delicious bagels and matcha latte's! it's refreshing and not too sweet, and the line moves quickly. [[HIGHLIGHT]]in the summer, it's a semi-open dining indoors and out which is really nice![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] huge selection of cream cheese spreads as well -- highly recommend! read more

Court Street Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Absolutely horrible experience. Waited for nearly half an hour in line (only ordered a single bagel) while 2 dozen people who came in and ordered after me were served and left. When I asked them where my bagel was the told me they don't do refunds and walked away (I assumed to make my bagel) but then they came back and told me they voided my order. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Incredibly loud place, terribly rude service when ordering as well.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Overall atrocious experience, terrible place. Will never come here again read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]It was so packed in here but service was quick.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Lots of different cream cheese flavors. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Super delicious clean space.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Such a cute neighborhood bagel place![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I tried ordering a sausage, egg, and cheese and they were out of sausage by the time I ordered (it was still the morning hours so I was kindve surprised), no biggie though! I went with a sesame bagel toasted with plain cream cheese. These bagels were hefty. Like really thick bagels. I've had NY bagels before, but this one was really thick and really dense. [[HIGHLIGHT]]I can't say it's the best one I've had, but the service was quick and there's a constant flow of people ordering and waiting for their food so beware-- it can be pretty crammed if you're trying to snag a seat inside.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

A mistake almost every time I go here I should've known better than to drive off a few blocks before checking if my bagel has the right cheese or condiments. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It's a shame because they have a great location.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] It just ruins my day when I have to always walk back or run back depending on if I'm in a rush to correct my sandwich or forced to endure something sh***y. read more

It felt immoral to come here after reading a piece about how it scandalously changed ownership, but I really wanted to pinpoint our to go bagel shop in the neighborhood. There was practically no line for a weekday morning. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The bagel shop was super hot with a lot of employees suggesting that the business would for sure pick up.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I got the toasted everything bagel with scallion cream cheese which was delightful. I can't believe a bagel w/ cream cheese is now over 6 dollars, which seems to be the average now/the norm due to inflation. The bacon egg and cheese on a toasted sesame bagel left a lot to be desired. The bagel was 90% of the meal with barely any bacon and egg. I would have preferred to pay more for more protein/substance than have what I got for just a dollar more than the bagel with cream cheese option. read more

Hot mess (in a bad way). The bagel was mediocre. The real issue here was the complete lack of organization and wait time. I went with a friend and when we ordered we were told it would be a 25 minute wait. We said that was fine. 25 minutes later my bagel came out (they gave me egg when I ordered sesame) but my friends did not come for 55 (fifty five!) minutes - despite us ordering the exact same thing at the exact same time. And we were not the only people it happened to. The entire place was packed with people who's orders had been forgotten and had waited over an hour. Save your money and time and go literally anywhere else. read more

Court Street Bagels had a controversial switch of owners but their popularity is as high as ever. I walked by on a Saturday morning and saw that the line didn't spill outside like it usually does and decided to go in for a bagel. The order/payment process was relatively fast but then the wait for the bagels began, and went on, and on...By the time I got called up I checked against the time on the receipt and 23 MINUTES had passed. My order was a plain bagel with cream cheese and a sesame bagel with lox and cream cheese. Nothing difficult or time consuming. By the time I was called up to get my bagels, I was told they had run out of plain bagels. What? This is a bagel shop on a Saturday at 11am. I just waited for 23 minutes. How do you run out of plain bagels so fast? Needless to say the whole experience left me more than annoyed and there's plenty of other bagel shops in the sea. read more

Wonderful fresh seafood lunch spot deliciously prepared. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Great service and ambiance.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Amazing coffee and staff is really friendly. [[HIGHLIGHT]]love the environment ![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Best breakfast spot around the area read more

Court Street Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is probably more like a 3.5 but I've been on a mission to try a new bagel place semi-regularly and this was my one this morning because a friend and I were headed to the NY Transit Museum which is nearby. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The location is cute and like many things in the city, lovingly cramped.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] One thing that irritated me was that the pick-up area is right in front of the door and the line to order is all the way in the back which means we had to fight through the morning crowd just to look at the menu let alone order. I had a toasted sesame bagel with garlic & herb cream cheese because I figured that was a safe bet for trying a new place (I tend not to branch out unless I can at least trust the basics of a place). The friend I was with got an untoasted french toast bagel with strawberry cream cheese to which she complained that her bagel was very tough (we had recently tried another place that was so fresh we had no problems with untoasted bagels) and said it tasted like she was having a day-old bagel. I thought with mine being toasted it might be better but I still ran into a similar problem. Also, like most bagel places I've seen they charge for cream cheese and charge even more for flavored cream cheese. I expected a bit more bang for my buck because I felt like for the size of the bagel they offer (which is a good size and was very filling!!) I should have gotten more cream cheese. The sesame bagel wasn't as flavorful as I would have liked but was still yummy, slight chewiness aside. The garlic & herb cream cheese didn't taste like much which was disappointing considering, once again, they charge extra for flavored cream cheese. I wanted to get pictures, but we were almost late for our reservation time at the museum so no dice! Service was nice and was relatively efficient for how busy it was on a Saturday morning. It's nice that they give you a ticket because some bagel places just call out whatever you ordered and hope for the best (which is brave considering I used to work in service and the amount of grown adults who seem to forget what they ordered the moment I try to confirm is scary). I came on a busy weekend morning so I'm willing to give this place the benefit of the doubt and maybe try it again at a calmer time, however I work during the week so I have no idea when that will be! read more

