A small mom and pop pizza place that has great pizza great customer service and great prices I'll be back

New Location corner of Gilbert and Stetson = Pizza was good as well as the chicken wings and bread sticks, price was good for what you get. We walked in and ordered and waited in the store. Store was very clean and in order. Will definitely be returning to this location. Thanks for your service. read more

The spicy hot wings were the best in town! They are baked, not dried out, and not too spicy. Just the way I like them! read more

Ordered a pizza and cheese was only on half of it. the dough was bubbly, they need to learn how to proof their pizza dough.

My daughter has gluten sensitivity and loves Dominos Gluten-free crust. I love to order online because it's convenient with minimal wait...however, when I received my email stating my order was ready, I am greeted by team member telling me my pizzas were just placed in the oven the online order is off with timing, I recommend calling store for a more accurate timeframe. Staff is polite and on task. read more

Diamond Plus Pizza - Nobody waiting but me - Pizza Near Me - Hemet, California

The food is great. But over the past few years the prices have gone up and the portion sizes have gone down. A small antipasta salad used to easily feed two with leftovers the next day. Now the medium barely feeds two, and no leftovers. Same goes for the small calzone. I'm going to start looking for an alternative. read more

The best pizza I've ever had. I'm from the Bay Area, and we have good pizza. I had to go to southern California and came across this pizza place. So glad I did. The pizza was so flavorful. I'm surprised it doesn't have 5 stars. read more

First time I ordered from this place. Pizza was delivered cold. The cheese is NOT real mozzarella it was gross!!! While they put a lot of Pepperoni on it, the Pepperoni was not good, it was the very thin generic kind. I will not order from this place again. read more

Never eat at this restaurant diamond Plus Pizza on Stetson and Gilbert very poor service from the owner he's rude to women I've been a customer for over 4 years and I've been putting up with his disrespect but I had enough today I will never support someone that is rude and I believe he's prejudice against African American women read more

I just moved to the area so I wanted to experiment and try a beer pizza place. The workers were so kind on the phone and made my food in a timely manner. The stuff we ordered came out perfect! They are very generous on the cheese and I love that !!! Also calzones are HUGE, pictured is a medium size one lol read more

See all

Possibly the worst pizza I've ever eaten I my life, soggy sloppy mess. XL pizza maybe 14" $22. It's a conveyor belt pizza..just all around horrible. By the time I got it back to the hotel you couldn't tell the difference from the soggy dough to the dissolved cheese. Left it sitting on on the table overnight and when I picked up the box to throw the pizza in the trash the pizza box soo wet the bottom fell out. The outside of the building looks like skid row, bums passed out on the sidewalk, months worth of trash blowing around. read more

We moved to Hemet about a year ago and we're anxious to get some good pizza, after several tries at local restaurants we finally landed upon Diamond Plus Pizza as our favorite pizza. Every Friday night it's pizza night and we always order pizza and salad and we love it,they're very accommodating and the order is always correct. They do a great job the delivery is fast and the food is delicious. We will continue to patronize this business as I feel it is the best pizza in Hemet. Thank you for the great job that you do. read more

I decided to stop here 1 night after a quick search through Yelp for some pizza. It's not in the best of neighborhoods: there were ppl hanging outside the other surrounding businesses. Anywho, I walked inside... very small place, luckily it was only 2 ppl sitting and waiting (come to find out that they found the place through yelp as well). I was asked by the cashier if I had a pickup, I told him yes (I had placed a phone order). There was a little mixup at first but then I was finally handed my order. As in other reviews I've posted, it's always a plus when the food is steaming from the bag or box: indicates freshness! Drove back home to enjoy my food with my family. The pizza was good. My only complaint was that it was kinda bland (the crust at least), like it should've been brushed with an olive oil/garlic mixture. The meal also came with some breadsticks and a teeny tiny cup of marinara. It should've been at least 3 or 4 cups of the marinara for all that bread. It was yummy, but a bit on the watery side. They are reasonably priced. I got 2 large pizzas and a box of breadsticks for under $20! Not bad at all. You can see all their deals on their website. I believe they do charge when you use your debit, I didn't know this until I saw the receipt. Overall, tasty pizza and good service. read more

