First time here and I really enjoyed their seasonal flavors , the apple pie and the pumpkin pie cheesecake are delicious. I opted for the warm brownie sundae and it was yummy. I would go back to try more of their flavors, give them a shot. read more

Colonia Dairy Maid - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Colonia, New Jersey

See all

Great ice cream Lines are always long Too bad they don't accept debit or Apple Pay. read more

Yesterday was special! Got a gorgeous cake from Colonia Dairy Maid. It was the best ice cream cake ever!!! What quality products, plan to try more . Staff is knowledgeable and service is timely . Had a line out the door so that tells you everything you need to know. read more

There's a reason the line's always out the door! After my son's baseball game or my daughter's dance practice, this is one of our favorite spots. A true staple in the community! read more

A local institution, they don't make them like this anymore! Forty different flavors, many of them unique, all quite tasty. For the price, you really can't get a better deal - this giant cup of ice cream (a regular, apparently, was just $6). It certainly isn't the best ice cream you've ever had, but it is quite good, and an awesome throwback and a necessary stop if you've even remotely close in the summer. Cash only. read more

Colonia Dairy Maid - a cup of ice cream with sprinkles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Colonia, New Jersey

Looking for a local ice cream shop, then this is the perfect spot to go to after dinner or just for a treat. This shop has a lot of flavors, and there are a lot of workers working behind the counter. The parking is not bad at all because there are a lot of spots in the back. The line also moves really fast even though the line goes out the door. The cost was about 4-6 dollars, which is great for the amount of ice cream. This place only takes cash, but do not worry, there is an atm machine right behind the counter. MC got peach with mango ice cream, Nick got the cookie dough, and I got the chocolate fudge brownie with nuts. They were all super tasty. Make sure to bring water because after eating all that ice cream, you start getting really thirsty. Overall, I would recommend anybody nearby or passing by to try this ice cream shop out. Watch out for people walking around when driving around this area. read more

See all

Remember to bring cash!!! Great selection for great prices. Just wished they accepted cards. Service is fast and the girls behind the counter are always polite. read more

Colonia Dairy Maid - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Colonia, New Jersey

I'm back after 2 years ( I can't believe it's been that long). The options are so overwhelming too me but I guess it's also a good thing that they have so much to offer. I got 3 diff flavors and toppings and was satisfied with my order. My partner didn't enjoy his as much. He says he's has better (can't remember the exact flavor). They still have outdoor seating which I love and of course be prepared to wait in line as it's always still busy. read more

See all

I love this place especially as the weather gets warmer. It's a perfect place to go get a diverse option of ice cream and sit outside and enjoy it. I didn't give a 5 star rating because I always forget to bring cash and it's cash only. They have an ATM on site but the fee's are insane as most businesses are. The service is always great and the staff is usually very friendly! read more

This establishment has a charming ambiance, but its location on a busy road restricts the availability of parking spaces, despite having a decent parking lot. My partner, who is a native of this area, frequents this place often, and we have visited it several times. It is always crowded with customers. The waiting time can be quite long, but conversing with each other is not a bad way to pass the time. The place can get congested at times, as there are many patrons who crave an ice cream, but the ice cream is worth it. It satisfies the palate and is very flavorful. I always order the vanilla cone with sprinkles. If I ever order anything else, please make sure I am alright. The service was commendable for what it was. A few young employees behind the counter were running around frantically and tiredly, but they did an excellent job. This place has been in operation for a long time, and I understand the reason. Good service, good read more

Really great service, got there as it was closing and they opened the doors with open arms

This place is so cute! Right on route 27 I've driven past it so many times and finally stopped by. There's a small parking lot on the left and behind the ice cream store. This place is CASH ONLY. FOOD - limitless flavors and flavor combinations! tons of toppings too not just sprinkles. They have milkshakes and Italian ice too. I was basic my first time and got small cone vanilla soft serve with sprinkles. I love that they fully coat the soft serve with sprinkles. I asked for an empty cup so I could use it in case the ice cream starts melting. Instead I put it upside down in the cup and it fit perfectly. The small cone soft serve fits a medium cup. SERVICE - friendly staff and very quick turnaround on order time. When I went there was a long line so there was someone outside taking orders. The menu is inside it's written big but there's soooo many flavors that if you haven't been here you need time to read through. That's partially why I just got vanilla. COVID - the inside is completely closed. There are two windows, one for placing your order and one for pickup. You stand around outside while waiting. I wish that they had the menu painted on the windows or on a chalkboard outside. Since we can't go in it's hard to see the menu unless you stand up against the window. Check out my pictures I zoomed in and took pictures of all the menus best I could. read more