I was on a hunt for a new bagel spot as my local place was becoming not so tasty anymore. Food: I ordered a bagel with avocado and turkey bacon and tomato and was pleasantly surprised by the taste and quality. Service: The cashier was kind and pleasant. I will definitely be returning. Ambiance: Standard bagel shop. Roomy enough for seating, small but just enough space to maneuver around and dine in if you choose too. read more

Court Street Bagels - Outside. - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

What a find! Had a delicious everything bagel with egg and turkey and it did not disappoint. This place is small but it sure does get busy and packed! The gentleman behind the counter on Friday morning was the kindest person ever, not only with new customers, but with his regulars also. Service was fast and fyi cash only! read more

See all

In the morning when coming home from work, I would walk by. One time I stopped here to check it out. They do have a large variety of bagels.

10/10 bagel shop in Brooklyn! My friend and I walked over the Brooklyn Bridge from Manhattan just to try it after researching the best bagel shop in NYC. Well worth the walk! Be prepared to wait, it's a small place but they work fast. It's also CASH ONLY, so plan accordingly! Lots of bagel options, and even more cream cheese options to pair. I went with the Sundried Tomato cream cheese on Everything Bagel. Look at those chunks of tomato! There was no shortage of shmear on that bagel. My friend got the Apple Cinnamon cream cheese on a plain bagel and raved over it, too. We also witnessed the sweetest thing while there. The owner is super hands on, I get the sense he's there every day. A couple of patrons didn't realize it was a cash only place and got to the point of paying when they realized it. The owner kindly told them it was no problem, to just come back later to settle up with him. I thought that was so kind of him! It really says a lot about him and his business. He truly cares about his patrons. I was also amazed at how cheap it was! I think my bagel with cream cheese and a Diet Coke can was $4.50! Please add Court Street Bagels to your list of must try places in NYC. I can't wait to go back! read more

Court Street Bagels - Sundried Tomato cream cheese on Everything Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Bagel prices can go up to $23 here. I ordered the court street bagel with salmon and cream cheese, it was good but I feel like it was a bit costly. With a drink added, you can easily pay around $30 for a breakfast which is pretty interesting. Service is a little slow, they should add more workers for the morning rush. read more

Court Street Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The everything bagels are good. And for that alone, I'd give it a 4-star. I don't typically get anything on the bagel. I just literally want a bagel put into a paper bag. The cashiers are usually good about not touching their cash register and then touching your bagel, but I was there this morning and the cashier with her gloved hands touched money/cash register then put my bagels in a paper bag. No paper to grab the bagels or tongs were used. It's on me for not having said anything right in the moment. And I should have even though the place was busy. Bringing this to management attention about food handling etiquette. read more

I am a regular customer of court st bagels, even though they are prone to messing up my breakfast sandwich order or serving me uncooked eggs. I return because when they can pull it together, it is a solid sandwich. Today, I wanted lunch, and ordered a chicken cutlet- they messed up my order, serving it on a roll instead of a bagel, but, more importantly, the chicken was disgusting and inedible. It resembled a flip flop more than food. I don't know how much longer I can do this, the deli on smith and bergen would never feed me that. read more

Court Street Bagels - Disgusting - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We were in Brooklyn watching a basketball tournament and knew we wanted NY bagels to bring back home to Texas. Our hotel was nearby and Yelp steered me here on an easy walk. The line was long but moved quickly. The owner himself was working the counter and greeting regulars and visitors alike. I enjoyed a bagel with lox and the amount of cream cheese in the bagel is insane. Hubby had a bagel with egg and ham and cheese and he was loving it too. A couple tiny tables at the front where we could enjoy our breakfast but most people did takeaway. The bagels we took home were warm when we left and they survived the flight and kept in our freezer while they lasted (which wasn't long). read more

Court Street Bagels - Perfection - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Food (5/5): - Amazing bagel! I got a toasted everything bagel with lox, scallion cream cheese, red onions, tomatoes, and capers. It was so nicely crisp and the ratio of cream cheese to salmon was perfect for me Service (5/5): - Met the owner who has such a wonderful and kind heart! He was so warm and welcoming that I'm not surprised at all by the amount of guests that come visit Ambiance (5/5): - Just your regular casual bagel spot! - No frills but lots of community and warmth here :) One note I have to make is that I came here pretty early on a Saturday and there was already a line. However, once they were opened, they helped everyone pretty quickly so I didn't have to wait too long. I will be back! read more

Court Street Bagels - Outside - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I'm a sucker for NY bagels. They just hit differently! I enjoyed a lox bagel sandwich from here while chilling at Brooklyn Heights Promenade with its magnificent cityscape (well, as magnificent as it can be from the current poor air quality). On-point NY bagel tacky-sponginess. Tasty lox and whipped cream cheese. I docked a star only because it was a bit expensive for a lox bagel sandwich based on what was given (I've had some that were of the same caliber but less expensive while being even larger). Still, I overall recommend this spot especially if you're looking for pretty good bagels. read more

