Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Don & Penny's Restaurant

    3.8 (13 reviews)
    Closed • Closed

    Order Don & Penny's Restaurant Takeout or Delivery

    Don & Penny's Restaurant Photos

    Business Info

    DON & PENNY'S RESTAURANT ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Good for groups
    Outdoor seating

    You might also consider

    More like Don & Penny's Restaurant

    Recommended Reviews - Don & Penny's Restaurant

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    30 days ago

    Helpful 6
    Thanks 1
    Love this 4
    Oh no 0

    3 months ago

    Amazing. Everything homemade and service was awesome. If you are in the area stop and enjoy

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Toni L.
    0
    135
    34

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1
    Photo of T D.
    0
    35
    0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jessica P.
    81
    28
    549

    16 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of David M.
    115
    21
    6

    7 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    7 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 1
    Photo of E G.
    0
    433
    15

    9 years ago

    I was never a fan of this place. They have alright pizza, but it's definitely an old divorcee kind of place.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Tom S.
    0
    14
    0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Don & Penny's Restaurant

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 2,572 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Decaro's - Wings

    Decaro's

    4.4(72 reviews)
    0.6 mi
    •$$

    Let me start off by saying I rarely leave reviews. However,…read morewe loved this place so much that there was no way we couldn't say something. We're in town for the boat races & this afternoon my husband's engine came right off the back of the boat. While thankful it wasn't at the bottom of the Mississippi, getting it back on was more than a chore. Hot, tired & hard at work, we had a couple of teams to feed. We called in a large order & we were accommodated within half an hour, at a reasonable price & it's safe to say, it's the best pizza any of us have ever had. 12 people, 2 families, 2 racing teams, we all agreed. We weren't "just" hot. We weren't "just" hungry. It was literally JUST that good! We will absolutely see yall next year! -Diamond Z Racing

    Decaro's is a wonderful surprise. We initially intended to eat at another restaurant in the area…read morebut it was closed for the day. Decaro's became a hastily decided Plan B. We had no expectations but we were hungry. What a wonderful Plan B this turned out to be. It was mid-afternoon so the place was relatively quiet, in a pleasant way.Everything was clean and the dining room looked inviting. We seated ourselves and the waitress quickly came to take our order for drinks and food. She suggested the day's special, a personal pizza with two toppings, side salad, and a drink. It sounded great was was a real bargain so we both went with it. The wife ordered a simple cheese pizza and I ordered mine with sausage and mushrooms. In very short order, our salads were presented and they were delicious. The lettuce and vegetables were all very fresh, not the sad looking stuff you frequently see at other restaurants mid winter. Even the croutons were delicious, light and with just the right amount of crispness. Next came our pizzas piping hot. We both loved them .They came on a thin cracker type crust, my favorite, sauce was sparingly applied but tasty, and the Italian sausage on my pizza had wonderful flavor with just a light kick to it. My wife truly enjoyed her cheese pizza as well. We'll definitely be coming back. I'm tempted to try their Italian beef sandwich next time. It was highly recommended by the staff.

    Photos
    Decaro's - Decor

    Decor

    Decaro's - Sausage and mushroom personal pizza

    Sausage and mushroom personal pizza

    Decaro's - Dining area

    See all

    Dining area

    Joe’s Pizza and Pasta

    Joe’s Pizza and Pasta

    3.4(40 reviews)
    4.0 mi

    Joe's Pizza, really doesn't get the recognition that it deserves. I'm guilty myself, not thinking…read moreabout them when I go to order carry-out or delivery. After my flavorful Italian Sausage and Jalapeños pizza today, I will call Joe before a national chain. It was National Mom and Pop Business Day and my local Joe's posted a picture of their owners on Facebook and it prompted me to order. So I got on their website and ordered my favorite, Sausage & Jalapeño Small Thin Crust Pizza. When I order pizza from any pizza joint, I always add special instructions. I am not a fan of "square" cut and request mine to be cut "pie", the traditional way to serve pizza. My Italian Sausage was spicy, the sauce had zing to it and there was plenty of jalapeños. The jalapeños even had some crunch to them, which tells me, they were fresh. Then of course, the mozzarella cheese was plentiful on top of everything. The website was user friendly and when I arrived, the young ladies working the front counter were friendly and polite. Good pizza and friendly service will have me ordering pick-up again. Sure I can have them deliver, but I don't mind the short drive to pick it up myself. Support your local mom and pop businesses.

