Stopped here for lunch on Wednesday afternoon. I started with the tortilla soup and it was very average. There wasn't a lot of chicken or anything else in it - it was mostly a semi-thick broth surrounded by lots of tortilla chips. My husband ordered the Reuben and was so so disappointed. The corned beef was tender, but he was appalled when he removed the bread to find a layer of corned beef folded in half to cover half of the sandwich. There wasn't much corned beef at all. Cole slaw also tasted like bland cabbage. :(( Not sure we would return. read more

See all

Great service at bar Very honest menu suggestions. Had a some good shrimp taco's as well as good steak salad. Beer selection was fair. Good vibe read more

Fantastic margarita pizza. Perfect crust, super fast super hot oven, fresh ingredients in perfect ratio. Closest we've had since living in Italy! read more

We sat at the bar because typically service is en pointe, well it definitely lacked this time. Was not impressed, had to ask for everything.

Very good food, we order take out from here sometimes and it is just as good as dining in. Nice ambiance inside, with lots of beer choices. I prefer to go on a week night when it is less busy, but that is just a personal preference! read more

We came in for lunch with our kids. We sat outside and it was perfect! Crayons and wikki sticks were given to keep the kids busy. The food was excellent and the service was even better! read more

Service was good, nice atmosphere - multiple tvs showing different options. Beer selection on tap is decent. The food was very mediocre. I had the Bianca pizza, ordered it extra crispy. It was doughy and had way too much cheese for my taste. My partner had the Sicilian sandwich and liked that it wasn't overloaded with meat but it was otherwise "fine" read more

I came to my hometown to visit for my birthday and decided to check this out since it was downtown. We walked out after being seated because no one ever came to our table to wait on us. Unfortunately, from the moment we walked in, it seemed like having any customers at that time was an inconvenience for the wait staff. read more

I came here with a friend twice on the same day (crazy, right?) On the first occasion, the pizza was so good we had to return. The service was nothing out of the ordinary, we ordered the Margherita pizza, and we also wanted a sandwich. We asked our waitress "Ava" for her opinion on the sandwich. She recommended the Uncle Mark sandwich, which we ordered. The pizza was so good even though there was more crust than cheese and tomatoes (as you can see in the picture). The sandwich was good too. After our meal, we went sailing for 2 hours on Lake Erie; we were hungry and decided to come back again. We asked for the same table because the place was not busy. And we got a different waitress. This time we had a racist waitress with puffy lips serving us. I say racist because she asked my friend for her ID when she asked for a beer. My friend is not from the US, so she showed her her national ID (which is the same ID she used earlier in the day, proving she was 21+), and the waitress said, "I can't serve you alcohol with that ID wait... let me ask my manager" after I watched her come and go to other tables for several minutes--that indicated the issue she raised wasn't her priority. We, as customers, were not of her interest since she had not returned to us. Then as she was going to other tables, and she wasn't returning with her manager or a solution to her issue, we decided to leave for the lack of service and bias discrimination. We headed to U Pick 6 Public House, and I cannot stress enough how different it is. The service, well, the staff at Public House is more mature and on point, and the menu is the same, except it includes a more extensive beer selection. We had a great time there, and we both agreed that the place was nicer. So I would suggest that if you are looking for a good pizza place and you are not from around here, choose U Pick 6 Public House over Tap House. It is the same restaurant menu, except that the beer list includes more beers, the staff is very attentive and welcoming, and there's no racist discrimination drama. read more

U Pick 6 Tap House - Margherita pizza (slice) - Pubs Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

The cider was decent. However. There was no toilet paper in the ladies room, there was a roll of paper towels. Don't order the nachos, it's clearly chili from a can with canned cheese sauce thrown in the microwave. The chips don't even scoop the toppings. Save your money and your appetite for some place else. The waitress was very nice. But there are four hostesses fooling around at the counter, you can't even walk to the bathroom without toilet paper in it. read more

