Great tasting, fresh ingredients, hand crafted - love it. Salads are great too. Eating in is ok- small, crowded interior. Cash only! Worth it! read more

Awesome pizza. Lots o' cheese. Also ordered a salad with cheese ...again, awesome. Lots of cheese and the red wine vinagrette-style house dressing was really good. They do have a dining room, which certainly could use updating, but it is very clean. The pizzeria is located in a small strip, and as others have said, parking can be hard to come by. And if you DO find a spot, well, be uber careful backing out, because you will be backing onto a 4 lane road complete with turning lane in the middle. (guess that makes it 5 lanes, huh?) But, overall, worth the hassle. It's certainly not the cheapest pizza, but it IS one of the best I have had in a loooooooong time. read more

What can I say but this place reminds me of the type and style of homemade pizza I used to have as a kid. Very tasty with great sauce and real topping not mass produced tasting. Decor was very 70's with a very jut box and old beer lamps and signs a long with menu board that have to peg the letters and numbers in. read more

This is the best Ma & Pa place around! I love how the deccore has not changed since the day it opened - if people complain about that LAME - but anyways..... I moved out of Macedonia - neighbor town to Northfield - about eight months ago to DC and I can not wait to go home to get a slice or I should say square of this place. It has just the right amount of cheese, pepperoni and grease. Of course beer too! Staff is nice but I really don't care if they were good or bad just don't change a thing about the decore or the PIZZA! :) read more

Definitely of the best in Northeast Ohio! Every time I order from here is just s good as the last! worth the trip if you love good pizza!

I was eagerly looking forward to Farinacci Pizza opening in Brecksville. As soon as I heard it was open, I ordered a large (which is really a medium as it is only 12 inches) and a salad. The pizza was average, but the salad was a joke. It came in a plastic container similar to the size of cole slaw in a deli. There was 1/2 slice of a tomato, 1 cucumber slice and 2 black olives. The rest was lettuce. I had to add to it when I got home to make a Real salad. The large/medium pizza was $12.80 for a 1 item pizza. Guess I will stick with Romeo's and East of Chicago. So disappointed. read more

This is the pizza of the Gods. I have grown up eating Farinacci's, and can't find a pizza that compares. By far my favorite crust, I don't know how they do it. You can't go wrong with a half sausage, half pepperoni pizza. But don't forget a fiesta salad, just make sure you're a cheese lover as it's topped with a cheese mountain. The only thing I would change is to take off the cold-cut ham. Not my favorite. Only downside is they don't accept cards. Additionally, the decor could use an update (it could have stood an update in the 90's!). But that really adds to the charm I guess, don't let it scare you off. Top notch! read more

Local mom & pop pizza spot that has been here forever! My mom said she would come here all the time for pizza as a kid. I really liked the pizza here and the staff is really friendly! I will say the portions were smaller than what I had imagined. A family size felt like more of a true large and a large was more of a medium. I personally like the saltiness of the pizza, but someone with a less tolerant salt palette may feel otherwise. All in all I'll definitely be back and would recommend this pizza place! read more

Pizza was very good. My wife and I enjoyed it. If you like sausage pizza they have a recipe that's apparently from the 70's. (Good stuff) Seems like a good group of people working in there. Very friendly atmosphere. I will definitely be going back in the future. read more

Best pizza in Northeast Ohio! Been going here for 20 years. There are also locations in Cuyahoga Falls and Hudson. The Falls location is good and tases the same to me but have never been to Hudson. Great old school pizza joint, cash only. Get the sausage as a topping- the deluxe pizza is my favorite. Fantastic homemade salad dressing as well. Easy pick up option too- call ahead 30 min. Usually. read more

Ate here while visiting Cleveland. A friend who grew up in Ohio recommend it and said it was his favorite pizza. It's also a local favorite. It's an old school pizza place but the Pizza is good but different then the pizza we are use to in the NJ/NY area. I recommend giving it a try though. read more

