TL;DR: Small shop, but great quality. I went to this spot to try and wasn't expecting much. Seeing how small the shop was as well with a crowd gave me a bit of concern that it was all about the numbers and not the customers. Boy was I wrong! The cashier there was handling each customer and giving excellent service. While helping customers at the register, she would remember each person that comes in to help make a mental line queue. She was able to clear out the rush of customers quickly, and effectively. For the food, I got half a supreme pizza and the other half, a taco pizza-- a unique twist to a classic. The quality of the dough is incredible. Not overcooked, but still had a crunch and soft center. The ingredients were all so fresh and generously sprinkled as well. I was surprised at the price for the quality as well! For the negatives, these are minor, but: - waiting inside is very small-- would recommend to order online. - toppings fall off easily, but it might have just been a one-off issue. I'll have to try again! - pizza felt a bit small compared to other restaurant chains. I do eat more than most, but I was able to eat a large by myself. Definitely will go back. In fact, I went back the next day because I wanted more of the supreme pizza. I can't recommend this place enough! read more

Your Pizza Stop - Half Supreme and Half Taco! - Pizza Near Me - Menifee, California

New to Menifee, Nice town, I like it. Had a craving for pizza. Oh Yelp ... whatcha ya got??? Your Pizza Stop that's what !!! Again, not disappointed!! I ordered a large combination and a side of garlic parm wings bone in. The crust wasn't too thick as I like a thin crust. I took her recommendation, and it was what I was hoping for. The wings had a creamy garlic parm sauce that wasn't overboard on the garlic and Just enough sauce that the wings were not drowning in sorrow. They were just as good the next day warmed up. Oh and they have bake to go pizzas!!! That's my next try. Oh yeah, I'll be back !!! It's too close not to !!! If you're close like me, or visiting, uh, you should check out Your Pizza Stop. read more

First time ordering from this pizza joint. Heard great things about it and normally I stay away from fast food, but they have both Chicago deep dish style and New York style pizza. Since I lived in both cities and a very familiar with these types of pizzas I had to check it out. So, ordered a New York style large pepperoni and sausage pizza for pickup. The employee on the phone was very helpful and respectful. I arrived 10 minutes prior to the time she said it would be ready and she brought it out to me piping hot right away! My only criticism would be that the crust could have been a little more done( like in a brick oven). Otherwise it was great. The inside was small and for pickup only, no table or chairs for eating. read more

Your Pizza Stop - Box it came in - Pizza Near Me - Menifee, California

See all

I been going here or delivery for about 6months.The first time was pizza which is good and sauce is good. The meatball sandwich tastes different every time. Please lighten up on black pepper. Sometimes to much. I'll try again soon and see if I could eat it. read more

Best pizza in town. Closes pretty early so time it right. Quick and easy service. They offer a take and bake option too read more

Your Pizza Stop - Menu 05/2026 - Pizza Near Me - Menifee, California

See all

What happened??? Let's hope it's just one and out. But my last two orders have been wrong. The first time I let it go pizza is pizza, the second time yesterday nobody answered the phones. I hope this isn't the end o Menfees best pizza read more

I was really looking forward to a Chicago Deep Dish, so I decided to give this place a shot. I ordered through their app for pickup. My mistake was ordering in a hurry as it was almost closing time, so I didn't read the descriptions carefully and ended up ordering a 'Sicilian Deep Dish Pizza' instead of the 'Chicago Style', which is the one made like a pie. When I picked up my order, I realized I had ordered a thick pizza, not the actual deep dish I wanted. I was super disappointed (with myself) because the app clearly described the difference. Regardless of my mix-up, the pizza tasted good, so fluffy, and with fresh ingredients. It was a little light on the sauce, and the edges were a bit burnt and hard to bite, but overall it had a good, satisfying taste. The service was great, fast and efficient. The pizzeria smells amazing when you walk in, and they have a couple of counter seats if you want to eat in. I'll definitely have to return to try the actual pie I originally wanted, hoping it lives up to the great deep dish I had in Chicago. read more

See all

I so badly wanted to love this pizza shop and make it my go to from all the amazing reviews, but that is not what happened :( I ordered 2 large pizzas, one regular crust and the other thin crust. Both pizzas were burnt to a crisp around the edges/crust, so much so that we couldn't eat the crust, between the burnt smell and not being able to bite into the crust due to how hard it was. But the middle of the pizzas were like raw dough. Both of them. Each time a piece was picked up, the toppings, cheese, pepperoni and sausage would literally slide right off the dough. Sadly this was not worth over $50 and I don't think I'll be trying this pizza again. read more

Always delicious. Crust is on point. Good service. Ambiance is good. Price is great for the value. read more

See all

Pizza just ok..... passes ..... raw ah chicken wings. Like come on pop em a little bit longer the oven tf.

