So many different flavors of cupcakes! I had a blackberry cupcake with a cream cheese layer and blackberry frosting. It was very flavorful, soft, and fresh. I also had a lemon macaroon that was delicious. They didn't have any macaroons on display, but since I saw on yelp that they sold them, I asked the nice woman working there and she let me know what flavors they had that day. read more

I didn't read any reviews before coming here. I, like Juliana L., wanted to write a good review. I ordered sugar-free chocolate, as did another in our party. It was dry, very crumbly, and had a long, lingering bitter after-taste. The frosting was way too thick and also did not have a pleasant flavour. My wife simply ordered the frozen yogurt in a cone. Very watery and nearly tasteless. What a disappointment! I give the place two stars for the exceedingly friendly and accommodating server. When I'm back in Yuba City, I hope to return and give Cupcake Magic another chance. I really hope to see improvement. read more

The cupcakes are ok but not the greatest I ever tasted. Most of the frostings were way to sweet and heavy, but I did like the chocolate cover pretzels. read more

Went in to ask if they by chance had gluten free cupcakes, they do!! I was so happy! It was some kind of berry cupcake, my husband had the gluten-full version. The prices were reasonable too! We'll be back! read more

I'm giving 5 stars just based on the customer service and friendliness! I haven't bit into my cupcakes yet, but I was so impressed with how sweet and friendly they were here. Very hard to find these days!! I will gladly support a local business like this, especially when they have a great attitude and personality! read more

Cute place. Owner seems very nice. But she is a retired nurse not a baker. Had 3 types of their cupcakes, very dry. The chocolate one was very dense and the flavor was off. Frosting was not creamy like I was expecting. Coconut was yummy but dry. Not sure how she gets them so dry but I would rather buy some at Raley's. I hope she can improve and make it! read more

I had the vanilla salted caramel cupcake and it was amazing. I have to say without a doubt the best cupcake I've ever eaten. Would definitely stop every time I'm in the area. read more

Took the kids for a treat and the kids got some cake pops and cupcakes. The cupcakes were pretty dry and the cake pop was overly dipped in chocolate. Maybe we went on a bad day. read more

Absolutely delicious! Best vegan cupcakes I have ever had! So incredibly impressed!! Thank you for a great experience!!!

The peanut butter cup is the best cupcake I've ever had. A little pricey but worth every penny! The chocolate chip cupcake is tremendous as well. read more

I went there yesterday and had a peanut butter cupcake. The best part about the cupcake was the peanut butter cup that was baked inside; the cake was very dry and the frosting was not very flavorful. Another person that I was with had the chocolate raspberry. There was hardly any raspberry inside the cupcake;therefore it was pretty much a chocolate cupcake. That cake was also dry; it was almost stale. The staff is very friendly, and there store is very nice;however, I will probably not go back there. read more

I must say the store is very cute. But what i liked about it most was the service. Tammy was very helpful. So nice, here i came in baby one one hip a four yr old too excited at the idea of cake! Not only did she give me a complete run down of the window display but she also helped serve me and assited me with getting a cold cup of water. I tried the coconut and loved it my son the carrot cake. I also bought two minis the strawberry and the choclate raspberry mousse. Delicious. I will definitly come back again! And will suggest it to others read more

My family and I are always searching for great gluten free baked goods. These cupcakes were great! I would recommend them to anyone!

The cupcakes are super moist and scrumptious. My favorite cupcake is the strawberry. For the topping on it they used a fresh strawberry not a canned or preserved one like other bakeriers. Excellent place delicious cupcakes. read more

The cupcakes are excellent one of the kind and my coworker and I make it a point to stop by every week if possible. So treat yourself it's worth it. read more

I went to Cupcake Magic when I was waiting for my to go order from Sopa Thai. I got two scones, 1 cranberry and 1 blackberry. I got to say they are very moist. The blackberry was my favorite. The lady that waiting on me was very nice and friendly, and was not pushy when I could not make up my mind on the flavor that I wanted to order. I will be going back to try other things. read more

I just bought 2 macaroons the Neapolitan and birthday cake, seriously the best I've ever had. Macaroons are really difficult to make let alone get right! They have the perfect flavor and texture. I've gotten these cookies other places and been less than thrilled, even attempted to make them myself, and its a lot of work. Simply the best. read more

Cupcake Magic - Best macaroons I've ever had! Neapolitan and Birthday cake. - Bakeries Near Me - Yuba City, California

Just stopped by this cupcake shop and got some of the chocolate cup cakes with chocolate icing, not bad the cake part was a little dry and crumbly - not sure if they were yesterday's leftovers or not read more

Best macaroons and ice cream sandwiches are soooo big and good! Place is always clean/cute and people are very friendly.

