Cold Stone Creamery

Loved the cake tasted great, loved the decoration, showed them a reference picture of what I…read morewanted and they did exactly that!

Ordered a carrot cake. Requested they add raisins and nuts to cake…read more No occasion- just because. It is delicious! Truly delightful. Well done!

Crosscut goodness!

See all

Cinnamon Raisin French toast!

Mel's Downtown Creamery - Pawcatuck

4.2(90 reviews)

1.8 mi

A family owned, old school ice cream parlor that brings you back in time about 50 years. I can…read moreappreciate a good homage to what once was. I am all for new trendy vibey establishments but there's something so special about that old school classic vibe. There is so much attention to detail when the branding was designed that mustn't be over looked. The owners are also outstanding humans and constantly giving back to the community and supporting Local fundraisers. The staffing is usually on the younger side but I can appreciate a young teenager that wants to get out there and work in the community. Social interaction is super important in one's growth and you get to experience that first hand the more often you visit. I have always had great experiences, and I believe the owners are doing things right when they are interviewing and finding goo staffing. You can tell Mel has a passion for baking/culinary/sweets and provides an absolute top notch experience. From sundaes to ice cream flights and even big kahuna challenges, there is literally something for everybody. The menu is forever changing with seasons and customer input :) I tend to bring my young boys in for a small treat on the summer weekends when we're in downtown Westerly. We purposely plan on getting there at opening which is noontime. At that time of day they are much slower than later on into the evening. This allows my picky/indecisive boys to try a few flavors before committing to something. They can also perouse all the candy/ sweet treats, which they will inevitably convince me to get something to take home with them. I highly recommend stopping in for an after dinner sundae after a nice dinner at one of the other local dining establishments Cheers *****Spoiler alert. I cannot wait to see the finished product of the step side ice cream/sweet treat truck, coming to a town near you***

I love an old fashioned set up for icecream and shakes, etc. Unfortunately, this place does not…read morehave it. The floor was dirty, the back counter messy and not well kept. The person that was behind the counter was completely immersed in the latin song that was on the radio. The decor has 1950's decorations but no 1950's music. She was unkept herself. The shake, not good at all, bland and did not ask if I wanted whipped cream, the service crappy. Need to update the facility and get help that wants to be there.

Banana Split

Soft Serve Vanilla Ice Cream

See all

Camryn's Mystical Unicorn Shake

Nana's Westerly

4.3(115 reviews)

1.9 mi

A rainy day calls for going out for breakfast, and in this case, it was Nana's. We were staying at…read morean Airbnb nearby and our host recommended this place, so we decided to try it out. The GPS led us to a parking lot, with a good number of spots and Nana's was 20 steps away. They do have a patio with a few tables but because it was raining, we went straight inside. When we arrived, there were only a couple parties seated, but by the time we were mid-way through our meal / leaving, the place was packed. Our server helped us with understanding some of the items on the menu and also warned us about some of the iteme they didn't have, like pepperoni, mushrooms, and donuts. With that in mind, we ordered risotto balls to start and the pesto egg and cheese sandwich (baked fresh eggs, pesto, cheddar cheese, lemon aioli, brioche roll) and Dijon and lemon chicken salad sandwich (slow roasted chicken thighs, lemon aioli, herbs, local greens, pickles, and side of fries) for the main meals. The Yaupon iced tea caught our attention since it has indigenous tea with rotating fruit fusion so we ordered one just to try it. The risotto balls came out a little sooner than the other items. We loved the crispy outside, but not a huge fan of the inside since it was mostly risotto with not enough cheese or something to glue it all together. The sauce tasted like a fancy marinara - it was tart, lightly sweet, but a tad acidic and herby too. In our minds, we imagined our main plates looking differently, but I think it was mostly because we didn't do a good job of reading the menu. The pesto sandwich was good. The eggs reminded us a lot of a quiche-spongey and light. It did not have a strong pesto flavor. The roll seemed homemade; it was good and airy. The Dijon lemon chicken salad sandwich was okay. The chicken thighs chunks were tender, and I could definitely taste the pickles, lemon, and Dijon. I think it needed more salt or even something sweet to balance out the acidic flavors. The bread was well toasted. The fries were delicious with the right amount of salt, crispiness, and variety. The iced tea was not our favorite as it tasted overly sweet which might've removed any fruit flavor. The staff was very attentive, they have lots of tables and high chairs to choose from, and lots of natural sun coming through the large windows.

