Great take n bake thin crust pizza. Amazing deli-style subs. Order ahead, or online, or in-person. They've got a freezer of frozen pizzas too! Best pizza around. read more

I hesitated to post a review during these tough times , but this has continued to bother me. I went into the store to order a takeaway pizza ( 4 stars). However.... no employee was wearing a mask. When I questioned the employee , she said it was mandatory and she was young and couldn't get the virus. I said that was not true and then she threw down her own and said. Have a nice night lady and walked away . Another person took my order. She wash her hands but again no mask or gloves on. This is Food service, in the time of a pandemic and the CDC guidelines say a mask at the very least should be worn. I give the manager 1 star for poor training of the employees. This is dangerous and truly disrespectful of the customer that wears a mask.. we protect each other. I would caution going here unless the CDC guidelines are strictly enforced. read more

Fast friendly service with one of the best pizza options in Oshkosh. A must try if you haven't already. read more

I have long loved Eaton's Pizza. I no longer live in the area and I will without fail purchase this pizza each trip to Wisconsin. My family knows the best gift they can bring to me when they come for a visit it a few of these pizzas. Truly amazing! read more

My first visit to a "take and bake" pizza place ever, and a good experience at that. My destination was 45 minutes away, so it made perfect sense to not get an already baked pizza. I ordered two, one for my carnivorous family, a classic with fresh sausage, pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, etc., etc. They don't have anchovies, so I bought some at Pick "n Save and they put these on for me as well ("we have never had this request before. How do you do this?") The second pizza was a spinach artichoke garlic sauce "white" (no tomato sauce) pizza. Both were excellent, took about 25 minutes to bake. I thought the taste was equal to or better than the highest rated pizza parlor in the area. And the price was very reasonable. Support local. This family owned business has been around for 30 years and for good reason. Definitely a winner. read more

My family and I had pretty much stayed with the franchise pizza places, such as Pizza Hut and Domino's, when ordering pizza. Occasionally we would get a take-and-bake pizza from Papa Murphy's, but the pizzas weren't our favorites. Recently we got some coupons for pizzas to Eaton's Pizza that is a local chain of restaurants. The restaurant we visited had a nice layout to it. Along with the area where they prepare the pizzas, there was a nice area for knickknacks to browse while you wait. The staff was very friendly and the pizza was made quickly. Best of all, the pizzas are very good. Our kids absolutely love them. I don't know if it is the sauce or the cheese or the combination of the two, but the pizzas have a lot of flavor to them. So, if you are looking for something different from the traditional pizza places, I would definitely recommend going to Eaton's Pizza. read more

Best pizza, best subs, best wraps, best service, 100% THE place to go when you can't seem to decide what you want.

The worst part about Eatons is livng about 20 miles away. I loved going there as a kid, and I still love going as an adult whenever I'm in town. It'll forever be my favorite place to get subs read more