I want to be clear - I still love Bagel Pub as a chain of bagel joints, but on my most recent visit to the Park Slope location I have to confess to being a bit let down. At first, things seemed normal. There was a line at the counter, I put in my order at the counter and then paid at the cashier station. The bagel I got was delicious and well toasted. The strawberry cream cheese was fantastic and I'd get it again. So what changed? Well, two things really. First, I had to wait for quite some time to get a seat, and when I finally did, the back of the chair felt like it was going to fall of if I leaned back. So be careful with whichever chair you pick to sit on. Second, service was...gruff at best. Almost everyone I interacted with on my most recent visit looked annoyed to be there. The only exception was the guy who took my order. Everyone just looked...annoyed. It really felt unwelcoming. Again, I am happy to visit Bagel Pub again in the future, I just hope the reception is better next time. read more

Terrible service and major food safety concerns I had a awful experience here. First off, it was nearly 90 degrees outside, but it felt even hotter inside the shop because the AC was completely off. Second, the customer service was awful. The girl taking orders was flat-out rude--after taking my order, she literally told me to "move" instead of politely asking me to step down. By that evening and into the next morning, I had severe diarrhea. In that kind of heat, dairy like cream cheese spoils incredibly fast if it isn't kept cold. If you visit this shop and notice it's hot inside, do yourself a favor and leave. It is not worth getting sick. read more

Bagel Pub - Everything bagel - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Home SWEET HOME! Small bagel shop in BK. Short walk from Beanmongers coffee shop. I adore a NY bagel. This was my classic bagel as I became a adult, lol There is NOTHING BETTER....Thank a crunchy outside soft inside bagel and Bagel Pub did not disappoint. You do have to arrive early as the shope opens early and everyone wants to stay their day with a delicious bagel. So many varieties, I saw Jalapeño cheese bagels, hummmm not to sure but worth a try my next visit., Blueberries cream cheese, fruits mixed into fresh cream cheese, just everything looked delicious. Service was slow but more than worth the wait. I cant wait till by grandson is old enough to have a to bagel. We will sit in small and desirable serting area and enjoy . read more

See all

Atmosphere 10/10: looks like your local deli but more modern and clean. Service 10/10: workers were kind and attentive. food: 10/10: they put a good amount of cream cheese, and the bagel was fresh, and soft. Overall rate: 10/10 would definitely come back again. Their bagels are worth the price. Price: $6 read more

Bagel Pub - Everything bagel with tofu cream cheese. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Great location, nice staff, delicious bagels, so many amazing cream cheese options!! Also vegan and gluten free options. The are on the walls is so cute too. read more

Bagel Pub - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Aesthetic: Crowded, lively bagel emporium What to try: Egg bagel with veggie cream cheese Service: Attentive Parking: None Rating: 5/5, this was my best bagel in NY. The egg bagel untoasted with half veggie and half honey walnut cream cheese was incredible. The pumpernickel everything with Zaatar cream cheese was also fantastic! read more

See all

Overpriced place for mediocre sandwiches and bagels. The staff here are among the rudest I've ever encountered. They also love to mess up your order--beware! read more

Staff giving out food was rude forgot my order and gave me so much attitude. I'm sorry girl. It's not my fault. It's 12 p.m. in Brooklyn and everyone wants a bagel but I didn't do anything to you lol bagels probably fire though. I haven't tried it yet. However my girl Lisa was great. She was nice. She took my order. Update: bagel was fire, but still rude customer service read more

Bagel Pub - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I always walk by and see such a crowd here. Very popular spot but the service is efficient. The space has a lot of seating indoors, outdoors, and in the back. They have a variety of bagels, cream cheese options, sandwiches, salads, etc. I went with the Fresh Lox #1 on an everything bagel. Good solid spot to satisfy your bagel craving. read more

Bagel Pub - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

i stopped by bagel pub after passing it many times and always noticing how busy it was, so i finally decided to try it. i ordered an everything bagel with garlic and herb cream cheese. the bagel itself was soft, but overall it felt pretty standard. it was good, but it didn't really amaze me. what truly stood out was the cream cheese selection. they have so many different flavors, and everything sounded really appealing. the garlic and herb cream cheese tasted somewhat like plain cream cheese with a few spices mixed in, so next time i would probably try a different spread. the staff was very friendly, nice, and accommodating. there is plenty of seating inside, and even though the place gets busy, people tend to come and go, making it fairly easy to find a seat. overall, i would definitely recommend checking this spot out. read more

