I've passed by this place whenever I have to go to the Village Pharmacy but last week I decided to go in and get something to try. The cookie with their nifty names makes it a bit hard to choose but in the end I decided to get the Eat 'More and one with a mixture of chocolate and nuts in it; I think that was either a Trail Mix or a Bliss cookie. Each soft and moist cookie immediately hits your mouth with a full flavor or butter, sweetness and texture from the fillings. I just had the one with the cookies for an after-brunch dessert and I love this one more than the Eat 'More. Small bubbles of ooey gooey melted chocolate and brittly nuts was felt with each bite and the remaining taste of the butter is what I can't overcome after I finished eating both cookies. That's like the White Witch's temptation to Edmund with her turkish delights in The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe". Will I be going back to this location soon? The location on Church Street is more convenient for me so maybe. But for now I am putting up a good resistance towards the allure of the other flavors before I go back to trying an ice-cream sammy. read more

See all

The first time you ll get cookies there, you ll be woawoed as i was. Then you may realize it was ok, but not to the point to look forward getting more that soon. Then you ll go again, and will get the confirmation that cookies are creative but that most are just ok. They also need to be eaten the same day as they really do get hard super fast. I d really like to be more supportive of the place as i like sweets. On another note, the store at bayview is way brighter, nicer and frindlier than the Church's one. read more

Mediocre cookies. Small and pricey. The matcha white chocolate cookie (2/5) was extremely salty which masked the matcha flavour. The shortbread stuffed cookie (3/5) was on the sweeter side but I liked the contrast of textures between traditional cookie and shortbread and it was pretty unique. read more

This review is long overdue as a frequent customer.. I'd heard all about the cookies and then this place popped up in my neighbourhood. I went immediately, and have been going back ever since. The staff are incredibly friendly, the product is consistent.. These cookies are honestly pretty great. It comes with a side note however - they are a bit of an acquired taste. They have a salty component to them (the butter?), and at first it was off-putting but it then became part of the draw. Take out only in this location, but there are plenty of places to eat them in the neighbourhood. Well worth a visit. read more

Having lived in the Village for a number of years, I was quite happy to see a place like this pop up. The staff was very friendly and cheerful, which I really appreciated. While I definitely appreciated the many flavours offered, I would definitely agree with the rest of the more critical reviews in that the base dough was the same, with a piece of a chocolate bar, etc baked in the middle. I was hoping for something with a fresher take - maybe mixing the bar/deconstructed ingredients into the base dough to create that individual flavour, but hey - to each their own. I would say it is worth a shot but it might not be your shot of milk (a nice touch that they offer.) read more

All I can say is... Craig's Cookies has my heart. Hands down, they have the best cookies in the city - I can't believe it took living in the city for three years to finally try this place out. Had to line up a bit but the line moved fast, and it was WELL worth the wait. I got the Salted caramel (and something) cookie, the one with oreos in them, and mint chocolate ice cream - the ice cream sandwich! Chewy, delicious, not too powerful but still so good. Would recommend and will definitely be coming back to try the other flavours! read more

Craig's Cookies - Front Window - Bakeries Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

See all

Wow. Sweet and salty goodness. These are the most decadent, soft, rich, bold cookies I have eaten in a long time. Definitely for a Sweet Tooth! We ordered their mix bag dozen, and boy are we satisfied. They still felt warm when we got them, super fresh and filling. Mostly focused on OG chocolate chip but elevated! I would recommend this for a indulgence as they are so sweet. read more

I am in love with these cookies! They are so delicious, and with all the flavors being tasteful, it just brings so much joy. I'm so glad to be able to enjoy these fresh baked cookies in the comfort of my home.Will definitely be supporting this local business! read more

Craig's Cookies - Craig's Cookies lovely packaging - Bakeries Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

Incredible. We tried 6 different flavors and they all had a fantastic soft texture at the center with crispy edges. So impressed!

These aren't your fat free, sugar free, gluten free, flour free cookies......these are your old fashioned chewy gooey favourite snack from your childhood cookies. They're delicious, come in many flavours, fresh and, a little heavy on the stomach. Pure comfort food when you're feeling down or you want to treat yourself. Their flavours do change for the season.. but the staples like chocolate chip are always available, mmmmmm! OH. you can also get cookie sandwiches with ice cram in-between.......way to heavy for me, but Im sure amazing!! read more

These are by far the best cookies! Delicious cookies! (I love your TikTok too lol who could write a bad review on these cookies? They're literally the BEST cookies!) read more

Awful unfriendly company. Cookies are terrible. Customer service to be desired. Pass this one up.

