Homemade Mexican food at a great price. My husband and I go regularly and the waitstaff recognizes us. I have never had an problem with the service or food. So many delicious things to choose from. El Sarape is my place for comfort food...and when I need a margarita to de-stress. Everyone we take there always asks to go back. read more

Great service, amazing prices. Come for the food, stay for the beer. Food is delicious and fresh but trading $4.25 for a 24oz Modelo is unreal. read more

Love this place, great food, friendly staff and unreal prices. Dine in or carry out, never had a meal I didn't love. Great guacamole.

I rarely if ever write reviews for anything, but I decided to make an exception in this case. In my many years of eating at restaurants, I can assure you that this is the worst service I have ever had. So bad in fact, that I finally had to get up to get my own napkins. In addition to the atrocious service, the food was mediocre at best, the atmosphere is extremely noisy, and the food handling by the staff is a little questionable at times. read more

My husband and I ate here once and the atmosphere was quaint in the restaurant. Very nice place for a couple or maybe a small party. It looked to me that most of its patrons were "regulars." On another note, we have ordered from there for take-out several times. Food is great for the area and their prices are alright. I don't like how much they charge for a bag of chips & salsa (you know the same you get in a basket in-house), but whatever. read more

I was just visiting from San Diego and I needed my mexican food fix. El Serape satisfied my cravings and left my belly full. The food was great and there was enough left for take home seconds. The prices were actually lower than I would've expected for a sit down restaurant... especially since my serving was huge. Tasty salsa although I would've liked if there were more flavors, ie salsa verde, hotter, salsa fresca. (they may have them but I didn't ask) Anyway, good restaurant. read more

By far the best authentic Mexican food hands down. I've searched high and low for an authentic Mexican restaurant since moving here from CA, and this place is excellent! Prices are reasonable and portions are large. They also have a 2nd location in Ashwaubenon near Hwy 41 - so if you're here for a Packer game, this place is just a few minutes away. I always order burritos or enchiladas, and their burritos are huge. Also use their take out and service is always prompt. They have great homemade salsa too. I love their spiciest foods, but mild is good too. Special lunch deals also offered during weekdays. This is the place all the locals love. read more

The service was fast and accurate. The chips and salsa are great. Had the chori-pollo diner and it's amazing! The chorizo is a bit greasy but it's suppose to be. Comes with chicken beast and chorizo mixed together and covered with cheese dip. No need to say more! read more

We visit this spot often, I am from Texas, and this is the closest to my hometown food. Saying that, the service here is lazy, slow, and the wait staff seems to not be too concerned about their patrons. If you try to make a plate special, they usually say you cant. After arguing they may, but it will still come out wrong. The blended drinks are weak too, so avoid them. I have looked for food that tastes the same, but I havent found it in Green Bay....... yet. read more

I was always told great things about this place by many people, but when I went there I was a little let down. And I've actually been there maybe 5 or 6 times, and I'm still not overly impressed. It's a good place to eat: the food is pretty tasty, prices are reasonable, atmosphere is good, the menu has plenty of options; it just didn't live up to the hype. And that's not the restaurant's fault, I was just setup to expect more. read more

I order here all the time until recently when I ordered 2 burritos, they were soggy and had no flavor. I called and spoke to the manager who said he was unable to remake the order or refund me I kept pushing and he finally told me the owner was coming in later and he would talk to them and call me back the same day the manager never ended up calling me back so I called him the following day and was told that he had a meeting with the owner and were not able to refund or remake our order but wanted us to try them again but they could not guarantee that the food would be good. I will never be back at this restaurant again!!! very upsetting read more

During the deepest, darkest part of winter, the surest thing to beat seasonal affective disorder is a trip to El Sarape. No, I'm not suggesting that you drown your sorrows in one of their Big Gulp-esque margaritas (although that's certainly an option too-- they are super delicious) but the fresh ingredients in the house salsas (you get the standard super-garlicky red and then a milder green tomatillo-based salsa for the freshly made white corn tortilla chips) will beat your post-winter funk in a heartbeat. The burritos are gargantuan and the prices are very affordable. It's only place where you can get takeout for $14 and have at least a second meal out of the leftovers. I highly recommend the ribeye taco with fresh guacamole or the amazing shrimp burritos (ala Cancun) which are shrimp rolled in a white corn tortilla, covered in white queso and lime zest -- outstanding! Everything in this place is fresh, right down to the housemade Horchata. Do yourself a favor and just order a pitcher right away, because you'll need its healing coolness when you accidentally overdose on a quart of the amazing salsa. I'm kind of stingy with the five star reviews here on Yelp, but if I could give a 4.5, I certainly would for El Sarape. read more

