I went to this pizza establishment because of the name I figured should taste like New York pizza. I had that lunch special two slices and a soda 749. How good can it be at that price? I was shocked it was wonderful. You could have it crispy or not. Your choice. The two slices could have been dinner. They were extremely large. I've been back three times in one week. I'm sold on the pizza. It's not a large place. Probably only accommodate 20 people. Sam M read more

I cannot wait to come back to this place!!! We shared a slice of grandma pizza and a meatball parm sub. The meatballs were light and fluffy. The sauce was delicious. The service was fast and friendly. And I had enough left overs for lunch! If you're looking for some delicious Italian food that's quick, this is the place for you!! read more

East Side Pizza - Grandma pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lantana, Florida

See all

OK, so I took my pop for Pizza a few days ago by where I live and he tells me that the Pizza by his house is better than the Pizza I took him to. So today I have to try it with him. East Side Pizza is very good. It really was delicious pizza. They have a small display case with at least six or seven different types of pizzas that I could see and you can have two slices and a soda for a special price depending on the type of pizza you get. Obviously plain cheese is the cheapest of the options. I tried both the cheese and the pepperoni with a soda. It was like seven bucks. They offer a menu of hot sandwiches and other dishes. I didn't try any of those so I don't know how they are. What I can say is that the pizza was very good. Two really large slices served on a nice tray with all the toppings available, garlic, oregano, chili flakes, and Parmesan cheese. The place isn't that big. I think I counted about six tables and a small counter with some high chairs. It's very comfortable, very cozy. The woman behind the counter wearing the legalize marinara T-shirt was very friendly. Overall, it was a really good experience and I will have to go back and try some other stuff especially that grandma Square Pizza that looked really tasty. read more

East Side Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lantana, Florida

See all

Wow! The pizza here is really good, and the prices are definitely what keep me returning, and able to order more than I normally would at a pizza spot. I've ordered from them multiple times since seeing them pop up on DoorDash. So far, we've loved the regular cheese pizza, the pepperoni pizza, and even the Greek salad. My kids were not fans of the garlic rolls, but I enjoyed them very much! The perfect spot for grabbing pies when headed to Lantana Beach, which I do quite often. So grateful for East Side Pizza! read more

Why I'll order again: hits the spot, and the craving, when we need it You HAVE to order: classic pepperoni pizza Tony's Tip: tread lightly outside of the pizza realm Everyone needs a local pizza place. In fact, home doesn't really feel like home unless you got one. And now I got one. When we're at our Winter getaway in Palm Beach, some nights just call for pizza (okay, I have to call for the pizza). About a year ago, the wife and I did a mini tasting tour, grabbing a slice at three of the higher Yelp-rated pizza spots in the area (Lake Worth and Lantana, which are just across the bridge). East Side won hands down. The place is nothing to look at. It's a small joint in a strip mall that has seen better days. But that's where hidden gems like this lurk. And when it comes to the core mission, East Side gets it done. The pizza is your classic neighborhood recipe: thin but chewy crust, slightly sweet tomato sauce, classic mozzarella (and plenty of it!), plus a decent coverage of toppings. We've tried a few combinations and liked them all. My order is always ready at the pickup time, and we've never had a pizza that was overcooked. One caveat: I tried an Italian Combo sub once, thinking they'd execute that well. They didn't. The bread was hard, and the meats too thick. Basically inedible. My wife's Eggplant Parm sub also fell short. I'm gun shy about trying another sub. But when it comes to pizza, this is our place. read more

Was craving a pizza found this place and it's my new go too the wings are saucy and delicious and the pizza is everything I looked for crunchy crust perfect . read more

The food here is great. I'll be back very soon. I actually forgot the name of it and I live in the area, but Yelp helped me remember that I was there. Shout out the Yelp too. read more

This was the best pizza that I've had in this area! Done exactly like I ordered it! Crispy crust and delicious! read more

I very much like their pizza, their prices are reasonable and they have a daily lunch special. The place is usually packed at lunch. My particular favorite is a pizza with anchovies and tomatoes and this is a place that has anchovies. Thank you. Delicious. read more

Pizza Slices. NOT BAD. Better than the last time I ate here. The Cheese Slice was equal parts Cheese and Tomato Sauce when it comes to flavor. The SICILIAN Slice was more Cheesy in flavor which I prefer but still needed some more oomph. WALK DON'T RUN. read more

See all

The food here was great! We will definitely coming back! Service was great we were greeted with a smile :) the place clean and with that pizzeria vibe! read more

Pizzas great. Nice shop. Took out but could've eaten there. I don't recommend the calamari.