This place seems great. Lots of fresh food options, lots of fermented stuff and their coffees/teas…read moreare also really good. Their Cesar salad is amazing. Donuts are good, baked goods are really good as well. The atmosphere is cute and the service is good. It was a little pricey, which is my one negative. I think the salad was like $21 and it was not very big. Still good though.

Pepperoni sweet and spicy - SM (neo style)

See all

Nanas spritz

McQuade's Marketplace

3.2(51 reviews)

1.6 mi

Great little market but the prices are completely insane and out of line... they take inflation and…read moremultiply it by 10.... the place is clean and staff is friendly but it's just not worth the gouging!!!

Love the place love the prices love the help behind the bakery counter the fish counter the meat…read morecounter, but the girl cooking breakfast throwing F bombs everywhere complaining about people looking at her waiting for their food. Took 20 minutes to get breakfast. Wow they stood around and laughed and joked. Some people don't have that kind of time in the morning so I felt it was very disrespectful.

See all

Whiskey Brothers Project

5.0(1 review)

2.9 mi

Terrific new lunch takeout spot. Ordered the Cuban sandwich and was impressed with the complexity…read moreof balanced flavors. Absolutely delicious sandwich and not at all greasy. Will be back to try the other sandwiches on the short list as well as the ramen. Hope these folks do well in the space where both Loveridge bakery and many years ago where Pizza Lady was.

From the owner: Whiskey Brothers Project is a craft batch Soups & Sandwiches Take Out, as well as being one of…read moresoutheastern Connecticut's best high end caterers. From scratch cuisine to impeccable service, Whiskey Brothers Project can fill a plethora of your culinary needs!

See all

Blue Rocks Catering

4.5(13 reviews)

1.6 mi

We hired Blue Rocks Catering for our wedding, and it was hands down one of the best decisions we…read moremade. Our planner recommended them, and after comparing menus from other vendors, Blue Rocks stood out with their creative options and emphasis on fresh, local ingredients. We booked a tasting with our chosen dishes and were blown away--the food was better than restaurant quality, and our only hope was that they could replicate it on the big day. They absolutely delivered! The hand-passed appetizers on the Fort Adams lawn were a huge hit--especially the bacon-wrapped dates, scallops, and mini hot lobster rolls. Dinner was equally amazing, and impressively served hot and fresh despite the challenges of an outdoor venue. Our planner, who has attended countless tastings, even commented that it was some of the best catering she had ever experienced. Highly recommend Blue Rocks to cater your wedding or event, Katie was awesome, making everything easy and taking control over any and all requests, big or small! Thank you so much!

This is a little late, and I apologize. Our wedding was 11/22/25, and I cannot say enough about the…read morequality of the food. Our guests are still raving about it. I will certainly continue to recommend them to everyone who is looking for a caterer. That said, this was a second wedding (both of us in our 70's) and most of the planning fell upon us. We hired their coordinator for the day of and once we dropped off our centerpieces, etc., for the reception, I was free to spend the rest of the day getting ready, relaxing. I didn't have to worry about a thing at the wedding. Noelle was terific. Everything was just as we had pictured it at the ceremony and reception. It was perfect. I hope I can work with her again as we plan a few family events in the future

See all

Joyce's Everyday Gourmet

4.8(19 reviews)

0.2 mi

Everything here is the epitome of home-cooked delicious food. Today I got a grilled steak salad…read more Excellent amount of steak with delicious fresh greens. Everything is extremely fresh. Wonderful staff, pleasant and ready to help. Self service coolers make it a great spot to grab a quick and delicious lunch.

Everything here is excellent. Fresh gourmet foods daily. Fresh bread, pastas, salads. Excellent…read morepies, cakes, scones.

