The Tiano's large pizza special never fails as a fresh low cost spur of the moment meal.read more

Today we decided to order pizza from Tiano's. We called ahead to order three pizzas. The person who…read moreanswered the phone immediately said, "Tiano's, hold for a minute," and left me on hold for about five minutes before I finally hung up. I figured they were busy, so I called back about 15 minutes later, but the call went straight to voicemail. The voicemail was not even set up. My wife and I both tried from different carriers, Verizon and Spectrum, and had the same issue. We kept trying over the next 15 minutes, thinking maybe the phone lines were tied up because they were busy taking orders. We eventually drove there to place the order in person, only to find they were not busy at all. When I mentioned the phone issue, they told me they "always have problems with the phones." I can only imagine how much business that costs them. I placed the order, and the lady with the thick dark-framed glasses read it back correctly: two large cheese pizzas, one large half cheese / half pepperoni and ham pizza, and one chicken calzone. We were told about a 30-minute wait. When we got home, the order was wrong. We received three large cheese pizzas, with no pepperoni or ham on the specialty pizza we paid extra for. The chicken calzone also had ham in it, which I assume was supposed to go on the pizza. Now I'm wondering where the pepperoni went. Unfortunately, the person who ordered the calzone does not eat ham, so that ended up going in the trash. On top of that, the quality of the pizza was disappointing. The middle of the pizzas seemed undercooked and sloppy. When you picked up a slice, all the cheese slid right off. It's a shame, because we really want to like this place.

Tried Star pizza twice now. First was a hot Italian sandwich, the fried ravioli app and homemade…read morechips. Sandwich was very good, the ravioli with the marinara for dipping was great, as were the homemade chips. We dined in the next visit and had a medium pepperoni and mushroom. Very good pie, crust was tasty and nicely done, held the toppings well with a little sag when held, but definitely not soggy. Sauce was just the right amount and very tasty. Service was excellent on both occasions. Hometown feeling, and watching the owners greet long time customers was endearing. Will definitely return.

It's honestly shocking it's taken us this long to try Star pizza since it's in our home county, but…read moretoday was the day! Online ordering made getting our pizza seamless! I walked in and my order was ready to go. The staff was super friendly and the space brings a sense of nostalgia with the vinyl booths and bar area. The pizza was SO GOOD. Crispy pepperonis, melty cheese, a crust that's just the right thickness. I think this may be a pizza winner for us. We will definitely be picking up Star Pizza when in Mayodan frequently!

We just moved back to the area after 12 years in Raleigh and are very impressed so far with the…read morefood we have received from this location. Very fresh compared to the food we used to get from papa john's and dominos where we moved here from. Have ordered from this location 4-5 times in the past month and the delivery times have been prompt and accurate. Will keep ordering from them unless something goes drastically wrong !

After a good experience several months ago we decided to go there for the lunch pizza buffet on…read moreMonday . This was the last straw. We waited for 15 minutes after the buffet had started for any pizzas. The waitress only knows how to say" they are on a rotation ". We heard this several times as we tried to get a pizza we liked. They don't have or offer menus according to her. They don't have any pastas available. We waited for a full hour for a second round of pizzas just in case. When we finally left nothing new had been brought out. The only pizza on the bar was one that was there when we walked in over an hour earlier. When we ask about new pizzas we got the popular " they are on a rotation. I am only the waitress. The cook does the pizza. I guess she isn't allowed to speak to the kitchen staff for any reason. If they have a manager then is a poor excuse for one. As much as we enjoy Pizza Hut pizzas we will find a location that has an interest in treating customers as a paying part of the equation through which they get paid. We are done with this sorry excuse for a restaurant!!

The pizzas here are very good, we like them well done and the service in the drive up window is…read moreexcellent. Join the club and you get rewards and emails sent for specials. Nice place. Glad they kept it open. (It was closed for awhile).

Come here all the time to get leftovers because they have a policy where if any food gets leftover…read morethey can give it out weve went there twice 10 mins before closing and some old hag would say we dont have anything when we visibly saw food leftover and she said it with so much attitude and disrespect and said were closed no closing is not until 10 not 9:45 please learn some respect and maybe look up your policy

I'll never go back here. The pizza was below average and another time that I was forced to eat…read morehere, I only had a salad, one medium bowl, for which I was charged the whole buffet price even after raising the issue at the register. .

The crew of Thursty's is more than accommodating and pleasant, however, if you are looking for fine…read morecuisine, you came to the wrong place. I admit I only tried some of their custom pizza (pales in comparison to ci-ci's), their soup of the day (chili - right out of the can), their salad bar (small, shredded lettuce - right out of the bag, spinach, fixin's) was the healthiest thing going. Remind me not to fall into the trap of eating here again...

This was a great place to stop by for just some good ol' bar food. The appetizer sampler was…read moreawesome. I loved each appetizer. The southwest egg rolls were INCREDIBLE. The loaded potato skins now live in my mind rent free. The mozzarella sticks were pure cheesy heaven. Onions were to die for. Ranch was on point! The wings were really crispy. The flavors I got: lemon pepper and garlic Parmesan were both dry rubs and had awesome flavor. I really liked the lemon pepper. 10/10 recommend.

Great downtown spot in Mayodan. I have been here several times and consistency rules. Great…read moreburgers, crispy wings, delicious sides and cold beer (YES, they serve liquor as well) This is a bar/ restaurant that is open late. Each visit has had a family atmosphere, although I have not visited later than 8pm. Wednesdays are wing Wednesday, currently .75 each any count.

New help, because the 1 girl that works there on 2 different occasions is hateful, the parking in…read morefront of the store is nasty filthy

Never looks like the pictures. Very disappointing... taste is okay... but build the sandwich like…read morethe picture