What more could a girl ask for on Valentine's Day than a night at Penn and Beech creating your own candle? From the moment we walked in, it was cozy chaos (they were busy, of course!), but Rebecca made the whole experience absolutely fabulous! We picked our scents, jotted them down, and chose our candle jars. Picking a candle name is always my favorite part! Rebecca was a total pro, giving spot on recommendations for which scents paired best together. I wasn't loving my top three picks at first. We actually ended up swapping scents from each other's selections, and it turned out AMAZING! The value is great for the experience. Our jars were just under $40 each I believe, but they have a variety of jar options starting at $25, plus a larger, higher value option for those who want it. Penn and Beech is perfect for a GNO, date night, or even a team building event with work. Fun, interactive, and totally IG worthy, definitely a Valentine's Day win! read more

See all

Customer Service: Rebecca was very attentive and knowledgeable!! She was quick to check if we needed anything and was so patient with giving her scent combo recommendations. I especially appreciated her interest/participation in smelling the combos when mixed. Would love to have her help again next visit! Looking at all the scents in the store, the selection could seem overwhelming! But you are encouraged to take your time as you pick out your favorites. It is worth the time to evaluate and see what 2-3 scents you want to mix up. Value: The experience is priceless! But to make your own candle and have a drink could run about $30-$40, and I think it was worth it. This place is perfect for a slow chill day when you need calming, or even a date night! I'm definitely coming back! read more

See all

This is another great location for Penn & Beech, right in the heart of downtown Fishers. A friend and I had a great overall experience here outside of feeling a bit rushed towards the end. The staff member assisting us was very kind, super knowledgeable about which scents blend well together, and even recommended a few to help round out my friend's candle scent. I love that they have cups of coffee beans tucked among the shelves full of different scents (necessary). After visiting other locations over the years, I also appreciate a brand new selection of candle vases to choose from that I have never seen before. This location seems pretty busy, so I highly recommend making a reservation prior to stopping in. read more

See all

Very fun experience for the fishers area, just know that the price is high but it's for the experience.

This experience was such a vibe! From the music, to the candles, to their service...everything was so chill and perfect! It was our first time going and Grant was so helpful and very knowledgeable! He was very attentive and helped us make great decisions for our scents! It smells amazing in there due to all the scents and the lighting is perfectly bright enough but also dim! They even offer a drink menu which is a nice touch! The pricing really isn't bad...you pay the price of whatever vessel you choose! They're running a special of buy 3 get a 4th free which is what we did! We were pleased with the pricing for the experience and the number of candles we were able to create! Super excited to come back! read more

Penn & Beech Candle Co. - Wax Melt & Candle - Candle Stores Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Date nights are the best nights! I love candles so this was perfect & so thoughtful. I've been to the Carmel & Downtown locations and always have a great experience so I was excited to try the new Fishers location. There's so many scents to choose from so it's always hard to decide on the type of candle I want to make. This time I decided on a vanilla/amber scent. There's also so many different types of vessels to choose from, I chose a signature branded one. I can't tell you the full prices (remember this was a date night haha) but I think it was worth it. Ben was amazing! 10/10 he was funny & kept us entertained as we made the candles. We got there fairly late (after work vibes) & were the only people there, which kind of made it more special. I would revisit this location. read more

Penn & Beech Candle Co. - Scented Oils - Candle Stores Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Penn & Beech was such a fun experience! Highly recommend. Candles can be picked up on the same day, but they also allow you to pick them up up to 14 days later read more

This was my first time visiting the Fishers location, but I've been to the Carmel and Downtown locations before. This spot is so cute! The storefront is adorable and the vibe is very clean. The only downside is parking is a little confusing. We parked in the garage around the corner, but then had to cut through some construction to get to the storefront. I wonder if there was a better way... This was also my first time going during the fall when they have their fall scents out. The employees were super helpful with picking out which scents would go well together. I went for autumn lodge, pumpkin pie, and sandalwood for my candle. Definitely a fresh & cozy scent! Overall a positive experience! My friends and I went to Taylor Swift Night 1, so naturally we needed the exclusive Swiftie candle! It was a little pricey at $43/candle. But it was a collectible so we splurged. They played Taylor Swift on the speakers the whole time we were there, so it was a good time! I'll definitely be back! read more

Penn & Beech Candle Co. - Swiftie candle - Candle Stores Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

