the food was pretty good, Jesse our server was awesome and took great care of us. maybe think of using him in management

If you're looking for something similar to Texas Roadhouse, Colton's in Kirksville is a great option. The rolls were absolutely addicting, and it's easy to see why this place is so popular with the locals. My steak was a little tough, but the baked sweet potato was delicious. The real star of the meal was the ribs, they were tender, flavorful, and literally fell off the bone. I'd definitely come back for those! read more

Looks good inside makes for a good place to eat with your family, foods alright not great but decent enough. The waiters are very nice too at least its not fast food read more

Oh my goodness! This Colton's restaurant was INCREDIBLY PHENOMENAL! I was traveling with my elderly father-in-law who tends to be quite messy. This place was clean, orderly and full of BEAUTIFULLY KIND, FRIENDLY & CARING mostly young ladies. The food was DELICIOUS! I was highly impressed With Ellie at reception & our server Frances, both were so nice. read more

We love to support local when in new towns. We did a bunch of that but wanted a steak so came here based on other reviews. Long story short - think Texas Roadhouse. Popular place based on the dinner crowd. Everything we ordered was good and the service was also very good. Love the buns with honey brought out early. The smashed potatoes were also great. Would go back. read more

Not the best of Kirksville, but a good place to catch up with an old professor. We shared a rack of ribs. The salad was what I expected, and sometimes you just need an American diner salad. Ribs were fine. I left stuffed. read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - Ribs and Salad - Steakhouses Near Me - Kirksville, Missouri

Ate here while visiting. Typical chain restaurant steak place. Food and service was good... Only complaint is I hate when you just get started with your appetizer and then they bring your entree out early..... Need better timing! read more

Excellent service and the food is expertly prepared. The atmosphere is like that of a Western town. Highly recommend.

Ordered smoked 10oz sirloin on DoorDash for pickup. I have eaten this twice before in person and it's been great. I do not normally complain about food because it can't always be perfect and I would have left it at that had I not been treated so rudely by Colton's staff when I called to tell them my order wasn't satisfactory. The manager told me it supposed to come in two 5 oz pieces. The ones I had in person were one 10oz sirloin. What I got tonight was one 2.89oz and one 3.1oz(I weighed them on a reloading scale) of what seemed to be meat boiled in water with liquid smoke in it. The manager said sorry you didn't get what you thought you should and basically left it at that. No offer to make something else or refund my money. I will say for the most part the staff is great, you get your food fast but I feel like as much as I shop there I should have been treated better. read more

Good food, fast service. I got the Smoked Sirloin and a baked potato. Good meal with lots of seating

Expensive "food" that I wouldn't even feed to my dog. 4 Soda's alone were 20 dollars. Used to be a good spot to stop at and was usually packed. Now it's absolutely empty and for good reason. Never again. read more

Driving back from Nashville, our navigator took us through back roads of MO through IA. Trying to find something that wasn't fast food on Memorial Day was tough, but we landed on this place. What a fun surprise. Overall great steak option. Theme reminded me of Texas Roadhouse. They do serve rolls, but with butter and honey on the side. Peanuts are also available. Nice thing is they do ask you to check your steak to ensure it's cooked to your requested liking. What we ordered: Kids mac and cheese + fries - not box stuff Smoked steak w Caesar salad and loaded baked potato - only con was Caesar salad. Very light dressing and only served w red onions. Everything else was great Ribeye w two sides Hawaiian steak w sweet potato fries read more

Service was good but the food was abysmal. the picture attached will explain everything. This picture was taken after I sent it back the FIRST time read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - Prime rib special - Steakhouses Near Me - Kirksville, Missouri

See all

This steakhouse is pretty great. There foods that I eat are very good I recommend the Montana burger. Their service is excellent even when there busy. The ambiance a classic Wild West with their country music playing. read more

Colton's used to be great but recently they changed around all their ingredients to a much lower quality. It has ruined just about everything on their menu. Very disappointing. read more

wife enjoyed luncheon catfish and I enjoyed country fried steak. Service with good and the food was excellent. Do not not believe we could have a more delicious lunch. read more

The service has always been quick and the staff is friendly. They do have a braille menu for those who can't see but the staff will also answer questions you may have about an item or if a certain item is available or not. read more

Just love the strawberry pecan chicken salad! Thank you for having vinegar and oil! Always great service!

This is the second time we've had lunch there and both times were excellent. Our service was friendly, professional and quickly done. The server found out it was our friend's birthday and they brought her a bday sundae. It's a great place to lunch, meet friends, celebrate etc. read more

See all

Small town crew took my steak and almost full beer while I was in the restroom for less then a minute. Manger was mad at me for leaving my table for a minute, nobody came to apologize read more

Love this steak house. We have only ever had 1 bad server 1 time in 3 years. I would say we have eaten there 12 plus times over 3 years. We have eaten during wk. for lunch special, and on wk-ends for like fathers and mothers days. We have ordered sirloin, ribeye, burgers, chicken fried steak, dessert, sides and all been good. Last time we really got quick service and server came by often-she was fantastic. Peanuts upon request when you arrive. Great steak house, great pricing, great atmosphere. Now if the 3 of us could eat for $42 with tip would we go often-yes, but it is a steak house so more around $70 with steaks, soft drink and tip, so we go more for bdays, and other special occasions, but then again it makes it more special to go every once and awhile. We love it is local and we have a steak house. We love a good steak, and good service. read more

I am from Oklahoma City and came to meet family. Colton's by far is the best steak house I have been to. I'm 72 yrs old and have been to a few. Their rolls, house salads are fresh and flavorful. I like that there is not loud music playing and you can actually have a conversation. Let me say this about their Ribeyes. So, so good! Service polite and prompt. Thank you for a great time read more

Me and my wife came to Kirksville for Valentine's Day and decided to eat dinner at the restaurant. The Waiting staff was polite and very efficient. The food was hot and delicious. Two thumbs up. She even make sure that we got peanuts on the way out the door. Two thumbs up I would definitely suggest this restaurant and I will definitely be back. read more

See all

Ordered prime rib cooked medium came out cold to touch, wouldn't recommend if you like hot food.

