Warning to fellow consignors:…read more I am incredibly disappointed with my experience at this shop. If you are looking for a place to consign your clothes, look elsewhere--unless you enjoy risking your items going missing without a trace or spending hours looking for your items. The owner herself didn't explain the process upfront which would give anyone pause from leaving their stuff here. Rather was rude when I said she didn't explain it upfront. There was zero accountability for lost or stolen items. When you hand your clothes over to a consignment shop, there is an expectation of basic care and security. Sadly, that is completely absent here. They have a policy that basically shrugs off theft or loss. They simply do not care about protecting your inventory. I had a few items that I never was able to find and the owner was no help. I was given attitude for any question I had. Spent hours looking for my items. Originally when I asked the owner how it worked, she failed to mention that I would have to look for everything myself at pickup. When my consignment period was up, I had to go through the crowded racks and hunt down every item myself. I spent so much time digging through racks just to recover some of my belongings. As a customer, a consignment shop should provide a level of partnership and trust. This place takes your items, cuts you out of the loop if they get stolen, and forces you to do the heavy lifting when you want them back. Save your time, your energy, and your items--consign somewhere that actually values its clients or better yet donate them to someone who really needs them.

The VERY BEST quality designer clothes, shoes and purses in the area !!! ; } I have been coming…read morehere for years ... even to the previous owner and the new one is even better !!

Was there the other day. Prices were awful!! They need much better help!! Girls didn't know…read moreanything!!Or even offer to help me! Fort Myers location!!!!

I have visited on at least 3 occasions and every time they indicate specific requests and never…read moretake the items they are asking about consigning. I have multiple items with tags from lululemon, athletca, loft, anthropology and they do not take those items. The store mostly has name brands from old navy, kohls and Walmart that are NOT current from this year - maybe 5-10 years ago. I would not recommend consigning or shopping there if you are interested in current name brands .

A nice unassuming shop. Lots of decorative items. Staff is very helpful. When I couldn't find…read moreprices they found them for me. I found a booth that had lots of albums at a reasonable price. Some great deals too.

Called to ask a question and they treated me like I was stupid.... Rude customer serviceread more

Love this store!! So…read moreI am constantly in here buying everything from jeans to jewelry, and these ladies are super helpful, polite, and knowledgeable!! If you go in here, ask for 'Chandler', or 'Arielle'. These girls are like personal shoppers!! No pressure sales, but will help you make an outfit!! I can't say enough good thing about this location, or the awesome quality of the items sold here!! You have to just go in and check it out for yourself!!

I'm a longtime clothes thrifter and have visited this store MANY times since I moved to the area 10…read moreyears ago. Early on, I wasn't super impressed, but then things changed for the better around 2020 and it was reliably good for years. I always appreciated how well-curated the front section was, since I could feel confident that most of the really desirable items were there. If I didn't have a lot of time, I'd just peruse that area. But it was also worth exploring the whole store when I had the opportunity. I almost always left with something good. This Spring (2026) the place took a turn for the worse. I thought at first it was temporary, due to some remodeling that was taking place. Unfortunately, I don't think that's true. The remodeling seems to be done but the store is worse rather than better. With the exception of shoes, the front area is smaller and not well-organized or well-curated. In general, there seems to be a much worse selection, and the store feels cheap and a bit seedy to me. I'm not sure what happened! New manager? I hope they get this figured out or I will soon be taking this store out of my regular rotation.

Visited this store on Friday 5-8-2026. What has happened? A store that was always well organized…read moreand fun to shop has become a disaster!! The racks have been changed around, the merchandise is all over the place in complete disarray, the line up was to the back of the store, items are lacking pricing, the plus size racks are so cramped you cannot shove the hangers over to look at anything. What used to be the best store of all is now the worst. Won't go back for a while. Someone needs to get it together. Perhaps a new manager?????????

What was supposed to be a quick stop for my daughter turned into an unexpected family shopping…read moreadventure. My daughter wanted to browse for something cute for herself, so we stopped into Plato's Closet about 30 minutes before closing. I was a little worried we'd be rushing, but the atmosphere was still fun and relaxed despite shoppers trying to squeeze in a few last-minute treasures before the store closed. The best part was watching the shopping bug spread through the family. My daughter started browsing, then the other kids decided they wanted something too. Suddenly everyone was searching racks, comparing deals, and showing each other what they found. Lol. I wasn't even planning to shop, but I ended up finding a pair of Calvin Klein work slacks for The Mr. for $18; I couldn't pass on a deal like that. That's one of the things I love about stores like Plato's Closet--you never know what you're going to find, and sometimes the best deal is the one you weren't looking for. Years ago, when my oldest son was a baby, he grew so quickly that I regularly sold his outgrown clothes to Plato's Closet. Walking through the store now and watching that same child use his own money to buy clothes for himself was really special. The staff deserve a shoutout as well. Even though it was close to closing time and they were clearly working on end-of-night tasks, everyone we spoke with was friendly, patient, and welcoming. The cashier was especially kind while helping the kids check out their purchases, which I appreciated. We came in looking for one item and left with several happy shoppers. That's usually a sign of a successful trip. We'll definitely be back for another treasure hunt soon.

10/10 service they're so friendly! They have great prices! Also they have a huge selection! Looking…read moreforward to coming back!

We had visited Max and Ollie's on a guided tour some months ago while they were recovering from a…read moremajor water line failure, but this time they were actually open for business and we had to stop in. Very glad we did! They're decorated for the holidays and had a large amount of holiday-themed housewares and all manner of fun kitsch, and we found a wreath (with mini-lights and music) that we had to have. Highly recommended if you're into retro goods and vintage clothing, even just to browse through (but I bet you find something to take home with you!).

Owner is amazingly sweet as can be! Very fin, unique store. Love it! Deb Richmond. Oh and there is…read moresomething unique for everyone on your list! It would not let me scroll up but I would give it a 5 star rating!

What's not to like about this amazing thrift store? I've been helping a couple of friends make…read moredonations and when I showed up with a car load of items, three helpful humans had the whole vehicle unpacked in two minutes or less. Dorian greeted me immediately. He is very friendly, polite, and welcoming. The store is clean, well organized, and has a great selection. I've enjoyed shopping and donating at this location. Of course I'll be back to support their cause.

Large thrift store. Prices seemed high on some clothing. Yellow label was 25% which helped. I…read morefound a few great things. Very friendly staff. Store was also clean. Would recommend.

Tons of great finds, lots of furniture, doors, hardware, frames, etc. You may get lucky and find…read moreexactly what you need at a fraction of the price. Take your time and look around; staff is friendly and helpful (some are volunteers so be patient).

Best priced items in the area! Super nice staff. Clean. Great selection! They roll out the red…read morecarpet for everyone!

This used to be the store I would go to for alot of my clothes and sometimes shoes or other things…read moreI needed. I went in there today for some Nike clothes and was very disappointed. Very crappy selection and they used to have alot of cute Nike clothes. Then I gave up on that and went to look for some jeans or maybe some other clothes. It basically all sucks now in there. Very little selection and what there is, is just crap. There is a better selection at Meijer, which is where I ended up. I wondered why the parking lot was so empty at 4pm and now I know. My family ussd to be obsessed with Kohls and after talking to them when I left, they said they haven't been there in years because it's just crap in there and they don't have anything anymore. They may as well close. Sad to see that today but I doubt I'll be back.

Very rude customers service. Do not want to help. Refused to look up a recently purchased item from…read moremy Kohls charge until I showed her the return policy on the website. Then she was "magically" able to do it with no problem. Manager was also no help and rude.