After visiting Penn and Beech, I'm considering quitting my job and becoming a professional candlemaker! I'm not sure if I have all of the qualifications, but I do know that mixing my own candle is lots of fun! My friends and I had a girls night out at Penn and Beech in downtown Fishers. The studio is located in the heart of the city, surrounded by restaurants and shops to check out while waiting for your candle to set. One thing to note is that Penn and Beech is a small storefront with no street parking, so you have to park in the lot near the city hall and library. Also on the topic of the studio itself, there is a step up to get into it and it's very narrow inside with lots of tables and candle cases crowding the area, so it's not the most accessible for those in a wheelchair. The "lobby" area of the studio is fashioned with a couch and LED sign, making it the perfect location for a photo op! We started off by picking our scents, and there were literally hundreds to choose from. I tested everything from "pomegranate" to "old books" to "hotel lobby!" We were given clipboards to write down our favorites, and then we were presented with little bottles of scented oils to mix together. I was going for a "strawberry shortcake" theme, so I combined "oven-baked bread," "strawberry jam," and "vanilla bean" to achieve the perfect fragrance. At Penn and Beech, you pay based on your "vessel," and a current special is "buy 3, get 1 free." Being a group of 4, we had to take advantage of this deal! The employees are so kind and helpful, they even assisted us in creating the perfect scent combinations by assessing the "vibe" we were looking for. I regret not staying longer for some drinks! Penn and Beech is the perfect place to create memories with friends, and come home with a homemade souvenir to remember it by! read more

See all

I had so much fun with my family! We made a reservation for 7 and they accommodated us so well. There are so many scents to choose from and you can mix and match whatever you want! You got to pick out whatever vessel and personalize the sticker on the bottom. Definitely recommend this experience and make sure to make a reservation! read more

Everything was perfect about this place! Especially the assistance and support I received from Hannah W.!

We went to this location last night for a galentines book club meeting. The girls working were extremely sweet and helpful. They had good music playing and made sure to help us curate a perfect candle! The location is very narrow and small so if you are wanting to come with a party, I highly recommend booking a reservation! Can't wait to pick up my candle... and come back to make another! read more

Fun place... great for a date night. Call ahead to book your time. Lots of options. Takes maybe an hour.

Avid Penn and beech goer here. Love their selection and it's always a great time with friends and/or family! That worker Abigail is super cute and friendly! She deserves all the tips! read more

Such a fun experience! Giving a gift for a special occasion is one thing but actually having a memorable experience is another. We had so much fun and made lifelong memories that far exceed a store bought gift. Highly recommend!!! read more

Penn & Beech Candle Co. - Candle Stores Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Loveedddd this! So much! An amazing experience. The waitress was great and kind, really good service . I loved the smells and selection of smell. Price was great! read more

See all

What's fun and exciting experience! Went with part of the family and it was an absolute blast. Will definitely be going again, soon!

Best experience ever! My best friend and I went to celebrate our birthdays and it was so fun! Never thought making my own scent could be so exciting. I love my candle and now it's almost gone so time to get ready to clean out the jar and go back!!!!!!!! You must go at least once!!!! So fun and the space was beautiful and the staff was super sweet! read more

The Fishers location is a great place for the Fishers shopping community. The candle pouring experience is a must to put on your "to do" list! I have been to all 3 Penn & Beech locations and my experiences have always been wonderful! The servers are always helpful and make an excellent experience. Congratulations on your newest location! read more

Had a GREAT first time experience at Penn & Beech Candles. It was 5 in our party. The host was very informative on how we select the best smells for our candles. It was a very nice outing with me, my daughter and my nieces from out of town. My mother also attended- GREAT time and will be back read more

It was a fun experience for my cousins from Alabama. This was my second time and I enjoyed it like it was my first time.

I set up a candle pouring party for my mama's 70th birthday and Penn & Beech did not disappoint. The staff were extremely friendly, helpful, and kind. The whole experience from start to finish was so much fun. We will definitely be back. read more

I've been twice now. We had a great time. Lots of scents to choose from. We would go back for sure!

Super fun girls night! Our hostess was very helpful and patient she made sure we got the best deal for our experience. All the scents smelled so good my candle came out great read more

Great staff. Very accommodating and patient. Would recommend to anyone looking for an intimate morning/afternoon experience.

We had a wonderful experience making candles. Ben was our scent specialist and was helpful in recommending scents that paired well together. Will definitely be back! read more

Staff is very friendly and knows amazing combinations! Definitely recommend to have a date night, girls night or group of friends!

Not a good experience! Expect you to give 18 percent tip on top of expensive candle costs