The gentleman I did business with was honest, punctual, and accommodating. When you rent a car on Beaver Island, do your homework before you get off the boat! The roads are all gravel and rutted two tracks. Don't go expecting to rent a 2024 Lincoln Cadillac! The vehicle will be safe, and dependable. They will sometimes be less than spotless. In other words, don't be a wedding party Karen read more

See all

Duffy promised in writing to drive the wedding party I was standing in and guests around Friday to Sunday for an agreed upon fee. A week before the wedding, he backed out of his promise and said he would only drive people the day of the wedding, leaving everyone without transportation. The morning and early afternoon of the wedding day, he had his phone turned off and refused to answer calls or help the other vendors get to the ceremony and reception. When he finally did answer calls and showed up to shuttle people to the ceremony, he showed up in moldy cars that were in terrible condition (picture attached). He should not be trusted, his cars are a health concern, and his attitude was abysmal throughout the entire weekend. He treated us all so poorly and used foul language when speaking with the bride and groom. He doesn't have an ounce of professionalism in either his personality or fleet of cars. read more

Duffy's Car Rental - Car Rental Near Me

Car was literally full of dirt. Seemed like it hadn't been cleaned or serviced in at least five years. Several engine lights going off every time you turn on the car. I thought the price for the rental was ok until I saw the car. I wouldn't use this service again. read more

DONT RENT FROM DUFFY!!! We rented a car and it was filthy inside and out. I expected outside, but we had to wipe dirt off the speedometer window to read it. Couldn't put our bags in the trunk because it looked like someone had a mud bath back there. Then anytime you approached 40 mph it started shaking like crazy. I was afraid the car was gonna bust up, and that was on the paved roads. We told him about it, and he just said to have a nice day, and hung up!? read more

Picked up a rental from Duffy's ....didn't even mind that it was an old, dirty, smelly, s10 blazer but I didn't feel it was a safe vehicle to drive. If you want to play it safe take the ferry and bring your own car.. read more

Do not rent from Duffy. I got married on the island and we were in contact with him for a little over a year for him to shuttle our guests to and from ferry/hotels/rehearsal dinner wedding ceremony and reception all weekend. He set the price and we paid it. A week before the wedding he calls us and says he's not doing Friday or Sunday, saying he never said he would be doing it all weekend. Then we went back to our texts and read them word for word saying he would, then says he's not going to do it anymore and starts yelling and cursing at us. forcing me and my bride to shuttle all of our guests. He said he would still do all day Saturday and when Saturday came around and said he's not shuttling anyone in the morning and only is driving at night.Then 30 minutes before our ceremony texts my now wife "just so you know I'm not making any money on this" even though HE SET THE PRICE!! Petty, terrible to work with, goes back on his word. Oh yeah, and his cars are gross and one of the shuttle cars had black mold growing in the back (see picture). Just an all around terrible experience. Bring your business elsewhere on the island. read more

Duffy's Car Rental - Black mold in the backseat of one of the cars - Car Rental Near Me

Great service, rapid replies, cooperative, honest and a pleasusre to work with! If you need a rental car on Beaver Island, Duffy's is the best! read more