Wonderful experience. I needed 4 items appraised for insurance purposes. I was warmly greeted…read morewhen I walked into the store. I left my items and a few days later received a call to pick them up. Again, I was greeted with a smile. The appraisals were thoroughly explained to me. They did a beautiful job cleaning my diamond wedding band. This will be my "go to" jewelry store should I desire a purchase or need a repair. A very nice experience.

Family owned with very nice people working in the establishment located in Lakewood Ranch on Main…read moreStreet. This store has favorable return policy and stands behind their very nice merchandise. You can rest assured that you are dealing with real professionals with your satisfaction in mind. From our standpoint, overall a very smooth transaction. We will be back for all of our jewelry needs; purchase, repair, etc.

Why Diamond Vault? I shopped around local and big box jewelers to have this custom ring built. I…read moreloved they were family owned and present on-site. The staff was less about sales, instead focused on my story and Alina guided me with her expertise. They were upfront about their pricing, guarantees, values, and sent me picture updates during the process. I would recommend anyone looking for their next statement piece to check out their gallery and enjoy the same experience I've had.

Great honest people kudos to the man that requires a higher education for all his sales peopleread more

Top-notch jeweler. Prices aren't cheap but are reasonable given the quality. The store also has a…read morenice selection of inventory, beautifully displayed.

I had a ring repaired. The jeweler is excellent! He is very knowledgeable and reasonable.read more

Jeremy is a fair & honest man & very knowledgeable in his area. He bought our gold jewelry for a…read morefair price & gave me good advice on a large diamond

On a recent trip to Sarasota we enjoyed a too-brief visit to Thayer Jewelers. They have a wide…read moreselection of magnificent and unusual pieces at every price level. I left with a exquiste antique jade necklace. Thayer's will be atop our itinerary on our next trip.

Offer fair, realistic assessments, very knowledgeable, no pressure, honest appraisals, excellent…read moreservice.

I can't say enough good things about the employees of Bartlett Jewelers. I stopped in with a watch…read morethat had a broken link, and instead of rushing me through, Maria and Oleg took the time to carefully add the link and then made sure everything worked perfectly before handing it back to me. What really stood out was their kindness and generosity with their time. It was clear that customer service was their top priority, not just making a quick sale. I never felt rushed, and they genuinely wanted to be sure I was happy and comfortable with the result. Experiences like this are rare these days. If you're looking for a jewelry store where you're treated with care, respect, and professionalism, this is the place to go. Highly recommend!

Connie and Peter are some of the nicest and highest integrity people you will meet. I recommend…read morethem to everyone who buys or sells jewelry and art.

Owners Connie and Peter Woodruff have a wonderful selection of newly designed and estate jewelry…read more They can work with you to design your unique wedding ring or help you find the perfect tennis bracelet. Behind the twinkling displays of rings, necklaces, coins and an a great selection of bracelets, you will find an exhibit of luscious oil paintings, "More Local Color," a collection from the artist group, "Local Color." Landscapes, florals, still life paintings complement the jewelry and add a perfect foil for the sparkly!

This business is closed permanently. I tried calling them, fortunately they called me back so I…read moredidn't have to waste my time trying to visit.

Tom is an outstanding person and created the best gifts for my children…read more From jewelry repair to crafting diamond art work. A very honest person that I felt comfortable doing business with. Nothing like a used car sales person. Respectful and up front.

They do have a lot of nautical themed jewelry, and if you just want to go in and get a souvenir…read moremermaid in gold to remember your vacation, then this is your guy. But if you have anything more complicated than a watch battery to repair, avoid this place for custom work. They made such a mess of the piece I gave them, they are lucky I actually paid them. First of all they insisted the piece needed lasering instead of soldering and charged me a fortune to "send it out". The piece is sapphires and diamonds and actually a skilled jeweler knows you don't have to laser sapphires and diamonds. The problem is they don't have a skilled jeweler. They have the owner's son with about three weeks of training. Having said they were sending out to be lasered, it's pretty clear "Junior" used it as a practice piece, because it was so bad, I am now having it redone at Tilden Ross, a real jeweler.

I love this jewlery store! Years ago I came here and the staff was so pleasant. I came back and…read morehad a pendant made into a ring. It was my 17 th year of being married and i really wanted all 17 stones in the ring. My husband gave me the pendant in the early years of our marriage. I was so happy when i picked it up and all the stones were in it and it was just beautiful. If you want something beautiful to remember your trip to Anna Marie island, this should be on your list of places to stop. They have beautiful AMI jewlery and other beautiful jewlery to choose from. I think the prices are reasonable. They have items for every price range. Thank you John and your wonderful staff.