U Pick 6 Tap House - Nasty soggy nachos, if you enjoy cheese whiz and Hormel chili in the microwave, this dish is for you. - Pubs Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

Fifth time here over last 3 years. Food has been mostly good. This time was different: both pizzas were very undercooked leaving a doughy mess in the insides. Pretzel appetizer was overcooked. Surprising during Restaurant Week, too. Service was fine. Because of this, probably won't return for a long while. read more

We had excellent service and excellent food here. Staff were very friendly and attentive. We would have went back during our mini-vacation but wanted to try other restaurants and bars in the area. We would go back if we vacation in Erie again. Walk outside in their outdoor area, fairly near our there read more

U Pick 6 Tap House - Menu - Pubs Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

See all

I came here after work with a few friends at the suggestion of a friend that went here earlier for a beer. It's definitely a nice, chill place to grab a beer and hang for a little bit. I ended up sitting at the bar with friends and we got some dip, pizzas, and beers! I'm not a huge beer drinker so I went with the cider they had available and it hit the spot. My friends got the pumpkin IPA and really enjoyed it as well. Pizza wise, I got the chicken cordon bleu pizza and shared that with a few others pizzas. I will say the chicken cordon bleu pizza was a winner and I'd order that again. Overall, I really like the place and it's not as loud as a typical bar which in the current pandemic makes complete sense. Despite that, they did a good job keeping the tables apart and not letting the inside get super crowded. read more

U Pick 6 Tap House - Chicken cordon bleu pizza I think very tasty - Pubs Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

The food was not good and the service left a lot to be desired. This place is not what it used to be.

I was excited to try this restaurant. We felt so rushed to order. It was like our server wanted us in and out - as quickly as possible. I ordered a side of mayo with my burger/fries and when it came I asked where my side was - and my server actually pointed to the mayonnaise that was squirted on top of the burger? Am I not allowed a side of mayo? Kitchen running short? We were not checked upon for drink refills either. I was surprised how bad the service was. We couldn't wait to get out of there and go somewhere else. read more

See all

Food and service are always fast and good. Come here for lunch frequently and they always get our food, drinks and check to us promptly. The building, bar and seating is comfortable and the atmosphere is great. read more

I got a flight of beer and flatbread during happy hour and it was a steal. The chicken pesto flatbread as absolutely to die for! Soooo good! It wasn't that packed during happy hour and the waitress was super kinda and fast. read more

Very friendly staff, even though my group and I had to split bills and all various cards. They went above and beyond to do everything nice! Food was delicious and a great value!! The pizza muffins were soooo good! I had never heard of such a thing, but they were tasty! read more

We really enjoy the Tap House. It's a place to get acquainted with beer and ale varieties and sort which appeal to your taste. You can get samples to choose a selection you want with a meal. The tap house gives me a chance to find a style and brand of brew I like. I enjoy getting an introduction to new options. Service is great and food is good. read more

Fabulous food! Excellent service! Beautiful outdoor seating! The tasty burgers are enormous. The fresh cut plank fries are cooked to perfection. The artichoke dip is seasoned to tantalize your taste buds with delightful dipping chips and sourdough bread sticks. read more

U Pick 6 Tap House - Pubs Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

Today made my second visit to this establishment. My first was two weekends ago when my wife and I got away for a weekend in Erie. We chose this location for dinner one night, since they had an outdoor patio, and we were also permitted to bring our therapy dog in training. My wife and I both ordered flatbread pizzas which were really good. I also had a flight of beer, six different kinds that were numbered and coincided with the extensive beer menu. The servers this evening we're very friendly. They even have an outside bar window so you can sit at a bar stool and your right inside the bar. The only drawback of the patio area is that it is a little tight Because there are several tables and chairs, especially bringing our dog. Today I sat at the outdoor window bar, and ordered a steak and avocado salad. Got the blue cheese on the side. This is a very large salad and I left extremely full. Again very friendly staff and great service. I will definitely be back when in this area. read more