Court Street Bagels - Gotta have a lox bagel while I'm here :) - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Excellent pumpkin cheese spread on egg bagel. The service was good and [[HIGHLIGHT]]the cafe is super cute![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I walked out of my way to get another one before catching our flight home. read more

There is always a long line outside, especially in the morning and over the weekends. Usually it would be less crowded after 2pm. Fortunately the service is efficient so you don't have to wait too long. The owner greets every customer and offers help passionately :) ＊ Sourdough Bagel w/ Low Fat Veggie Spread ＊ Sourdough Bagel w/ Tofu Lox Spread ＊ Whole Wheat Everything Bagel w/ Tofu Sundried Tomato Spread Chewy bagels. Especially love how chewy and moist the sourdough bagel was. The bagels are quite on that pricy side but not kidding, their portion is really DELUXE. They stuff the bagels with super thick layer of spread and many pieces of meat/lox. The shop provides plenty of low fat and tofu spread. Highly recommend for vegans and those on diet. **** They only accept cash. There's an ATM inside the store. My Recommendations: Sourdough Bagels, Low Fat & Tofu Spread Worth Returning? YES I always come back for their bagels read more

See all

Go to bagel place in the neighborhood. They have good vegan options. Quick service. Good (not great) coffee.

I went here for the first time today. Let me say this place ain't worth the time or money. My eggs taste soapy and I also got a plain bagel that looks horrible and not edible. The cashiers acted like they hate there jobs. This place get a reward for horrible service and food. I rather go to McDonald's and get a breakfast sandwich. This place is read more

Court Street Bagels - Whoever thought this bagel looks edible or sold this should not work here. This looks horrible! - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We were visiting and we pleasantly came across Court Street Bagels. We came to this spot twice we loved it so much. The place is small, although it was nice to get a table to eat. The service was quick. The Eliza is a sandwich I could share since they definitely don't skimp on the meat. read more

See all

As soon as we arrived, we knew it was the right spot with a long line out the door. We finally made it inside after about 10-15 minutes, so not too bad. They had multiple people taking orders. I got the Deluxe Lox Bagel ($18) on everything bagel, which included tomato and onions with scallion cream cheese. I opted out of the capers since it's not my thing. The bagel is huge and stuffed with so much cream cheese. The contrast of the onions gave it a nice crunch. These bagels are so soft and fluffy inside too. The bagel is delicious although definitely pricey, but I'd say it's pretty normal for a lox bagel in NY. The boyfriend also got the Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Breakfast Bagel ($8). This was tasty too, but not as stuffed as the cream cheese. read more

Court Street Bagels - Deluxe Lox Bagel. - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The best place to eat bagels in NYC any time of day. Simply perfect I easily recommend it. read more

Major side note: As of Monday (yesterday from this review,) Court Street Bagel is now operated under a different owner. Peter; the original owner for ages; was closing the place due to rent issues but it appears to be run by someone else now. Don't have any other details on who is running it and I am unsure if the bagel quality will be the same nor if it'll stay open. You can check the debacle on reddit and other pages. Edit: It's the Smith Street Bagel bros apparently. https://www.nycbageltours.com/news/the-truth-behind-the-court-street-bagels-saga Anyway, this is (or was as per the note above) one of the bagel places in the area but the only good one. Yes there's a bad spot up the street on court in downtown Brooklyn (LA) and the also not great Atlantic Bagels but along with Smith Street a good 15 minutes away, this was always excellent and they have daily lines for a reason. Always a solid quality bagel though their sandwiches were a bit overpriced even for the neighborhood (go to the excellent 24 hour spot on Smith Street/Smith Street Gourmet Deli instead.) When I got a hot one, they were very good but even for the rare times I went for lunch or the times I got a non hot one, they are/were still better than the other spots listed. My usual preference is/was a sesame or poppy with cream cheese not toasted (because a toasted bagel is bread in the shape of a bagel.) Lox spread was pretty solid here with plenty of lox and was honestly worth it also. They put a ton of cream cheese on also. Low 4/Mid 4 read more

Best local bagels in the area since Smith St has been closed for months now. Highly recommend my order, SEC on everything with chipotle mayo. I would go in person otherwise you're probably gonna get the wrong order delivered as I have many times read more

service was super friendly! i got a onion bagel + jalapeno cheddar cream cheese. only complaint is that the cream cheese was a bit stingy, but the whole thing was only $6.5 so can't be too upset!! SO DELICIOUS!! read more

Good bagels, fast service. Nothing particularly remarkable about anything but my friend did complain that her plain bagel was smaller than ours. read more

Cute bagel shop with a white variety of bagels baked in house and a selection of cream cheese. Around 6$ for a bagel and cream cheese. The portions are huge and will definitely stuff you up! They add a ton of cream cheese, so make sure to tell them less cheese if you don't want that much. The black and white cookie isn't the best so I wouldn't recommend read more

See all