash after hanging out at Presque Isle. read more

We had an awful experience at Crazy Oven and we will never return! We placed an order for a medium cheese pizza, three pepperoni balls and a calzone. You could choose your filling for the calzone. When asking the waitress she said like pepperoni and sausage. We have a lot. I really don't know. Then she indicated that anything that goes on their pizzas could be the filling. After sitting for twenty minutes the waitress came back to say there were no pepperoni balls. OMG! "Okay", I said "I'll just share the medium pizza that was ordered." After waiting forty minutes and no food. We noticed that a table next to us that came after us were getting their pizza. So we decided that we had waited long enough, paid for a pop and left. We will never be back! Last year it was Stevo's you could by pizza by the slice and yes, they DID have pepperoni balls! read more

I have never eaten at Crazy Oven but judging the manager's behavior, it's not somewhere I would ever want to eat. We were at Sara's for opening day and anyone who is from Erie knows how crazy it is on opening day, let alone opening day of 2020 when the drive through is the only thing open. The line for Sara's was through the parking lot of Crazy Oven. The restaurant isn't even open and the manager drove here just to yell at the poor Sara's employee about their cars being in his parking lot. The boy directing traffic was very polite and the manager from Crazy Oven continued to scream at cars and customers at Sara's. So unprofessional. I will never eat there. read more

Taking into consideration food plus service, this place earned its lone star.

This place is so good!! The Pizza is amazing and the calzones to die for. Don't pass this place up before heading into the Park. Everything tastes like from scratch and oh the fresh cut fries are so good. Full service bar too! We stayed at the Sara's Campground and just walked over !! read more

Although the food was decent, the service was very slow. The food was brought out a little at a time and one member of our party did not get his order until everyone else was finished eating (and it was just a pizza!). And as for the live music, WAY TOO LOUD and totally unnecessary! It was impossible to carry on a conversation with others at the table! read more

This is the remade Stevo's. I had a great pasta dish. Others tasty looking pizza, calzone, wrap. Attentive wait staff. Prices are still reasonable. New decor is nice. This is a fun place for a group. read more

We came from Mentor Ohio to Erie for Waldameer. We ordered pizza here and our 5, 6, 8 year old would not touch this barely cooked pizza. You are better off going and getting a frozen pizza at the grocery store. Not good at all. read more