I'm sorry but this is the worst pizza I've ever had in my life. We were told by a friend that this place had the best pizza, only reason we didn't try it before now is because they don't deliver and only accept cash. We were so excited to try this little mom and pop pizza but it was such a let down. Awful cheap toppings. Trust me when I say a frozen pizza is better than what they are serving. read more

Another place that fails to live up to its hype........ Maybe a trip in the WayBack Machine would help one understand all the hub-bub about this "local legend". I was left wondering if they bought their pizzas at Giant Eagle in the frozen section. read more

We have been coming here for 20 years. This evening we have never felt more insulted. I called to order two pizzas and a salad. I verified with the high school student who was speaking on the phone whether or not I was calling the location on Old Route Eight. Three individuals heard me ask that and get the answer of yes. When we got there, the pizzas were not there but at the Hudson store. The manager was beyond rude: whether or not you or we made the mistake, that was no way to treat loyal customers. Attempting to embarrass us in front of an entire restaurant rather than attempting to find a solution is just poor business practice. While our order was eventually provided and delicious, we question we will go back. Everyone is entitled to a bad day or even a rough evening: no one however should be belittled or treated as we were. read more

Found this on my Yelp app because we wanted a pre-movie meal and boy it was GOOD. The place was small and only takes cash or check, but for the price you can't get better pizza. Two of us were stuffed with pizza and salad for under $20. The wait staff were very friendly. Will definitely go back. Thanks Yelp! read more

This little place is great. Our waitress was amazing. Cant wait to go back and get some more pizza!

Our neighbor highly recommended this pizza joint for dinner after the Browns game. So we ordered take out as they don't deliver. Grabbed cash from the arm since they don't use credit cards. Pizza place is small not much parking and not much seating but the employees were very friendly. Not a long wait for the pizza and when we got back home we ate. It was delicious. Even the kids enjoyed. Outer crust was thick inner crust thin and moist. Cheese on the perfect side. Sauce perhaps sweet? Not sure but it was delicious! We will order again. read more

1brought my sibling here for her birthday and it turned into the gathering from hell. The food took way to long to cook. We waited over 40 minutes, other tables who came in after we did received their food within a few minuted after we received ours. 30 minutes in, we told the waitress we were ready to go because: (1) she didn't check on us or give us an update on our food (2) we had no food (3) she took my sister's drink away because something was in it but completely forgot to bring her another one for roughly 15 min (by this time I waved her down). Now I understand when a place is busy, things may take longer, but there was only 4 tables (including ours) that was taken up. After the manager convinced us to stay, the waitress then decided to check on us more consistently. I went to pay and here's the best part NO CREDIT CARDS ACCEPTED, CASH/CHECK ONLY!!! There was no signs outside or within the establishment so how are first time customers supposed to know. I give 2 stars because the pizza was fair. I've already had people ask me the name of this place, so they would never go there. Fyi, the waitress offered us a lollipop at the very end of the fiasco. I think she knew she messed up. The mgr was good and meant well, the waitress seemed very distant from us (really didn't help since we were the only black folks there) until I threatened to walk out. Both my sister and I noticed how she wasn't paying us much mind our first 30-35 minutes in. Will not be going back. UPDATE: 9/11/2015. Spoke with the mgr about our experience and his response was "It is what it is" read more

We always come here when we are in town visiting family. The definition of a whole in the wall joint. The pizza is great and so are their salads. The service is friendly and quick! Cash only so come prepared and ready to eat! read more

I was really rooting for this place because it's got a lot of local history in Northfield. But to be honest the service was a little rude and the pizza was okay. A solid three star but didn't knock my socks off. read more

Love the pizza, especially the family size, but lately hate the wait. I call up, order the Za, they tell me 30--40 mins or whatever. So I get in my car and drive up at 40 mins. (cause they don't deliver) and there's still no pizza! And they're like, "oh, sorry - we are swamped - another 25" or 15, blah blah. Seriously, the first time I was like, "oh, well, it happens," but after the fourth or fifth time, I think it's time to move on. Which is sad - it is my favorite pizza in the area, but I really can't deal with the crazy waits. read more

Really good old fashioned pizza. Cash only. Reminds me of how pizza was back in the day.

