This is pizza as it should be. No frills. Filling but not you're-going-to-need-to-roll-me-out-of-here filling. The margherita is perfect, the closest thing I've found in the area that tastes remotely like NY style pizza. I will gladly leave Portland on a 25 minute excursion to get eat this pizza. Lunch during the week had customers in and out, but it was easy for us to get a table. Very friendly, neighborhood style service, where everyone's a friend, even if you've just met for the first time. read more

Drove down from Portland to try Coletti's and we were NOT disappointed. Coletti's offers a Neapolitan style pizza - which is important to know. Very different from Greek, New York and New Haven style pizza. Deliciously different from what we usually get in Portland. We ordered online but ate in the restaurant. The service was very good, friendly and knowledgeable. We had the Margarita pie and the Sausage and Broccoli Rabe pie. My husband is a pizza snob and he LOVED the broccoli rabe pie. Both pizzas were cooked perfectly with generous amounts of cheese. The margarita pie had just the right amount of basil. But the star of the show for us was the sausage/broccoli pie! We had never had broccoli rabe on a pie before. The broccoli rabe was tender, well seasoned, and had a floral note to it, the crust was chewy with just the right amount of char and the sauce added just the right acidity. The only thing we felt was lacking (slightly) was the sausage. It was so mild that you almost couldn't taste it. It was cooked well and no gristle at all - just lacking that sausage flavor that you expect when you order sausage on your pizza. Regardless we would and WILL order it again. We will definitely be back and strongly recommend Coletti's if you are in the area. If Coletti's is looking to expand - please come to Portland! read more

Coletti's Pizza Factory - Homemade sausage and broccoli rabe pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Biddeford, Maine

The flavor of this highly talked-about pizza is bland. It's not sweet, thank goodness, although some folks like it, and it's not savory (garlic and tomato forward) this pie is neither, so like I said bland. Also, the shape is terrible - too thick and puffy on the outside and too thin and flimsy closer. It's impossible to pick up a slice. I was very excited due to the hype, but when it arrived we were disappointed. read more

I went here for the first time recently and in my opinion, the pizza here is extraordinary. The crust is perfect. The spicy pepperoni was my favorite pie. As I was eating in the restaurant, I ordered another pie to-go because I knew that there wasn't going to be much left over. Highly recommend. I'll drive from Portland to get pizza here going forward. read more

Awesome margarita pizza with eggplant. I'm always impressed when I order pizza from Colletti's read more

Phenomenal pizza, the friendliest staff, and Francesco is the nicest guy! 5/5 experience, my new favorite pizza place. What a gem. read more

Coletti's Pizza Factory - Beer - Pizza Near Me - Biddeford, Maine

See all

Saturday afternoon, very quiet, no music playing but something is on in the back kitchen area. We sat at the high top and there's additional seating at a bar in the back. Super friendly staff and owner came out to check on us and our food... very special! Pizza was delivered to us piping hot with fresh, quality ingredients and a nice char on the bottom. The sauce and crust are delicious! Will definitely stop by again when passing through and try the spicy one. read more

Great. Very casual owned localy and yummy. The wait is sometimes long but its worth it!

Love this little place. Owner and chef is originally from Naples Italy. He's is great fun to talk to but he's often too busy cooking and serving. The pizza is award winning. It is primarily take out. Very small seating area which is not all that comfortable. But, 5 star pizza!!! read more

This is the best pizza in the area no question! The chef is in their everyday whipping out fantastic pies so you can tell that love and care is put into ever since pizza. I got the margherita to keep it basic and it was anything but basic! great flavor, great crispy crust, and great fresh ingredients. I got take out but even just walking in the staff was so amazing, Collettis himself wanted to pose with my pizza when he saw me spanning some photos! Also got the tiramisu for dessert and wow!!!!! Might have been better than the ones i had in italy, even my friends who don't like tiramisu were going crazy for it. Everyone must try this place. read more