Hands down the best cookies I've had in a long time!!! Crisp on the outside, soft and gooey on the inside. If you go the fererro rocher is to die for! It seems like they use the same cookie dough base for their flavours but I'm not hatin'. If you have a good thing, why change or deviate from it right? I'm so glad we made a stop at the shop...staff are extremely friendly and helpful. read more

Delicious soft and gooey chocolate chip based cookies. I went twice and tried the classic, pride, and almond cookies and they were all great. The best part of Craig's is how friendly all of the staff is. Would recommend if visiting Toronto. read more

These cookies are insanely good. Love all the creative flavours but even the classic chocolate chip is delish ! You will not be disappointed ! read more

Fab cookies!!! Service is delightful! Decor is amazing. Cookies are delicious! I would recommend these cookies to anyone :) My fave is the mini egg! read more

Cool idea, but certainly overpriced. One cookie costs the same as a whole box at the grocery store. Get someone a $30 cake instead of 12 tiny cookies. read more

There aren't enough words in any language to convey the magic on Craig's cookies. Every experience (I have been a few times now) has been fantastic. The collaboration between Craig's cookies and Dutch Dreams ice cream has made this the best one-stop shop in the whole city for dessert. I highly recommend the mint chocolate chip ice cream with their mini eggs cookie or cheese cake cookie! read more

The Dutch Dreams ice cream flavours they had were amazing - We tried the Brownie (combined with a Skor cookie) and Wildberry Cheesecake (combined with a dark chocolate cookie) flavours. Both were scrumptious. Service was very quick! The only thing that I didn't enjoy was the staff person who very curtly asked us to stand further away as another customer ordered just behind designated area near the counter. Otherwise, a great snack on a hot day. read more

I really wanted to like the cookies and not worth the price. The cookies were more salty than they were sweet :/

I have walked by Craig's Cookies on Church Street and always wanted to try it. Tonight I tried. I went in and it smelt amazing and the cookies looked amazing. I picked out two and attempted to pay but could not because there was a problem with and only take tap. They also do not accept cash. I was informed I would have to use a different card but I do not have another card. So they just looked at me like "sucks so be you then". I suggested that most people would have just comped the cookies in this situation. Ian who decided to interject even though I was talking with another store representative, looked a me and in a sing-song voice said "Sorry, have a good night miss" even though I am obviously 20 years older than him. I was not being a Karen but I was so socked by his rudeness and obsequiousness I felt myself about to ask to speak to a manager. Instead I asked for his name for this review. and left. The funny thing is I am sure that they throw out dozens of cookies every night. Because of Ian I will never know if Craig's Cookies are good but I know the service sucks! read more

MY NEW FAVOURITE PLACE. LOOVEE the cookies! Every cookie I've tried is delicious and the chocolate just melts in your mouth omg, if you haven't gone - GO!! read more

This place is super cute and the cookies are tasty. However, I do find them to be salty tasting and are ultimately all the same base with a chocolate bar in the middle. Would be nice to see smaller pieces mixed throughout the dough. read more

I had waited to try Craig's Cookies for quite some time and all I can say was that they delivered on everything! Their cookies are beyond incredible and have proven that they are worth the hype. Do yourself a favor and try Craig's if you haven't already!!! read more

BELIEVE THE HYPE!! These cookies are incredible!!! I am obsessed with Craig's, I have never had such a unique and delicious cookie. Their flavors are amazing and there are so many to chose from. This place is a must try!!! Im salivating just writing this review read more

Delicious cookies, seasonal flavours, coffee beans and mugs, fresh coffee, eggnog, milk, gift boxes, bulk discounts... The cookies are loaded and salty and boxed with a cute rainbow heart. My husband and mom are now addicted to them too. We liked the cheerful staff singing along to Britney Spears. read more

Their cookies were a bit of a let down. The prices are crazy! They put soo much junkfood into the cookies that I had a hard time actually tasting the cookie itself. It's hard to enjoy a cookie that makes your teeth hurt because it's just too sweet! They are not bad cookies, just sometimes less is more. read more

Fantastic cookies! I ordered a large variety to give as Christmas gifts. They were delivered on the day I requested and were all delicious, soft and chewy. read more

I love these cookies. They're expensive, sure, but you won't regret trying them. The selection changes each day but I've seen flavours like pop-tart, pirate cookie, baklava, and others. Interior is beautiful too. read more

Fantastic cookies and wonderfully friendly staff. A real treat. I've tried the Bueno, Baklava, and Classic cookies so far. All amazing. Highly recommended for locals or for visitors like me. read more

i've already written a review about their other location, and my thoughts on this one is similar (reasonably so cos they sell the same things haha). their cookies are actually really addictive, and i can't resist picking some up every time. they have a wide selection of other foods that are stuffed into chocolate chip cookies, with my favourites being the cinnamon bun, strawberry pop tart & the banana bread. so, you could say they have a lot of variety but not really, because every cookie except the toffay one has chocolate chips. however, i've noticed an issue with the cookies.. they are really really greasy.. (disclaimer -- i don't know if this is normal for all cookies) i split a box with my friend, and so i had two cookies wrapped in napkins. later, i noticed all the grease that was seeping through the two layers of tissue. as well, i recall having the cookies in both paper boxes & bags, both of which the grease managed to soak through. oh well, in their defence, cookies aren't meant to be healthy, right? read more

amazing cookies, amazing service and amazing atmosphere! there is not one complaint about this place. my girlfriend and i got 4 cookies total and loved them all. 10/10 recommend and we're going back asap!! read more