I cannot comment on the taste of the pizza, as I did not have any, but my family said it was just…read more"meh". They give you a buzzer when you order, after about 10 minutes of noticing a pizza on the counter, we went and asked. Sure enough, it was ours, and they never rang our buzzer . Definitely a little disappointing after paying over $30 dollars for a pizza.

We're staying at tamarack this weekend and decided to order pizza and take it back to our room. We…read moreordered the New Yorker with no cheese and added pepperoni. This pizza was top notch!!! even without cheese! My husband and I thoroughly enjoyed it and said this is the best pizza we've had in Idaho! Definitely worth it. Would 10000% order again!

Pizza was very good! Locals eat here. Place is a bit rustic. Coke products. Nice salad bar…read more Small parking area. They do lots of carry out.

Called in order to go. Hot and ready when we got there. Great service. Pizza tasted great!read more

We stopped by The Reserve at Tamarack Resort and had such a great experience that I had to leave a…read morereview. From the moment we sat down, Alfred completely elevated our visit. He went above and beyond with his service--attentive without being overbearing, and genuinely invested in making sure we had a great meal. Every recommendation he made was spot on. You can tell he really knows the menu and takes pride in what he does. We ordered the chicken plate, and it was absolutely delicious--perfectly cooked, flavorful, and one of those meals you keep talking about afterward. Between the incredible food and Alfred's exceptional service, this was easily one of the highlights of our time at Tamarack. If you're in the area, do not skip this place--you're truly missing out if you don't stop by. Highly recommend, and we'll definitely be back.

Chef Charlie is great. Alfred is a great. Small menu (not complaining - just FYI)…read moreSteaks, sides, sauces and desserts are all great. The only problem is the reservations.... They have an empty restaurant at 4:30 and won't let you in. We watched so many people get turned away but we sat in the restaurant by ourselves from 4:30-5:45. It's a quiet, fine dining restaurant. Limited number of tables so book early if you want to go. Small bar to sit at. They have a kids menu with mac n cheese, chicken tenders, steak or butter noodles. Coke products. You can room charge if you're staying on site. Coat rack near hostess. Bathrooms down the hall near the market. Wine menu. Brunch on weekends.

Yummy food, great beer, and kind service! The restaurant was clean and we were served promptly! All…read moreof the meals and drinks came exactly as we ordered and felt like a fair price!

The service was terrible. She was very rude and then the wait to get our salad containers was very…read morelong. The salad bar was not stocked with fresh vegetables. We were waiting for garlic bread and still had not gotten the bread 30 minutes later. We finally went to talk with her and she then admitted that she forgot about the bread and it burned. There was only one other family in the restaurant that had already been served.

Oh my god! This place is fantastic. First- who cares…read moreabout big ass speakers on the porch, they are inviting you in. They were playing The Grsteful Dead - so rock on! Second - the pizza is freaking delicious. The crust on this pizza is something I have never experienced. We had the Pesto chicken. To die for! (PM Dawn reference) Beer selection along with wine- top shelf. Third- the dude behind the counter run the show without the show. They get you what you need and let you be. You wanna watch Tommy Boy on VHS, you may! Side note: Thank you for the two customers who came in to get their pizza: (1) pajama beer in hand guy- you rocked it. (2) summer dude in sandals and shorts, must be from Idaho. (it's 39 degrees) GO TO CRUSTYS!

Well, they were finally open today and it did not disappoint. We had a smokejumper with elk…read moresausage, cranberries and jalapeños- amazing. The thin sourdough crust was awesome allowing you to savor the toppings instead of having a mouthful of dough!!! Service was amazing and we got our order within 15 to 20 minutes and we felt the price was reasonable for the type of pizza and being in a tourist spot... I didn't want normal on vacation.. I can get that at home!!! So, do not judge the book by the cover... it's a little rough on the outside but the food is great, a must place to eat in McCall.

Called and placed an order to-go. Pizza was hot, ready and on time. The Big Growler pizza was…read moreamazing. Inside looked nice and clean, hostess was very nice when picking up the pizza.