See all

Work birthday and the guest of honor wanted Coletti's for lunch since he had heard such great things. We got a margherita and another with added ricotta and sausage. WOW - both were excellent but I am seriously in love the ricotta and sausage. So much so I am ordering one for myself (and the 4 cheeses) to bring home for dinner tonight. Best pizza I have had in a very long time! I wish I had pics to share but it was gone really fast! read more

One of our fave pizza shops when we first moved to Maine and lived in Pine Point. Now we are much further away in Freeport, but decided to trek down to get one our fave Maine pizzas. It had been 6 years! Still super yummy, I think the pizzas are bigger now. We ordered 2 as I thought they used to be more individual+ size but maybe my mind didn't remember correctly. Hey leftovers right? We got the spicy diavola which was always our go to. Not as spicy as I remembered which actually was a good thing. Super cheesy and the basil within so yummy. I actually think the pizza crust edge got even better or mine was just perfectly cooked. They do a lot of takeout. Even saw out of state tags coming. We sat inside and ate. They also have a few dessert offerings. This place frequently makes the rounds of top pizzas in Maine so definitely check it out. read more

See all

Wow! I had the pleasure of eating at Coletti's and having their classic cheese pizza. That was DELICIOUS. Service was amazing, music was nice, and it was small and quiet. Sometimes it's the hole-in-the-wall locations that have the best pizza! read more

How fantastic is this authentic pizza that tastes delicious and the high quality ingredients make you feel like dancing! Goooooo! Best pizza I have had here in the North East and I have been a LOT OF PLACES! This is TOP! Thanks Frank, we don't know you but WE KNOW YOUR AMAZING PIZZA ARTIST. read more

See all

The best pizza in Maine. The crust was delicious, the sauce was so rich and flavored well and the toppings - wow. The folks working there were so kind, and we can't wait to come back. read more

Coletti's Pizza Factory - #4 Spicy Diavola Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Biddeford, Maine

Up north to help my parents out with some things around the house and did the research in Old Orchard Beach to Portland. Obviously Portland is the major city around here so that would be the spot to go but then again, this is seafood country so when I went there a day ago I couldn't help but get a lobster roll at the highroller. SO it came down to Pengs and Colettis and it just so happened that Pengs was randomly closed so I begrudgingly opted for Colettis. I was excited but as soon as I took my first bite of their cheese pie I needed a gallon of water from how salty it was. We got a cheese pie and a sausage, onion, pepper, and garlic pie and the crust was the only reason I would give this an additional star from the bottom. Super disappointing, couldn't even finish the cheese pie and while the other pizza was edible, they were super skimpy on the sausage and OD on the peppers. Don't get me wrong, way better than Dominos...YES I HAD DOMINOS MY FIRST NIGHT BECAUSE IT WAS 12:30 AT NIGHT AND I GREW UP ON IT. But unfortunately this place did not live up to my hopes for it and it hurts me to say it for a spot that clearly has good dough but I would pass. I've read a lot of good reviews which is why I drove 20 minutes to pick up their pizza but how does anyone making pizza add salt consciously or accidentally? The other pie had no salt taste and 4 people tried the cheese and nearly gagged. read more

Coletti's Pizza Factory - Pizza Near Me - Biddeford, Maine

Looking for a Late lunch and came across this pizza joint on yelp. Nondescript building looking like a house yielded that warm, wafting Italian bready smell of pizza cooking. Order at the counter, a limited list of specialty pies with a toppings list that can be added on to create your own. A short list of cold canned beverages are available. Our pie was brought to us, by the friendly staff, as soon as it was out of the oven. It was delightful, slightly spicy sauce, gooey cheese and crisp crust with hints of basil. We enjoyed every slice. You might want to stop in and give them a try. read more

