Just ok. They do have a good selection of ice cream and it tasted good. I felt $7.49 for a single scoop hot fudge sundae was a little much but maybe it's inline with other ice cream places. My daughter did not like the strawberry banana smoothie she ordered. The young lady who helped us was cordial but not particularly friendly. The other girl behind the counter spent almost the entire time we were there (we ate our ice cream at a table inside) chatting with a female customer who she obviously knew. I also accidentally tipped my cup over at the register and about half of my whipped cream fell out onto the counter. I told the young lady who served us what happened, apologized and tried to clean it up a bit with some napkins. She only mentioned she could clean it - in hindsight it would have been nice if she had offered to give me a bit more to replace what I lost but that never happened. When she was done charging us, she then came out from behind the counter and sat and chatted with another third young lady who was there (possibly another worker?). It just gave an unprofessional vibe and I do wish more adults in businesses would provide the young adults with some guidance and lessons in good customer service within the hospitality industry. read more

Good going Hinsdale! For years there was no ice cream shop downtown and after a lot of residents requests, Every Day's a Sundae opened here (last year I think?). And this shop is awesome!! They have a lot of flavors that can be eaten in cups, waffle/sugar/or plain cones, or in the form of shakes/malts. They also have banana splits, traditional sundaes, and floats/sodas. Plus other treats like gourmet popcorn and chocolate dipped bananas. The inside is decorated so cute! It's painted vintage lavender-pink and white. There are cute photos and a mural on the wall depicting the Sherman's ice cream they serve which provides a modernly executed old-fashioned charm. I liked the vintage ice cream wrapper puzzle framed on the wall (pictured.) We loved the ice cream. What they do right with their product is the wide selection of flavors. Lately Oberweiss has severely limited their selection (a lot of places have....category management was the necessity of the past decade). But it's ICE CREAM! When you go out, into downtown Hinsdale no less, you have come to expect greatness, gourmet, top-of-the-game kind of food situations. This assortment of flavors, cones, toppings, etc. brings that essence to the going out for ice cream experience but doesn't toss out the folksy soda-shop charm that goes so well with it (and doesn't make it feel forced, either.) This business so gets all of that. Nice job! read more

Parking on the street right out front. It's quite a large ice cream shop. There are seats right by the window and the place was clean. The staff were nice and did not rush us when we were deciding our ice cream orders. It was quite difficult to decide because we were not allowed to try the flavors ahead of time. They give big portions so it's good to share with someone if you don't usually finish your dessert. I would come back again if I do come back to this area. Not a lot of dessert places in this area. read more

Every Day's A Sundae - a bowl of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hinsdale, Illinois

See all

Cute little shop. There are lots of ice cream choices. Scoop sizes are huge! After eating dinner, their baby size was plenty for me. I had the key lime pie, and it was tasty. Staff were friendly. read more

Cute and clean ice cream shop with lots of flavor options. It was hard to pick one! I really enjoyed the amaretto cherry-flavored ice cream I selected read more

Very very clean on the inside, and the ice cream was amazing. Liam was all smiles, and the kindest employee I have ever met! Definitely the best ice cream in the area. read more

Great location, friendly staff, always staffed properly, BUT they really need to get new spoons. The spoons they have are not stiff enough and can barely get a decent scoop out without bending or breaking. Don't let the spoons ruin the overall ice cream experience! read more

Every Day's A Sundae - Spoon - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hinsdale, Illinois

Chocolate brownie is freezer burnt and the spoons are flimsy. Nothing worse than trying to eat ice cream with terrible utensils!

Specialty Sundae is pricy ($9.25) but huge ( 3 scoops ) and they did not skimp on the toppings. Staff was very nice read more

Every Day's A Sundae - Sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hinsdale, Illinois

Best ice cream and staff ever! Very clean and easy in and out. Try them out. My daughter loves their cotton candy ice cream

liam was very kind,helpful and friendly. he tried to make conversation and a great connection

Great ice cream flavors... the black cherry was delicious! Only thing is the ice cream is a little soft and was already dripping down the cone as the worker handed it to me right after scooping it. Maybe the freezer needs to be kept colder! read more

Straight ice cream is great. Great service and nice people working there too! Only critique is that they need to improve the milkshake game.... A bit too thin, ideally less liquid. Definitely check it out! read more

Loved the original shop in Downers Grove and this one is just as good. Thank you for bringing Sherman's ice cream to Hinsdale!

This place is fantastic! Excellent ice cream, wonderful service, beautiful building and a great location. Easily the best ice cream shop in Chicagoland (and we've been to many!) read more

We didn't expect to see a big place for just an ice cream shop.. ordered a chocomania & a moose tracks for the kids, and they really love it! Be back to try other flavors wherein they offer alot! read more

GREAT ice cream! moose tracks is da bomb, and service is amazing. the spoons kinda suck tho

this place is awesome, ever sense fuller house started using dips n dogs as storage i had been super sad and I never thought Hinsdale would get an ice cream shop again but guess what they did and it is amazing i recommend the New York cherry read more