Great for lagers and pilsners I didn't get food but the bar…read moreservice was great and beer was exceptional Plenty of seating Lots of beer options

Met up here on a Monday evening and was excited to try it since I had never been. I got the fries…read morewith preserved lemon aioli - these magical bites somehow stayed hot and crispy through the whole meal. I tried (& loved) their Belgian triple since it had just won a silver medal at the NYS Craft Brewers awards. It was well-deserving of the honor it received! Staff was friendly and attentive, and it was easy enough to get a bartender's attention for a refill. Seating area was bright and spacious with great atmosphere. Parking situation is kinda hairy - extra tight spaces in a small lot, but it was manageable for a Monday, and there's street parking if you don't happen to get a space in the lot. Cheers!

Just what we needed for some girlfriend time after going to the coffee shop needed a cocktail and…read moresome good lunch. Thank you Michelle. I don't know how you do it. It was a room full of people and you handled us all.

Friday was our first time there. We were seated right away for some drinks and a late lunch…read more Service was outstanding and I enjoyed was the atmosphere at the bar. Many seemed to know one another and it reminded me of a modern Cheers type feel. We ordered the turkey wrap with waffle fries and the Korean Good For Your Soeul Burger and tater tots. Everything was absolutely delicious and enough for two meals. I would highly recommend the Old Stone Tavern. That extra crisp on my tater tots and melt in your mouth flavor on the burger was on point!

We went here the other day for a late lunch and had a good time! They had a somewhat long wait for…read morea table, but we were able to get drinks at their inside bar and appetizers while we waited. For our entrees we had the bbq platter, dog plate, pear and prosciutto flatbread, and the cowboy burger. Everyone really enjoyed their dishes! They also had a good selection of beers and had other beverages such as wines, seltzers, and sodas. We would go back here again!

Come for the views, the lively atmosphere and the beer. The food isn't very exciting but is priced…read moreappropriately. We ate outside on the enclosed patio on a rare and perfect 72 degree sunny not humid day. We were told it could be an hour to be seated but our text message came in after barely 10 minutes. Our server was friendly and service overall was prompt. The Mac and Cheese was enjoyable and I took home the leftovers and ate them later. It wasn't as cheesy or luscious as I might have hoped, it was just enough cheese to do the job. The finely diced chicken had good fire grilled flavor but was pretty dry. They offer a Buffalo version of their mac and cheese but there are several hot sauces on the table. Not sure how much difference there would be between their buffalo mac and just sprinkling hot sauce on the mac and cheese with plain chicken which is what i did. The chicken salad wrap was satisfactory and VERY generously filled. It was really almost too big and it came with a comically huge quantity of potato chips.

Went into this establishment not knowing the area and what to expect.. I must say, from the food,…read morethe drinks, the service, atmosphere and hospitality, I was rather impressed. Definitely would recommend. McKenna & Chris, the best of luck to you and I will definitely be back soon after my son's Brockport Football games! See you then!

The chicken Francese is terrible. It looks like canned soup. Presentation of it was not good. That…read moreshould be an indicator to the kitchen to not serve it to customers. The burger was okay though

Unfortunately, this restaurant is permanently closed .. They…read morehad the BEST steak you'd ever want to eat. The rest of your dinner would have been just as good. Thank you for the years you were open.

Soup AND Salad WITH Bread, in addition to your meal ... in one word, YUM!…read more Upon entry, we felt like we were stepping into a different dimension and simpler times. Candlelit tables and dim sconces on the walls provided a warm, inviting vibe. Surprisingly, the server who greeted us knew us by name and warmly welcomed us to the National Hotel. Our server was knowledgeable, friendly and had a great sense of humor. The meal was coursed out perfectly and we enjoyed every bite. Stuffed mushrooms to start were piping hot and flavorful in a ramekin of butter. The hottest thing in Cuylerville was the freshly baked bread-in-a-bag! Perfect to get every morsel of mushroom soup out of our bowls. Usually you have to choose between soup OR salad, not here! We got a fresh greens garden salad following the soup! Our main entrées of steak were perfectly cooked to temp and tasted great with the red wine. The mashed potatoes were fluffy, flavorful and satisfying. Peanut butter and chocolate pie brought our experience to a close. To wrap up the evening, we got to thank the chef and her husband for an amazing dining experience. This is one of a kind gem and we look forward to our next visit. Bring a loved one, go for a special date night or just stop in to treat yourself. You will not be disappointed.

