I rarely leave negative reviews, but after my overnight trip on the Freedom out of San Pedro from…read moreJuly 7-8, I feel other anglers should know what to expect.
The trip got off to a bad start with an unexpected fuel surcharge, even though fuel prices have recently dropped. That immediately left a poor impression.
The captain's attitude throughout the trip was disappointing. Instead of helping anglers improve or offering constructive advice, he often blamed passengers for losing fish because of their drag settings. At one point, he even commented that he doesn't like eating fish and was only there to make money. That isn't something you want to hear from the captain of a sport fishing boat.
The crew also seemed disorganized. There were three deckhands, but they weren't wearing sport fishing shirts or uniforms, making it difficult to tell who was working. Two of the deckhands appeared to be very new and inexperienced. Rather than training them professionally, the cook, Eduardo, publicly scolded one of the new deckhands in front of all the passengers because the wrong sodas had been stocked in the refrigerator. It was uncomfortable to watch and embarrassing for the young employee.
The food was another major disappointment. The tacos were bland and lacked any seasoning. The breakfast burrito I received contained undercooked eggs, and I even found eggshells in it.
The way the bar tab was handled also raised concerns for me. I personally drank two beers the first evening and four beers the next day, but I was charged for nine beers. Since Eduardo handled the tabs directly, I questioned the charge, but it left me feeling uncomfortable and with little confidence that the tab was accurate.
The captain announced that Eduardo would make a "last call" for food before the kitchen closed. That never happened. My brother and I went to order cheeseburgers while the kitchen was still open, the food was still out, and nothing had been cleaned up yet, but Eduardo refused to cook for us while he sat on his cell phone.
When we brought our concerns about Eduardo to the captain, his response was essentially that nothing could be done because of Eduardo's family connections. That was frustrating and not the kind of accountability customers should expect.
Throughout much of the trip, the captain and co-captain spent their time fishing instead of assisting customers. They kept the fish they caught and never offered any to the passengers.
The ride to San Clemente Island was smooth, but the fishing itself was disappointing. We left the fishing grounds earlier than expected so we could return to the dock by 7:00 p.m. When it became apparent we would arrive too early, the boat slowed down and took a longer route around Catalina Island, making it feel like time was simply being wasted.
Overall, this trip felt more focused on collecting money than providing a quality fishing experience. Between the captain's attitude, the inexperienced crew, poor food, questionable bar tab, and lack of customer service, I cannot recommend the Freedom. There are many excellent sport fishing boats in Southern California, and based on my experience, this would not be one I would choose again.