Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Cookie Maven

    4.9 (7 reviews)
    Closed 10:00 am - 7:00 pm

    Order Cookie Maven Takeout or Delivery

    Cookie Maven Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Cookie Maven

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Amy M.
    0
    38
    0

    8 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Judy C.
    0
    43
    40

    10 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Wow, what a great place for sweet treats!! We went today and chose an assortment of cookies. All were a hit! We will definitely be back!

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Cookie Maven

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bakeries 651 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Sweet New Creations

    Sweet New Creations

    4.7(33 reviews)
    15.6 mi
    $

    Highly recommend Sweet New Creations! Daisy, the owner, responded quickly after I reached out to…read moreher for a cake for my daughter's third birthday. I was so happy to see that she offered a variety of flavors for cakes especially Ube macapuno. We ordered a 8x5 round Ube macapuno cake with Ube buttercream filing and macapuno strings. When placing the order it was very smooth without any complaints or confusion. The cake was absolutely divine! It was moist and flavorful, not too sweet, it was perfect. My family demolished the cake! She will be our go to for family events.

    Attended a baby shower on Sunday, we had a few friends who were in charge of pulling this off for a…read morefriend. My gf was in charge of getting the cake which she ordered from Sweet New Creations. The Mommy To Be is a huge Harry Potter fan & I honestly wasn't sure how we would incorporate this theme into a baby shower but we did and boy oh boy was the cake out of this world! The details were amazing! The little baby cake topper was so cute, and they gave instructions on how to keep her (to dry her out) which the mom will do. The cake not only looked amazing it tasted delicious also. Often so many of the ascetically nice looking cakes don't taste so good. In this case it was a win win all around. I usually just have a bite of cake to taste it as I am not a dessert eater but I ate the entire piece. Definitely will go there for cakes in the future!

    Photos
    Sweet New Creations
    Sweet New Creations
    Sweet New Creations

    See all

    Cake Fiction - Silver Crown and Damask Bat Mitzvah Cake with Peony Flower

    Cake Fiction

    5.0(16 reviews)
    5.4 mi
    $$

    Cake Fiction was the one vendor we used from a recommendations list our wedding venue gave to us. I…read moream SO glad we did. Their barn itself is also super cute, just going up for the cake tasting session was magical in itself. Picking just 3 flavors to sample from their list of cake combinations was so hard, which was a good thing! You are allowed to have a different flavor for each layer of cake at no additional cost, so we had fun with those. We picked the olive oil cake with passion fruit cream, the walnut almond pound cake with raspberry mousse, and the lemon cake with orange flower blossom cream. Well, my husband talks about that passion fruit cream more than any other part of our wedding (I try not to be too upset about that), it was that amazing! My favorite flavor was the raspberry mousse, and I keep hearing a ton of compliments on that flavor in particular from our guests. The only critique I would give to Cake Fiction is that they didn't give the venue a list of the flavors so nobody knew what each layer was and my husband and I had picked the flavors months before and couldn't remember either. I also appreciate how up-front Cake Fiction was with their pricing, which is listed online on their website to give you an idea of an estimate for your cake. We ended up going with a naked cake with just buttercream frosting on the outside which saved us a bit of money, and it looked so beautiful after our florist put a couple of flowers on it for us and it really fit in well with the theme of our barn venue. I made my own cake toppers out of clay and they were a little heavy so I was worried about them on top possibly sinking into the cake, but the cake was sturdy and the topper sat up there proudly! And finally, Paula is also the sweetest lady ever and you can tell she really has a passion for her work. It's lovely that we have such a great wedding cake baker in New Jersey. Now if only they would open a tiny bakery so that we can get two cupcakes with our flavors next year for our anniversary. :)

    Paula and Simon created an absolutely amazing 70th birthday cake for my father in law who was in…read morethe air force during the Vietnam War. The cake was in the shape of a phantom f4 jet and it was absolutely perfect. The attention to detail was impeccable!! My father in law thought it was a plastic model because it was made so well!! The staff at the restaurant kept coming in just to take pictures. The best part ~ it was absolutely delicious, too!!! I can't say enough good things about cake fiction... I can't wait to have them make another cake for us!!!