See all

It was really nothing to sneeze at. I would have been better off ordering from dominos or Pizza Hut. I honestly love ordering from mom and pop shops because small business keeps the community alive. This time around I was truly disappointed. The highlights would be the customer service and the amount of veggies the put on my half vegetarian half pepperoni pizza. I expected better sauce, some seasoning at least but lack luster to say the least. I wish I had better things to say. read more

We were craving pizza but wanted to try something new, and not from the usual big chains. I'm glad we did! We ordered a large 1 topping, an order of 8 piece hot wings and 2 canned sodas.. We were very happy with the pizza flavor. Very good and rich in cheese! The only reason I'm giving 4 stars is because of the wings. Unfortunately they were cold when we opened them, perhaps because they were sitting while they made the pizza. However, they were VERY good in flavor! Perhaps it was our bad luck. Other than that I would've given 5 stats for sure. Our total was just a little over $20. Give them a try! read more

Diamond Plus Pizza - Large 1 topping pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hemet, California

See all

We are new to the area. My husband loves carne asada pizza. But we were unable to find out here in San Jacinto. So the next best thing was a Philly cheesesteak pizza that we found on the menu. We were happily surprised. Our food was delivered quickly. It was hot & fresh. The food was delicious. The Philly cheesesteak pizza could have used a little more meat & cheese, but it was very tasty. We also ordered the cheese bread. It was the bomb.com. Sooooo good. We also ordered the hot wings. They were really good also. I would have liked them a little crisper. But that's just my preference. I will definitely be ordering again. read more

See all

Best pizza in the in 2 cities and surrounding area, good prices good quality ingredients. Service is excellent, fresh food takes time so if you are ordering at their location have patience it WILL get busy but a phone order will be more convenient and easy for pickup. read more

Great pizza. Very skeptical cause of the reviews but it's legit fire my son loves his pizza and BM enjoyed her wings read more

See all

Pizza was extremely cheesy and doughy. I tried the pepperoni and sausage as well as Hawaiian. Both were fresh and tasty. Friendly fast service! read more

this place makes the best cheese pizza!!! i always order with extra cheese.. just so good

Spent 4 hours at dentist after biting into a foreign object in my pizza. I called the manager to inform him of what happened and he was extremely rude. Be very careful when ordering from this place. Wings were good. read more

Their pizza is bomb - really enjoyed it - a lot of pepperoni and cheese crust was bomb 5 stars for me! read more

Diamond Plus Pizza - Pep Lovers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hemet, California

My kids and I are pretty picky with our pizza and we wanted to support smaller businesses. Try this pizza for the first time tonight and it's pretty good. My kids loved it.. definitely will order again. read more

Diamond Plus Pizza - Cheese bread - Pizza Near Me - Hemet, California

See all

This place has really really good pizza and can hang with the best of them and the customer service is excellent and also this place is spotless I recommend this place to everyone it would not disappoint and it's affordable which is a plus nowadays read more

Fist time ordering Pizza from this spot. I based myself off of the reviews on Door Dash (Never trust Door Dash Reviews). Everytime I use they're reviews I end up with a not so great dine-in experience. Anyway, seriously guys what type of cheese do you guys use?!?! It looks and taste like plastic. My kids Love pizza and got thru half a slice each and refused to keep eating and on top of that 3 people out of 5 got the runs. The pizzas look pretty in the Pics but taste like plastic in real life. If you fail at making a simple pepperoni and cheese and a side of cheese sticks (pizza) should you really call yourself a pizzeria????? Also, wtf! To all the people who reviewed this place and got them to 4 stars. You guys don't know shit about good pizza. Stick to the frozen pizzas from Stater Bros. read more

