Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Commodore Barry Pool

    4.0 (8 reviews)

    Commodore Barry Pool Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Commodore Barry Pool

    Recommended Reviews - Commodore Barry Pool

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of James O.
    44
    33
    23

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 5
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 1

    11 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    15 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Commodore Barry Pool

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Swimming Pools 32,918 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Seahorse Fitness

    Seahorse Fitness

    3.7
    (6 reviews)
    1.5 mi

    I had to come here for a lifeguarding class and it was DISGUSTING. The deck of the pool was…read moreextremely disorganized, the pool water was sometimes cloudy and i'm pretty sure I saw a used tampon in it, and there were bugs flying and crawling all around. Not to mention, the floors were all grungy, especially in the locker room. DONT COME HERE IF YOU HAVE ANY OTHER OPTION!!

    Tommy is the owner of Seahorse Swim Club. In my opinion, he is the best teacher. I would highly…read morerecommend him to teach adults or children how to swim. Even the fearful children who cries due to water phobia and refuses to get into the pool, Tommy is the one who has a special talent and can persuade and teach with ease. I have withnessed it personally with my seven year old son. He would patiently teach the swimming techniques and follow through with the repetitive strokes, whether it is free style, backstroke, breaststroke. Can you believe my son, who almost drowned last summer, can now swim freestyle, backstroke and breaststroke? I am very appreciative to Tommy and Seahorse Fitness. The facility is neatly setup with towel and shower stalls. The indoor pool is consistently about 75-78 degrees temperature all year round. There are lap swimming lanes and general swim sessions. All swimmers must use goggles and swim caps. The locker room is a little bit outdated, but I believe the primary focus is the teaching staff and lifeguards on duty. There is always a lifeguard everytime I visit. The instructors are very capable, friendly, patient and experienced. Each instructors have their own specialty. One teaches butterfly extremely well. Another teaches breaststroke very well. I had each demonstrake their best qualities and taught my kids. Thank you Tommy and Seahorse Fitness!

    Photos
    Indoor pool
    Indoor pool
    Disorganized pool deck and dirty floor
    Disorganized pool deck and dirty floor
    Indoor pool

    See all

    Indoor pool
    Double D Pool

    Double D Pool

    3.8
    (21 reviews)
    1.5 mi

    They are open 11am-3pm then close for an hour from 3-4pm. At 4pm they reopen til 7pm. While these…read moreare the official hours, they hardly ever open on time. Usually it's about 11:15/11:20am. It is hard to understand why because there are usually a bunch of attendants sitting around in the front at 11am but they never open the entrance gate til around 11:15/11:20am. Sometimes they have to wait for the police attendant to come. Once they do open, it is pretty fast to get inside. They look to make sure you have a lock. They require you to rinse off before going into the pool. On the deck, they don't allow you to wear anything besides a bathing suit or a white tee and flip flops. Not supposed to bring food, books or cell phone out.

    I'm an original New Yorker born and raised in Park Slope Brooklyn, I still live in Park Slope, I am…read morevery familiar with this pool, and how it was before all the gentrification, lots of changes at this pool for the better, the pool has definitely improved, the pool is very nice but the staff is the same ol' same ol' NYC City Parks and recreation Staff hospitality, being that it's a city pool, expect to receive the same treatment as if you were in a City Jail, the Pool staff dosent greet you with a "Hello" they greet you with a "Do you have a lock?", "Let me see your swimming Shorts", Bag search, "No phones on the pool deck." The staff makes sure to harass you as much as they can, you aren't allowed to have fun, they have a problem with everything, no running, no jumping, no holding on to each other while swimming, phones must be in the locker and cannot be used in the pool deck. The kiddie pool was closed on this day I visited because someone shit in it. I actually read in the news that they closed the entire pool the week before on one of the hottest days of the summer because someone shit in it. Google it if you don't believe me. The atmosphere has definitely improved, but not worth coming here again since the staff likes to make sure that they manage every little detail and impose each and every rule upon you. You really can't have fun at this pool, everything is a problem, literally my 4 year old daughter was holding on to me while swimming, they said "No holding on to each other while swimming." This place has potential but as long as it's ran by the NYC Parks and recreation it will always be a toilet.