I wanted to like this place, but unfortunately that wasn't the case. I picked up a large assortment of cupcakes here for my co-workers and family. The good: The flavor variety and there's lots of frosting! The red velvet cupcake tasted amazing! The bad: Some cupcakes were undercooked on the inside. The coconut cupcake was very dry. The espresso cupcake tasted like cigarettes (I don't even smoke but it tasted like an ashtray). The rest of the flavors were ok, but sort of bland. These aren't great quality cupcakes so I think they're overpriced and I wouldn't pay more than $1 for a cupcake here. The really bad: They sometimes keep their doors open and a lot of flies come in. They crawl all over the cupcakes and the owner still sells them and just swats the flies away. It was very off putting to say the least. read more

We enjoy going here; however they are a bit pricey for our budget (we only go on special occasions). Sometimes the cupcakes later in the day taste a bit dried out, but overall they must be doing something right cuz we keep coming back. read more

We tried the carrot cake, red velvet, St.Patrick's Day cupcake and a lemon cupcake. My favorite was the lemon (#1) and the red velvet (#2) and the carrot cake a close 3rd. The owners were delightful and were very friendly. I will return to try more of a variety as much as my waistline will allow. ;) They have gluten-free cupcakes as well, which I appreciate! The cupcakes were all delicious and moist and we went a few minutes before closing time, I was impressed! read more

I love coming here.....they make the best cupcakes in town hands down. My favorite are the banana split, almond joy, and black and white...they are very friendly and its a nice clean place. read more

I have been to this store at least 10 times for a little sweet treat break and often get to-go dozens for family get togethers. I have to eat Gluten Free and unless I make it myself I can rarely find fresh GF goodies and never at a yummy bakery. Everyone in my family loves the regular cupcakes and I always love the GF...they used to have a 4-in-1 cupcake too that was Gluten/Sugar/Dairy Free & vegan I think. They had to quit making it beause not enough were sold, so people on special diets need to ask for this option because they were fantastic!!! read more

My son loves this place we walk 1/2 mile each way to get his favorite Carrot cupcake and the owners are so sweet to him !! We love this place !! read more

This place is great. I love all their flavors but my favorite so far was the gingerbread with the wine frosting. Too bad its seasonal!. I go in here probably too often for my paycheck lol but its so good I can't stop. We deserve to treat ourselves right? I always come in for one, and end up with at least two, most likely three. They know me by name and I think its so cool that Yuba City finally has a cupcake shop. I lived in the Bay area and really missed them. People are nice, and even during Xmas Stroll when I got burned by next doors soup, they helped me cool the burn down and did some first aid. The cupcakes I bought though did the most to dull the pain :D. Other great flavors are lemon, and the new peanut butter jelly :). Feel like a spoiled kid eating her favorite thing. My boyfriend likes the Guiness stout one which was seasonal :( And I hear special Vday flavors are coming up! read more

Wow! Stopped in on my way through town. Needed some bday dessert for an employee and these did not disappoint!! I got a dozen assorted cupcakes and they were a hit with the whole crew. Very moist and the frosting was so good. I do not like a mouthful of sugary sweet frosting but this was different, maybe made with cream cheese but I'm not sure. It was perfect whatever it was! the couple that helped me at the counter were so nice and even at 5 p.m. they had a good assortment to choose from. My only disappointment is that I live an hour and a half from them. Now that I've discovered them I want more! read more

I LOVE this company. I never have liked cupcakes, but I tried the blueberry cheese cake and OMG!!! I went and tried their cheese and sausage muffins and I am dying to figure out how to make them myself. Everyone that helped us when we called and visited always was so very nice and helpful!!! read more

Delicious! The peanut butter and jelly are to die for! Not a pb&j fan? You can't go wrong with any of the fresh fruit cupcakes. my personal fave is the blackberry cheescake. Everything is made from scratch with care. Very friendly service, too. read more