Coletti's Pizza Factory is a pizza restaurant in Biddeford, Maine, known for its authentic Italian-style pizza, which blends Neapolitan and New York traditions. The owner, Frank Coletti, is from Naples, Italy, and personally makes the pizzas, The restaurant offers takeout, delivery, and catering, and is often described as a "hole in the wall" with a focus on high-quality pizza rather than a traditional dining experience. On the reccomendation of friends I decided to try Coletti's out. The restaurant is definitely unassuming upon entering I noticed several parties enjoying pizza and friendly conversation. The smell of pizza cooking was very inviting. I ordered a four cheese pizza and when I recieved it was not disappointed. The crust was thin and slightly charred with the edges crusty but soft to eat. The sauce had a nice fresh tomato taste and the blend of cheese delightful on the palate. The young girl at the counter was very friendly. For my first experience I was very impressed , felt the pricing was reasonable and look forward in trying more of their pieces. I recommend Coletti's Pizza Factory read more

Coletti's Pizza Factory - Pizza Near Me - Biddeford, Maine

See all

I came here for lunch today at 2, the sign said open but when I went inside there was nobody there. I'm sitting here as I type this review, it's very strange. I've said "Hello" a couple of times and waited several minutes and nobody answers. I can hear a TV playing loudly in the background so I guess they just can't hear me? read more

Coletti's Pizza Factory - Vacant area? - Pizza Near Me - Biddeford, Maine

Tastes Just like the pizza grew up with in East Boston and Chelsea!! Crispy and authentic..

Delicious pizza and excellent customer service. Comfortable dine-in option and very friendly owner and staff. Can't wait to go back!! read more

I would like to give Coletti's 10 stars. This place is my idea of a perfect pizza. Walking in this place is unassuming. It is not fancy it's just pizza and drinks and a few tables. We talked to the Italian chef who is the real deal. I knew we were in for a good meal. We got the normal cheese and then a spicy sausage with ricotta. And a bottle of red wine. The pizza was divine. Perfect crust chewy and flavorful. It wasn't too greasy. Cheese ratio was perfect and although the spicy indeed was spicy the combo with the ricotta was out of this world. I know you have tons of options for pizza but this is a real deal Italian pizza and worth a try! read more

Best pizza I've had ever, anywhere and I'm old. I'm a big fan of NY style pizza but Colletti's is its own style - better than NY. Odd that it's in Maine - almost worth a visit to Maine just for this pizza. read more

The pizza is absolutely dynamite! But the service is horrible. I've tried calling in pizzas early knowing that they are very busy which is a great thing! There's one staff member running crazy trying to keep up with the phones and the foot traffic. Like I said the pizza excellent, but you better order your pizza 2 hours in advance. Either way it's awesome stuff! read more

Grew up on NY/NJ pies. When we moved to Maine finding a great thin crust pizza was out of the question until Frank opened Coletti's. Spot on every time. His dough is perfect and his sauce, also perfect. The Mediterranean,add sausage, is our go to but they are all very good. Be sure to bring home desserts when they are available because you won't find anything as authentic as Coletti's. Frankie C knows his stuff!! DJ read more

Best pizza in Maine, possibly New England. Authentic Italian pizza. Don't go if you like Dominoes pizza.

I was told this is the best pizza in the area and it is absolutely true! I'm from LA and have had pizza in NYC and Chicago...this is better!

Lived in a neighborhood that was half Italian growing up and had great pizza there. Was glad to find Coletti's when I moved to Maine. He has the best pizza around. Authentic and not loaded with garbage like they do in the midwest. Crust is wonderful and toppings are great. Service is always good too. read more

To drive down the street, you wouldn't necessarily notice that the business houses a pizza artist. That is a mistake. The facade is underwhelming and no frills. The dining room is bare bones, unadorned yet spotless. You go to Coletti's for the pizza. We sought Coletti's out at the recommendation of a local weather broadcaster, an Italian from New Jersey. He knows good food and raved about it. (Insert happy dance here.) The pizza was screaming hot, on the most crisp and airy crust. Toppings were delicious and in a sensible amount. Two of us ate an entire pizza. We were full, and yet not stuffed. There was none of the heavy bloat. After we finished, the owner came out to ask if we enjoyed our meal and told us about his process-cold fermentation of the dough and organic flour. It made for a very digestible and delicious pizza. We can't wait to go back! read more