Great place to go for a good meal and fantastic service. We had their steaks and they were tender and cooked perfectly. Our waiter was super friendly. read more

The food here was awesome! It reminds me of one of my favorite restaurants. I loved it and would definitely recommend it to anyone looking for a good meal and the prices are reasonable I feel for the portions u get. read more

It speaks volumes of a restaurant when you choose it to be the first place to treat out of town guests. The smoked ribeye is beyond delectable. Salmon here is mouthwatering. If the wait staff isn't certain rather than guessing out a question they go to the kitchen for their answer! I love this! I haven't tried a burger from here yet! But I feel confident it will be cooked to perfection and will NOT disappoint! read more

The food was ok. It seems like they stole the menu from the outback. The service was great, the young lady cleaning the bar and serving us was entertaining. The restaurant is clean and the bar has plenty of room for a few friends to chill and have a drink and meal. read more

See all

Service wasn't great. Tables with dirty dishes all around us. Ordered a draft beer and was told the keg needed to be changed but 10 minutes later brought an unopened bottle and said no draft. Trash all over the floor. We have eaten there several times and have never seen the mess we saw today read more

If you are ever in Kirksville ... this place is great. We went to dinner two nites in a row. We are still here. Might do a 3rd nite.

I had chicken fried chicken and it was delicious. Crisp, tasty, and not greasy. Service was good.

I have been here twice for lunch and both times it was very good. Easy to pick good local places like this because the parking lot is full at 11:30. As I like chopped steak (glorified hamburger patty), I chose this with smashed potatoes. The steak was cooked perfect served with grilled onions and green peppers. It was a 10 ounce patty and tasty. The potatoes were pretty good even though they were instant, but not the overpowering "instant" taste. I also had a salad which was excellent. They were smiling and welcomed me when I went in the door. I sat in the bar as there were quite a few people in the dining area and wanted to watch TV. Waitress was very good and attended to my needs. Gonna be a regular stop for me when in Kirksville. read more

Colton's Steakhouse & Grill - Steakhouses Near Me - Kirksville, Missouri

We dropped in to visit friends and with a party of 8 they quickly accommodated. The food was tasty and the service was good for a Saturday afternoon. Beat part was spending the afternoon with friends. The 6oz sirloin I had was cooked perfect and the vegetable and potato was great. Nice reasonably priced meal. read more

Quality is dependent on when you go. You might get a perfect steak or it may seem dried out and flavorless. I've gotten juicy burgers and burgers that barely touched a grill. So raw that it's falling apart and bleeding. The rolls are always good and the salads are usually great. Never gotten any grilled chicken that wasn't dry but the fried chicken items were flavorful. Their flavored teas are a must. Always check for their seasonal/temp items as they're normally good, especially the pulled pork nachos. read more

starting with the good, started off very great with whoever sat us!. but we sat down and waited about 15 minutes just for a drink order. I heard a lot of cussing from the back On her talking bad about her tables. She had kinda pink hair and i believe her name was Cassandra. I'm usually not the type to leave bad reviews but my experience was horrible!. read more

This place is pretty good. The steaks are alright . The fried pickles are amazing and the customer service is generally pretty good.

This place has amazing food and the staff are helpful and courteous. Went in for lunch and was helped by a great waitress named Alyssa who was super friendly and helpful. The meal came out in about 10 minutes and did not disappoint. I highly recommend if you are in the area! read more

Has went way downhill. If you are going to hire a fry cook, they sure aren't anything more, make sure they know when a hamburger is medium well and when salmon is cooked through. Hint, a bit charred on the outside of either doesn't signify doneness. The server was pleasant though read more

My wife and I were taken to Colton's steak house in Kirksville for my Birthday for October 5, 2022. This meal was for my Birthday gift from my kids and they joined us for the meal. They said this has always been the greatest place to eat. We drove 125 miles to Kirksville for this gift meal. This is the worse steak house experience I have ever had. Sent the steak back once because it was totally over done "brown" tough and dry, rather than medium rare. The second steak wasn't as good. There was no sour creme or butter on the dry baked potatoes and the dry rolls weren't any better. Would have been totally awful to swallow this tough steak without A1. .The waitress had put us outside on the patio as we had requested. We ran out of water. She never came back to refill our waters but offered to as she was going to run my sons credit card. All we wanted to do was get out of there as soon as she ran the card. My daughter in law told them in advance at the reservation desk so that I could be sung to and gotten desert because of my birthday. Nothing happened as we complained to the waitress over the meal and she was mad at us and just wanted us out of there. And I was very nice to her with my complaint. My daughter in law gave the front desk a "fit" as we were leaving. We had nearly a $100 ticket and my son gave the waitress a tip anyway. As we were leaving in the parking lot another couple overheard our conversations and they too were "livid" about their dining experience as well and the place was not even crowded. A fast- food drive-through burger would have been better. I felt sorry for my kids as this was their gift to me and they insisted on paying for this. Definitely not worth a $100 plus tip. Don Hamilton 573-324-3000. read more

I brought my mom out for lunch and we ordered appetizers and our entrees. We had fried pickles and spinach artichoke dip to start and they both were amazing. Colton's has the best fried pickles. Then we had mushroom swiss burger, and a Philly steak sandwich. The sandwiches were ok. The service was great. Our server kept our water and tea refilled when needed and even brought extra ice for my tea. read more