Way better when we expected!!! We hesitated to get but definitely worth and workers are so friendly! Definitely will be getting my pizzza here more often! read more

My dad and I ordered pizza last night for the 49er game. Both of us got food poisoning really bad this all day. Dad is 87 so this is concerning. Never order here again. read more

This pizza holds up. Moved here 2019, tried a few places in town and this place gives you your bang for your buck. I usually throw pizza crust away but this I do eat, something they put in it? Maybe because the pizza is made with care? Staff is on point and respectful. Only thing I would change would be location so I could feel safe sending my wife, other than that love the pizza! read more

Took two hours for a large 3 topping pizza and the place is only two miles from my house to make my first and last experience even worse my crust was not fully cooked. read more

Not understanding all the great reviews but ordered two large one topping pizzas and when I arrived guy said he made two of the same ones which is not what I ordered but I didn't want to wait so I said that's fine I'll just take two pepperoni. Wasn't offered a discount or anything but it's ok. Get home and all the hype is all smoke and mirrors!! Talk about no flavor at all. Dough was extremely bland lacking salt, sauce had no flavor. Really just a big disappointment. Would rather warm up a digiorno seriously! Definitely won't be back, only good thing in that center is Mikeys Donuts. I do recommend them! read more

11/12/21 Pizza, has changed, I think it's the sauce. Ordered spaghetti and meatballs, for the first time, Nope, avoid. If you know good spaghetti, this is not it. Sauce was dull, meatballs definitely frozen. Ordered a large salad, got a small salad in la large bowl. Lettuce, with their pizza toppings. For 6.99? No. Will probably not go back because now the food tastes cheap. read more

We were having my niece and her boyfriend over to watch the new Bill & Ted movie, I mentioned I was going to order pizza, I didn't want Pizza Hut or Little Caesars, erc. I started looking up all the Pizza places in Hemet and San Jacinto & comparing what they had, I decided on Diamond Plus Pizza, my husband told me to just call our regular place and order but I went with Diamond Plus Pizza, The pizza & Anti Pasta salad arrived, smelled really good, my husband kept asking me where did I order this from and continued saying this is the Best pizza he has had in a long time. The salad was fresh and tasty. We were very pleased, from now on I will be ordering from Diamond Plus Pizza. Thank you Diamond Plus Pizza for a great meal with family, If you want Delicious & Tasty Pizza call Diamond Plus Pizza. read more

We just tried this for the first time- Pizza was really good and the sauce was great, Jeremy delivered it hot and fresh ..,.

I never visit the "yelp" website but I had to today. My family and I just ate "the very best" pizza I have tasted in Hemet. Not to mention the greatest pizza I have had in many years. It was fantastic!!!! The breadsticks were excellent as well. The prices are a bargain and the service was great too. They had my order done on time, although, they don't have online ordering my call was picked up on the first ring. I will definitely be buying my pizza from here for now on. Thank you Diamond Pizza for a fabulous meal! read more

We love this pizza I use grub hub to get it since I'm so far great pizza great toppings.

I thought I would give it a try due to all the 4 star reviews. Pizza was pretty bad my daughter would not eat it and my son said it taste like three day old pizza. It reminds of cafeteria style pizza, with the cheapest cheese you can find. Will not be back. However, I can say I gave it a try. read more

We were looking for a new pizza place to try and came across Diamond Plus Pizza and glad we did. We got a classic pepperoni pizza and it was delicious and the wings were spot on. Would return just for the wings. Decent prices. Was able to order online for pick up and was ready within 20. Will definitely be returning ! read more

Good and fresh pizza. The dough was very soft and you can tell it was fresh. The only thing I don't like is the location..... be prepared to see people walking around the parking lot or just standing next to the liquor store, that is next door read more

The pizza was good and they have good deals I didn't like the overpriced small antipasto salad and three dollar delivery charge but I'd still order from them again. read more

Excellent pizza and great deals for pick up! The dough is so nice and chewy I love it and my picky eater has no complaints