This is my go to shop for TCGs in the Cotati/Rohnert Park/Santa Rosa/Petaluma area. They have a…read moregood collection of single cards, including extensive bulk bins of lower priced cards. The staff are knowledgeable, friendly and helpful. They recognize regulars. Thier prices are very reasonable.

NEW LOCATION: 5800 Redwood Drive, Suite B (under Sign Dynamics)…read more Always a good trip to Rohnert Park when we get a chance to stop by the card shop and get the hook ups from Alex! Loving the new space, too! Lots of wall space for sealed products and lots of storage boxes & display counters with singles of assorted sets (Sports, Magic, Pokémon, Lorcana, etc.)

I had the best experience, the moment I walked in I was greeted and welcomed in . I bought a dual…read morecharger and 2 batteries and also another rc truck hahah . Thank you to you all for making my experience a great one and I'll be coming in for future purchases

Great Service and Staff. I enjoy assembling 1:35 scale polystyrene military vehicles…read more I had some technical questions regarding model paints, shades, and washes. The individual i spoke to spent a very generous amount of his time informing me about the issues I had with particular model paints, stains, and finishes.

The service is great, my fiancé bought a bunch of magic cards here and they're really informative…read moreand helpful. The selection is pretty good, especially the manga, they could use some more boy love but that's okay. Tom Beland used to work here and I miss seeing him. Definitely recommend getting anything by Brian K. Vaughn. "Y The Last Man" is incredible. The best story of all time. The prices are good and I've been coming here for years. Bigger location now and there's an upstairs! Yay!!

The only positive I can say about this shop is they have about three wonderful employees, decent…read moreselection, and have snacks. For example: I asked someone for help locating a small amount of cards and all he answered was idk. No effort to check anywhere besides the front glass case, etc. Also the majority of the time this shop has things for sale at scalper prices. Plus they try and push their own product called Vaulted Rarity which is just repacked cards with crappy value,etc . Also, if you try and turn in cards for store credit or if you dare cash value, you're going to majorly ripped off and get a small percentage of what it's worth. I've also ran into a lot of toxic customers here during gaming tournaments not really abnormal for the card gaming community but expect to have them do nothing if issues occur. Parking is not wonderful either with either small parking spaces, illegal parking behind othe cars during release weekends and people racing through the parking lot. If you want to not experience being ripped off, bad customer service, and be in a welcoming environment.... I would recommend going to Harveys in Rohnert Park.

So happy we stopped in here! This has to be the best game store I've ever been to. The decor alone…read morewas worth the visit but they had everything you could possibly want. I personally left with BG3 cards, dice, candles and choose your own adventure book. They had so much to look at we went back the next day of our trip. The customer service was excellent too, so nice and helpful

My family and I would shop here more often if the Staff were friendlier. We never know if we'll…read morehave positive or negative treatment by the person at the register. Today my daughter and I went in for her to pick out a birthday gift for herself. The young woman at the register, Jupiter, was very rude to us. My daughter chose a pack of Lorcana cards and I was looking at the earrings, but Jupiter was huffing and puffing impatiently since she had rung up the cards and wanted to finish the transaction. I asked her a question about the earrings that were on the counter and she snapped that she didn't know and that I should just look at them to figure it out. As i kept looking at them for less than 15 seconds, she slammed her hand on the counter and abruptly turned around to do something else. When I picked out the earrings to buy, she snapped, "Is that it now?" I asked for her name which she barked it at me while asking my name in the same confrontational way. I maintained being friendly to her, mainly to spare my daughter, (she's a sensitive adult with special needs.) As we walked out, Jupiter tried to cover her tracks by thanking us and wishing my daughter a happy birthday, but the damage was done. My daughter said she doesn't want to go back in there if Jupiter is there. This isn't the first time the Staff has been rude, and while we've also been greeted by friendly workers, the negative treatment has happened often enough that it's clear that half of the Staff needs to take a refresher course in basic customer service.

Great shop, great guys, great cards! Every time I go in they alway have a couple cards that I want…read more Making it hard not to buy something every time I go in. But I love that! Justin and his brother are a plethora of knowledge. Love the guys at the road show!

It was my first time at the store. Bob was very nice and welcoming he even gave me a free pack. The…read moreprices are really good and he offers a lot of discounts. Be mindful the hours are later in the day but overall I would highly recommend and will be back again!

