My first review was less than stellar, maybe it's having the DoughBoys collaboration, maybe it's…read moremore options than being heavy on the IPAs. We went to a smoke/BBQ beer pairing which was delicious.

A few of us met up at Sager Brewery, and I'm glad we did. I honestly didn't know much about the…read moreplace it's tucked down the street from Living Roots, and since I'm not much of a beer drinker, so..., From the looks of the outdoor setup, I'm guessing there's seating available when the weather's nice. Inside, it's a big space, and it got busy fast even when we arrived around 5 p.m. on a Thursday. Turns out it was Trivia Night, which we hadn't planned on, but a nice surprise. If you've got friends who don't drink beer, there are other options. Just don't expect much from the margarita it tasted like it was from a can and was a pretty small pour. I tried a strawberry sour beer (can't remember the exact name), and it was excellent. One friend had the kombucha, and another went for the margarita. We also ordered wings and two pizzas to share. A heads-up on the wings: they're not pre-sauced--they come with sauce on the side. I'd recommend asking for extra, along with a side of what I think was house-made blue cheese. We tried the Cajun Hot Honey and DoughBoys sauces--the latter had a kind of honey mustard vibe. I believe they brine the wings, smoke them, and coat them in rice flour. They came out hot, super crispy. Be aware before you chomp down. We shared two pizzas: the Spicy Sausage and the Truff Daddy, which had cheese, truffle oil, mushrooms, and more. Both were solid picks, and between the three of us, we only had two slices left by the end. Ordering is easy--you can scan a QR code or just walk up to the counter. The staff was lovely and super helpful. Trivia Night was a blast. We only stayed for two rounds and even managed to win a couple of free beer tokens. That was cool! You can make reservations online, but we just walked in and found a table with no issue. Parking is available on the street or in a lot behind the buildings. All in all, I'll definitely be back.

Really enjoyed the half plate. Sauce is slightly non-traditional, reminding me of The Commons old…read moresauce. Paired really well with Just A Beer.

Joined co-workers for a beer and was not disappointed…read more Easy parking in back Friendly staff Lots of seating and good beer and food selection Their hazy IPA was good- not quite as hoppy as Other Half but tasty on an afternoon after work!

Just what we needed for some girlfriend time after going to the coffee shop needed a cocktail and…read moresome good lunch. Thank you Michelle. I don't know how you do it. It was a room full of people and you handled us all.

Friday was our first time there. We were seated right away for some drinks and a late lunch…read more Service was outstanding and I enjoyed was the atmosphere at the bar. Many seemed to know one another and it reminded me of a modern Cheers type feel. We ordered the turkey wrap with waffle fries and the Korean Good For Your Soeul Burger and tater tots. Everything was absolutely delicious and enough for two meals. I would highly recommend the Old Stone Tavern. That extra crisp on my tater tots and melt in your mouth flavor on the burger was on point!

Great for lagers and pilsners I didn't get food but the bar…read moreservice was great and beer was exceptional Plenty of seating Lots of beer options

Met up here on a Monday evening and was excited to try it since I had never been. I got the fries…read morewith preserved lemon aioli - these magical bites somehow stayed hot and crispy through the whole meal. I tried (& loved) their Belgian triple since it had just won a silver medal at the NYS Craft Brewers awards. It was well-deserving of the honor it received! Staff was friendly and attentive, and it was easy enough to get a bartender's attention for a refill. Seating area was bright and spacious with great atmosphere. Parking situation is kinda hairy - extra tight spaces in a small lot, but it was manageable for a Monday, and there's street parking if you don't happen to get a space in the lot. Cheers!

I've been wanting to check this place out for a while, so a dear friend and I finally came by for a…read morevisit. This spot is old-school in the very best way. The staff is fun and helpful, the menu is solid, and the burgers are stellar. If you're sharing, they'll even offer to cut the burger for you which is such a thoughtful touch, because doing it yourself can quickly turn into a big ole mess! They have a great selection of beers on tap and bottled, plus cocktails and other drinks. The customers are characters in the best way, which just adds to the charm. It's also a little bigger inside than I thought. I'll definitely be back. Street parking is available.

Super friendly staff, our bartender, Jenna, was really nice, attentive. It's a good old pub, but…read moreupdated nicely- clean, fresh paint, tin ceiling. The food was excellent. Get the French onion soup. They make it with a grilled goat cheese sandwich instead of the standard croutons. And the cheese is super thick and rich and the broth was delicious. Will 100% get this again. The haddock fish fry was good, crispy but thinner parts of the fish were a little dry. The beef on weck was awesome. Very tender sliced beef, soft roll with lots of salt and caraway. Horseradish sauce was creamy and just hot enough to add some kick. Au Jus on the side so the roll didn't sog out. VERY good.

The drink was amazing. I got a flight of the hazy ipa, NE triple IPA, the cherry sour and the amber…read moreale. The bartender was very nice and personable. And the ambiance was very chill! Def a spot I would like to return to and some point!

We loved this place. Great feel and wonderful beer. The porch / patio look great and we cannot wait…read moreto come back with our pup. Bar keep was very friendly and a great time. Come get some great brew.

I'd actually give 4 1/2 stars if I could because there was only one thing that could have been…read morebetter. The food was excellent; I had the Friday fish fry and it was delicious! I got a nice sized piece of fish that was beer battered and cooked beautifully, and the fries were very tasty. I ordered extra slaw because places never seem to give you much, and that was good too. They also gave me plenty of lemon, which is another thing that some places are skimpy with. Overall, I really enjoy my meal! The only negative is that the food was a little cold so I had to re-warm it first. It came in a pizza box, which I thought was strange, and that might have had something to do with it. But I'll definitely order the fish fry again, and I'll probably try something else as well!

A solid spot that my partner and i wanted to get ton on park Ave. interesting place with solid wait…read morestaff. Very friendly and interested in making us happy. Food was ok. Chicken special could have kept more sauce. Just missing something more. Curious if this opinion changes in the future Nice feel. Lots is younger folks. But that's ok. We look forward to coming back.

It was mad busy and we had no reservation! We were still able to be seated. Had a great fish fry…read moredinner and beer! Food & service were great great!

The Sheffield is a great spot for a dependable plate of food…read more Well cooked, simple solid menu, great beer selections Their fries are tasty! Service is friendly and professional, and happy hour specials! A perfect neighborhood place