Guess gotta try fish. Pizza soggy, sausage awesome. Wish could buy seperately! Hand made, but pizza just soggy! Would've given 1* for pizza, but not tried fish, so... read more

Pretty good pizza in my opinion. It's a cash-only joint and dimly lit. Could very well be my new go-to pizza place. The large pizza was on the smaller side, so plan accordingly! read more

The salads were wonderful we especially like the shaved mozzarella. The pizza was good. The customer service was fantastic! We felt like each staff member was genuinely trying to make our experience positive! That was really refreshing in today's industry. read more

Hands down still the best pizza around. I've been going there since 1978 and I have raised my son on it. He prefers them to any other place. read more

Great old school pizzeria atmosphere and super inexpensive. Get the salad too, you won't be disappointed.

If I could give this place zero stars I would. The pizza was bland. The crust was too doughy. And the orange greasy layer that I had to remove was disgusting. The garlic bread was cheap tasting and flavorless. And the salad was a basic side salad. read more

Typical NE Ohio local pizza. Nothing stands out as being better or worse than anything else in the area.

Best pizza in the area. We usually order to go, but they have a small dining area. I do not know of a better pizza north of Akron. My family loves this and we visit often. The menu's limited to pizza and salad. The only place better is Luigi's in Akron. read more

Love the food. The pizza with fried peppers and mushrooms the best. Gotta love a family owned restaurant. Used to NY style pizza, this is nothing close but great for Cleveland standards! read more

The old school ambiance is what keeps our family coming back. Small, dark pizza parlor mirrors what Farinacci is: a family-owned restaurant since the 1970s. Pizza is really good, as are salads and garlic bread. Service is slow; usually one waitress working. Lollipops brought by at the end is the perfect capstone to the family restaurant experience! read more

It's a hole-ine-the-wall pizza place that doesn't deliver, has hit or miss parking, shuts down for a month at a time in the winter for vacation, and doesn't even take credit cards, but this pizza is amazing. The place is usually packed on the weekends. It's the best pizza you can get anywhere around here. It's worth the trip for sure! The sausage is home made and to die for. Get a few family sizes to go, it's great reheated if there's any left! read more

Always great food. Great atmosphere. Great staff. I will always get pizza here! It is evenly priced and the owner cares about his business. Joe if you are reading this never change what you do. Keep everything the same cause that is one reason I love coming here! read more

Delicious!! the only bad thing is that the week we usually decide to have a "Farinacci's Pizza night", the "family" is on vacation somewhere great!!! read more

I'm a huge fan and dine in once a week. The pizza is great and the service is awesome. I love mom and pop restaurants and the wonderful family feel. read more

Best pizza!!!!! I've been coming here for years and I can't get enough. I love their salad dressing and fresh mozzarella. Stop by and pick up a pizza and you'll see why I'm a lifelong patron. read more

Truly the best. They don't cut corners and will serve you the most delicious pizza ever. Good old fashioned pizzeria pizza. Crust is not too thick and not too thin. Go there. You will not regret it. Oh, did I mentioned the owners and staff are pretty amazing too? read more

I have been a big fan of Farinacci Pizza for years. Never been disappointed. I would say the only thing that lacks appeal is how small the location is. Dont try to go in there on a busy eveing around dinner time, you may be waiting, and there really is no good place to wait. Other then the size of the place and the old school decor, the pizza and hospitality is great! Never had a bad experience with service. read more

Best pizza around the south side.....a throw back to the way pizza parlors used to be in the good ole days. If you don't like that, get it to go! read more