We went during the off season for McCall, mid April. Staff was friendly and helpful. Sweet potato…read moretots and sauce were yummy. Garlic cheese bread was simple, made on focaccia bread. Pizza was tasty and toppings plentiful. We had the BBQ chicken and all enjoyed it. We appreciated that they had more open hours as many businesses this week were closed all week, part of the week or closed yearly. Milkshakes were good too!

Every time we come to Council to visit we always plan on getting pizzas from here because they are…read moreabsolutely delicious. This last week we picked up multiple pizzas for family visiting. My personal favorite is The Lumberjack but they are all so good. Their salads are also great. The staff is always so friendly and welcoming too.

We were passing through town at dinnertime and took a chance on eating at a small town pizza joint…read more We were surprised and delighted with the quality of the pizza here! Fresh ingredients, homemade sauces, and a tasty crust were all used on some unique pizzas. My wife built her own while I ordered the Chicken Carbonara which includes a spinach artichoke heart cream sauce with fresh mushrooms, bacon, chicken, tomatoes, and onions. It was superb and I'm not a fan of heavy cream sauces like alfredo; this was a lighter cream sauce. My wife ordered a build-your-own pepperoni mushroom pizza with light sauce and loved it. The only criticism was that the crusts were a little overdone, especially my wife's which was black on parts of the bottom, but you could not taste a burnt flavor. The service was average; the attendant at the counter could not tell us the answers to some detailed questions and didn't make any effort to find out but the service time was typical for a fresh-made pizza on a fairly busy Tuesday night. The place was very popular for both dine-in and take-out. There is an outside covered patio which more than doubles the small inside dining space. The inside is LOUD so don't expect a quiet intimate conversation when you go. The place could use a little attention to detail in clean-up, the bathroom door had dirt and grime that could have been easily removed. Sizes are small, medium, large and extra large and value increases with size, naturally. The prices are not inexpensive but we felt that the quality of the pies was worth the cost. We are pleased to have found a good spot to eat while we are out on western Idaho day trips.

We are visiting McCall and looking for a pizza option... there are a few to choose from. I am happy…read morewe picked Hometown Pizza. I've read posts about other items on the menu, this rating is just based on what we ordered - pizza! Pros - great pizza! We order a large cheese and pineapple pizza for 3 kids. A medium 1/2 garden & 1/2 combo for two adults. The garden was delicious (great flavor, fresh, good veggies/ crust proportions of ingredients) -- and no complaints and full bellies for everyone else. - super quick, ordered and it was ready for pick up in under 30. - very reasonably priced $50 for two pizza that fed us and left a few slices for lunch tomorrow. Cons - the website for ordering online was a little clunky, but worked... (not bad enough to knock off a star). - while everyone else liked the crust one kid did not, it was thinner and had a different texture (less "bready") than other pizza places, e.g. Papa John's. (IMO it was good!) The place was packed at 5pm on a Wednesday so that might mean something!

I went here many times. The buffalo chicken pizza is heaven. It makes me mad not to see too many…read morepeople in here. The people behind the counter are really nice and hospitable. The ambiance could be better, but if more people really knew about this spot, it could be a serious hit. I'm backing this up, it's good.

Absolutely wasn't sure what to expect when I saw the name of this joint but with just a few choices…read moreof where to eat in town we decided to give it a try. And so happy we walked through the doors. Yes, it's totally a dive restaurant/bar BUT the hostess was soooo friendly and accommodating and the food was top noche delicious. I especially enjoyed my juicy bison burger service with a nice piping hot and crispy side of fries. I also ordered a double shot of Jameson and the pour was generous! There's plenty of TVs to watch the football game from almost any seat in the house. Very cool joint; wish we had a Cougar Dave's back in my town!

The food was awful, I got a blt and the bread was so stale you could knock it on the table. I want…read moreto support local but this is NOT the place. $16.75 for a sandwich is wild, hit subway on your way out of town.

Explosion of flavor with each dish & every bite! Great beet salad, with well balanced marinate…read more Bacon wrapped dates, YES! Perfectly crisp bacon, sweet & savory date. Shrimp tacos were perfectly cooked & seasoned. Wonderful selection of wine. Glass of red Kionia completed the experience. Staff was personable & friendly. Another great place to dine by Chef Topple

This is our go-to place and we're so lucky to have it in Donnelly. We love the pasta bowls and the…read moreflatbread and of course a bottle of wine! Kyle is the best.