1. Cynthia's Hallmark Shop

1. Cynthia's Hallmark Shop

0

Fishers, IN

Cancel

Open app

Search

Cynthia's Hallmark Shop

5.0 (2 reviews)
Closed • 10:00 am - 8:00 pm

Services - Cynthia's Hallmark Shop

Cards and stationery

Gift shops

Cynthia's Hallmark Shop Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Cynthia's Hallmark Shop

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration
Photo of Phil B.
105
1592
6261

5 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 4
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Cynthia's Hallmark Shop

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Cards & Stationery 297 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Gratitude Boutique and Gifts - exterior

Gratitude Boutique and Gifts

(4 reviews)

I was exploring Fishers along 96th St and noticed this little shop next to the Hallmark store in a…read morestripmall just east of I-69. Apparently, it opened about 2 years ago and somehow, didn't have any Yelp reviews. Well, I always enjoy checking out gift shops, especially when they feature a great deal from local artisans. When I first entered, I realized that the shop has three sections/rooms. The first is mostly gift items featuring candles that are made by and support women at Wheeler Misssion, funny socks, and a variety of items that suitable for gifts. Many have inspirational themes as well. The room beyond that features women's clothing and jewelry. I will let someone else who knows more about those things review these items, but the space was colorful and easy to move around in. The back room, or man cave, is small but is a great place for guys to hang out while their lady friend shops. There is a TV back there as well as some items that might be fun gifts for men. They've figured out the shopping experience of married life here! ha! Although I didn't get to meet the owner, the woman who was working during my visit was friendly and very helpful filling me in on the source of items and how the owner supports other local businesses and artisans. The kind of business that lots of Yelpers also support, so if you are in Fishers, check this place out before shopping at some big box store or online. It was a place I felt welcomed. Review #3723

Clever ideas, great gift ideas. Unique home items. Fun clothing & jewelry. Friendly, helpful…read morestaff!

Unplug Soy Candles - The Mysa Collection consists of a double-walled luxury soy candle featured in three different sizes.

Unplug Soy Candles

(36 reviews)

So fun! Easy! And the candles are amazing!!!!! The shop is gorgeous and the employees are so nice…read moreand helpful.

Such a cute place! Very, very cutesy. I'd say this spot is more chill than other candle-pouring…read morebusinesses I've been to. The staff that was there when I visited was pretty young, which could explain the laid back vibe--but they were all very nice, helpful, and super knowledgeable, which was awesome. Starting with the not so great: - A downside to this particular place is that instead of choosing different scents to mix, they already have them pre-mixed. For example, champagne and clean linen scents are already combined, rather than letting you choose and mix them yourself. Since it's structured this way, it does speed up the process, but I will say there are still a few pre-mixed scents you can mix together that would probably turn out smelling great. - When I went to pick up my candle a few days later, I was disappointed to find that it was damaged. Not sure how it happened, but I was shocked when I unwrapped it to discover it was chipped. Even more disappointing was that the staff wrapped a damaged item without mentioning it to me. On the positive side: - It's BYO food and drinks, which we loved. My friends and I brought a bottle of prosecco, charcuterie, and quiche to enjoy. Our server let us eat, drink, and chat before starting the candle pouring, which was perfect for catching up! - Parking is easy - Gorgeous vessels to choose from - Reasonably priced They also have a little gift shop with an assortment of trinkets!

Cynthia's Hallmark Shop - stationery - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...