Bagel Pub - everything Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This has been my go to breakfast spot on days I go in for work. The bagels are always fresh, the multigrain bagel is always delicious and filling. Their coffee is also decent better than other cafes nearby. The service could be a bit better, a few cashiers are slightly moody and not the friendliest to repeat customers so I just pay for my food and leave. read more

Bagel Pub - Bagel with Butter - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I love ordering bagel pub, always fresh everything. Delivery service is always good and fast. The berry mango smoothie is thee best. The chicken cutlet sandwich came with fresh mozzarella, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo it was so delicious, the cutlet was fresh and meaty. The bread roll was very fresh and warm. They serve up the best breakfast act lunch options. Definitely a must. read more

Bagel Pub - Berry Mango Smoothie - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The bagels here were not great. I got a plain bagel on toasted with scallion cream cheese, and the bagel kind of tasted stale. I was hoping for a more chewy bagel texture, but it just tasted really dense and like it's been sitting for a day or so. Maybe they just had an off day? Either way, theres a lot of good bagel places in nyc so not sure if I would come back. read more

Beautiful bagels with excellent chew. Love the variety of cream cheeses but this the everything bagel wasn't as good with my usual fave jalapeno cream cheeses. Had a bite of hubby's everything bagel with garlic herb cc and it was divine. Coffee is solid, no frills. Nice smoothie selection, overall a solid bagel option when Essa and Best are too busy. read more

Bagel Pub - Everything Bagel with jalapeno Flavored Cream Cheese - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Most bagel places only sell drip coffee, much to my delight Bagel Pub also serves Espresso drinks, and pretty good ones, too. Both the latte and chai latte were great. Their bagels are also solid. I overdid it a little bit by getting sun-dried tomato cream cheese, an egg, and onion, lettuce, and tomato. The bagel ended up quite packed and ended up being a juicy, slippery mess. Will probably opt for fewer watery veggies next time, but bagel and cheese were great! read more

Bagel Pub - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The problem is not the food. I ordered a bagel with vegetable tofu, and the price was $10! This is crazy. I had the cashier check if she rang it up wrong and she said that was the price .when did price of a bagel get so absurd? read more

I'm not a bagel connoisseur, but these were definitely great. The salmon one was so fresh and hearty, I could eat it every day. The staff was quick and friendly too - definitely recommend. read more

This place was crowded but the line moves very quickly! The vibe feels very much like a cozy old world pub (hence the name) fused with a bagel shop. They have so many different types of cream cheese, and are very generous with it on each bagel. I had the pastrami lox bagel sandwich which was a huge meal! You could easily share it or save for leftovers. The banana latte was very interesting--they blend banana into the milk so it's almost like a latte smoothie! Really enjoyed it. read more

Bagel Pub - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is like a bagel factory. They are just trying to move the people though. They messed up my order, didn't slice my bagels (not hard) and also gave me the wrong bagels (c'mon!). Maybe the workers are stressed, maybe they don't give a s----. I'm so sad Bagel Market Closed down the street. They were the best. read more

My fav bagel place in NY, you can't change my mind. Sausage egg and cheese bagel w a side of cream cheese read more

See all

5 stars for the pickle cream cheese alone. The caramel iced coffee was perfect, the egg and cheese bagel sandwich hit the spot, and the everything bagel with pickle cream cheese nearly caused a dispute because neither of us wanted the other to eat it. Fresh bagels, tons of cream cheese flavors, and absolutely worth a stop. read more

These bagels are lovely and really hit the spot. There are plenty of options for what to add to a bagel - I suggest looking at the menu before you get there to have a solid option cause there is just too much to look at in person. They've got some good options for vegetarians as well. They were super busy and quick with their orders. The staff were super friendly too. This is a great spot to grab a bite with a friend and catchup or just read. Not the best spot to work on your laptop since it's so busy. Vibes are really lovely. read more

Bagel Pub - Egg Sandwich on a Bagel - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

My brother and his girlfriend took my fiancé and I to Bagel Pub for lunch during our visit to NYC and it was fabulous! It was my first New York bagel and it did not disappoint! This location in particular has a really cozy vibe with plenty of fun bagel paintings adorning the walls! Service was fast and easy, and everything tasted great! My fiancé got lox on an everything rye bagel which I had never seen before, it was tasty! read more

See all

Really slow service - had to wait 30 minutes for a sandwich. Too many other options in the area to justify coming back

