My wife and I are both beginner skiers and read the great reviews about Donner being a good place to learn. Actually, it is definitely NOT a good place for complete beginners. We already took a lesson from NorthStar the day before, and I was skiing on most of their greens plow-style with no problem. My wife was falling a bit but could handle turns. The next day, we went to Donner, and I really wanted to like the place given the description of a family friendly old-fashioned place.When we arrived, the place felt great with its old-style cabin, and the parking lot is right next to the main lift.
Rentals - on their website, they advertise $40 adult rental and lift ticket deals, but this is only good on Tues-Thurs. Otherwise, rental + ticket = $78. We weren't the only ones confused because there were 4 separate people who came in after us on Friday asking exactly the same thing when their total came up to be double what they were expecting. Their website is a bit of manipulative advertising.
Slopes - really slippery on a fine sunny day. No precip for nearly one month. My wife and I both just could not stop on their gear + slopes. The whole layout of the place is poorly designed for beginners in comparison to bigger resorts. First, all of their runs dump on the big, pretty steep hill that you see from the parking lot. If that hill looks too steep to you, then don't ski here, because there is very little room at the bottom for you to stop, and you can't avoid this area since this is where the two main lifts are. I saw several people plowing into each other at the bottom and lots more who fell of their backsides to try to skid to a stop.
The bunny slope / magic carpet area is just terrible for beginner skiers because of the steepness of that area. The flatter part is way past the beginning of the magic carpet, and you have to go UPHILL for ~80 ft just to get to the beginning of the magic carpet. My wife was completely struggling to get to the carpet, and she wasn't the only one. I found it extremely difficult myself, and I notice that several other people did as well. Some of the kids were pulled up by their walking parents, but ALL the adult skiers had to just take of their skis and walk up. The width and length of the magic carpet itself is also clearly made just for little kids and not for adult beginners. I asked one of the older instructors who was just standing there about why it was so slippery and her reply was that I should put my toe down and take some lessons. She then went on complaining about how few people there were to take lessons to some other staff.
Green runs - tried two of them, and they were both fine in parts but other places were too steep or maybe it was their rental gear. The other side of the lift 6 is pretty flat, but again, everything dumps to the hill at the end.
We only skied for 1.5 hours but my wife had enough and said she wanted to go somewhere else that was better designed for beginners. I would have tried more of the runs, but she was totally frustrated with their poor layout, so we returned our stuff and prepared to go elsewhere. We paid for full day rental, helmets, and lift tickets = $85 x 2, and we asked the manager, Gio, if we could have a return of a half day, but he said that under no circumstances did they ever give any portion of any refund at all. His offer was a voucher for another day at Donner that had to be used in 15 days. He also said that we were the only people in the last two weeks who complained which just simply is not true since I personally saw three different groups asking about various complaints like a wrong charge, etc.
It's a shame because I really wanted to like the place, but overall, I had a terrible time at Donner. It's NOT particularly friendly, and it's just awfully designed for adult beginners. I had a much better time at North Star, where the people are lot nicer and everything is just designed better. In my opinion the price difference, especially over the weekend, is really worth it, but it does get a little crowded. Maybe Donner would be better for intermediates. The only saving grace was the spectacular view of Donner Lake and the surrounding mountains on the way up. read more