Ordered an ice cream for delivery and it was ready quickly and I appreciated that they threw in a spoon too. I do wish my chocolate waffle came in a separate paper baggie instead of wiggling around in a plastic bag with the ice cream cup. Tons of mix ins so I maybe wish I didn't order extra but that's on me. Really tasty! read more

Cold Stone Creamery - a hand holding a cup of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

We ordered 3, 2 scoop Sundays. The ice cream was very good and the caramel topping, A+! Everything was still frozen and not melted.

One word.. RUDE! Horrible service. Waited 30min for an online order and she let half of our other order sit on the counter. So while they were making the other half of our order everything was liquid by the time everything was done. Would not recommend this location to locals. Poor moral with staff and run by poor management. read more

I know my flavor preferences aren't that the "kids" like these days but if you have Butter Pecan on the menu, it's what I want. So I ordered what was supposed to be "butter pecan". You'd think there would be pecans in it. But, nope. None. You want pecans in your butter pecan?, you better pay extra. The ice cream I got was mid way between soft-serve and hard pack ice cream...kind of odd. Also, a strange grey-ish color. I've never ever seen butter pecan this color! I've been eating it for more than 50 years. What I got tasted chalky. I ended up throwing it away. Won't go back. read more

Checking in gives a 10 % discount .Wonderful customer service! The girls were so helpful and offered samples of the flavors. Did not hesitate when I asked to make a substitution on a menu choice! No pressure to upscale for additional items Very clean and welcoming. read more

Quickly greet by 3 team members that offered to answer any questions we may have and also offered samples. We picked out items and all 3 of them assembled our ice cream creations. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Banana Carmel crunch - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

I suspect heaven smelled just like this creamery! Store was super clean and the girls were super friendly...which just made the treats even better! read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Smiles and Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Awesome service from Allyn and Kate!! Great attention to detail and superb customer service! Made our 5 person family order seem equally important! read more

When we like to treat ourselves to a lil something special, we hop into this creative little Ice Cream shop just off Sadler Road. It's tucked very neatly in a corner & often overlooked. Almost everyone is familiar w/ what Cold Stone Creamery has to offer - choose your Ice Cream Flavor and then pick your Mix-In's such as fruit, candy, syrups. This location is trying hard to be the perfect local Ice Cream parlor ... they employee young adults, who are likely still in school or recently graduated. They aren't very well trained in offering pleasant Customer Service, but they aren't rude either. They are just getting the job done. We stopped in on a Saturday evening to treat ourselves for our Anniversary. We felt rushed & hurried even though we were the only customers in the store. Since we don't stop in as often as we'd like to, it took us a few minutes to read the board full of signature creations, browse the available flavors & decide from all the wonderful options. The young ladies behind the counter did okay, but there was no smiles, no pleasantries, no excitement. Not sure what I was expecting, but I was underwhelmed. There was some confusion on the Yelp offer of a free Waffle Cone upon check in. And, I had been chosen as the winner of a free Pint of Ice Cream through a Facebook promotion so they had to call & verify it with the owner after I had verification pulled up on my phone. While we were waiting for them to figure everything out at the register & over the phone - our Ice Cream creation completely melted :( The ice cream is heavenly - as long as yA get to it as soon as it's been mixed because it begins to melt as soon as it's scooped out of the freezer & they begin mixing!! Maybe they should keep it cooler inside, or check to see just how cold that mixing Stone really is. We have visited other locations who actually had a Stone that had a thermometer on it to ensure it stayed at a colder temp so your creation stays cold as it is mixed. We had to ask for a punch card, & these young ladies didn't seem to notice our disappointment, or care when they passed us cups of melted ice cream creations. We spooned up our liquid $12 desserts & tried to just be positive and enjoy ... Hopefully our next visit will be more satisfying & we will KNOW to grab that cup the instant it's filled so we can enjoy it while it's still in a solid form. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Cream Brûlée w strawberries & blueberries - SUPER YUMMY!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Had the best tasting ice cream for a super cheap price! Definitely recommending this to people I know!

My family stopped by after a dance recital. We were pleased with the large selection and the prompt service. We left satisfied. Great job Cold Stone! Mission accomplished! read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Oh also, the ice cream was delicious! Super friendly staff and will definitely be coming back! read more

Great ice cream and even better service by Allison, Sydney and Emily!!! I would highly recommend trying the Coffee Lovers or the Cookies Make Everything Batter. read more

Great experience. Tremendous service. Quality ice cream. It made for a special time with my granddaughter.