See all

The ice creams are delightful, however the staff here has been rude. Its not our first time experiencing the rude nature of the staff at colonia dairy maid. I mean you are an ice cream store and you should know how to be sweet and nice to kids and customers, however none of the young staffers here know any of that. We were regulars, however, this was our only visit in 6 months and the same rude, abrupt and sharp behavior continuing. read more

Colonia Dairy Maid - Bubblegum flavor with sprinkle cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Colonia, New Jersey

This place was good, they offer alot of flavors for ice cream; soft serve, sundaes, shakes, cakes and even ice cream sandwiches. This place is located off of a major road and does have parking for the customers. This is a cash only business, and I do believe they have an atm inside. It's small inside, so there aren't any tables or places to stay and eat your sweet treat. It's basically counter service and the expectation is to go. I wish they had a place to sit, I don't live in the area and I would have melted ice cream by the time I arrived home. Overall, this place has a lot of traffic and the locals must frequent. read more

The ice creams are really yummy. My favorite is chocolate nut brownie fudge. The only reason to give 4 stars is because of the server with pink hair (sorry don't know her name) is extremely arrogant and behaves like she is super frustrated. She continuously pushes you to hurry towards checkout. Even the customer after me felt the same and expressed it to her but she was still being rude to all the customers. Management I would strongly recommend if you want to keep the business up and running please focus or staff or provide training Good staff is the key to success read more

Colonia Dairy Maid - Menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Colonia, New Jersey

One of my favorite local spots. During the summer months it can get crowded but it's worth the wait. My favorite is the waffle cone ice cream. read more

Colonia Dairy Maid - Strawberry, Cookies & Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Colonia, New Jersey

This is our favorite ice cream place in middlesex NJ. It's cash only so please make sure to be prepared. They have great flavor ice cream here for affordable prices. My boyfriend loves the sorbet here and i don't blame him. please make sure to visit Colonia! read more

Colonia Dairy Maid - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Colonia, New Jersey

This place has a ton of flavors and a lot to offer. It is very small inside and is basically a tiny walkway to order ice cream. However, the parking lot is randomly big for the space and the establishment has a proper small seating area in the back to enjoy the ice cream. I had the peanut butter butter cup (I think) but whatever I had was delicious. It was chocolate ice cream with peanut butter and tasted like a Reese's. The ice cream is as smooth and creamy so it was delightful. However, some of their flavors tasted a little freezer burnt which might impact the customer experience in this establishment. Nonetheless, a small is a lot of ice cream in my opinion so it's worth a try. I would skip the ice cream sandwich but it intrigued me because it was soft served ice cream in the middle. Maybe their soft served ice cream or Doll whip isn't that good? That would be a question to answer next time but for hard ice cream I would recommend this place (hopefully the flavor isn't a littler freezer burned). read more

Colonia Dairy Maid - Ice cream sandwich - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Colonia, New Jersey

See all

It is good place for great ice cream nice selection of flavours and good service. The people are welcoming and the place is always busy. The ice cream itself is yummy and creamy. There is seating around the place but none in the store itself. Wish it was closer it is 30 min drive from my place. read more

Good afternoon I was there on Sunday with my wife we order the twist soft ice cream she ordered the vanilla with rainbow sprinkles I order the The chocolate i was very disappointed no flavor the chocolate very weak maybe was a bad batch or the product is not the same . Hopefully they will correct this I will give it one more try thank you read more

Colonia Dairy Maid - Soft ice cream .Twist and plain Vanilla. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Colonia, New Jersey

Colonia Dairy Maid is a staple of the town and has been serving for 25+ years. This is a cash only place so make sure to bring the cash. This local ice cram shop is open all year round. Prices are extremely reasonable. Great variety of 40+ flavors, 20+ toppings and various cup sizes. Soft serve ice cream is so fresh. Monster shakes and ice cream sundaes are also awesome. whatever you get, you can't go wrong at this place! On summer nights you may have to wait in line, but it is so worth it. The lines move quickly as they keep plenty of staff in the evenings for the summer time rush. The ice cream flavors change for the seasons and are creative and homemade! read more

Happy Tuesday my Adventurers! I have been coming to this ice cream shop since I was a kid. It really hasn't changed much except for the faces behind the counter and several flavors on seasonal rotation. Everything is pretty fresh and rich with flavor.. I personally like the chocolate marshmallow with rainbow sprinkles or the chocolate soft serve with rainbow sprinkles. It can get really packed---to the point the line is winding out into the parking lot. Quite annoying if you literally want one thing but that just means the place is extremely popular. This is going to sound dorky, but a few years ago they had one I think it was called Smurf--bright blue ice cream that stained your entire mouth with marshmallows. Clearly sensing a theme here, but it was so creamy and unique plus a riot when you smiled. I purchased the sugar cone a few days ago with 3 large scoops of ice cream and didn't finish it. Had to store in the freezer for another day but it cost about $5.50! Will be a loyal fan for future generations to come! read more

