Food was nothing special. Service was slow, but our waitress was very friendly. They weren't very knowledgeable about food allergies. I'm convinced the rice was Ben's ready rice. I found it weird that they gave us rice and beans "for the table" and the portion size of the rice and beans was for half a person. The pollo loco was hidden under a mount of guacamole. I don't think I'd come back here. read more

Fiesta Mexican Grill & Cantina - Enchilada Sampler - Mexican Near Me - Oneonta, New York

See all

Egads! We'll start with the good. Our waitress was new and a little meek but lovely and visited us just at the right time. My husband and I both had a house margarita. You could taste the tequila which I find "house" marg's tend to be weak at other spots so that was nice. We were seated right away and the decor and music was festive and bright. So the food: not a hit for us. My husband thought the tamales tasted like they had been frozen and then heated up when he ordered. The salsa and red sauce on our meals tasted like canned tomato sauce in my opinion. And not even like store bought salsa but straight up a can of tomato sauce. I was just visiting Oneonta but if I were to ever return to the area, I would choose another restaurant. read more

Fiesta Mexican Grill & Cantina - Tamales - Mexican Near Me - Oneonta, New York

See all

Visited for a weekend and asked the clerk at a nearby game store for local recommendations. His top 3 included fiesta, which is a bonus vouch included in my review. Service was immediately available, we were seated in under a minute and had our drinks in 3. Our waitress was friendly, and was flexible as we had trouble deciding. We had the chimichangas, Chili Relleno, the goat cheese chorizo appetizer and Fajitas. My companions spoke well of their chimichangas, all of us agreed that the bread, cheese, and sausage in the appetizer were unexpectedly good. Perfect amount of heat in the sausage, a nice hard chorizo sliced on the margin, and the bread was freshly baked and had a beautifully crisp crust. My chili relleno was well seasoned, the meat was tender enough to cut with the side of my spoon, and the pepper was cooked perfectly. Perfectly well done, not so far that it became soggy like some places do by mistake. All in all, a very nice surprise. read more

This place we stumbled upon by accident. It sucked. Bottom line. When you sit down the tables are on a slant so your drinks could spill. We asked for queso and all they could supply us was melted mozzarella fondu queso. It was gross. Our food had hair in it (curly) and the beans were straight from a pedigree dog food can (moosh). I don't understand why the staff was unhappy with us when we asked to have the food removed from our bill. If you can choose- go to local wal mart and get some taco items. read more

Vegetarian burrito was fine, but seemed to have frozen vegetable medley in it (not fresh peppers, onions, etc.). The margaritas were absurdly too sweet. My friend and I got different margaritas and both had to send them back. Mine had an odd shade of green, yet the waitress claimed it was just triple sec, tequila, and (she claimed) fresh lime juice. I learned today that friends got a margarita pitcher here last year, and they also couldn't finish it because it was too sweet. read more

I don't understand the negative comments. I noticed most were from last year. we had six in our party. we all ordered different entrees and we were all satisfied. strong Margarita!!!, I had to walk for awhile. try the specials! Steve CA read more

Ordered out.everything was delicious. Burritos were prepared with just the right ingredients

Mediocre food. If you want some chips and salsa, and margs randomly this will hit the spot. Food is your typical Americanized Mexican grill. Had a lot of problems at our table when we went, in regards to allergies. Emphasized an allergy and they brought out a product with everything still in it. When we brought it up you could tell they just opened it up and tried to remove the allergy. Then they tried to make us pay for another replacement, when we sent that one back as well. Will curb a random craving, but beware if you have special dietary needs or allergies. read more

I don't know why the ratings are so low on this restaurant. We don't go out that much in Oneonta but Fiesta is one of our top choices. Not everything on the menu is hot-spicy, which is great. It's authentic Mexican, not Tex-Mex. I just get a flavored margarita here. The standard marguerita is just average, but we love the food. Happy Hour is a good deal. Half price appetizers. Margarita Monday is $4 rocks. The photo here is chicken taquitos for $4. $8 and I'm full with a marguerita under my belt. If you're hungry for more than appetizers, try an ultimate burrito!!! read more