We love this Pizza! It's the best delivery Pizza in Menifee. The Owners are great people and they take pride in their Restaurant and Food Quality. We always go for their 2 Large 2 Topping Deal they have it feeds at least 4-5 people. We like our Pizza a little more crispy so we ask for it well done. I would definitely get your order in before the rush at 5-6pm since it's usually about an hour delivery, but it's well worth the wait. Their Antipasto Salad is pretty good and their Garlic Cheese Bread is a favorite of ours too. Its a small hole in the wall pizza place, but they make some amazing Pizza. I would definitely give it a try if you live in the area or if you are driving through. We've been ordering from the for over 10 years now, and it's still just as good as when we first started ordering from them. read more

Best pizza in town. Great rewards always order on line and they have never got the order wrong. Staff is friendly they also have a pizza that feeds about 15 people. read more

Ordered several pizzas to go. Prices were reasonable. Pizza and toppings were very fresh. To go only. Pizzas ready on time. Good customer service. We will be back! read more

Pizza was very good before, quality has gone down, the Answer for the undercooked pizza and still blood on wings was , "we are sorry it was Door Dashes mistake" As if they (door dash) made the pizza and undercooked wings. Very disappointed and very unsatisfied with the way quality has downgraded.. They have Lost a customer, that got the best and now worst of this place. From one of the better places for Pizza, to a very sad one. Get Domino's, at least they will fix your order and replace with actual cooked food. 75 dlls for uncooked food, very sad . The rest of the comments are starting to make sense. Owner should start paying more attention... read more

Your Pizza Stop - Not cooked fully raw dough. - Pizza Near Me - Menifee, California

See all

I am one of those strange folks that like a thin crust anchove pizza. Pizza Stop makes it perfectly.

Nah, brah. This ain't it. There are reviews on Yelp indicating that this is a 4.5 star place. It shouldn't be. There's a sign on the door that says it's New York style pizza. It's not. Here's what it is, though: not good pizza. Remember Boboli premade pizza crusts? That's what their crust tastes like. Ever taste tomato sauce straight out of the can? Now you know what their sauce tastes like. Their cheese may be the worst offender. It looks like, and has the consistency of cheap frozen pizza cheese. My god, it's bad. And the sausage is definitely the giant bag of preformed cheap Italian sausage that is more soy protein than pork. If you see this place, follow the instructions hidden in plain sight in their name, and just... Stop. Turnaround and go to someplace (any place!) better. read more

Your Pizza Stop - Pepperoni and sausage slices lunch special - Pizza Near Me - Menifee, California

Portions, quality, down, price up. Ok, raise prices, we get it. But to also reduce portion and quality and quantity of toppings, sauce going nowhere near the edge of the now-smaller pizza? No bueno. Do one or the other, not both. I would have rather paid more for same but this is ridiculous. Not worth going back. Was our all-time, all the time best and only place for pizza. No more. Kind of insulting. Recently seeing same comments by others elsewhere. read more

Great service from phone order to delivery. All handled by a pretty girl. (Sorry I didn't get her name) Pizza was exactly what I asked for and delivered promptly. Pizza was great with plentiful toppings. A+! Bravo pizza stop read more

First Time trying this place out. Placed an order on their website for pickup at 7:00pm Friday night. Estimated pick up time was 1 hour. I arrived at 7:50pm to check on the status. They said it'll be another 10-15 minutes. 8:20pm it was done. The pizza shop itself was small, a few stools to sit on inside but not a place to eat. There is a table and chair outside. The workers are very nice and attentive. I ordered a Large Build your own pizza regular crust with 5 toppings. You get 8 slices for the 14' large. I like that the pizza was not greasy (that's a plus for me) We will definitely be back. Yes it's busy but it's a good sign. read more

See all

First time coming here and let me tell you glad i found them...we were craving pizza usually we get dominos, caesars...but this time we stumbled to this place and they had alot of menu items..and prices are good especially for pizzas,lasagna,and hot sandwiches...we were met with great customer service..friendly and patient...we had to let people go before us because menu had alot of choices..finally we ordered the combo pizza,lasagna and meatball sandwich...and wow they were all pretty good...pizza dough was made perfectly..lasagna was gooey with alot of cheese and the meatball sandwich was perfectly made with enough meatballs and sauce...our son loved the pizza so much to say i dont want little caesars anymore..they got good linch specials so we will get that for our kids instead of mcdonalds all the time..coming back to try the deep dish pizza read more

We don't eat here often but when we do we are always happy and satisfied. Pizza was nice and hot which is always a favorite. Many thanks.

This is my usual place to get pizza from, but my order today was way off. I ordered a pizza with 5 toppings, two of which were non-existent and the rest was very sparse. The pizza looked flat and didn't taste very good either. So bummed! read more

This place is awesome! Pizza was great Chicago style. I would definitely get pizza from here again!