The food is consistently super fresh here! Everything is high quality! The service can be slightly slow as it takes awhile for the workers to put together orders. But the atmosphere is always fun! We love the outdoor space and the overall energy. read more

I thoroughly enjoyed my bagels from here. I really like their bagels. The breading was fresh, chewy, juicy if that even makes sense, and delicious. I got the "Everything" bagel 2x. I got a ABC Omelette Breakfast Sandwich which was warm and delicious. Great flavors and warm and chewy ingredients. I was also very impressed with the Lox #2 Bagel. The capers, onions, tomatoes, scallion cream cheese, and fresh lox paired superbly together. One of the better bagel shops in NYC for sure and definitely in this area. 100% would get again. read more

Ya sorry this just isn't it. Got a specialty spread and bagel, the thinnest use of the spread, and it was an extra $4 for that spread. Felt like such a stooge walking out of there. $8 for a bagel with cream cheese that has some small bits of scallion in it for $8 and being given a thin thin layer. No way. read more

Inattentive workers who ignore you while they prepare takeout orders. Also, I was not given the courtesy to know that my food was ready and what I said something there was no response. The food is adequate.. read more

Best bagel spot in my neighborhood. 10 out of 10. Too many spreads and you can't go wrong!

I cannot believe I have not written a review of this place. I go there all the time. The bagels are great and the bacon egg and cheese bagel is an experience to definitely remember it is soo good. The food is fresh and the service is usually pretty quick even when there is a line. Price is good also for fresh food and the service is friently. read more

Classic bagel and coffee combo. Loved the brick interior with interesting decor, and quick service. Bagel sandwich was huge and served as two meals for me on a work-from-home day. read more

Bagel Pub - Egg Sandwich on a Bagel - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

got lox #2 on an everything bagel and my brother got the BE&C on an egg bagel. both were delish and the filling was not skimpy. we also got the sweet treat pressed juice and it went well with the bagels! service was good. read more

Bagel Pub - Sweet Treat - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Always great bagels from bagel pub. Their bagels have gotten more expensive recently, but they're still my go-to for a solid bagel in the neighborhood. One of my favorite things is that they have a whole wheat everything bagel which is so fun! They almost always have a line but they're quick. The seating inside this location is limited but there's generally pretty quick table turnover or there is a bar area where you can sit or stand if you're just one or two people. This location is super close to the park too! read more

Bagel Pub - Lox with scallion cream cheese on a whole wheat everything bagel - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I got the ABC sandwich on an everything bagel. Bagel Pub is one of my favorite spots for bagels in the city and definitely the best in the area. The everything bagel has the right amount of seasoning and has the right amount of chewiness in the inside and crispness on the outside. They also didn't skimp on the bacon which I appreciated. The sandwich did take a hot minute to come out but otherwise Bagel Pub is a great spot to go for a quick bite :) read more

Bagel Pub - ABC Sandwich - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

On my 3rd or 4th time here now where I ordered a breakfast sandwich with avocado, was charged extra for the avocado, and then received no avocado This is really consistent, poor level of service for a $15 breakfast sandwich. Have now made my decision to stop patronizing this location read more

Came here again to try another option and I got the Blueberry bagel with Mixed Berry Cream Cheese this time. It looks super pretty but when they asked if I wanted it toasted, I said "No, no toasted" and then I literally see them toast it in front of me. Like, WHAT LOL. read more

See all

Hate to write this review but this was some of the worst service I've ever received. There was no line but waited by the "order here" spot for about 15 minutes. No one acknowledged me. The workers were by the grill laughing and just wiping things. When I actually ordered, I stood in store for 30 minutes, there were no order tickets other than mine. When I got my order, the bagel was cold the eggs were lukewarm. Definitely not a bagel pub experience. I was extremely disappointed and shocked by this. Wow read more

The bagles are great don't get me wrong, but the staff here could use some work. They are extremely rude and act like you are doing them the greatest disservice by simply ordering a bagel or asking where my order is after 30 minutes, which unfortunately is a common occurrence here. TLDR: good bagels, rude staff read more

Great selection of fresh bagels and cream cheese spreads of multiple dimensions.. also meats and salads to choose from. Service was good you order and wait limited seats. Had the narrow hallway deli vibe . Deliciously Incredible choices .. read more

See all

The fanciest bagel store in Park Slope Brooklyn. BP is always packed in the morning. They offer something for everyone and the prices are not outrageous. On weekends, it is a family destination. The staff is friendly and service is excellent, considering many mornings of long lines. read more

See all