Great pizza, great service, and even better ambiance! Feels like I'm at home eating here. The pizza tastes like home, thank you guys!

First time going to Elizabeth Pizza and happy that I did. Ordered a large pepperoni pizza and had to restrain myself from eating too many slices at one time. Good crust, good cheese to sauce ratio and the pepperoni had a nice flavor to it. Will be back to try other variations soon. read more

Elizabeth Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

Visiting from Los Angeles. Thought I'd see the old neighborhood. This pizza parlor has been here forever. Not sure if it's changed ownership but the pizza was great. Thin East Coast style. Had 2 sausage and 1 pepperoni slice, and a soda for $9.00. Good price, great pizza. Will visit them again. Was here Friday, August 27, 2021. read more

Elizabeth Pizzeria - Tasty, East Coast pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Elizabeth, New Jersey

See all

Service was awful and the food was jack shit. It was wat to overpriced for what they gave. I recommend coming here because it was an absolutely amazing experience. read more

Pizza is good but very greesy ..and they could cut the toppings a little more for example Onions n peppers should be diced n thrown on top not in whole sliced pieces .... read more

I have been frequenting this local spot since I was a kid. It always hits the spot. Great pizza at a great price. The owner is a very nice and friendly guy. I just wish they accepted credit card for deliveries. Only cash is an inconvenience. read more

Worst service ever. Worst pizza ever as well. I called for delivery, and after one hour called to follow up. Driver went to wrong hotel. Then they said they don't deliver to my hotel ( which they do). Then they said they do deliver, but driver is busy, they will call me when he gets back. I called them back 30 mins later, and was told he will still deliver, and pizza is still hot. It shows up after TWO HOURS. Pizza was soggy and was definitely the worst pizza I've ever had. read more

ELIZABETH PIZZERIA... I AM A BIG FAN.... NOW GIVE ME MORE...!! I used to called a delivery from Elizabeth Pizzeria every single weekend and maybe other days between-whiles of last 2 month, I take my order so easily now, at first I was mixed between each-other and still not decide what is my favorite Pie but now I love Flat sausage and mushrooms with cheese, in my opinion there is no meal better than Pizza especially when I was hungry. The only thing that made me give 4 stars is for them was I keep waiting for delivery too long until starving but when he arrive i forget my made and keep eating. I think their price is a little cheap and good for my wallet. read more

quality of pics , poor , the f -finger, cig butt . low class, wonders whats in the food, this Place was the best in the 70's & 80's . what new owners? read more

The pizza didn't have a lot of sauce on it which made the pizza dry. It wasn't the best pizza best pizza. Maybe it was sitting out for a while. Idk but I've had better pizza in my lifetime. The mozzarella sticks were on point though. read more

A TRULY TOP QUALITY PRODUCT AND CURRENTLY OFFERED WAY BELOW WHAT IT'S WORTH I was referred to Elizabeth Pizzeria by a colleague, one of their long-time customers, who raved about the quality of the cheese they use and how they prep it. He's a highly successful businessman, so I took him at his word. I didn't regret it. The plain slice I sampled was as good as I've had anywhere. If it were at a price point of $2.25, I would still be a buyer. However...at $1.65???? I was incredulous. It turns out, some new start-ups on the same block, are offering an (inferior) slice for a buck, in an attempt to capture business. I have seen this scenario before. It never works. They cause some noise for a while, and then they go belly-up, unless they have something so good, in which case, they have to raise their price. So, for now, the management at E.P rides it out, selling their superior product substantially below its true worth. Trust me, my family was in the wholesale food business for generations, and in the year 2011, you cannot sell a slice for a dollar unless you use frozen pre-grated cheese (a.k.a pizza chains) or sell the customer a slice of bread with a sliver of cheese. So, for now, the winner is the customer, as you can enjoy a lunch of two very filling plain slices and a drink for under five bucks. Hell, you can spend almost TWICE that amount at the fast food joints and get nothing more than salt, trans fat, and flavor enhancers. In addition, the owner has a personality, which is rare among pizzeria owners. Most have NO personality, which is actually preferable to the majority who have personalties of a rusty drain pipe. The only other menu item I had was the turkey sub, which, although reasonably priced at $5.25 and sized at almost-full, fell short in terms of quality and meat portion, but so-what? It's a pizzeria, and that's what will keep me returning. Using Boar's Head would require a much higher price point, which I'm sure the community would not support. The location is not Union/Cranford/Westfield. In those towns, EP's slice would be $2.50, minimum. Which compels me to write: the city of Elizabeth is inundated with pizzerias, which run the gamut from cheap greasy spoons, to legendary landmarks Santillo's (unsurpassed for brick oven pies) and Spirito's. Elizabeth Pizzeria is unique in that it's a casual quick-bite eatery with a quality on the level of the elite. I will return to E.P. for one thing: QUALITY. And for now, the $1.65 slice makes me feel like a thief. Hence, I give them the highest rating without hesitation. -A. . read more

My six hungry coworkers and I were exhausted and hungry. From Seattle. So we needed some good real pizza. Got the everything pizza,margherita, and pepperoni. DELICIOUS. The crust could have been a tad bit thinner. But otherwise YUM. read more

I havent ate here for a while i used to alot but just recently i orfered a Sicilian pizza and it was burened a little but good overall i would eat here again it wasnt bad just a little burned read more

Dope Buffalo chicken sandwich place is great to eat pizza is good as well I will be back for more

Solid Food everything you would expect in a local pizza joint in the northeast

I've tried every pizzeria in Elizabeth and hands down Elizabeth Pizzeria is THE best!!!

came late night but still remwmber like it was yesterday if in the area is a must to go to .

They got order wrong. Got all noodles no sauce barely existent. Salad was asked for meat lettuce and cheese and Caesar salad. It was loaded with everything and wrong lettuce. Wanted garlic knots received bread sticks dry, no butter. Recommended by Hampton. Don't order here! read more

Once you've had good pizza, you can never go back. All my life I have tried different pizzerias, but none has been worse than this one. Their pizza was absolute garbage, yet the have the nerve to say they have the best pizza in town. Walk a few blocks and you'll reach John's Caffe which is a thousand times better. You can't say you have the best pizza in town when Michelino's is a part of the same town. Honestly I recommend that people just keep walking and eat somewhere else as this place is horrible. read more

Ordered a pizza and breadsticks.. Said it would be delivered in 30-40 minutes. Had taken over 1.5 hours. Their reasoning was that "we're busy and only have one delivery guy". So mad. Upon receiving pizza, it was cold. Never again. read more

We were visiting town and found this restaurant on our GPS. The pizza was great. The large was really big, the crust and sauce and cheese were exactly like they should be on a good pizza. We would definitely recommend this place. read more