My recent Doordash order was delicious! It arrived early, hot, and perfect! I appreciate the equal distribution of toppings in my BYOP this time :) and the wings were meaty in size! Not a complaint, but so the business is aware, the beverage options listed in the Doordash app are Coke products. What I received was Pepsi (again). Please update for your customers! TYIA. note: menu pages 1 & 2 as of 05JUL2023. read more

See all

I happen to be dropping off a package at the Post Office next door and I took a chance on this place for lunch. This is the only place I go to for Pizza now. They are generous with the toppings and the cheese is really good. The dough is not too thick or too thin, just right. If you want to give it a try they do have by the slice deals. They also offer different foods to pair with your pizza. read more

I heard about this place from my picky parents and brothers. They Gordon Ramsey everything we eat, but this time they said I had to try it. So I did upon arriving a person who's from New York said "this place has the best pie, reminds me of home". I instantly thought I was in for a treat. When It was my time turn to order the girl at the counter was so absolutely nice and helpful I swear everyone that works there loves the place just by the ambiance in there. I absolutely love their pizzas and salads. This time I ordered knots and omg they came with garlic butter and marinara sauce and it was absolutely yum. I recommend this place as the number 1 pizza spot. Will not disappoint read more

The pizza was great! We loved the red sauce and the overall flavor of the pizza. We will definitely order from them again!

The pizza is super good! I love a super thick layer of cheese and they manage to do it here without the pizza being all greasy or soggy. Ordered online and everything was ready to go on time and the people up front at the restaurant were nice. Quick and tasty read more

Coming from someone who is a New Yorker and struggles to find good pizza that compares to back home, this is the closest to that and close by 10/10 recommend and the service is great as well! read more

Your Pizza Stop - Pizza Near Me - Menifee, California

I was looking for a decent pizza that offered delivery and the reviews here looked pretty good. Service was fantastic over the phone and communication on delivery was accurate. I didn't eat there so I can't comment on the dining room or cleanliness but I didn't see any nasty pictures or big complaints on here so?!? Pizza was really delicious. I got a classic pepperoni and a meat lovers. Crust was crispy and soft, nice balance of sauce and toppings. Meat lovers was on the salty side but with all that meat and bacon, kinda expected it. Was not disappointed will be a return customer when I am out here again! read more

Beware! They've changed pricing. When you order a pizza there's a base price and all additional toppings are extra. We paid $40 for a 14" pepperoni pizza and dry, flavorless wings. We won't be back. read more

First time here! Was greeted warmly by the crew there! The pepperoni pizza was amazing! It was hard to find it first it's tucked in into a little small corner. But it gives mom and pop authentic vibes. I will definitely go back again. read more

The pizza sauce tastes like if they opened up a jar and just poured it on top. I've tried Giovanni's pizza and the sauce is delicious. Can't compare the two. read more

Have ordered there twice. Pizza and sauce were tasty but toppings both times were very skimpy( not worth amt paid)

My husband and I wanted some good pizza and our number one suggestion was Your Pizza Stop. Glad it was because it hits the SPOT for real! Nice, light, crispy crust that has the right amount of spice that you might be fighting over crust and not feeling like it's all you've ate. I am typically not a crust fan but found myself eating most of it. Fine, I left one bite. Topping are fresh, real ingredients that bring it all together. For desert the cannolis are a must try. Yummy!! Service is friendly but not really a lot of room for dine in. Not an issue for us as we like our pizza to go. You can set up a time for pickup online through yelps website link very easily as well. Great overall experience! read more

Sergio is their Pizza man, this is best! We always get the "surprise ". N order cooked crispy one shell edge. Every time I go there I see his head comes around n saws "Hi". Very good. I always get "Herus" at least a week read more

Just average. There was a hair in our pizza. Gross! Service was ok. There was one girl that was very friendly but the one that helped us. Asked for the dressing/ sauces on the side of the sub came on it! So they don't follow directions. Won't be back. read more

I ordered a pizza to go. Gave me an eta of 35 minutes and was right on time. The pizza I ordered was sausage, olive and red onion with a garlic butter sauce. The pizza was tasty. Both my wife and I was impressed and this remains Our go to pizza joint in Menifee. read more

I give your pizza stop five stars!!We are new to the area my family and I enjoy this pizza very much Great customer service always very friendly.... This is our new favorite pizza stop I highly recommend them read more

After tasting their Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, Your Pizza Stop instantly became MY pizza stop whenever I'm in town! I ordered their deep dish with their homemade meatballs, sausage, and mushrooms, and Zomg, it's *chef's kiss*! It's hella saucy, cheesy, and absolutely delicious. The way they fold the crust over the stuffings makes every single bite worth it! Freshness is key here; I made sure to savor it as soon as I got home, and the flavors just melted so well together! With each mouthful, I felt like I was transported straight to the windy city itself! This shop is tiny, but mighty! And the staff is very nice! read more

Your Pizza Stop - 12 Chicago Style Stuffed Pizza - with Italian Sausage, Homemade Meatballs, & Ricotta Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Menifee, California