See all

What a great Irish pub. Hands down John (owner) perfected his tap for Guinness. It's a perfect pint every time. The menu has a wide variety to fit anyone's fancy. I had nachos (add steak - it's so good!) and the Italian'boli. Both were outstanding. We had a big party and everyone was so happy we closed it down over pints. If in Erie check out this spot it's a ton of fun!! read more

I have been to their public house location but this was my first trip to the tap house. We came with a party of 7 on a Saturday around 5:30pm and we were seated immediately. Love the decor with all the beer taps. Would have loved to partake in a beer but I was there for an Athletic endeavor. I ordered the turkey avocado sandwich with a side salad. It was really tasty. The tap house is kid friendly. We brought my daughter who is 2 and I saw several families with small children. They have some outdoor seating that I would love to check out next time. read more

Good service, place was busy, seated right away. A bit loud, but decent. Ordered pizza and stromboli. Both were very good. Fresh dough, good taste. Mary was our waitress, recommended a beer of the 22 on tap, and helped with food. read more

See all

If you're visiting your student at Gannon, give this place a try. Great menu variety. The burgers are delish!!! Street parking a available. Opened for dining in during Covid. read more

U Pick 6 Tap House - Reuben Bites - Pubs Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

We were looking for a welcoming dinner for four that could accommodate my parents and my older brother (who happens to be vegetarian). Our family was only going to be in Erie for a few days and we wanted to have a dinner in the downtown area. The dining area and bar were dimly light and the atmosphere was warm for the wintertime. Erie can be kind of dreary so it was refreshing for the weather to not be terrible for once. Our server gave us great beer and wine recommendations as we were able to take in the Christmas decorations hidden throughout. The appetizer list was about ten selections deep, with plenty of options to please any kind of eater. We settled on the Asiago Artichoke dip, which was perfect for a group of four and came with warm tortilla chips and thin bread. The food menu consisted of a variety of specialty flatbreads, pizzas, burgers, wings, house specials, Stromboli's, etc. The flatbreads seemed to be excellent portions, as two of the people in our party enjoyed them. I had the carbonara pizza and chicken tortilla soup which were perfect portions. This was probably my longest review ever, but this place really made me feel at home and the drinks and food were unique and satisfying read more

See all

This place rocks. Was visiting Erie Pa for splash lagoon. We asked the girls at the hotel and they recommended it. I was a little worried when walking up because of my kids. Walked in they set us right up with kids menus and a craft thing they played with until the food came. The craft beer was amazing as was the food. It came fast and had great service. Thanks so much! read more

U Pick 6 Tap House - Pubs Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

There are a few locations of U Pick 6 but I think they are all worth checking out. It's a mix of a restaurant and bar feeling to it. They have a wide beer selection and the Italian 'boli is wonderful. Would recommend. read more

This was probably some of the worst service, or lack there of, that I've had in all of my yelp reviewing. You would think with a large group of people looking to spend quite a bit of $ and time in a restaurant would get treated with even a small level of hospitality and kindness. Instead, I was told by a server to use "logic" when I thought someone in our party had informed staff we were out on the patio and simply asked if we'd have a server outside (when he came to check on a table next to us). He pointed at sign saying we'd need to go inside, I thought we had, so I was just asking as to be sure. He then acted as if it was an inconvenience to take on another paying table. You'd think, that even with that miscommunication, a restaurant would train staff to be courteous and say "no problem, let me get your order." I don't always believe the customer is right, but in this case, the condescension and attitude was totally uncalled for and really left a sour taste. We gave our business to the bar across the street, and I think anyone else should too. They actually greeted us, welcomed us, and thankfully we enjoyed our night and dinner in the end. You can do better, Tap House. read more