    Photos
    Double D Pool
    Needed on a hot day
    Needed on a hot day
    Double D Pool

    See all

    Asphalt Green - Battery Park City

    Asphalt Green - Battery Park City

    2.8
    (50 reviews)
    2.8 mi

    I visited Asphalt Green to drop in for lap swimming…read more The facilities are clean and bright. The pool has lots of windows and natural light. I was kind of intimidated, because I don't get to lap swim very often. I wound up sharing the lane with 2 or 3 other people. Everyone was really friendly and communicative regarding lane-sharing. Would definitely go back for a swim. The only thing I would change is add more time slots available for adult lap swimming.

    I have been a member for more than 3 years until late 2021. I used the pool exclusively, not the…read moregym, not the steaming room, so here's my review of the experience revolving the pool mainly. For what it's worth, I indeed noticed that the steam room has been closed for as long as I remember like other reviews pointed out. The pool is very sizable, and its length (25m) is perfect for lap swimming. It is very well maintained and I never had a problem with the condition of the pool. I swam a lot and this pool definitely satisfied my need for exercise. I had 2 issues with the experience with the pool. Firstly, I think the staff on the pool could do a better job at coordinating swimmers of different speeds in different lanes. Sometimes, you will have relatively slower swimmers chilling and floating around in fast lanes, which could be a pain for faster swimmers, and vice versa. On some days, the staff will coordinate and direct slow and fast swimmers to different lanes, but not always. In this case, you have to communicate with your fellow swimmers on the same lane, which is fine, but some days you just want to get in the pool, finish up your swim target, and get out, without worrying about bumping into people in the same lane. Secondly, there are definitely rush hours which the pool gets super crowded. It is quite often that I would have to share a lane with 3 other swimmers. And I recall I once had to share a lane with 5 other swimmers, though this is pretty rare. The new pool that I switched to requires scheduling in advance and allow only a maximum of 2 people in the same lane, which I like a lot. During COVID, AG also required scheduling, and I think there was a 3 people limit per lane, which I love, but that ended. These are minor inconveniences that did not hurt my experience. Overall I am pretty happy with what I got from my membership with AG. Also, the billing team has been wonderful, especially Josh and Nick. They helped me multiple times during my 3 years+ of membership with setting up my account, switching between different membership types, helping with my adhoc requests, and eventually canceling my membership. They were very responsive and helpful and made everything very easy for me.

    Photos
    Fitness Center
    Fitness Center
    Fitness Center
    Fitness Center
    Fitness Center

    See all

    Fitness Center
    14th Street Y

    14th Street Y

    3.2
    (65 reviews)
    2.5 mi

    Came to 14th Street Y to see Mark Jason Williams' play Straight Face Lies. It was a funny, familiar…read moreplay about family and the lies that are sometimes told in the name of love. It was an enjoyable evening. What was remarkably with the company is I was running late (damn you MTA!) and my friends spoke with organizer who actually gave a ten minute grace! I made it within that window and I was able to enjoy the play. I thanked the lady after but I'm so sorry I didn't get her name to publicly thank her here. Taking pics of course is frowned upon but when has that ever stopped me. Building was clean and looked well kept. 14th street Y's staff was very friendly and welcoming. I'll definitely consider attending other events here. The End.

    Not a safe place. I was a long standing, peaceful member until one day I was harrssed and…read morephysically threatened by an employee. I asked staff for help and they ignored me. A few days later, a staff member told me by phone that the matter was being investigated. She lied. My membership had been cut off. I asked why. No one told me. I made repeated requests to rejoin, and least, tell me what MY offense was when the other person so clearly violated me. No reply at all. Not even the courtesy of a response. I'm an elderly white woman. The other person was half my age, large, and black. She said, "I'm going to get you," and could have done real harm to me. The only explanation I can see is racism.

    Photos
    Check out the amazing performances in the 14Y Theater.
    Check out the amazing performances in the 14Y Theater.
    Check out our refreshed fitness center with brand new equipment as of 1/1/2023.
    Check out our refreshed fitness center with brand new equipment as of 1/1/2023.
    Personal Training available!

    See all

    Personal Training available!

    Commodore Barry Pool - swimmingpools - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...