Jeremy is a fair & honest man & very knowledgeable in his area. He bought our gold jewelry for a fair price & gave me good advice on a large diamond read more

On a recent trip to Sarasota we enjoyed a too-brief visit to Thayer Jewelers. They have a wide selection of magnificent and unusual pieces at every price level. I left with a exquiste antique jade necklace. Thayer's will be atop our itinerary on our next trip. read more

Such great customer service and such stunning pieces. My husband brought me in for an anniversary gift and I could not be happier with the piece I got. We will surely be back again. This is now our jeweler of choice in Sarasota! read more

I have been dealing with Jeremy for almost 20 years. He has outstanding jewelry at very reasonable prices. The most important thing is ,he is very trustworthy and the most knowledgeable on gems in the area. read more

I trust and have confidence in my purchases, The jewelry is varied and beautiful. The exchange policy is fair I limit my jewelry purchases to a select jeweler in both of my residences and I support Thayer in Sarasota My only suggestion is I would like them to have someone available on small repairs and watch batteries where I could drop off and wait or come back in a couple of hours. read more

Best one of a kind jewelry selection. Great costumer service and they wrap the gifts for you. read more

Thayer Jewelers - Diamond ring - Jewelry Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

I was taken care of like a queen. I took repairs and an item to be appraised. I was glad to hear it was worth, at a minimum, more than I had paid. They were also interested in selling them for me, so I left the Australian opal, tourmaline, and diamond gold hanging earrings with them. They made a minimum guarantee, which is the type of service I expect from trustworthy, ethical business people. You will not be disappointed working with them. read more

Quality jewelry, great customer service, a good place to look for that special piece

Such a great jeweler. Highly recommend and can trust. This will be my go-to jeweler.

We stumbled in here by chance a few months ago looking for our new wedding ring set and let me tell you I'm so glad we did. They were so kind and not pressuring at all. I use to get such anxiety going to jewelry stores but not here. At Thayer You feel like family. They have the most extraordinary pieces, you can't go wrong here. We found the unique rings we were looking for that will last generations. Thank you Thayer! read more

Thayer Jewelers - Jewelry Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

Only jeweler I trust in all of Florida!!!! Jeremy Thayer is the most professional, kind, and fair person. I definitely recommend going to Thayer jewelers for anything of your watch/jewelry needs. read more

See all

I cannot say enough good things about Thayer Jewelers. From the minute we walked in they were attentive but not pushy. They educated us and catered to what we needed. My ring is absolutely stunning. I cannot imagine going through the engagement ring process with anyone else. We will return here for years to come. Simply not a better diamond team out there! read more

I've been working with Jeremy Thayer for years, and recently he helped me with the most important jewelry decision of my life - buying an engagement ring for my wife. What was great is that he didn't just show me rings, he taught me what to look for and gave me an education on diamonds. After seeing what some of my friends have gone through buying their rings online, I can't recommend Jeremy enough for anybody in the market for an important piece of jewelry. Thanks Jeremy & Thayer Jewelers!! read more

Thank you Jeremy. Another great purchase at Thayer Jewelers! I had been looking for a diamond wedding band for my husband for at least a year without success, I wanted something tasteful, masculine, a clean classic look with substantial stones. I found it at Thayer Jewelers. It had to be sized up four sizes, they did an amazing job, "perfect". When I picked the ring up, Jeremy brought it out in a little red leather box that opened up each side from the center. It was a perfect box for the presentation. We went out to dinner Saturday night, I had our waitress bring it to my husband with the little red leather box on a dessert plate after dinner. I had butterflies in my stomach waiting for this moment. He loved it! Thank you Jeremy Thayer for helping make another very special moment in our lives, our 4th anniversary. read more

I have been dealing with Jeremy Thayer for over 25 years. Every piece is a work of art. I have never seen another of any of the merchandise that I have purchased from Jeremy. The values are phenomenal! Character, caliber, commitment! Those are the three C's of this operation. You will not be disappointed I give you my word! read more

My husband and I had been looking for a replacement engagement ring for me for some time to celebrate a big anniversary. We not only found the perfect ring at Thayer Jewelers but we were so impressed by the professionalism and gracious service that we experienced. Jeremy Thayer has a high level of professional knowledge and experience which he gives his customers the benefit of. He and the other members of the staff are so patient and courteous. We felt no sense of pressure at all, just that they sincerely wanted to be sure we were totally happy with our choice. The inventory is enormous and remarkable in terms of how tasteful and classic it is. Having looked many other places before coming to Thayer Jewelers, I know that the values there are excellent. We could not have been happier with the ring we bought and with the level of gracious, thoughtful and professional service. We intend to return to Thayer Jewelers whenever we are considering a jewelry purchase in the future. read more