Our Go-to Favorite for a delicious slice, they're huge by the way. Try Grandma's Pizza or the Spinach Ricotta with fresh garlic owned by a local who was born and raised in Lantana! read more

Ucccch! What was once the best pizza in the area is now by far the worst. They literally buy their ingredients from a place that is even worse than even Dominos. Pizza tasted like something you get in prison. Its obvious that this place was sold. A god damn shame. Take my advise and go any place else!!! read more

Great Pizza. We searched Yelp for reviews stopped at this cute little place with a NY theme. I like that they focus on quality ingredients and it shows in the product . It was 15 minutes before closing so what we could order was limited. The pizza sauce was spot on and the toppings on our pepperoni, sausage, mushroom and onion pizza were plentiful. I even enjoyed the pizza crust. We also had a Greek salad, they make their own dressing and it had a slight sweetness to it. I don't eat much pizza, however, the people were friendly , the restaurant was clean and the food was great. read more

See all

New place replaced Umburto's. Pizza was good. Could use more toppings around the edge.

The pizza is greasy and it's floppy but you taste the quality. Big slices and not a chain so you know it's decent. 7.1 read more

East Side Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lantana, Florida

This is some of the best pizza in Manalapan you can find it's right off Dixie Highway. Thin crust perfectly cooked. They sell slices too, which is really hard to find in Florida. The service is really good, People are warm and friendlyand the ambience, Well, it's a pizza places. Got a pizza place vibe. read more

Absolutely love that there was a gluten free option. Delivery was super fast. Pepperoni pizza and chef salad was fresh and delicious.

We read the reviews and was excited to try their pie. The pepperoni and onion pizza we ordered was pretty disappointing! See the picture. All the components were quite good except for the onions. Maybe it's a short-cut for them to cook a bunch of onions at the beginning of the day, before they put them on the pizza and bake it? These were super-caramelized. They belonged in soup--maybe, except some seemed to still have the skin on. Just....gross! read more

East Side Pizza - Pizza with pepperoni and onions. NOTE: I did not order caramelized onions. - Pizza Near Me - Lantana, Florida

I love their pizza. I am originally from New York and it's very hard to find good pizza here in Florida. My Favorite pizza is the Quattro Formaggio yummm. Great delivery service always on time. Absolutely no complaints. Quiet little cozy place to eat. read more

East Side Pizza - Quattro Formaggio and regular cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lantana, Florida

Yoooooooo, Back again and had to get my NY Style pizza on !!! We all herd of famous Prince St Pizza In Manhattan NY which they are famous for their square bottle cap pepperoni Sicilian well theses fine Italiano's make that pie even better !!! Also had to try their Roast Beef hero with sauté onions and their home made au jus which dresses off and make this hero complete !! The roast beef was tender and delicious well seasoned ... another must try !! Definitely hitting this four days a week while I'm down here ... Had their regular slice just to make sure their NY Style slice was still on point and this slice blew me a way ..., their pie crust it perfected and their sauce is home made & they are using the best mozzarella !!! One of of the best slices I've ever had ... Highly recommended & definitely a must try !!! Thanks, Greg D. read more

See all

I made my own sausage pizza with fresh mozzarella, basil, garlic, sun dried tomatoes with ,garlic, basil, and said light on sauce. I got a pizza loaded with Roma tomatoes m, some fresh mozzarella, basil in whole large leaves barely any sausage, , garlic in whole cloves, regular shredded mozzarellla and it's gummy from all those damn roma toma!! It's the worst I've had next to the nearby Round Table. And it was like warm. I said 'easy on the sauce.' There is over a cup from one ssongle piece. Soggy pizza anyone? gross. 'Chef refused to remake and deliver it. 'We dont have any driver tonight anymore.' Really at 5:30pm on a Sunday? B!!!!!! Don't order from here's. I'm a chef. It's likes hotel saying they have a pool and there is a dirty stream. I paid $3.50 for sun-dried tomatoes. Or a guy asking me out on a dinner date and you get a hot dog from a cart on the street and a can of Diet Coke and then he says ''Let's go to my place, I have this great Spider-Man movie from 1987! We can make microwave popcorn!" read more