Was here with a group from work just down the street. We had a reservation and were seated quickly and the drink orders were taken right away. 9 waters and 2 sodas which arrived quickly. The food arrived fairly quickly and looked good. I opted for the spicy burger and was very disappointed. It was dry and very over cooked. After reviewing the menu online it said that they are always cooked well done and juicy. I agree with the well done but there was no juice to be seen. The only heat was from raw jalapeños. The sriracha was not noticeable and there was a big hunk of the end of a red onion that wasn't even edible. The same group will be returning for another lunch in a couple of weeks and I will try something different after I ask my coworkers how their food was. read more

After reading the reviews I had high expectations for this local pub, however, there is more to the story. I was greeted by a friendly hostess, seated quickly, and my server was great. They have a nice selection of beers, but ask the price before you order. I tried their featured Sierra Nevada Hazy Little Thing. It was good and served quickly in an 12 oz. can size glass. So far so good, but the bill came and the glass was $5.25 before taxes and tip. I ordered the Reuben sandwich and thought I would splurge and try their featured baked pub fries. The food came quickly. The Reuben was tasty and typical Reuben. The fries came in a "cole slaw" size cup was at best half full. The manger was rounding and ask how everything was and I said good, except that I paid extra to get the pub fries and showed him this skimpy serving. He said "yeh, that is the way they are". He did offer to substitute something else and I said that is fine, I just won't order them again. So you be the judge..... 12 oz beer, standard Reuben sandwich and an order of fries about the size of a McDonald's kids order for $15.37. I laid down $20 because my server was as sweet, friendly, and attentive as any I have had. Sorry I did not catch her name.... I am not cheap, but I am also not foolish. Just wanted you to know and think before you ordered. read more

The food and drinks were fantastic along with the service. The owner was even nice enough to come over to our table multiple times to ask how things were and check in. The service was great. We will definitely be back in the future! read more

Came here for late lunch with a friend. We were informed by our server that it was happy hour (4-6pm) 50% on their flat breads and pizzas. I wasn't expecting much since i'm in Erie...but wow. The place were patronized by lots of locals. I also enjoyed the gastropub-ish feel. They have a wide selection if beers, but i don't drink so I don't really know what is good. We ordered a cheese pizza, buffalo chicken pizza, grape bacon balsamic flat bread and shrimp pear flat bread. I liked the grape bacon balsamic flat bread best because the salty bacon was paired well with the tart and a bit sweet grape and balsamic, followed by the buffalo chicken, which had good flavors like ranch, buffalo sauce, celery! I didnt care for the shrimp pear because I thought it was too sweet and too fishy for my taste. The cheese pizza tasted flat. Come by Tap House and check this place out:) read more

U Pick 6 Tap House - Bacon Grape flat bread, Four cheese pizza. buffalo ranch pizza, Shrimp flat bread - Pubs Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

Excellent food! I was a block away at a hospital and I just couldn't face the cafeteria one more time so I walked a block and that's how I ended up here in this marvelous eatery--- which also is an amazing brew pub. I'll let someone else rave about the beers, I'll be raving about the food. The smoked, baked wings are so amazing! The salads are big and tasty. I had a crab cake salad and crab cake appetizers. We ordered pear with smoked cheese and balsamic vinegar flatbread. Yum! We liked it so much we went back 2 more times in the next 24 hours. Chef came out and talked to everyone to get feedback. Unassuming and genuine interest in our opinions of his food. This has a youngish vibe at night when the beer is flowing. Noisy but manageable. I was there at one in the afternoon one day and there were kids outside in the garden area. At 4:30 it's pretty quiet. Actually it was a great place to get away from the pallor of the hospital. The waitstaff are great! Very attentive. The kitchen is really just a HALLWAY! Some delicious food is pumped out of that little space. I can hardly wait to go back there with beer drinking friends... read more

