I've been on an Irish Pub kick for the last week and Thatcher's is a classic…read more Hubby of course had a Guinness. He likes it here because they have the full size pint glasses where many other restaurants have switched to the smaller size. I got a Stella on draft because I'm not a fan of the stouts and lagers. Hubby got a cup of the hearty beef barley soup then enjoyed his corned beef sandwich with seasoned fries. Very big portion that he is going to have for lunch tomorrow. I went with the chicken curry. It's my daughter's go to favorite for this place and I know she will be happy to have some of my leftovers since the portion is so huge. Hubby liked dipping his fries in the sauce (as did I). Such a joyful meal! I highly recommend it! He got a coffee and we split a piece of cheesecake. It was a large plate for a small piece. It may not have been too small, but perhaps some Whipped cream or a smaller plate to appease the eye. The service is fantastic! We sat and had menus right away, whenever we finished a drink or food. They cleared items right away and were very attentive. There were TVs over the bar with various games and it looks like this was the place for World Cup soccer. The bar area is very lively and a fun place to hang out. But there are also multiple rooms where you can have a quieter meal or even outdoor dining when the weather permits. If you haven't been here, do stop by when you are in the Denville area. You will love it!

Huge menu Nice staff…read moreGood for groups Bar and dining room area Lunch specials Nice staff Street parking

We have three months to complete the 2026 Tri-State Stamping Tour with American Legion Post 289 in…read moreWest Milford, NJ. 158 places across NJ, NY, and PA to visit to support the Veterans and those who support them and get our books stamped! This is stop 22/158. Very nice tavern. Darts here. Nice set up two boards. Great bar area. Large. Comfortable.

Stopped in today while doing the 2026 Tri-State Stamping Tour with American Legion Post 289 in…read moreWest Milford, NJ. 158 places across NJ, NY, and PA to support the Veterans and those who support them. This is stop 22 of 158. What a fun place!!! Dart boards but no time to play. We enjoyed chatting at the very large and clean bar area. Comfy and such nice folks. Our bartender was a delight. Definitely will find time to stop by again.

Excellent food and such a fun vibe! I loved the signage and murals. The bartender was great, very…read morefriendly and attentive despite being the only 1 working behind the bar plus waiting the tables. The southwest chicken wrap, fries, and voodoo chicken sandwich were all great. There is a pool table and a lot of TVs. We would definitely return here!

Looks like your standard dive bar on the inside. Food was very good and staff were very attentive…read more Had lots of TVs to watch football games and a live band came on at 9pm on a Saturday. Also have a lot of local beers and ciders! Would go back.

We've eaten many times at the breakfast restaurant next door and each time we've said we need to…read morestop in at this Tavern. This week, my wife, my stepson, and I, stopped by for a late dinner and drink. This is a small, cozy bar with I'm guessing is a lot of regular customers. There's a nice bar along with a few tables. I had a Sam's Oktoberfest to start. We ordered cheesesteak fries and a pretzel to share as apps. I then had a cheesesteak sandwich which was really good! The woman serving us, who I believe is the owner, was very friendly. She also does all the cooking right at the side of the bar which was cool. Parking easy, prices very reasonable. This was a fun stop!

We loved the attention paid by the amiable bartenders, the food was good and ample, and the owners,…read moreBridget and George are great. Definitely an eclectic mix of entertaining customers.

Quite a few years ago (before I was on Yelp) I met a friend of mine for lunch at The Second Half…read moreand really liked the place. This past Saturday was an overcast August day so my wife and I decided to stop in for afternoon drinks and appetizers. We didn't realize there were Happy Hour specials, but that made it even better! Sitting at the bar, we ordered cocktails, mozzarella sticks, and pretzel bites. My Old Fashioned was perfect and the food was good too. It was a fun atmosphere at the bar with everyone just enjoying a Saturday afternoon. We also had TV's with preseason football. Our bartender, Dennis, made great drinks and was very pleasant to talk to. A nice bar and a fun time!