    Photos
    Cake Fiction - Naked Wedding Cake with Fresh Fruit

    Naked Wedding Cake with Fresh Fruit

    Cake Fiction - Birch Bark Fondant Wedding Cake with Carved Initials

    Birch Bark Fondant Wedding Cake with Carved Initials

    Cake Fiction - Birch Tree Bark Cake for Woodland Wedding

    See all

    Birch Tree Bark Cake for Woodland Wedding

    Sweetly Spoiled Treats - Rainbows and sunshine

    Sweetly Spoiled Treats

    5.0(2 reviews)
    43.3 mi

    Although it is officially the year 2019 (Happy New Year once again to everyone), my heart is still…read morew/the 2018 holiday season -lol. What can I say other than I absolutely love that specific time of the year! I sometimes reminisce before moving forward and posting a few additional holiday-oriented reviews is on my to-do list before moving full steam ahead into 2019. It is imperative that Sweetly Spolied Treats is highlighted..This company definitely satisfied me + my family's sweet tooth with fantastic tasting cupakes during the Thanksgiving and Christmas holiday. It all started in October 2018 as Sweetly Spoiled Treats Owner/Baker Asia Grant-Williams had a section displaying some of her desserts at the "Damn Gina"! Day Party/Pop-Up Event at Taj Lounge in Manhattan. I purchased a Strawberry Cupcake and a "90's themed" Sugar Cookie. From the moment I took a bite of that Strawberry Cupcake my life has never been the same....let's just say that I became hooked.for lack of a better word-lol. Once sending an email raving about the cupake it was not much later that I ordered a dozen Strawberry Cupcakes ($36 - $3 per cupcake) as part of our Thanksgiving dessert. Asia puts "love" into her desserts and these cupcakes had strawberry fruit inside and on top of the cupcakes. My family enjoyed them so much that one minute they were there and the next day they were all gone-lol. My brother requested more cupcakes which led me to placing a Christmas order for two dozen cupcakes ($ 72). One dozen Strawberry Cupcakes and One dozen Assorted Cupcakes that included Caramel, Red Velvet, Vanilla and Chocolate Cupcakes... Asia decorated/adorned then with supercute holiday themed shaped toothpicks and packaged them in neat clear cupcake boxes. My favorite are the Strawberry and Caramel. Asia creates rich, moist, fluffy cupcakes that have delectable frosting and are scrumptious! The ordering process was easy as I simply emailed Owner Asia Williams and she then sent online invoices so that I could make payment via credit card. She also delivered the cupcakes to my home which was much appreciated. Valentine's Day is right around the corner and I have already started thinking about ordering some cupcakes for my loved ones.... Please check out Sweetly Spolied Treats webite aa well as the company's Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get more information and see some of beautifully made cakes, cupcakes, etc. You will also see pictures of various flavored desserts such as Key Lime Pie Cupcakes, Samoa "Girl Scout Cookie" Cupcakes, etc. Desserts can be created for any and all special occasions. Sweetly Spolied Treats serves NY, NJ and the Pennsylvania area.

    All I have to say is red velvet!!! I had the pleasure of having the red velvet white chocolate…read moreKitKat cupcake and oh my god!!!! Incredibly delicious!!! The perfect amount of sweet! Not to mention her sugar cookies I legit requested a bucket full for the holidays. You can definitely taste the love.

    Photos
    Sweetly Spoiled Treats - Custom   cupcakes

    Custom cupcakes

    Sweetly Spoiled Treats - Sweetly Spolied Treats displayed desserts during "90's" themed Day Party at Taj Lounge in October 2018

    Sweetly Spolied Treats displayed desserts during "90's" themed Day Party at Taj Lounge in October 2018

    Sweetly Spoiled Treats - Strawberry, Caramel and Chocolate Cupcakes

    See all

    Strawberry, Caramel and Chocolate Cupcakes

    Blue Sheep Bake Shop - Baby Shower Cake

    Blue Sheep Bake Shop

    4.2(237 reviews)
    16.3 mi
    $$

    As a returning customer, I had to stop by Blue Sheep Bake Shop's new location. They've moved from…read moretheir old spot on Division Street to Main Street. It's a short walk away, and they are now in Epic Cookies' old location. This new space is bigger and more front and center. A lot of people did not realize that their old location was even there on Division Street, until I took them there. They just opened this location about three days ago, so it was pretty busy when I visited today, and even Karin and her husband were in there helping out! Both very kind people! I came in for my favorite "Death by Chocolate" cupcake and was excited to try two new flavors, Coconut Guava and Lemon Raspberry. I usually check their website ahead of time to see what seasonal cupcakes they have before visiting, I saw those and rush over here. P.s. please bring back the Versailles Cupcake from Summer '25! That raspberry filling is heaven sent, and part of the reason why I came by to try the Lemon raspberry flavor! Even with the rush, the staff was just as friendly as always. I really love it here and always bring my family and friends when they are in town! I'll definitely miss the charm of the old location, but I'm excited for them in this new space and hope that it works out well for them!

    They have the best treats and had the yummiest ones at the Girls Night Out event! They made sure…read morewe had a good time and took care of us!

    Photos
    Blue Sheep Bake Shop - Funfetti cake custom

    Funfetti cake custom

    Blue Sheep Bake Shop - Exterior

    Exterior

    Blue Sheep Bake Shop - Beautiful and delicious custom macaron favors made by Blue Sheep Bake Shop for a rehearsal dinner. Just wonderful and so great to work with

    See all

    Beautiful and delicious custom macaron favors made by Blue Sheep Bake Shop for a rehearsal dinner. Just wonderful and so great to work with

    Cookie Maven - bakeries - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...