I have used Fantasy Cupcake for many custom orders for events. Always easy to work with and friendly. Just place your orders far enough in advance. The lemon poppyseed cupcake is THE GOAT. They have lots of gluten free options and they are all wonderful. I am pretty sure I have tried every GF cupcake and coffee cake options they have. I do love the cinnamon coffee cake as well. Be prepared to pay top dollar for gluten free custom orders. It ain't cheap but it's worth the money. You get what you pay for. This is a great local establishment. read more

Fantasy Cupcake - Lemon Poppyseed and Wedding Cake Cupcakes - Desserts Near Me - Canal Winchester, Ohio

See all

My first review was closer to their initial opening, I can say with certain that they've developed into a great local sweets shop/catering business! Their name is out and about, especially around the Canal/Pickerington area. I've been to several events on the southeast side of Columbus that are sporting Fantasy's cupcakes. Yes, their cake batter is moist and flavorful. The icing used is made from scratch, light and they don't douse the cupcakes with icing - a personal pet peeve. A wonderful treat! Their new location, three doors down from their old, much-to-small, space is great: tall ceiling, white and brick walls, a nice serving counter that incorporates several display cases; several tables and chairs line the opposite wall. Their gluten free offerings are in a separate area, which keeps stuff apart so no cross-contamination. The only thing holding me back from giving 5 stars? Their cupcakes are small for the price. Yes, the icing is quality and tastes great, but the physical cake part does not justify over $3. read more

See all

Delicious cupcakes and fresh baked the same day! They also have a sitting area where you can enjoy your treat! Overall, great cupcakes and laid back atmosphere. read more

Every cupcake on the menu is delicious. When they come out with new flavors, I'm not scared I'm not going to like it-- the staff are friendly and it's a bright and welcoming atmosphere. read more

There's not much to say about Fantasy Cupcake other than - WOW! So so good. Their sugar cookie is the best I've ever had and their selection of cupcakes flavors has something for everyone! They even have treats for your fur babies! I have ran into the owner a couple times and she's super sweet and you can tell she loves what she does. I have yet to try any of the coffee selections yet but will be sure to the next time I'm in. Highly recommend! read more

This place is on the main historical strip and has easy parking. The coffee is really good, the cupcakes are tasty and the staff is friendly. I would recommend this place if you're looking for a local coffee spot. read more

Fantasy Cupcake - Storefront - Desserts Near Me - Canal Winchester, Ohio

See all

Cupcake were just alright. In my opinion overpriced. Nearly $4 for an "okay" cupcake is kinda nuts, but we had already promised our children cupcakes before seeing the prices. We got Wedding Cake, Salted Carmel, Chocolate Fantasy, Snickerdoodle, Buckeye, and Red Velvet. All the other snacks were expensive as well $1 for one Buckeye, nearly $3 for a cake pop. Mediocre at best. read more

Cute little bakery on the main street of a historic area. Great service and lots of flavor selections. I wouldn't say the cupcakes were my favorite I've ever had, but hit the spot for a sweet treat after dinner! We ordered a lemon poppy seed cake pop, salted Carmel cupcake, wedding cake cupcake, birthday cupcake, and chocolate fantasy cupcake. read more

Cute store, I was so happy to discover there is a cupcake place in Columbus I hadn't tried yet. Their hours are generous, until 8pm so perfect for and after work drive to Canal Winchester. I got there at about 5 pm and they still had all flavors left, about 10 in all plus 3 different kinds of cake pops. The cupcakes are $3 each and pretty big, the cake pops $1.50. They look beautiful and it was again a tough choice but I managed to cover all the bases with only getting half a dozen. The highlights were buckeye and blueberry lemon. Buckeye is always a winner in my book and had the best frosting out of all of them. Lemon Blueberry a yummy lemon candy on top and good blueberry filling. All of the cakes could have been more sweet, it tasted like they forgotthe sugar in the cake batter completly and put it in the frosting instead. Maybe if I wouldn't have treid the bottoms first and then had the tops with only half the cake it would have been better. The frosting was way too sweet ( thats saying alot since nothing is ususally too sweet for me), so sweet in fact it had crucnchy sugar cristals in it, not so good. I had banana split, salted caramel, birthday cake and snickerdoodle, all sound and looked fantastic, the only flavor I got though was the too much sugar and nothing much else. I hope they work on the cupcakes, because the looks and cute shop are they just the taste not on par with alot of other options In Columbus. read more