*I ASKED FOR THE PIZZA TO BE WELL DONE/BURNT* I recently moved here from NJ and east side pizza is the only place that has filled the hole in my heart when it comes to pizza from NJ. They make a really killer NY/NJ style pizza that really reminds me of home read more

East Side Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lantana, Florida

Had the Sicilian pizza was very good there was not any uncooked bread in crust it was fully cooked the sauce is very good we will check out the thin crust next time read more

Very close to NY pizza! I've ordered a couple of times and so far it's consistently great! The sauce tastes just right, they're definitely using quality ingredients. The service is always friendly and prompt. The place looked clean and well maintained. Would definitely recommend to try! read more

I'm all for supporting local/family owned businesses. If I could give zero stars I would. Presentation is a mess. Pizza is decent but floppy and rubbery (had to warm it up since it came below room temp). Garlic rolls sucked. Took an hour and a half to get here and when we called to see the status, we receive attitude from the man on the phone and the response was "the driver is leaving now, do you still want it?". I paid for it didn't I?? You didn't have a problem charging my card an hour and a half ago. Any other pizzeria would have at minimum apologized and said they'd be there shortly. Not this place! Just so everyone is aware, we were told it would be here in 30 minutes. I would've picked it up had I known it was was going to take triple the time and without a courteously call saying they're running behind. First and last time I will be ordering from here. Not sure where the hype from these reviews comes from. I would love a call from the OWNER to discuss this further since I am not even mentioning the worst part. Not the spoiled brat taking calls on the phone. Plenty more pizzerias in the area that do not treat customers this way. I'm not one to bash a place like this, but it disgust me how this place treats their customers and takes ZERO accountability. read more

East Side Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lantana, Florida

See all

Excellent carry out spot. Great NY style pizza. Sicilian is nice and bready. I really enjoy their sandwiches. They have a few tables, but the ambiance is 100% takeout. Delivery is prompt and arrives hot read more

This is one of the best pizza joints in palm beach county. Really really good pizza!!!

No doubt about it. This is by far the best pizza I've had since living down here for 70 years. I ordered a plain cheese. I don't want toppings to distract me from the taste. I do add extra oregano and black pepper. Not a fancy place. More for take-out, however, they do have a few tables inside and a few outside. Friendly staff. Very clean on the inside. The pizza was cooked perfectly. The dough was very tasty. Crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside. They use a good grade of cheese. The cheese was not brown (overcooked) when taken out of the oven. A good amount, not flooded with tomato sauce. Will I go back? Hell yes! read more

I am super bummed bc this was my favorite pizza spot! We called last night and the person on the phone seemed unhappy that we were asking if they took AmEx? We were very confused. They were nice enough to tell us that delivery was very delayed- we get it! But we received a pizza that was inedible. When you picked up a slice the cheese legit fell off. Very disappointing. We had to throw the whole box in the trash. read more

A "get well" story. Very few places are perfect 100% of the time. East Side, both the current iteration and the 2010-2022 owners who acquired Bronx Tale have maintained a high standard of fresh authentic ingredients. attention to detail and fair pricing. But alas every now and then things go wrong. Tonight was one such instance; and the way they handled it makes me a loyal patron forever. Took out a very unique East Side burger, very rare (difficult) no cheese. Got it home, wife found it naked ( no cooked onion/mushrooms, well done). I called to adjust price. Even tho within 30 minutes of closing, they offered to deliver a replacement, which showed up PERFECT in about 18-20 minutes. Wife loved it. The MOD had said " anything to make it right and keep your trust". Now I'm a regular but not one of their $500/month crew, and this service to keep a customer is getting pretty rare in the solo small businesses in the fringe neighborhoods around West Palm Beach. I hope these guys maintain a level that keeps them going because they are definitely customer conscious. read more