I can't believe all the negative reviews...I have eaten here several times, and had their cupcakes/cakepops at parties. Their ingredients are very fresh so if you purchase, drive home in a hot car, or let it sit anywhere the frosting will start to melt and fall off- that's a given. My friend did purchase vanilla cake pops for a Sac Zoo birthday- she gave them to the kids at the end of the day and they were still well put together and tasted great. I have had the sampler, and 5 kinds of their cupcakes- my favorites are the blueberry cheesecake and dark chocolate raspberry. Least favorite was Maple Bacon- but come on that is just silly anyway. What I really like about this place is they are constantly changing it up and trying new things- and WELCOME feedback from customers..for those with negative experiences try talking to them instead of just posting a bad review..I bet they will try to help or fix what was negative. This week they introduced frozen covered bananas, they always have holiday themed flavors and decorations. read more

Great service and cupcakes! My favorite is the pumpkin ginger. I really enjoy going there to have something sweet along with my coffee and hang out for a bit. The atmosphere is very friendly and the prices are reasonable. It's my new "coffee shop" hangout and I love love love the cupcakes. read more

Cupcake Magic has magical cupcakes but the customer service is not so magical. I special ordered cake pops for my daughter's birthday. We didn't try the cake pops until we were already out of town at the party location. The cake pops were the wrong flavor, lemon instead of vanilla. Most kids don't enjoy lemon, but a cake pop is a cake pop, right? After the party, I contacted Cupcake Magic and spoke with the owner. I told her what happened, in hopes that she would offer us another batch of cake pops to make up for the mistake. Instead, she insinuated that this never happens and that they were most likely not lemon, but colored by the sprinkles. The sprinkles were purple. That doesn't jive to me. Lemon is lemon. She offered no compensation and gave me a snippy sorry. Aside from this blunder, I do not recommend you purchase the cake pops, not because of my mishap but mainly because they are not the best tasting. The cupcakes are much better and more economical as well. You get much more bang for your buck. It's a lovely store, with some yummy baked goods, but the owner needs to learn to cherish her customers, or she may find them diminishing. read more

If I could give this place zero stars, I would. I brought home six cupcakes. My son took one bite of his, and I took one bite of mine. It was a race to the garbage can to see who would spit first. We had two different kinds of cupcakes, and both were dry and flavorless. I would rather eat a Hostess cupcake than eat these overpriced, tasteless rocks. read more

I'm usually not the biggest fan of cupcakes but when I went to cupcake magic, I liked every single cupcake I have tried from the pumpkin spice to the red velvet. I always recommend this store to all my friends and I hope that it stays around for a long time. The people who helped me were really nice also, I can't wait to go again! The only and best cupcakes I will ever eat! read more

my advice is skip this place! I purchased a red velvet cupcake on a Friday afternoon. I asked what kind of frosting was on my cake and was told it was cream cheese with a base of butter cream. I will eat my hat if there was a speck of butter in that frosting! In fact,I would rather eat my hat. The cake tasted dense and pasty. The frosting left a film on the roof of my mouth. Yuck! I will say that the staff were very nice but nice isn't going to bring me back. I wish there were more options in town. read more

The shop is so CUTE and the cupcakes ADORABLE... and the owners SO NICE! I love stopping in for the little 2-packs when I'm going to visit sick friends/elderly in care homes (who aren't diabetic...), etc. They have wonderful flavors of cupcakes and you're always proud to present them to others. Check 'em out! read more

I was really excited about this business opening. The selection of flavors is wonderful--makes your mouth water as you read the menu. However, I wonder if they eat their own products. I have been there 3 times, and ordered different flavors of cupcakes. Each time, the cupcakes were so dry that I thought they were stale. Their cakes tend to be dense, and that's fine, but when they cross the line into dry, it's not pleasant, and it overshadows what would be a great flavor. At first I thought it was the "new oven" issue, but after my third time, I think they just don't bother to test their own products. I hope they learn quickly, or I don't think they'll be around long, and that would be too bad. I can't wait to try their fondue! read more

I was very disappointed in the customer service. I ordered cupcakes for my office and there was an evacuation for the flood. The owner did call and I said there was no way to pick them up. I left a message stating I'd like a refund and was told she does not do refunds. I contacted her through Facebook and nowhere on her Facebook did it have the refund policy or that only credit would be issued. Also she didn't mention it when I placed the order. Happy to take my money but felt like it was bait and switch when it came to losing the order. read more

This is my favorite place to go when I have a sweet tooth they have a great variety of cupcakes and other sweets if you have not tried cupcake magic before go and try you will not be disappointed! read more

I've tried the red velvet, banana split, and the blackberry cheesecake cupcakes. All were very moist and delicious. The frosting was so delicious on all of them. I'm tempted to try more and I'll probably be back to purchase. They were a yummy treat for my birthday :) read more