    I got the cauliflower crust pizza because I have celiac and I saw some promising reviews on find me…read moregluten-free for this place. Everyone seemed really nice there. I got there to pick up the pizza and noticed the restaurants not the cleanest . The pizza is very inedible. It's probably the worst pizza I've ever had. It was ridiculously priced too. I had two small cauliflower crust pizzas 40 bucks. I am not one who eats at Domino's or Pizza Hut but truly their pizza is better. Responding to the manager this is Joe's pizza in Godfrey. You most certainly did have a cauliflower crust and I ordered it and it was horrible.

    Photos
    Joe’s Pizza and Pasta
    Joe’s Pizza and Pasta
    Joe’s Pizza and Pasta - Entrance & Drive-Thru

    See all

    Entrance & Drive-Thru

    Pirrone's Pizzeria

    Pirrone's Pizzeria

    3.8(225 reviews)
    10.1 mi
    •$$

    Food, service, all around excellent experience!!! Salad is divine!!! Pizza is spectacular!!!read more

    Maybe it was the heatwave.. or maybe I was just off for a late dinner before bedtime…read more But this is the story of the "Root beer army" (so to speak). Pironne's is celebrating their 50th anniversary this year, so I was kinda expecting... I dunno... something extra when I walked in the door (I think I'm going to have to find a dinner companion for these jaunts, just to go with so people don't look at me like I'm weird (which yes, I'm taking a point off for). Walked in and the sign warned me they're short-handed, so I expect a little time between stuff. Anyway, I'm by myself and the kid at the wait station kinda makes it known (Just "One"? Okay.) You could tell he didn't want to be there that night, but honestly, I'm not sure anyone did (as it was still roasting outside and this place is cooled by fans about 15 feet in the air... it was hot and stuffy inside (despite it being a non-busy night). Come on guys, I know we're wanting to be an Italian restaurant, but it's still America: Air conditioning please! Waitress is quick over to the table. No sweet tea in the restaurant, unsweet only (And this foodie is having a sad day at this restaurant to start.). Okay, Root beer it is.. (She quickly brings one over and so I ask her (as I do EVERY restaurant), what do you recommend? "Pizza is our specialty." I get that... but which pizza? You've only got 5 on the menu and a do-it-yourself pizza. it shouldn't be that hard to have a favorite. But that's all I get out of her. Okay, well, just for that. I'll start with the appetizer sampler. Fortunately, this was a quick serve, because remember I mentioned a heat wave? Root Beer one... gone! (remember the heat wave?) Unfortunately it takes a little while for Sampler plates, so by the time the plate arrives.. Root beer two.. gone.. but at least the other waitress is there for the save.. Perfect timing! So, they give me two plates (two, again! Sheesh. I'm by myself for this excursion!) for the appetizer (can i say, Mushrooms should NEVER look this small when they're deep fried!), it's called "BATTER UP!" and two different sauces (marinara and then tomato/meat sauce), even though I'm here solo. (See what I mean about a dining companion, even restaurants don't know what to do for solo men). Now amidst all my complainy-ing to myself... I gotta say the sampler's not bad and the Tomato/meat sauce is pretty darn good (made everything on the sampler plate better than just "breaded Italian food" (so I'm giving a HAPPY point here). But the heat wave still going on, but at least a different waitress sees I'm needing Root Beer #3! But now we have to take a point away. I'm still working through the appetizers but I set them to the side "AWAY" from the main floor.. so if you have to get over them you have to go through my eating, when introductory staff guy comes over and starts to pick up one of the bowls I've still got sauce in and food on my plate. (Do you really want me out THAT Bad?), but I was nice and motioned to him not yet.. so i didn't make him feel too bad, I think (I can be a nice old man at times :P).. And the waitress is back to take my order and Root Beer #4, and we'll do a "pizza" and since she didn't pick, Supreme. At this time I would point out all their specialty pizzas were about the same price (by size) and "DIY" came out to like $2 more if you added the same number of toppings. SO we're watching the root beer slowly disappear again. cause this was the step that took a while (getting the pizza), but here's where I'm going to be nice, because this pizza was... actually good. Not sure if it was the sausage or what, but it did salvage the meal. Oh and there was a rootbeer #5 somewhere during the Pizza eating time, that I kinda of lost track of. So on to the report card! Food: 3/5 (again, whatever meat on the pizza was used and the appetizer meat/tomato sauce saved it from being ordinary) Cost:; Again, probably more than i was expecting, but this time i will say it was due in part to higher than expected pricing for pizzas. Again if it had been with a friend, splitting costs, not so bad, but for a dinner of 1.. Little more expensive than i'd hoped. Service: Even though the kid obviously didn't want to be there and the staff was stretched thin, so mot the best night of service (2/5) Ambience: This is the United States, lack of a/c kinda just ruined most of the evening IMO (and the single runs of luck I'm having).. 2/5) But hey I probably my root-beer quota for the day.. so no winners/no losers this time around. So in my esteemed morale of the story: Make sure you're with a friend to split the costs, and in the end, a solid pizza that isn't enough to take the restaurant to 4*, but a decent 3-star Oh yeah and remember if you're going in the heatwave.. dress cool! (or you might be in that beverage-drinking army!)