Coletti's Pizza Factory - Sausage and Broccoli rabe #2 Artisan Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Biddeford, Maine

I've never had a better pizza in Maine. I've never had a better pizza anywhere in New England. Easily on par with the best pizzas I've ever had worldwide. When you see a couple low reviews in a sea of fives, what you're seeing is the Karen effect. They love their DiGiorno's freezer pies and having a fit in public places. Whatever. More for the rest of us. Ignore the whiners. I'd drive an hour for Frank's pizza. Have many times. read more

Best pizza bar one. We travel from nh just to get it. Been to Italy multiple times, this is just like Naples

Living majority of my life in Boston, and long time fan of New Haven and traditional New York pie, it's been a rough go up in Maine since we moved here six months ago when it comes to finding a good pie. This is as legit as it gets! Now for the owner, totally bat sh*t crazy but in a great way! If you ain't eccentric, you ain't my type of people, you're probably putting out a subpar product. He's passionate about his craft, and has no time for your stupid BS! He'll let you know . Don't piss him off! We will be regulars from here on out. read more

Good pizza, tasty. The sauce was delicious- and it comes with basil. My only complaint is that the pepperoni could be of higher quality- see picture. Otherwise the people working here were very friendly. Oh and my wife says the pizza was soggy. I agree. read more

Coletti's Pizza Factory - Pizza Near Me - Biddeford, Maine

Hands down - best pizza in Maine! Possibly all of New England. Perfect Italian creations in every pie they make. Crust is a masterpiece, especially on cloudy days when the atmosphere is just right to create big puffy air pockets! Eat in for piping hot fresh cheesy goodness or take six pies home for the whole family or office party. read more

Best pizza ever. Be patient, it's worth it! Old fashioned ambience. We hope to go back someday.

FABULOUS PIZZA!!!!My Boston friends drive us 90 minutes for this pizza!!!So perfect .., the dough .. the cheese .. the sauce ... too good for words !!! read more

Lewiston by the sea has outstanding pizza! The dough is thin and crispy. The toppings of pepperoni, sausage and peppers were perfectly cooked. The San Marzano tomatoes and creamy mozzarella masterfully placed this pizza into a different stratosphere. It doesn't take rocket appliances to know that this is the best pizza in the State. read more

Coletti's Pizza Factory - Sausage, pepperoni and peppers. - Pizza Near Me - Biddeford, Maine

Absolutely 5 stars. Pizza place focused just on pizza. Neopolitan style. I have attached the menu as it was difficult to find on line. You can also create your own pizza. The crust was perfect. The ingredients were super fresh and I believe they make their own sausage. Prices are great. They take cash or debit. They have a parking lot. Small tables inside but too hot in summer with no AC. read more

See all

So I once again made my way to Biddeford for yet another Frank Coletti masterpiece. All I can say is "Amazing"! Pepperoni and sausage. ... perfection. I have said enough about this fantastic pizza. What I am sharing today is my strong recommendation to heat up your leftovers on a pizza steel at 400 degrees. The crisp returns and it is as good the day after as it was when Frank handed you the pie. Again, I love this pizza! read more

See all

The pizza was delicious, but the owner left a lot to be desired. The place was packed on a Saturday night, likely due to being featured on Maine Life that morning. From the kitchen, you could hear the owner losing his temper, but things escalated when he came out into the restaurant--where families with children were present--and began shouting. As we all waited for our orders, he started cursing at patrons, looking us directly in the face while ranting about to-go orders. The poor employee handing them out seemed overwhelmed, and instead of taking responsibility, the owner grew frustrated that customers weren't checking their orders before leaving. Isn't it the establishment's job to ensure orders are correct? I grew up in the service industry--I was a bartender and know what it's like to be overwhelmed when a place is slammed. But if I ever needed to blow off steam, I stepped outside. Losing it in front of customers? Completely unprofessional. I hope the owner takes tonight as a learning opportunity and maybe be more prepared for a busy night especially after being on a local television show read more