Great store, great staff, great stock, great owners, and great players…read more Huge playing area and game library if you just want to come by and hangout. Love this place!

Great store, great staff, great stock, great owners, and great players. Huge selection, friendly…read moreand attentive staff

A hidden gem on the north side of downtown Indianapolis. Paradigm games isn't a large store, but…read morethey still have plenty to offer. Best deal around for bulk magic cards. I usually stop in to the shop at least once a week, staff and the owners are all friendly. I haven't attended a tournament yet, but that will probably change in the near future. If you like magic, Pokémon, or games in general, head on down to Paradigm.

This store has so much to offer. It's almost infinite. They have anything from common games to…read morehard to find and almost obscure games. They are always so knowledgeable about everything and are more than happy to chat you up about anything in the game realm. If they happen to not have what you want or need, they are also very motivated to help direct you elsewhere. It's a magical and intriguing place to walk around and get lost in. I'm glad they are close to where I live too. I highly recommend them and I will definitely be back.

Girl wouldn't even let me read the magic cards asking me if I was ready yet I said no not yet not…read moreeven a minute later asked me if I was ready yet again honestly pretty rude don't think I'll be coming back again.

My brother and I were shopping at the flea market nearby and decided to stop in on a whim. This…read moreplace is cool! I was expecting some games but they had merch, books, and pretty much everything related to games you could ever want. Plus a bunch of tables to gather and play with others. My brother and I immediately both started texting our friends we knew would like it that they needed to check it out. I did not know so many different games existed. This place was hopping on a Sunday right at 12 when they opened. Truly, a surprising find!

EXTREMELY predatory business practices. Other reviews on here talk about poor online business…read morepractices - it is also poor in person. If you request a card pull, they fully expect you to purchase the entire lot despite condition, price, or edition (in my case a 13 quantity card pull). They will not divulge any information about price or availability over email. They don't care about customer service at all. Verbatim, I was told that they price explicitly off of TCG player, so I wouldn't waste your time getting finessed here and just go through TCG Player.

No, they don't have video games here. But yes, they do have board games and tabletop games of all…read morekinds. If you're into these types of games, this is the place for you. When we visited, there were several people at the tables playing games. The place was hoppin'. There's also a lounge area with comfy leather couches where you can play games or just hang out. Their website says that they are a LGBTQ-led store, which is really neat and not something you see very often in the Midwest. They specialize in underground games, small indie games and Kickstarter-backed games. Good Games is located in downtown Indianapolis, just off of Monument Circle. It's centrally located and in the middle of everything, so it's a good spot to relax and play games.

Super cool and clean hobby shop. Lots of unique board games, MTG and other gaming cards, Warhammer…read moreand other game related items. I appreciate a well laid out shop that makes it effortless to look around. Everything is clearly and fairly priced. They also have a huge area in the back for gaming tournaments.

This is a kid and/or adult's dream--regardless of what you're looking for. They have a bit of…read moreeverything for the kid who wants to play or find some unusual toys for their ever-expanding collection, or an adult who wants to revel in some nostalgia. In addition, the staff are kind, helpful, and knowledgeable about their various products. Finally, if you are looking to sell or trade some items, they are fair and considerate when reviewing your items. Every city needs a "Toy Pit."

I purchased four vinyl records from The Toy Pit on September 6, and unfortunately, the experience…read morehas been extremely disappointing. After the purchase, I discovered that the records I received appear to be counterfeit rather than legitimate releases. I contacted the store to try to resolve the issue, but they refused to provide any type of refund or stand behind the products they sold me. Considering how highly priced many of the items in this store are, I find it unacceptable that a customer can spend their money there, discover there is a serious issue with the authenticity of the merchandise, and then be left with no resolution. At this point, I will be disputing the charge with my bank. The entire situation has been handled very unprofessionally, and based on my experience, I would strongly recommend verifying the authenticity of anything you purchase here before spending your money.

I finally made it to the Moonshot Games storefront in downtown Noblesville! It's a small but mighty…read moreshop with a room in the back dedicated to board game events. They seem to have a larger focus on trading cards and accessories than board games and puzzles, the latter of which I'm most interested in. If I wanted a specific game, I'd likely go to their website first to check stock or order ahead rather than visiting in-store. Regardless, I'm glad to have a local business to support for puzzle and board/card game purchases!

Moon Shot Games in Noblesville feels like a well run Rebel base for tabletop gamers and TCG fans…read more Great selection of games, an impressive wall of singles, and a space that clearly exists for people who actually love the hobby. I came in for the Magic the Gathering Lorwyn Eclipse prerelease playing Two Headed Giant with a friend, and the entire event ran smoother than a hyperspace jump. From registration to the final round, everything was organized, on time, and genuinely fun. No chaos, no dark side rulings, just solid event management. The Magic community here is strong. Friendly players, good vibes, and a welcoming atmosphere whether you're a veteran Jedi or still figuring out which lands to tap. It's the kind of shop where you feel comfortable coming back even if you don't know everyone yet. Moon Shot Games has earned a repeat visit. Great staff, great events, and a community worth supporting. The Force is strong here, and I'll definitely be back for future missions.

This where I go for all of my tabletop gaming needs. It's always a treat when I get to go to this…read morewonderful business, which may seem hushed and quiet during the day, but it only adds to its mystique and charm that would be typical of a magic shop. This place works great for me because it's really close to my house and it's locally owned. That way I don't have to drive a long way to find what I need for my Dungeons and Dragons campaign. The Hero's Emporium has always had a great selection of brushes, paints, and miniatures that I have come to rely heavily upon as a Dungeon Master. I am always able to find the miniatures that I am looking for whether that be a female gnome paladin or several packages of gnolls that I can paint and throw at my party. All the miniatures are very reasonably priced too, so I can get even larger miniatures like a storm giant for only around $15. For as long as miniatures take me to paint, this is well worth the money. I also want to mention that they offer a decent selction of dice sets to choose from, which is important for any D&D campaign, especially when your dice are fickle. I also love that they offer both old and new sourcebooks for D&D as well as official Nolzurs paint sets, and Icons of the Realms. This gives me a large pool to choose what will be most exciting for my party. Finally I wanted to mention that this business has also done tabletop nights. Although I personally have not attended one of those events, I support the space this business is building for the tabletop community. The staff has also always been very welcoming and helpful, making sure that I am finding everything that I am searching for. I am also occasionally able to find expansion packs for a bit more obscure card game called Smash Up here, which is delightful considering that it's so hard to find in just a regular store like Target. I will continue to come back and support this business in their mission to help the tabletop community thrive.

Great selection of D&D and MTG stuff!…read more Also lots of other games, miniatures and accessories. They also have lots of weekly events and leagues to join. Fun atmosphere, great staff and customers!

It's a lovely little store, with wonderful pricing. Helped get me into Warhammer, so cheers to chat!read more

From the owner: Gray Gauntlet Games is a friendly local game store located in Fishers, Indiana…read more In addition to trading card games, like Pokémon and Magic: the Gathering, we also have a wide selection of board games, table top games, accessories and nerdy gifts.