    Photos
    Pirrone's Pizzeria - Dining area

    Dining area

    Pirrone's Pizzeria - Sausage and Black Olive pizza and Pasta con broccoli.  So good.

    Sausage and Black Olive pizza and Pasta con broccoli. So good.

    Pirrone's Pizzeria

    See all

    Tony's Restaurant & 3rd Street Cafe - Sausage & Goat Cheese Flatbread

    Tony's Restaurant & 3rd Street Cafe

    3.2(165 reviews)
    0.4 mi
    •$$

    Scrumptious! When…read moreyou're a regular, sometimes you slip into a routine and order from a group of your favorite entrees. There's nothing wrong with that, but sometimes you need to change things up. Last night, I did just that. I even changed up my adult beverage. My new adult beverage of choice was a, Sapphire Gin and Tonic. I've been gradually switching from vodka to gin and this was a smooth and refreshing cocktail. I was craving scallops my favorite seafood, but did not want the entree that comes with, lobster risotto. So I ventured out and tried the, Shrimp & Scallops with Portobello Mushrooms and Asparagus. It was sautéed in butter, garlic, shallots, red chili flakes and lemon. It was then served over a bed of linguine. I may have found a new favorite dish. Or at least, a new dish added to my rotation. I loved how four toppings were kept separate from each other. The three sea scallops satisfied my craving, the asparagus was prepared with a snap to it, the four shrimp were huge and the mushrooms balanced out the dish. The chili flakes, gave the dish an extra kick, that I really liked. Kept my salad the same as always, House Salad with House Dressing. The service at the bar was excellent. The bartenders are always friendly and professional. I like that they have a food server and a designated bus person behind the bar, so the mixologist can focus on making those refreshing cocktails.

    I was honestly surprised to see such a low overall rating because I had a fantastic experience…read morehere. I even noticed one reviewer repeatedly updating a one-star review after multiple visits, which made me wonder--if you dislike a place that much, why keep coming back? We ordered the NY strip steak and the filet mignon, and both were absolutely delicious. We also tried the artichoke appetizer, which was excellent. The drinks were equally impressive. Our waitress was incredibly kind and attentive. She proactively kept us updated when there was a slight delay and checked on us throughout the meal without being intrusive. The restaurant itself was beautifully themed, and everything felt well thought out and cohesive. Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed my experience and would gladly return.

    Photos
    Tony's Restaurant & 3rd Street Cafe - Beer on Tap

    Beer on Tap

    Tony's Restaurant & 3rd Street Cafe - Surf and Turf

    Surf and Turf

    Tony's Restaurant & 3rd Street Cafe - Bar view

    See all

    Bar view

    Roma's Pizza - Basket of Crackers

    Roma's Pizza

    4.4(146 reviews)
    8.1 mi
    •$$

    Pulled into a full parking lot and was concerned we wouldn't get a table, was seated immediately!…read moreNice place, clean, spacious and well lit. We ordered drinks, an appetizer and a couple pizzas. Drinks and appetizer came out quickly along with the side house salad I ordered which consisted of lettuce, tomatoes, black olives and mozzarella. I had the house vinaigrette dressing which was a nice dressing for the basic salad. Toasted ravioli as the appetizer were crispy delicious with a savory marinara sauce!! Pizzas came out oven hot and loaded with mozzarella on top. Crust was crisped to perfection and the toppings were plentiful. All in all a very pleasurable eating experience and the staff was on top of everything. Thanks Roma's, we will be back!!

    A friend and I came here one evening to enjoy some pizza. She told me it was her favorite pizza…read moreplace! Parking was easy, with a large parking lot outside the restaurant. Family-owned, Roma's was a delightful experience. After being seated, we were greeted by a friendly server and ordered our beverages. Browsing the menu, I ordered a Bosco Stick and a medium pizza. The Bosco Stick was warm and filled with gooey cheese. It reminded me so much of the Bosco Sticks I would eat as a child. The meat sauce was a great addition to use as a dip and wasn't too meaty. I ordered a medium pizza with extra cheese, jalapeños, and mushrooms. It was so good! The pizza came out about 25 minutes after ordering and satiated my pizza craving! Roma's is nothing fancy, however, it is a comfortable environment with delicious and affordable food. Next time I am in town, I will have to come back!