This was our second visit to Second Half on Main, and it was just as good as the first! The…read morehighlight of our experience was our waitress, Janet, who actually remembered us from our previous visit. That personal touch made us feel so welcome. The food was outstanding. I had the Santa Fe Bowl and the stuffed twin avocados, and both were absolutely delicious. My husband ordered the French dip and a salad, and he loved everything as well. Great food, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere--it's easy to see why we'll keep coming back. Thank you, Janet, for making another visit so enjoyable!

Came here for the first time today. Great outdoor space with cozy couches, picnic tables with…read moreumbrellas, live music, dog friendly and adults only areas too. Come for the beer and stay for the vibe. It's BYO-food and they have a QR code for the menus from the 35 places around. Plus they offer to go get your take-out order and bring it back to you! Next time I will partake in that service. Tonight I just had a hazy IPA.

Cool place centrally located. The WONDERFUL lady at the front informed me that it's a BYOF and…read moresometimes at night, they have runners who'll bring the food from local spots to you. The selections of drinks were great. Hard seltzers. Slushies. IPAs. Stouts. Good stuff AND affordable. I got a flight of 3 seltzers and my friend got the American Hobo. Staff was helpful, place was clean, and I love the outdoorsy, loungy decor.

They make a really juicy burger here with fresh ingredients. Probably a little too much dressing on…read morethe salad but the burger was perfection. Great service as well, our waiter was especially accommodating to our allergies and in making it right when the tap water tasted off. Would definitely not hesitate to come back and try their pizza.

Excellent dinner with friendly service…read more Stop here on a co-worker's recommendation. Well worth my time and money.

My wife and I stopped in here at Smith's on a Saturday afternoon in February and had a great time…read more This is definitely a local spot but even as first timers, we were treated as if we're there all the time. Our server, Kim, did a great job running the bar. Not only were the drinks well made, but she was super friendly. I had a bacon bleu cheese burger with onion rings and my wife had a cheeseburger with fries. Delicious! If you come here, one thing to keep in mind is that it's cash only. There is an ATM across the street at The Exchange though. After passing here so many times, we're really glad we stopped in!

Review from a poor man. After finding out that this place…read moreserves food (not sure how I didn't know this previously), we decided to go. I had the Chicken Parm (with a substitute of a side salad only) and the lady had Fish and Chips Here is the pros and cons. Pros. THE PRICE FOR FOOD IS BEYOND REASONABLE!! The cocktail sauce definitely seems homemade and has a great kick to it. Fries were had a good crisp and the fish was pretty good. The side salad was very good and was a decent portion. The chicken parm and fish portion was a very healthy size. The whole ambiance of the place reminds me of places from my childhood and that makes me happy. Cons. The fish could have been a slight bit moister but over was still good. The chicken parm was a bit bland in flavor and a bit thick in breading. Coleslaw, with the fish and chips, was definitely store bought. Overall, the place is worth the stop on through if you are on a budget or like place that remind you of an era gone by. but still want to eat out. Just remember that it is a CASH ONLY place. This is worth stopping on in at least once! We will be back to try other food!

Great place. I met a guy named Moke who apparently lives on one of the stools. He had his knee…read morereplaced so I bought him 10 drinks to be a nice guy.

Stopped in after a 7 mile hike for a nice cold beer. Cash only and no food. Great beer prices -…read moremost beers were $4 and the special was $7 pitchers of Miller Lite. We enjoyed a pitcher and the outdoor area. The set up is great. We came during the day so it wasn't super crowded but I can see this place being really fun at night. The only pitfall of the outside area is that smoking is allowed.

We came to celebrate Mother's Day. They had a wonderful…read morebrunch buffet. Everything was delicious. Service was great. Atmos Definitely coming back!

It's no longer the Rockaway River Barn! Rockaway River Barn closed, now called 11 Green. But…read moreservice at the old place was never great