Fantasy Cupcake - Desserts Near Me - Canal Winchester, Ohio

My favorite cupcakes of all time. Fresh! Flavorful! Friendly! The cutest little shop with best cupcakes & cake pops around. Favorites: Cookie Monster, Buckeye, Salted Caramel 2 different seasonal flavors every month too. Worth the drive from Worthington every time! read more

Fantasy Cupcake - Cupcakes, cakepops, cookies! What more could a sweet tooth want! - Desserts Near Me - Canal Winchester, Ohio

This place was a find! I found the place because the people coming out with yummy liking cupcakes. So my husband and I decided to check the place. The cupcakes was delicious. The staff are quiet friendly. The place is clean. read more

Disclaimer: I went in about 20 minutes to closing. I bought 6 cupcakes which made them $2.75 each. Bought 6 different flavors. All were very good. Icing was great. The selection was a little less than normal (again close to closing time) and the cake was a tad dry. Not enough to keep me from going again when I have a sweets craving but to pay full price that close to closing will definitely make me go earlier in the day. I'm sure when fresher, they are amazing. read more

Fantasy Cupcake - Desserts Near Me - Canal Winchester, Ohio

This shop is absolutely adorable. I love the desserts, and the coffee is excellent. The staff is so friendly and helpful. The one thing I struggled with adapting to is their hours, but other than that consideration, excellent shop! read more

Cupcakes are good but super expensive. Spent way too much on two dozen cupcakes. If you're looking to splurge this may be the place for you

I discovered this place years ago and it's shameful I haven't wrote this review and stopped in for almost a year. Fantasy Cupcake is family owned bakery in the heart of Canal Winchester. Last time I stopped in they were a few doors up from their current location but obviously their reputation is growing and doing well and it doesn't surprise me at all. They now serve coffee and have other bakery goodies to choose from like brownies and cookies. But their cupcakes are where it's at!!!!!! Our favorites are cookie dough, birthday cake, and snicker doodle. If you are in the area or not I would stop in and try not to be too overwhelmed by the smells and beautiful goodies you can buy! read more

See all

Cupcake tastes like any grocery stores bakery cupcake or something you could make yourself. only thing you are paying for is they are decorated Nicely. not worth it. So I make the 30 minute drive to small cakes s in Gahanna. Now those are delicious and also are decorated nicely. read more

delicious and rich cupcakes made from scratch!! they also have yummy no bakes that i can never pass up. since they've opened the new location, they started serving coffee and it's soooo good. they serve Roosevelt Coffee and it's always yummy. support local! read more

Fantasy Cupcake - seating area - Desserts Near Me - Canal Winchester, Ohio

We went in to simply purchase 3 cup cakes after dinner at Barrel and Boar, and we ended up buying an entire case! There were so many flavor options and even flavors I normally don't prefer, I liked ! Definitely recommend ! read more

I thought on the outside the cupcakes were going to taste amazing. I got a half dozen of assorted flavors. They tasted more store bought. Quite disappointing. Maybe I caught them on a bad day. read more

Cute shop. Beautiful cupcakes. They smell wonderful. They taste fantastic. Dense moist cake, homemade frosting, one of the BEST cupcakes I've ever had. Thank you for getting back with me. You helped me give my husband a wonderful birthday. read more

Fantasy Cupcake - Lemon Poppyseed and Buckeye - Desserts Near Me - Canal Winchester, Ohio