    Photos
    Roma's Pizza - Dining area

    Dining area

    Roma's Pizza - Pepperoni and sausage pizza

    Pepperoni and sausage pizza

    Roma's Pizza - Hours of Operation

    See all

    Hours of Operation

    Joe's Pizza and Pasta - Lunch Side Salad

    Joe's Pizza and Pasta

    2.3(7 reviews)
    3.8 mi

    Pretty good food: 4/5 stars…read more Price is a little high: 3/5 stars Automatic 18% gratuity was charged for our family of 4. I understand some places do this. Original receipt showed $96 and change. After CC was ran and brought back the new receipt showed $99 and change. Not the end of the world, but we won't be back.

    This is Joe's newest location in the Riverbend area and they already are on point with the other…read morelocations. The customer service was attentive and the food was at the same quality level as the locations that are established. I stopped by for lunch on a Saturday, I took a spot at the corner of the bar. I was quickly greeted and offered an adult beverage. They presented my menus, but I knew the offerings and knew what I wanted, but I enjoyed my craft beer for a while before ordering. For a appetizer, I chose their Boneless Wings with a Garlic Parmesan sauce. I knew I wouldn't be able to eat all 12 pieces, so I now have a work lunch. My entree was their pizza special which gave me a side salad and a 8" two topping pizza. My go to topping are always, Italian Sausage and Jalapeños. I absolutely love Joe's sauce and the fast that he uses Mozzarella cheese. I am also thrilled that he does not skimp on his toppings. I left 3 slices for tomorrows lunch, too. Godfrey is my usual Joe's location, but I will also frequent this location. This location is located in Eastgate Plaza which is quickly becoming a popular restaurant and entertainment complex. It is going to be the place to go.

    Photos
    Joe's Pizza and Pasta - Lunch Two Toppings Pizza

    Lunch Two Toppings Pizza

    Joe's Pizza and Pasta - Boneless Wings - Garlic Parmesan

    Boneless Wings - Garlic Parmesan

    Joe's Pizza and Pasta - To-Go Vessel not Eco-Friendly

    See all

    To-Go Vessel not Eco-Friendly

    Peel Wood Fired Pizza - Pepperoni, sausage, fresh mozzarella, and shredded mozzarella pizza

    Peel Wood Fired Pizza

    4.2(551 reviews)
    13.2 mi
    •$$

    What an incredible lunch special, for the low price of $18. You get to choose one item each from…read moretwo sections. The variety of choices allows you to create the perfect lunch. When I saw they had hot honey and pepperoni paired together on a 8" pizza, I instantly knew that was one of my choices. The fresh mozzarella and ricotta cheeses paired with the hot honey and pepperoni exploded with flavor. My only disappointment was the inner crust. The outer rim crust was very crispy, but the inner was soft and limp due to the excessive grease from the flavorful pepperoni. I guess that is something I just need to deal with for a tasty lunch pizza. My other choice was, the Apple Gorgonzola Salad. Wow. Double Wow! This has to be the best salad I have ever had. It was a delightful mix of, spinach, granny smith apple, gorgonzola, sun-dried cranberries, candied pecans, all topped with a delicious maple cider vinaigrette. I will be back for the large version and a glass of Pino Grigio as a dinner. As my usual, I sat at the bar. My adult beverage of choice, was a Peel Summer Lager. I may be going back to fill my growler, for the upcoming holiday weekend. The restaurant has a contemporary feel, but the acoustics make it a loud environment. I didn't mind the laughter and loud conversations, it was the yelling and crying toddlers that made me cringe. Service was friendly and attentive. I enjoyed watching the bartenders use their mixologist skills preparing all the cocktails. It pleased me to see they offer "hooks under the bar". That's a small detail that makes me smile.

    I recently checked out Peel's Happy Hour and had a lovely time. I sat on the patio and had a very…read morefriendly and attentive server. My friend & I each had a couple glasses of wine from the HH menu as well as the toasted ravioli and their specialty pizza of the month that had prosciutto, peaches, goat cheese, onion balsamic jam, basil and a balsamic honey glaze. The toasted ravioli was great and I'd get it again. The pizza was a really good combination of flavors but in my opinion they were too heavy handednoj the onion balsamic jam and honey glaze that tipped the pizza way too sweet and kind of buried the saltiness of the meat and cheese. I will definitely be back to check out this HH again!

    Photos
    Peel Wood Fired Pizza
    Peel Wood Fired Pizza - The best garlic cream sauce, kind of like a sister to Alfredo?

    The best garlic cream sauce, kind of like a sister to Alfredo?

    Peel Wood Fired Pizza - Blood Orange Wheat Beer

    See all

    Blood Orange Wheat Beer

    Don & Penny's Restaurant - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...