We are here from out of town. The desk lady at the hotel suggested this business and gave us a menu. We got a taco pizza. It was great! Thanks for the good work and amazing food. read more

We went here for lunch and ate in. Only 2 choices for seating. No bathroom. Clearly this is a carry out place. We drove out of our way to stop here so we sat down and ordered an XL pepperoni pizza with the garlic butter crust option. The pizza was just meh...I'm not a pizza snob or anything but I was not impressed whatsoever. These reviews on here lead you to think this place is the Mecca of pizza places but it's not. No reason for us to go back. read more

Cozzeria pizza is the best pizza in Elyria. The price to quality is fantastic! The regular crust is very similar to East of Chicago, but the "thin crust" really isn't what you think of when ordering a thin crust pizza. The thin crust is kinda bready, not cracker thin. The staff and the owner (owners?) are super friendly. I have never had a bad experience at Cozzeria! Can't go wrong with a sheet pizza for a party. Just note that they serve a large area, and deliveries can take longer than expected at peak times. read more

What a great place! We stayed a few nights during our Oberlin College visit and grabbed something on the fly that was yelp-approved and close. The Greek pizza had no tomato sauce and was incredible. The Gyro was also decent. The people behind the counter were very nice to us, especially considering we walked in the door to place a to-go order 20 minutes before they closed. read more

Really good pizza! Tasted very fresh, was prepared perfectly. Crust was tasty, not bland. Sauce was a good balance of flavors. Cheese bread was well cheesed and came with plenty of dipping sauce. Quick service, friendly staff. read more

Above-average for a Hometown Pizza Place the dough is okay the sauce is very good the toppings are okay seems like above-average quality for both salads pizzas Services good prices are fair read more

Came here from California on a business trip with 11 co-workers and we all had a great experience. The pizza was delicious and the service was great! It had a very warm, family style setting. read more

We have picked up pizza here two times now and have tried 3 different pizzas. This is easily the best place I have tried in This part of Lorain county in the two years since I moved here. I would recommend you stop by the thin and regular crust are both great and they make their own dough fresh daily. read more

My Mom and I recently made a cross-country trip from California to D.C. and waited until our last couple of days to search out a good pizza. We happened through Elyria a little late for dinner, but I found Cozzeria online, and the reviews were rightfully awesome! The pizzas were delicious, and even though this is more of a pick-up place than a sit-down restaurant, the owner brought out real plates and silverware for us to one of the two or three tables and made sure we were 100% taken care of, as did the other staff. Everyone was so friendly, kind, and hospitable--and a special thanks to our new friend who shared his balloon animal talent with us! Very cool! We got two different pizzas, both delicious, and the special garlic crust is the best. Thanks so much to adding to our great road trip adventure. We'll definitely come back if wandering through again! read more

Fantastic pizza. Owner is very friendly and a great guy to chat with. Next time I'm in town for business I will definitely be back.

Really good pizza! I've ordered pizza pick up here multiple times and was never disappointed. The crust is amazing and the ingredients are quality. I would rather eat at a local place than a chain and this place is well worth it. read more

What a gem of a place here in Elyria. Amazing pizza, great subs, always friendly service, a good prices. What more could you ask for?

Incredible pizza. My kid's school has a pizza night once every month and Cozzeria is the place that works with their school for the fundraiser. We usually order 2 large pizzas. Never been disappointed. read more

If you stay at the local Hampton order here. Great pizza, friendly service. I feel like I'm supporting local. And, with kids as a single parent they delivered to my hotel room. read more

This was my first time eating here and I definitely want to come back for more. I got the pierogi pizza which was something that I've never seen before and it was quite good. Very unique and a piece of art, the pizza crust kinda reminds my of Pizza Hut crust. Overall good experience. read more

Cozzeria Pizzeria - Pierogi pizza is a work of art - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

We came all the way from Lakewood to try this place based on reviews. We like to try random new pizza every once in awhile and this was our best adventure yet. The BBQ chicken pizza was amazing. Husband's cheese with the garlic butter was perfect. Staff so accommodating since we dined in! read more

The product is good but they overcharged me for my order and when I called about it they argued with me that they did not take that amount

One of the best pizza places around, and ran by great people!! Always friendly service!! One of the rare treasures of Elyria!! Me and my daughter love this place!! If you haven't tried it you should try the pierogi pizza, it's delicious!!!! read more

Wanted to try a new place. Came to pick up when they said it would be ready. The incompetent employees couldnt/wouldn't get the job done until the owner came back. Had to wait twice as long. No offer of any discount for our extra wait or anything... Wings were basic wings. Edible. BLT sandwich isnt strips of bacon. It's all ground up pizza toppings bacon. Philly steak had way too much mayo. Pizza was terrible. Thought it was kind of a thicker crust based on pictures. Looks and tastes like chef boyardee pizza. We'll never come back again. read more

Passed through Elyria for the night on road trip home to Chicago. Came recommended on Yelp. Food was delicious and place was spotless. Had three kids under 4 with us and the staff bent over backwards to make us comfortable, good people. Great find definitely recommend. read more

Co-workers and I on the way home from West Virginia to Michigan saw the reviews and decided to give it a try. Best Stromboli I've had in many years. Well deserved 5 stars read more

Cozzeria has the best pizza in town. The owners are so sweet and the pizza is amazing. The taco pizza is my favorite. I definitely recommend this pizzeria, it's a hometown shop with fantastic food!! read more

Best pizza and wings in the area. Friendly staff. Gotta try the pierogi pizza... AWESOME!!!!

First time here and I was impressed. I ordered online and it said it would be ready in 15-30 minutes. Got there in about 15 min and it was coming out of the oven. I ordered 2 calzones and they were perfect! Not only did the food taste great but the prices are very good as well. $6.50 per calzone if I remember correctly . read more

Stopped by on our road trip from Michigan to Pennsylvania. Saw all the 5 star ratings and knew we had to go. Amazing pizza! The boys wanted to order more when we were finished. Very nice staff. read more

Pizza was delicious, breadsticks with garlic butter delicious. Good prices.We had ours delivered, there is a delivery charge, They were quick and on time read more

Our stop was unplanned and it wound up being a great find. The staff was so friendly and made sure our meal was a delightful experience. We are from NJ and we were treated like we were special guests. The pizza we had was so delicious. Much different than your typical NJ pizza. We will be back for sure on our next drive to and from Chicago. read more

My favorite pizza in Elyria. Get the half sheet with the garlic butter on the crust! The cheese they use has a great taste and mouth feel, and if you ask for it cooked 'well done' the cheese has a wonderful bubbly crust to it. read more

I've ordered the taco pizza from here several times and it is very good. The service is excellent the restaurant is clean and the gentleman that owns it is very friendly and nice. I would definitely recommend this Pizzeria. read more