Horrible food horrible service I asked if they could customize my chimichanga so I could be vegetarian they first had to bring in 3 people to verify they could I waited 10 min then they come back and say they can't after everyone at my table got their food. The food was horrible no taste no flavor no nothing. read more

Had the special margaritas and it was awesome. The burritos are huge with lots of options. Great little place with the home town packer pride mixed with a mexican flair. read more

Hands down the best Mexican food in Green Bay. Large servings, good prices, great service.

El Sarape's is great. I've been there numerous time, have had great service, great food and a great atmosphere. I go alone most times and bring a book to read. Sometimes I read a long time having a beer and have never been felt rushed. Recommend it. read more

My favorite restaurant for Mexican food by far. Good deal and good quality, never disappointed. If you're one for burritos (like me), then this is definitely the place to go. I usually get the Steak Sarape Burrito (with Chili De Arbol - flavorful and spicy salsa) which cost ~$8 and will surely fill you up or even be enough for a second meal. El Sarape is the go to Mexican restaurant in town! read more

Good food, beer,pricing, and service. I have tried a number of their dishes and have not had a bad one. The dishes seem to be authentic and made to order rather than "manufactured" like some of the Mexican restaurants around the country. The staff seems to be genuine in their service to each patron. The decor is pleasant and lively. Definitely will continue to eat here while in the area. read more

Friendly staff and I usually always get the Robert special which is amazing. The fried ice cream is really good as well.

This is normal Mexican food. The place is clean and service was spot on. Will definitely return when in Green Bay again.

Food here is delicious, very busy, only problem we had was long wait on refills otherwise very friendly, and food is great for a great price. read more

The best of the best. Delicious and large portions. Comfortable atomosphere, reasonable prices. Nothing bad to say.

Good food, may need to stick to the lunch menu...full menu might make you too full! Prices are a little high for the regular menu but the good is good. read more

If I could give El Sarape 2 1/2 stars I would. The waiter was nice and attentive. Seating was a little bit crowded; we were there on a Friday night and there were enough empty tables that they could take a few out. Brightly colored and cute decor, but could have been cleaner. Traditional margaritas were good but the strawberry tasted like a smoothie. My husband's burrito was good, my daughter's enchilada wasn't. There are better Mexican restaurants in Green Bay. read more

Get the Sarape burrito! It is giant and will definitely feed two. It looks like one of those 5 lb burritos on man vs food. The "half size" burrito that you can order is a normally size burrito at other restaurants. The ONLY reason I did not give this place 5 stars is because they charge $1.50 for chips and salsa if you finish off the free basket--what a rip off! read more

Only thee Best Burritos around!!! Please try it yourself, I've never had better Mexican food!

Arrived at 6PM on a Friday night. Interior decorated authentically Mexican. Place was packed but we got the last available table. Waiter immediately brought salsa & chips and our soda. At 6:15 he took our order. Extremely large & varied menu. My wife & I both ordered a combination dinner. At 6:35 our meals arrived. Hot, delicious, filling...all at a very reasonable price. Waiter checked back to make sure our food was pleasing to us. Water glasses were regularly filled by waiter's assistant. Only complaint of the night was that the waiter never checked back to see if our sodas needed refilling. At 7PM he stopped to see if we wanted to order anything else. At that time we requested soda refills which he happily complied with. My wife and I split a fried ice cream. They normally didn't make it the way we requested but our waiter stated he'd see what he could do. 2 minutes later he showed up with the fried ice cream exactly as we had specially requested. It was large and delicious. We left our waiter a very generous tip as he did an excellent job in a very friendly, yet professional manner. We paid our bill and left at 7:15PM. We were happy to find that the praise that we'd heard for El Serape was well deserved. We are looking forward to the opportunity to bring friends here. read more