So we stopped in with our youth group on the way through for our camping trip…read more I would like to say, the gentleman at the counter & the other gentleman on the floor were very kind and respectful. However. The four tables we sat at were dirty and I wiped them down myself. The men's bathroom had feces on the floor, and the girls bathroom wasn't in much better shape. It was pretty gross. With those things aside, the pizza came quick and it was pretty tasty!

I ordered pizza from these people all the time and up until this year today as of 5/20/2026 my…read moreexperience has left me feeling like every company is trying to cheat the customer. if you're hungry for pizza go to the Pilot and you'll get a fresh one without someone trying to spit in your food when you complain about it at Pizza Hut. I called to speak to the manager today and she says that I'm badgering her because I'm gonna write a bad review I explained to her because she said she's been working for this place for six years and six years I've been a repetitive customer but this time I'm not gonna be a customer anymore and I was gonna write a review in which she was getting upset and saying that I'm badgering her about the experience that I had because I waited two days in terms of the time when I ordered it at 7:38 PM. Why would I want to complain to someone when the manager wasn't there? The manager of this Pizza Hut is offended because you know that you guys are skipping out on people's orders and it's not worth the experience or expense. There is no ambience you don't wanna sit there and have your food. They don't even want you to even be there let alone carry out.. I've only taken my food out because why it's not inviting it looks dead and boring, and it doesn't look clean to sit down. Take it for my experience they need to lose some money and take a hit to know that what they're doing is wrong when they're cheating the customer of product and ingredients of their pizza. Shame on you the franchise holder here in Tucumcari..

First, the phone number here is wrong, it ends with 17 not 77. I reported to help but they haven't…read morefixed it. When I had asked the place I was staying at if Godfather pizza was good he made a face and said I should go to Pizza Hut. So this place is actually gas station pizza, literally. It is inside Loves Gas station with a chicken place and subway. The workers work all counters. I got mushroom and olive..... not realizing it would be canned mushrooms.... those dont belong on anything accept for pasta sauce. The crust was just like pizza hut pan personal... baked in oil. There isnt much to eat in this town, so check the town before or after

It's actually located in a truck stop. The crust was cardboard. Toppings were pretty crappy. I…read moreasked for a salad that was featured on menu but was told no longer available:-(

We went to JC's New York Pizza Department last month 10/10 experience. We showed up last minute for…read moremy son's birthday with a party of 12+ and they treated us like we planned it for weeks. Monica the manager was so kind and welcoming -- you can tell she genuinely cares about people having a great experience. our server (I think Anissa?) was on top of everything and just as attentive. The kids had the best time playing the arcade games. And the FOOD... the pizza was delicious, the wings were incredible, and those honey BBQ glazed wings are dangerously good. If you're looking for a place that's family-friendly with great service and great food -- this is it.

Stopped in here while driving through town. It's a fairly large space with two levels and a…read moresmallish bar and an arcade that would be great fun for families with kids. We ordered a couple of individual slices of New York style pizza with our preferred toppings. The pizza was quite good. The beers were cold. And the service was fantastic. Our server, Gates, couldn't have been any better. He took great care of us while also serving many other tables and customers. This young man was really impressive and if he was my employee I would give him a raise!

And....they are back! Great pizza tonight-I think they just had a new employee who didn't know what…read morethey were doing.

Just passing through town and needed food. Walked a mile from La Castaneda hotel to the pizza…read moreplace. It's a shipping container next to and owned by the dispensary. Pizza is cooked in a brick oven. The staff were friendly and informative. The pizza was tasty. I would definitely eat here again.

This review is for takeout. Five stars for the guy who packaged up our food very thoughtfully and…read morechatted with me. The interior also looked super cute. My main disappointment the food is overpriced. The pasta dishes were pretty good, but not nearly $30 worth. The pizza crust is kinda doughy, which makes it feel heavier than expected... and also like it should cost less. I think if I'd dined in, the atmosphere would have pushed it up a bit, but on its own we were surprised by the bill.

Ambiance at 8:30p was quiet, there's recorded music playing in the background. As for the staff,…read morenot much to say. The greeter was friendly enough and seated me. The waiter as okay. The meal was the Sophia Loren and was great with a thick cheesy and spicy sauce over pasta, dried tomatoes and shrimp with every bite.

Pizza is usually good. Service is typically quick but sometimes can take a while when staffing is…read moreshort. I like how clean they keep it.

Delicious pizza, great customer service, friendly, Junnie was the best, made my day!!! Really…read moreappreciated her military recognition!

We stopped in for a late lunch and really enjoyed our pizza. The Meat Treat with green chiles was…read moreexcellent. Just the right amount of heat. And the crust was crisp and flavorful. Also enjoyed the Greek salad and the chicken wings.

Just a regular no frills pizza joint. You order at the counter and wait for your reheated pizza…read more Beer options are limited. Employees were nice.