See all

Fantasy Cupcake has amazing cupcakes! I get excited every time I know we are getting cupcakes from here! Leah is absolutely awesome, and her cupcakes are not only delicious, but also very creative! The last cupcake I had from here was called a "Buckeye." This soft chocolate cupcake was topped with a mountain of icing made from real chocolate buckeyes and covered in sprinkles. YUM! There are quite a few different types of cupcakes here too. I'd definitely check this place out if you haven't already been here! As an added bonus, she offers samples!!!! read more

Fantasy Cupcake - Desserts Near Me - Canal Winchester, Ohio

See all

I'm a cupcake snob. Why? Because they're cupcakes. In order for a $3 cupcake to be out of this world it's really gotta be something special. Got a pack of 6. The best of the bunch was the Raspberry White Chocolate-very nice flavor. The least fave was Banana Foster, I think it was called-tasted fake. I was expecting it to be more like a banana muffin. I'm guessing the flavor came from extract, maybe? Tried a bite of my friend's Cotton Candy cake pop. I literally spit it out into Buckeye Lake. I wasn't expecting the artificial taste of it. Not sure what I was expecting really. It's called Cotton Candy, after all.... However, I think you should try them out. Many flavors and a constant replenishment during the day makes it a safe bet you'll find one you love. For me, not yet.... read more

See all

Hours are ridiculous. Overpriced. I don't mind supporting small businesses, but I can find another small business bakery that isn't this outrageous for cupcakes. read more

Stopped in here spur of the moment. My daughter got a yummy and fun looking cake-pop. I got a s'mores cupcake. It was AH-MAZING! Adorable shop with a large selection. Wish I would've gotten more flavors to try! read more

So many great flavors and they are so cute. Cookie dough is my favorite. I had a custom order done too with a galaxy theme and they were so adorable and delicious! read more

The neighborhoods great, I always pick up a box of these cupcakes for special occasions such as for my mothers birthday etc. good location very nice neighborhood fantastic cupcakes you get what you pay for, very good company read more

My daughter and i have been looking for gluten free treats in the area. This place has that and much more!! I luv the mini cupcakes, they are the perfect size for anyone dieting. My daughter has to shop on the gluten free side. She is never short of options. If in town, this little dessert shop is a Must!! read more

Delicious cupcakes, great coffee, and friendly employees! Can't ask for a whole lot more.

With America experiencing a surge of little cupcake shops popping up all over the place like Georgetown Cupcake that has their own reality series on TLC, and the replacement of traditional cakes with cupcakes at parties, weddings, and other events, Fantasy Cupcake is most certainly a welcome addition to this niche industry. The cupcakes are large and come in a variety of flavors. The go further by changing up their flavors seasonally and for special events and holidays. Ordering large amounts for parties is painless and fun. As a resident of Canal Winchester, I stop in perhaps more frequently than those that live outside the village, but it's DEFINITELY worth the short 15 minute drive from downtown Columbus to experience what I believe are truly the BEST cupcakes in Central Ohio.... Maybe America. If you think $3 is too much to pay for a cupcake, then you haven't tried them. Try to keep in mind that these are not your average Wal-Mart or grocery store cupcakes. These are gourmet cupcakes designed to please the senses and create a moment of shear satisfaction and enjoyment. Stop in and try them..... I promise you'll be back. read more

This place is AMAZING. I would go to hell and back for these cupcakes. The Cookie Monster milkshake is Gods Work. It's flavor transcends normative milkshake structure and reaches incredible new heights of flavor. read more

Great cupcake flavors and consistently fresh and tasty. This is one of my favorite places for a wonderful treat or to take to a party.

I think I transform into a unicorn when I step into this shop. It is like the cutest ever, in the cutest town. And did I mention the cupcakes are also very cute, and very delicious? My favorite part is the fact that the icing is literally as tall as the cupcake itself, but I guess take that as a warning if you are not a fan of icing. But really, you probably will become one if you try these cupcakes. The owner is very friendly as well. Nice place. read more

Cute little shop with great Cupcakes, Ice Cream and Coffee. They feature different flavors each month so the selection seems to get better and better. Leah the owner is one of the nicest people you'll ever meet. Definitely a must visit if you're in the area. read more