Bob is a great guy and very knowledgeable. He's also willing to cut a deal as most of his prices…read moreare negotiable. He has a ton of boxes 1/2 off retail.

I walked into the store curious... child of the 70's and 80's... it was a Saturday and quite busy…read morewith people perusing and purchasing and fixing. Lots of amazing bits and bobs and the staff was incredibly friendly. Most shops selling retro games, the staff are standoffish or prickish... but here, they were friendly and helpful. I had a question on how to connect and older device to a new TV and I was provided with ample and VERY helpful info. Thank you!!!! I'll be back with my kids...

It was the winter of Nostalgia Alley's opening year. I wanted to get my friend an awesome Christmas…read moregift. I was greeted by Jason, the owner, and he was super welcoming, and we talked about what game my friend would like. He was asking so many good questions I didn't think about when shopping, we landed on Red Dead redemption 2 and another game. I always had a good experience at nostalgia alley throughout the years. From playing at their arcade to seeing what awesome stuff besides games that they carry. I will say, if you find yourself here in awesome Northern California that you stop at nostalgia alley because you'll be taken away at the gems you will find here.

One of the best comic (and toy) shops in the world...If you're looking for something specific, very…read moregood chance they either have it (or something related). Super friendly owners with a wealth of knowledge. Check it out and fill some holes in your collection!

It pains me to have to write this review. I've been a comic book collector in the Bay Area since…read morethe 1970s with over 45 years of experience with local shops. I used to consider Batcave one of the 'better' comic book stores. I first started going to the store in 2019 when my wife and I would make the store one of our main destinations to buy back issues when we were passing through the area. This store used to be something my wife and I looked forward to visiting. Unfortunately, that has changed. About a month ago, we made a special trip to Santa Rosa to pick out some back issues. We had not visited in a while and we looked forward to it. While browsing the back issues, I found that I needed to use the restroom. I saw a fellow customer go into a door that appeared to be a bathroom. There was no sign on the door indicating that this restroom was not for public use, etc. When the customer walked out, I went in after them. It was extremely gross inside with a mop partially blocking access to the toilet and I felt uncomfortable touching anything. The next thing I know, the owner was yelling at me aggressively through the door and pounding in a violent manner. He shouted, "The restroom isn't for public use!!!" I walked back out past the owner, apologizing profusely while he glared at me. I explained that I saw another customer go in to use the restroom so I assumed it was for public use. I told him I was extremely sorry, that it was an honest mistake and that it wouldn't happen again. The owner didn't respond, just scowled at me. I heard his wife loudly yelling, "(insert expletive insult here)!!!" I proceeded to put the back issues I had picked out back in their boxes. I no longer felt comfortable spending my money there after being shouted at and insulted. It was a mistake anyone could have made considering the door didn't have signage saying not to use it. But the owner's reaction was over the top and extremely aggressive over something so small. I went to find my wife, explaining what had happened when I showed up without back issues. She was extremely upset and unbeknownst to me posted a review saying that the owner's behavior was unprofessional. She was not ok with the way I was treated after so many years of going there. The owner could have responded to her review in an professional adult manner but instead he chose to throw a tantrum in his response, claiming that I had left urine on his floor causing a biohazard. I thought that was the end of it. However, it wasn't. A few weeks later, I was attending the old school Berkeley Comic Show. I walked up to one of the booths and started looking through a long box. Suddenly, a hand came over the box, blocking my view. A voice yelled at me, "you are NOT welcome here! You need to keep walking! You are banned for LIFE!" I walked away calmly, caught off guard by his unhinged anger towards me. He was shouting at the top of his lungs, trying to get the attention of the other vendors at the convention and his customers - anyone who would listen. He was trying to embarrass me and get the other vendors to turn me away as well. Thankfully, the other vendors paid him no notice. He was shouting about what a piece of garbage I was for using his bathroom, how pissed he was because my wife had written a negative review, he kept going on and on. I have honestly never encountered anything like this behavior in my forty five years of comic collecting. The level of anger coming from him was out of proportion for what was a simple misunderstanding. All I can only think that the owner must be an extremely unhappy and bitter person to hold such a grudge over something so small, that he would try and ruin my convention experience by embarrassing me to other vendors. Needless to say, I will never be shopping at Batcave again. I would encourage others to do the same. I wasn't even going to post this review until I was harassed in a public space by the owner. I only hope that the owner gets the help that needs, whether that's attending anger management courses or possibly going into a different field of business.