Colonia Dairy Maid (also known locally as "40 Flavors") is THE place to go on a hot summer night. I couldn't park until somebody else left. I had to wait on line ten minutes. WELL WORTH IT. The wait was long because EVERYBODY IN ISELIN was there. The eight staff were really hustling. Ok, so first things first: great ice cream. Great toppings. Generous servings. Fair prices. GREAT service. Jamie made sure she got my order right. She checked back with me step by step (I was getting a rather complex banana split) and she was happy to do it. Big personality, great energy, she made the experience fun. One small criticism, they say 40 flavors but I only counted 34. 36 if you count the soft-serve chocolate and vanilla. There's a reason this place has been in business for like 50 years. But don't take my word for it, just look at how many people were there tonight. read more

See all

It's an really nice ice cream store. If it can be made with ice cream, they have it. The soft serve comes in vanilla and chocolate but there is always be an additional flavor like raspberry or banana. They also carry a couple of sugar free ice cream. The prices are about the same in any of the store like this but it's about the cones and ice cream. I would recommend them highly. read more

This is my favorite ice cream spot! The servers are always friendly and sweet. Jamie is always a pleasure. I go all year round. As usual, they let you taste a small sample of whichever ice cream you're interested in. They've got more flavors than most ice cream places I've visited and they've got a good assortment of toppings. They get long lines all day in the summer, but there's a good reason for that. They also don't have seating so keep that in mind. Definitely worth a visit if you're in the area. read more

See all

Lots of flavors to choose from as well as toppings. Staff and friendly and very accommodating. I usually get the chocolate ice cream with brownie bites, walnuts, topped with homemade strawberry sauce. read more

Colonia Dairy Maid - a hand holding a bowl of cereal and strawberries - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Colonia, New Jersey

I'm one of those weird people who isn't super into sweets, but when I find something sweet I love I latch onto it, and Colonia Dairy Maid is one of those places. The store is an old style place with a slanted roof and tables/benches outside to eat the delicious treats you purchase inside. The interior is an area to order with a huge chalkboard sign overhead that lays out all the amazing flavors they have to offer. The staff is always cheerful and greets you with friendliness even towards the end of the day when I'm sure they're getting tired. Colonia Dairy Maid has (as advertised on the side) 40 flavors of ice cream including coconut, pistachio, mango, mudslide, coffee and more. They also have a little over a dozen different flavors of Italian ice. Today I had their mango ice cream which was creamy and just sweet enough without being overwhelming (something fruit flavor ice creams don't always achieve). My girlfriend had the Passion Fruit Italian ice which was tangy and sweet with a wonderfully smooth ice texture. I've also had the pistachio ice cream before which had just the right combination of sweet and savory that I love. The portions are pretty amazing. A standard scoop of ice cream is called their "Dixie" size, which is about all I can take in one shot - all for less than $2. The small looks like a medium to me and so on, it's simply awesome. I have not sampled them yet, but they also have pre-made ice cream sandwiches and cakes that you can drop in and purchase to go. If you don't want to take my word for it, just visit on a warm day and see how many people pile into this place. I went today when the place was about to close and I was only one of three customers. By the time I sat outside to eat my ice cream over twenty other people showed up and they just kept coming as I left! I'm really happy that I found this place by accident. It's not far from where I live and it has wonderful, reasonably priced treats. I know I'll be back regularly this summer (and beyond). read more

See all

Ice cream is good but the service is eh. All of the girls in here are unfriendly. Almost not worth it for that reason. And for all the clowns that are going to say, "you go there for the ice cream, not for the personalities," you are the problem and don't know the first thing about customer service. They also close a lot earlier than stated on Google. They should address that and just adjust the hours to when they actually want to close instead of them being lazy and closing early. What's the Scoop in Metuchen is a better bet. Better ice cream, better prices... and better customer service. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ read more

My friends and I went to Colonia Dairy after hearing positive reviews from my other friends. There's an array of flavors to select from and we were indecisive. We ordered three different flavors: coconut, Swiss chocolate almond, and chocolate fudge nut. The chocolate fudge nut is the best-seller, according to the employees. All three flavors were super refreshing and creamy. My friends and I loved the chocolate fudge nut because there is a great crunch on the nuts in every bite. The coconut flavor was my second favorite because it's light and fluffy; it almost reminds you of a Pina Colada. The Swiss chocolate almond was very delicious as well. The Swiss chocolate texture had an extra creamy texture. All of the ice creams are made in house. Overall, this dairy is excellent, and I would recommend going early before the flavors sell out. read more

Colonia Dairy Maid - Coconut and chocolate fudge nut - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Colonia, New Jersey