Beef shepherds pie with sweet potatoes instead of mashed potatoes. These come in 2 varieties. With corn or with peas.

Today's haul. Sweet potato topped beef shepherds pie; a shaved steak panini; an oatmeal raisin cookie

See all

Shaved steak panini was delicious

Griffin's Cakes & Pastries

4.6(8 reviews)

0.7 mi

Fantastic!!! so delicious everyone was raving about the cake and cookies! super friendly and…read moreresponsive! would recommend in a heartbeat for any of your cake or pastry needs!!! Delicious!

I didn't getting cakes from Griffin cakes for the past five years. Always moist, always delicious,…read morealways on time. She's very busy because her quality and execution is so spot on. Some of the best cake I've tasted and with a beautiful personalized touch.

Oatmeal cream pie whoopie pies

Whipped cream frosted 2 tier cake

See all

Fairy cake

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Amanda M.

15 years ago

Cold Stone Creamery is one of my favorites. As for chain establishment it's very nice. It's always clean and the staff is friendly. Sometimes they're not consistent on the portions or the add ins and if your taking the ice cream to go you only get a spoon if you ask. It's always quite in there and there is seating. read more

Jason C.

10 years ago

This one is the best Cold Stone hands down!!! They are awesome! Always treat you great, have a smile and the ice cream is outrageously good! Just remember to look around there, It is spotless. That is a HUGE thing for me is how clean a restaurant is and this cold stone is CLEAN!!! read more

Angie G.

10 years ago

Very friendly staff, delicious ice cream forever!!!Loveeeeee it.

Cold Stone Creamery - icecream - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Cold Stone Creamery also viewed

Tootsie's Ice Cream

4.1

(17 reviews)

This is my pick for local ice cream. Tom makes all of the ice cream. Last week I tried some black…read moreraspberry. It was nice and creamy and full of summer flavor. I asked him last year if he could make any sugar free ice creams. Well he got to making some. He now carries no added sugar vanilla or chocolate, and low sugar strawberry. The chocolate was fantastic. Stop by and enjoy a cone

The icecream was sooo good here! I believe they make it themselves. I got a hot fudge sundae, a…read morenice base of cold, velvety vanilla ice cream with warm drizzle of fudge. So simple but so delicious. You can tell when ice cream is good, and you'll understand that if you're a big icecream eater lol and this was great. The girl working was nice, and the place itself has a cute ice cream toy area for kids to play. The decor on the tables are little ice cream candles too. Nice touch.

Mango's Homemade Ice Cream

3.4

(42 reviews)

Good solid homemade ice cream. Really nice young people working there and good sized portions…read more We had gotten a chocolate cone, vanilla cone and peanut butter and chocolate cookie dough cup of ice cream. Everything was tasty and the prices were what you'd expect. Nice little shop in old mystic if you have a hankering for ice cream.

Ice cream shop in the Olde Mystick Village that is partnered with a pizza place and serves up ice…read morecream from Windsor S B in Rhode Island. I did not love their ice cream (as I felt it was a too icey) however I did love their homemade waffle cones. My chocolate chip ice cream had plenty of chips in it as well. They had a decent selection of flavors, but nothing spectacular. There was some seating outside but none inside, however this may have been due to COVID precautions 3/10

Rita’s Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

4.1

(29 reviews)

Had to stop while on vacation in Mystic as we don't have one close to us at home. Parking lot was a…read morenegative and seating outside was too . We were a party of 5 with one in a wheelchair. So we opted for sitting in the car to eat . Too hot to make it back to hotel without melting . We got two of the custards and three of the icees. Flavors were plentiful and everything tasted great!