See all

Only been here one time (tonight). Won't go back. They were slow and bartender (didn't get her name but glasses, brunette, long hair) was utterly bland and perfunctory. Least friendly, most boring service so far in Erie. Will not go back. HOWEVER: beer selection was decent, and place is kinda cute. Maybe other staff are better. UPDATE: well, guess I'll bump this review up a star or two as a result of super responsive message here on yelp from the establishment. I did not call a manager, but I typically do when service is outright bad. But when it's just bland, bored, not friendly and/or perfunctory, I just make a mental note that this is "one of those places" with a "not very friendly vibe". Not really the thing you call a manager over, actually. Some places are warm and welcoming - which I prefer - and some places are more cool and detached. My experience with this spot was that it's the latter, to a fault. read more

We went for lunch with a group of about 20 in between hockey games. Without reservations, SURPRISINGLY, we were sat immediately. The restaurant was pretty busy, usually a positive sign that the place is good. I kind of felt bad for the our server. (When I was a waitress, I HATED gigantic partites). She did a good job... Had a few mistakes but we're all human. One lady in our group asked about a salad but then ordered a pizza instead. The salad was brought out to her. NBD. She loved the salad- didn't send it back. And I ordered no mayo on my sandwich... Not only did they put mayo on it, bonus, I got a side of the goopy disgustingness. Ah well. I also did not send it back- just scraped it off. Do many people send food back? I don't like to... You never know!!! Anyways, great menu selection! Had a hard time picking because there were so many great-sounding options! I went with a new item: turkey avocado sandwich. It was delicious! Was craving fries but was surprised that they don't offer them, instead, kettle chips- which were tastey. My husband had the French dip. Others in our group got the chicken bacon wrap (was thinking about ordering that), wood fired pizza, burgers... This place has a great beer selection but unfortunately, I'm preggo and couldn't sample their vast selection. This is definitely a cool place! Would love to return if ever in the area again. FYI: Metered parking lot right around the corner. read more

I have to admit - the price is right! The food is not that great. Our group of four had: 3 burgers, and a ruben. The burgers were huge - at least a 1/2 pound after cooking. A burger that big needs to be offered the option of how you want it cooked. Mine was under seasoned & way over cooked - It came with onions, red & yellow peppers, and jalapeno ... all raw? It was weird - I can understand the onions and maybe the jalapeno but raw peppers ... Everyone else said - just passable. The fries are baked? ... stick to deep frying them - they put them in a small bowl and the bottom ones got moist - it was bad. Our appetizer was a big soft pretzel - which was under cooked [as in not brown enough] but the dipping sauces were outstanding. I have to say pass on this, I will try others before trying this place again. read more

A sister location to the Public House in Millcreek, they provide an impressive offering of craft beers. From IPAs to Porters to Lagers, most tastes can be satisfied. Inside, you will see a place with exposed brick, giving it an urban feel to it. The menu is limited to a selection of flatbreads, sandwiches and a few miscellaneous offerings. We started with the tortilla soup, which is very good. Next, I chose the crab cakes. Unfortunately, I did not like the texture at all. They were rather mashed up inside and did not have the structure of ones from the Baltimore area. We mentioned it to the manager to Gretchen, who was very kind and gracious. She made everything right for us. So, customer service does live in Erie! read more

U Pick 6 Tap House - U Pick Six - Pubs Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

Go to any other location. Great place but the manager here literally made a waitress ask to comp a meal from her own pay. Total joke Please email me derekcarstairs@gmail.com read more

We were visiting Erie for a girls weekend and to be safe, made a reservation at you pick 6 tap house because it was supposed to be graduation weekend. Our reservation was for 7 but we were running 20 minutes late (called and gave them a heads up). It was Saturday night and the place was not crowded when we got there. The food was decent, not really any complaints from our group, however the service was awful and the reason for the 2 stars. Our waitress was clearly uninterested in serving our table- it took forever for her to come take our orders and heaven forbid she ask if we wanted another round of drinks. She actually sat at a table beside ours with a friend and had a drink of her own while we sat with empty plates and glasses in front of us. The manager came over to see how everything was and one of the girls I was with actually voiced our dissatisfaction and the manager laughed and walked away. I don't know about any of you guys, but that's not how you handle a business. I don't think any of us will darken that door step again. read more