Excellent Food Service was good she took my drink away it…read morewas Grey Goose on the rocks and she thought it was gone when actually it still had some flavor in it! Dessert a Cheesy Eddies cheese cake was very over priced they need to get a different vender it was so small for $9 was way disappointing!! Can't say much about the ambiance .......love the decor and it could be a great ambiance if they could float some sound absorbers, that would b awesome! I would go back again for sure! I would recommend the short ribs, cooked to perfection and not a piece of fat at all, the Demi glaze was excellent, real mashed potatoes and I would add a little more garlic for my taste to the fresh green beans but they were fresh and very good! The dessert was good but not worth the price needs to b a bigger piece or get new venders ! My husband recommends the the fish fry biggest fish we ever saw actually had fish inside the tail cooked to perfection! I would give this place 4.5 stars

This is a really fun place to visit. The restaurant is in a restored firehouse, with a firehouse…read morethemed menu. They do pizza really well, but they also have a smoker and many smokehouse items are on the menu. Large portions, friendly, and lively service, and a great bar, at prices that are sane. Lots of beer on drafter by the bottle, and a decent wine selection. We love it here.

Great menu selection and the food is excellent. The servers are very friendly and it's beautiful…read moredining outside on the patio.

Place was packed! Doing great business!!! People were friendly!! It was Friday so I purchased the…read morebeer battered fish fry with onion rings, slaw, and a side of fries... Yummy!!! Onion rings were on point and the fries were just as good! The crisp on the fish was delicious. The slaw surprised me at first I wasnt a fan but I tried it again and I was very happy!!!!

Today I stopped off here with a group, the food was ok. Nothing to write home about. We got cheese…read morecurds and spare ribs. Cheese curds - eh, not bad. Ok stringiness. Bbq spare ribs - not smoky at all, super sweet flavor. Overall: not sure if i would come back, it was just eh, nothing that great.

Lots of new fall menu items right now that are AMAZING. This is a pork ribeye with creamy polenta…read moreand veggies. Very yummy!

I've never had a bad dish there, service is always friendly and fast, and the owners are very…read morenice. Family owned. Cool atmosphere, I love sitting at the table in the window!

My boyfriend and i were out in area so we decided to stop here. They opened late first off. Once…read morein and seated, we ordered Shepards Pie and Irish Beef stew . To our disappointment the food was microwaved and looked like mush. We were hoping for some comfort food on this cold day. Which isn't what we got. They did remove my entree but they wouldn't take his off. So, we're out $20 plus our drinks & time. We won't be going back.

I rarely give out five stars. Between the abysmal customer service that seems rampant these days…read moreand fast, slapped together food, this is a Hidden Gem (promise not to tell anyone, o.k ?) I was done with work, tooling around Henrietta, and thanks to my errant GPS, took a wrong turn down Clay Road. That's how I found this place. Since I came in on the Clay Road entrance, I had no idea it was actually in the Holiday Inn and Suites, on the corner of Jefferson and Clay Roads. Of course, this means that it has a huge private parking lot. I used the Clay Road entrance, leading directly into the restaurant. It's actually bigger than you would think. It's very sleek, modern and cosmopolitan. To the left as you enter, is a gleaming, polished, black marble bar and barstools, with large, flat- screen TVs flanking the bar. I seated myself at one of the tables between the bar and the long, rectangular high top that separates the dining room. On the other side of the rectangngular table, is a spacious, living-room area, with comfy chairs and sofas, and another large flat-screen. It's a great place to gather and have drinks, or just relax and scroll through your email. There were over a dozen people enjoying their drinks and laughing and a couple of teenagers chilling on the sofas, intent on their cells. An impeccably groomed server, Preston, immediately came over and greeted me and gave me a menu. He served me both times that I was there for dinner. He asked about my mother, which was kind. I was impressed that he even remembered, considering the amount of people he serves. He even remembered what I had to drink (Prosecco) the first time. I usually avoid eating in hotels, even while on a trip in bad weather. Between his excellent service, and the delicous food here, I was warming to eating in a hotel, even if I live in Rochester. The first time, I asked him what he suggested; he said their burgers were excellent. I ordered a build-your-own Burger, with cheddar cheese, tomato, lettuce, and onion. The burgers all come with a side of fries or Pub Chips. Preston said that the Pub Chips are made in-house daily. I went with those. I changed my mind and canceled the lettuce, fearing iceberg. Being rather soft-spoken, he probably didn't hear that, and my burger arrived with lettuce. Fortunately, it was not the iceberg that I loathe; it was a nice wonderfully green and crisp leaf lettuce. I took one look at the Burger and thought "Oh Mama, there's no way I'm going to finish this sucker," as it was huge...like the Grand Canyon of burgers. I'm not a picky eater, just not a big eater. But I had a very light, early lunch, and was pretty sure I could eat most of it. I ate it all. I'm not generally a fan of fried foods, but the pub chips were beyond delicious. It was all I could do to restrain myself from eating them all; I saved some for my mom and it was quite a sacrifice. She devoured them. Last week I bounced in and decided to try their chicken wings. Man, they really give Richmond's a run for their money: large, meaty drums perfectly slathered in delicious buffalo sauce. They were served with a handful of carrot and celery sticks and the de rigueur blue cheese. Nice presentation, too. I highly recommend trying this Hidden Gem. This place not only knocked my socks off, it made them roll up and down.