Always delicious and always worth the stop! We got introduced to Rita's when our daughter moved to…read morePhilly. Have found them in a couple other locations and were thrilled. I personally love their gelati!! For you who are like what is she talking about.....it's layers of icee and creamy custard! So refreshing. Mmmmmm

Seven Birds Ice Cream

3.2

(21 reviews)

Got a little sweet treat from Seven Birds Ice Cream as we walked around Old Mistick Village…read more We gravitated to the "Extra Special Flavors" and come to find out, they serve one of our favorite Connecticut-made ice creams: Honeycone of Chester, Connecticut. The Cranberry Oatmeal Cookie was calling our names and we each got a single scoop. The scoop was very small for $4.75, but we very much enjoyed the ice cream. There were a lot of other seasonal options and a variety of vegan flavors. The hours of Seven Birds may vary, I've noticed they'll close early during rainy weather. It's likely a big hit during the summer season when the village is very busy. There isn't much seating near the Seven Birds building. If you are visiting from out of state, I highly recommend trying one of the Honeycone Ice Cream flavors here if you find yourself at Olde Mistick Village.

It was alright. Not a lot of flavors to choose from. They were out of a few as well which is…read moreunderstandable because it was a very busy day around there. The service was pleasant and prompt. Could use some more benches but overall was a good ice cream.

Dairy Queen Ltd Brazier

3.6

(20 reviews)

Good location, tight parking spots, pretty speedy service. Well trained staff. Queueing on the…read moreoutside is roped off in a single line until you get into the building. Then it's a free for all between the 3 windows. All of the ice cream products are well blended here. This location doesn't offer any food items.

The menu offers food as stated on their menu on Yelp, however, it is wrong and only has hot dogs as…read morea food option. This page says they have salads and grilled chicken.....

Mystic Park Ice Cream

4.4

(15 reviews)

Just fantastic ice cream with the perfect benches to sit right nearby to watch the boats. Had…read morecookies and cream with PB topping and whipped cream. Hit the spot!

Right by Mystic River there's a little Candy Shop selling, candy, chocolate and ice cream. You'll…read morenotice them by the pink and green balloons. The ice cream can be purchased at the window. They had a very long list of available flavors. Some are traditional, others are a bit more unique. I got one scoop of the Banana Cream Pie. This serving size was very generous. This wasn't the best banana flavor I've ever had. The banana was pretty weak. It was more vanilla, with a bit of banana sprinkled throughout. There were some vanilla wafers in this ice cream also. While the ice cream was alright, the location of this cream is much more appealing than the ice cream it's self.

Sift Bake Shop

4.5

(44 reviews)

NOW THAT IS HOW YOU MAKE AN ICED LATTE!! Take note people. A latte shouldn't just be flavored…read moremilk. Look at that gorgeous color. The house made caramel syrup was amazing.

Happy #wowmewednesday with Traveling for Perks! I'm wowing you with a sneak peek at @sift_bake_shop…read more. We went to the @watchhill_ri location. I had a delicious coffee that I told the barista to "surprise me" with as well as a raspberry chocolate croissant. The day prior we took a bunch of our kids to @watchhillmerrygoround which is always a hit! After Sift I drove up the hill to get the closest possible look at @taylorswift 's Watch hill home for a photo for my daughter! A great and relaxing time!

Honey Dew Donuts

4.3

(14 reviews)

So I took a random 4 hour drive to CT. I had to stop here for my apple cider. It's seasonal. Well…read moreordered 2 med but they only had enough for a med and a small. They said it was the last that had for the season. They only charged me for the one but gave me both cups. There customer service was amazing. They were very friendly. Now mind you I dont have them around by me. But have tried many things there. I would go there over dunkin Donuts any day.

Honey Dew Donuts is great! The food and drinks sure beat the other guys. Friendly staff. Even the…read morepuppers got a treat at the drive thru.

Ben & Jerry’s

3.9

(34 reviews)

This is a small store front in the restaurant area inside the casino. So something you visit when…read morealready at the casino. It is very loud in this area right near the indoor waterfalls. The one person on duty was very busying during our visit and managed to help everyone quickly and accurately. Lots of flavors, cones, cups and shakes. No seating, take away only.

Always a great time for ice cream! The only time it's a pain is when the line is super long. They…read moremake their waffle tones onsite so it always smells like vanilla baked goods. I personally enjoy a simple chocolate ice cream on a waffle cone here. Service is always good!

Aunt Carrie's Ice Cream

3.4

(62 reviews)