See all

Love the Pineapple icecream here!! This place never fails to disappoints me. My favorite icecream is the Pineapple icecream here. It has chunks of pineapple in it which enhances the flavor. I have been here with couple friends as well as family. The only downside to this place is the limited amount of parking and the fact that they only take cash. I normally don't carry cash around with me so if i spontaneously make plans to come here and i don't have cash on me, i'm pretty much screwed. This is a strictly Cash Only place. I would appreciate if they started taking credit card as well. So one star off for that but other than that, amazing yummy icecreams and the prices are great! They have a lot of flavors so will keep coming back to try the others read more

Colonia Dairy Maid - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Colonia, New Jersey

Tonight was the first time I tried out Colonia Dairy it was amazing and the amount of ice cream you get is crazy! The prices are great we got three ice creams, it was only $20! We had banana split, cookies & cream cone and chocolate dipped cone they were all AMAZING! We will definitely be back! read more

Colonia Dairy Maid - Medium cookies and cream cake crunch cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Colonia, New Jersey

See all

Great priced ice b cream that locals love. Very nice people. Lots of options. Wish it was closer to walk to!

Unique flavors of ice cream, Cookie Monster!, at a good price. Recommended by a friend to stop here on a nice early summer day to relive her childhood. Well worth the trip read more

Colonia Dairy Maid - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Colonia, New Jersey

Who doesn't love ice cream?! Really?! Even lactose intolerant folks wants ice cream but sadly have to pass some times. After reading and viewing some pic reviews, I had to stop by here. I noticed on my drive that Carvel ice cream is literally down the block but it's empty comparing to this joint. As I pulled up and parked in their lot, (yes, there's a parking lot with plenty of parking spaces), I noticed the number of customers outdoors enjoying their ice creams. The second thing I noticed is the number of red benches and tables outdoors and there are plentiful seatings when comparing to other ice cream shops. Third, I noticed the sign on the side of their shop, "40 ice cream flavors"!!! I walked in and yes, even though there's a line of customers, it moved fairly quick. There's many staff and yes, they are all friendly. The most challenging thing is really knowing what ice cream to order. With 40 flavors to choose and also Italian ices, it was difficult to choose! You can ask for a tasting if you're not sure what to pick but be prepared for dirty glares from other customers as you're holding up the line. Kids come comes with a cone holder for any ice cream drip which is great. Their small cone is two huge scoops. Their small cup is about a pint size. Honestly, had I known the size of a small order, I'd share. The prices are a bit expensive similar to Dairy Queen's but hey, this is why I call it a sweet treat and not meant for everyday dietary. read more

Went there tonight and saw the server cleaning the inside of the glass with windex with all the ice cream uncovered and open below!!! Great to see they're taking precaution but the windex was spraying ALLLL over the open ice cream. It's common sense to not spray it over open food that you're serving to customers. Absolutely disgusting that they're putting chemicals in their ice cream. Never ever going back. Stay away from this place and don't give this ice cream to your kids!!!!! read more

Homemade delicious ice cream. We live so close and it's convenient. The staff is super friendly. My favorites are the soft raspberry and the hard rocky road. read more

I live 20min from 40 Flavors now but I was in the area this weekend and was so happy to stop by for a cone. Just like another reviewer mentioned, their mud pie flavor is AWESOME! So chocolatey, a little bit coffee-y goodness. It's both my sister's and my absolute favorite. If you don't know what flavor you want you can take a peek at the list from outside. They have a solid social distancing system in place where you order in one window and pick up at another. You have to listen for your order number but if you can spot what you ordered through the glass walls it helps a lot. Since I got 2 scoops on a cone (and one scoop was bright green mint chip) I knew exactly when my order was being completed so I could go right up to the pick up window and not leave the staff waiting for me. If you know this place you know how long the line gets, and that hasn't changed! If you can, I recommend trying to go mid afternoon when there are significantly less people. Once it's the dinner hour you'll definitely be waiting with a lot of folks but everyone is good about being safely distant :) Very happy to be able to support 40 Flavors during this unique summer season! read more

It's colonia dairy maid. You don't have to say more than that!!! Neighborhood staple. Best ice cream!! Hands down.

Yup, OBSESSED now that I got a chance to try the Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup. Also, the girls are doing a fantastic job maintaining speedy and efficient service given the circumstances! Always worth the 30 minute drive. read more

See all

Decent ice cream for a neighborhood spot. So many flavors that it was difficult to choose just one! I think there were 40 hand-dipped flavors total - whoa. I decided to try a scoop of the "Spongebob" (vanilla with M&Ms and brownie bits) as well as a scoop of the Cotton Candy. Both were good, but VERY artificial tasting/looking. I could see how these would be really appealing for kids, but I found both way too sweet and fake-tasting. Staff were friendly and prices were reasonable, so I'd give it another shot since I probably went a little crazy with my order! read more

Colonia Dairy Maid - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Colonia, New Jersey