Quality ice cream. I'm not a huge fan of ice cream but when I want some higher end ice cream we come here. They have dozens of toppings they can blend into your ice cream. read more

Very very good selection and the ice cream we got was tasty! The establishment was clean and sanitized and staff was helpful. Definitely will be going back SOON!!! read more

Outstanding service. Emily, Sydney, Allison were all wonderful. Great service made the great ice cream even better. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - customers in a cold stone creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Good variety of ice cream. It's pretty expensive though. Staff was friendly. They do let you taste the ice cream first, so that's good. Their vanilla was too sweet for me though. The lemon was perfect! read more

On a Saturday evening my wife and I decided to treat ourselves to Cold Stone for dessert. We sampled a few new flavors since our last visit & quickly chose our desserts. I had my usual chocolate & peanut butter signature creation & my wife chose the Creme Brûlée Signature Creation that was also the current advertised creation. Inside the store was neat & orderly. Everything looked well organized & clean behind the counters. The outdoor seating area was also well kept and easily accessible while offering adequate lighting to enjoy your ice cream after sunset or late evening. The service was average, not the best, but I've also had worse. The young ladies working the counter that evening seemed to be distracted, and just went through the motions. It just wasn't what you'd expect to get from Cold Stone Creamery, or any ice cream shoppe, really. Our creations were delivered to us almost fully melted & they didn't seem to be concerned at all. They didn't even notice our dismay at being handed a cup of creamy liquid instead of a nice smooth mix of Solid Ice Cream, and we were the only customers at that time. I'm sure we'll go back - because even the melted creation was still satisfying, but it would have been better in ice cream form. read more

It started my day with a smile on my face. I'm not from these parts but I do like ice cream. This Cold Stone filled the void that my co-worker and I felt while working out of town. From the moment we walked in we were greeted with a smile and samples of the new flavors of the day. I enjoyed my experience so much that I was compelled to write a review. Yelpers its ice cream plain and simple, and this Cold Stone delivered with a positive up beat attitude :) Who'd a thunk the best Cold Stone I would go to would be 3000 miles from home. read more

Megan ,Kate, and Chelsea, they were amazingly awesome and very kind hearted so I was going to leave a decent tip but then learned that that don't split the tips evenly and coming from a person that used to work in a restaurant that sucks so I didn't leave a tip Bc I wanted them to get the tip not the owner, the owner should definitely give them their tips read more

I've been to many a-coldstones in my years traveling around and though the product is always good, it isn't my favorite. I stopped in ColdStone Amelia Island this evening to treat myself and my husband on our way to see our daughter. The service was impeccable. Bailey and her friend Emily were so patient as we tried flavors. The girls gave us their recommendations and went as far as to put my icecream in a size up cup so it wouldnt drip. The girls were just fantastic, two of the best and kindest young people my husband or I have ever come across in customer service in all our years. We intend to frequent this coldstone many times to come when we are in town and look forward to chatting with the girls again. Fantastic job! I am not one to leave reviews, but these girls earned one read more

Sydney is amazing! She takes great pride in her work and making her customers happy! She did a great job, asked us exactly how we would like our hot fudge sundaes made... Right down to where we wanted to fudge placed! Great job. Cheerful attitude. Such a pleasure to come in here. read more

Service was fantastic Megan Kate and Kelsie were all very energetic and happy to serve us and they were all very helpful in choosing our flavors, but i was disappointed in finding out that my tip for THE GIRLS great service was not going to anyone but the owner who wasn't even working!!! Gross and disgusting that and owner could in good conscience take tips from those girls. read more

This is one of our favorite stops after dinner on Amelia Island, but tonight was extra special. We came in close to closing time, but even this late into the evening all the employees were in such wonderful moods! Kelsey in particular went above and beyond in making this a memorable experience for our three young children. Even behind a mask we could see that she was smiling ear to ear, and she went the extra mile in connecting with us. Thank you, Kelsey, for your professionalism, kindness, and positive energy! We feel the love, Cold Stone! read more

My ice cream was made incorrectly, soupy and missing pieces. Very disappointed when you pay $7 for ice cream.

basic ice cream shop.. was fun and pretty good. icing was terrible though and stained everything

Great service, good ice cream, and the new owners really turned things around. 100% recommend!

We stopped by on a "whim" and our entire family was sure glad we did! The wait was short and the staff was friendly. There were 8 of us and we had our cream in about 5 min. Place was Clean and outside tables were a nice touch. We will definitely come back next year! read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

I mean it's cold stone icecream! It's just good stuff. I stopped in one night 4 minutes before close. The young lady didn't give an eye roll, attitude or anything. (As she shouldn't but most in service industry don't like last minute customers) this lady was friendly and so nice and understanding me being 9 months preganant this icecream was going to make me happy! Thumbs up for excellent icecream and top notch customer service! read more

Excellent service and GREAT ice cream! A must have while visiting Fernandina Beach! The loaded peanut butter batter is phenomenal!