Just got a large cheese pizza well done from there tonight. I haven't had it in a while l, but remember last time I did the ravioli was amazing, the pizza was in the middle. This time the pizza was very good, it was a little messy, and not well done. But it was delicious, and I think I found my new pizza place for a while. Variety is the spice of life and when it comes to pizza I need to switch it up everyonce in a while. For cheese pizza i would say it's a 7.7 read more

My girlfriend and I were craving some Za and decided to try East Side tonight on the strength of the recent reviews (thanks to Greg D in particular). So glad we went. We ordered a large (16 inch) pie with pepperoni and mushrooms. They had a special for a Large two topping for around $14 I believe. We also ordered a Greek salad. The place was very clean but only one small table inside so obviously take out exclusively at this point. We only had to wait 10 minutes or so for our food and took it home. Pizza was just excellent. Good quality ingredients and perfectly cooked. A lovely, beautiful NY style pie here. The Greek salad was generously portioned and so fresh and good. Would have been a meal unto itself. Really impressed with East Side and another local gem to add to the pizza scene, which is fairly strong in the area. Looking forward to returning. read more

East Side Pizza - Almost forgot to take the photo before digging in. Large pepperoni and mushroom. So good! - Pizza Near Me - Lantana, Florida

So I have to write on here as much as I hate leaving bad reviews but I'm honest & I absolutely love pizza but this was not it our pizza took an hr & a half to be delivered. It has you order through door dash but the entire time it just said processing when my husband clicked on it, it then told us they deliver themselves, so why did we pay the DoorDash up charge and get a time of 30 mins for arrival time? Our pizza was cold the "cheese bread" was a piece of hoagie bread with a slice of unmelted cheese on the top and it was cold and when we asked for fresh garlic, it was missing but it looked like they sprinkled garlic powder on it. Giving them the benefit of the doubt & maybe they were having an off day. But 1 slice of cheese pizza & cheese bread shouldn't have taken an hr & a half when you place the order through door dash just to see that they deliver it and not door dash. read more

Stop in this afternoon for lunch , big mistake! Order cheesesteak with American cheese and nothing else , also ordered fries. The sandwich was terrible, very salty and bad tasting, ate less then 1/2 and trashed the rest The fries were almost as bad , they were coated with some kind of coating. Not very good Last visit for me!!! read more

How utterly disappointing! This had the highest ratings of any pizza place in my area so I thought I couldn't go wrong. Wrong, advertises fresh spinach on the Florentine pizza. It was NOT fresh, I despise all spinach with the exception of fresh spinach. Frozen or canned spinach is disgusting to me so totally wasted my money. One star because it came quickly, another star because the lemon cake was good, not great, won't crave it in the future and definitely won't be eating here again. read more

East Side Pizza - NOT FRESH spinach - Pizza Near Me - Lantana, Florida

I would DEFINITELY recommend this little pizza "joint". LOL .. they offer AMAZING varieties of pizza and you could customize your pizza, to your liking. MUST, MUST try their East Side's Special salad. It's very fresh and it has a lot of flavors. We truly LOVE this place . Boun Appetito !!! read more

One the best pizza at Palm Beach & the huge fresh Greek salad (their vinaigrette is the best believe me) Very kind people running this place. If you are a pizza lover you should stop at this place. highly recommended read more

East Side Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lantana, Florida

See all

I've had multiple problems ordering with them. I recently went for the first time in store, and the calzone was undercooked on the inside and mushy. Luckily, I found them person on the street which I gave it to. I've had problems with the service before and I again tried to order yesterday, but it seems that the online menu does not match what their actually menu is. I've never been to an Italian pizzeria in my life in general that does not have veal. I'm not sure if this is a South Florida thing or just the area in general. But I'm pretty baffled at the fact that it seems many restaurants as far as pizzerias in the general area where I'm at will not serve veal, probably because they just don't want to purchase it or maybe nobody orders it. But it's always been on the menu anywhere you go. So I'm going to write two stars just to be kind because normally I would do half Star but I don't think that's an option. I think the pizza is very greasy and I was not happy with a calzone at all. And, like I said, I gave it away to somebody who really needed it. read more