Fiesta Mexican Grill & Cantina - Chicken taquitos and pomegranate margarita - Mexican Near Me - Oneonta, New York

We almost didn't go here because of the bad reviews but the girls at our hotel said they loved it and so we decided to try it. The restaurant itself doesn't look like much from the outside but once inside you'll find it's decorated really nice. The waitress was very friendly and efficient and the food was very good. We had a taco salad in a burrito bowl. it's not real spicy which we liked and it was very filling. The margaritas are also very good. Judy read more

This is NOT a good place for Celiacs. They have a GF menu, but the fryer is shared and I was violently ill 20 minutes after eating there. I had a steak and corn quesadillas. I even asked if they put soy sauce in their salsa. Not safe if you are celiac. My husband's meal was dry and not good either. read more

We were given a salad that didn't even come close to what the menu said it would contain. Upon mentioning it to the waitress she said the menus had changed and offered us a desert or 10% discount. Make sure your order is correct. We won't be back. read more

Great place...our waitress was really good and amicable, personable and as much of a jester as me! Good atmosphere ..good food and fun and professional staff. I am only sorry I don't know her name to mention her here read more

Inedible. The cheese enchiladas had "slabs" of a white cheese. There was a minimal amount of cheddar on top of the enchiladas. I couldn't cut the enchiladas, I had to pick up and eat like a hamburger. Three bites in and I couldn't continue. There was no flavor and the texture was awful.... Thick and hard. I have no idea what kind of cheese it was. My husband's beef enchiladas were almost as inedible. It wasn't shredded beef. It was regular hamburger. The sauce was bland. The black beans and rice were okay. So disappointing. This cost us over $30. read more

Had dinner with the kids and grand kids today. My wife and I both had veggie buritos and they were quite tasty. I had the Poblano which was filled with rice, black beans, and crispy veggies. Drinks were nice and strong. We all enjoyed and will be back! read more

Good food, moderate prices. Service was great. Comfortable setting. Easy walking distance from Main st. Convenient parking.

The restaurant gets hyped up a lot but food is bland and almost no flavor. Got a Cali burrito filled with only rice and 2 tiny slivers of chicken. Nothing else in it. Nachos appetizer had almost no cheese. Food did not have any seasonings. read more

Being a transplanted native of South Texas to oneonta (don't wonder why) I seriously miss a good meal out that didnt consist of pizza, bagels, or fried rice. I desperately hoped that Fiesta would at least be a couple of steps above TacoBell. Honestly the place is nicely decorate. Chips are good, salsa ---not really. Food is nothing to write home about other than to say "yes I'm in New York", so what should I expect? unfortunately it didn't even meet the rating of "decent". So my family and i have resigned ourselves to the fact--there is no good Mexican food to be found in Oneonta. Well I shouldn't say no place, i cook some really good rockin Tex-Mex, with a knockout pico de gallo salsa --yum fyi no the brisket in oneonta aint all that either. So don't say go to that other place. read more

Great pit stop on our way home to Saratoga. Best Chimichangas & Enchiladas! Great chips & salsa. Always a favorite!

This place is under-rated on Yelp. Give it a chance! We are in Oneonta while our son plays baseball at All Star Village. Stopped in for dinner. What we liked: - solid margaritas. They accommodated our specific recipe requests. - warm and attentive service - above average chips and salsa - Monterrey tacos were slay! - this place has a salsa night first Sat of the month 9pm! What we didn't like: - nothing! read more

I wanted to give this place a chance, I really did, and tried to multiple times over. First things first- I'm not sure how or why they call this Mexican food. The flavors are incredibly bland. Taco Tuesdays are great deals, but I won't even go there any more for that. As you can see by their reviews, nothing there is consistent. Take out orders are incorrect every other visit. The environment is at least a decent attempt at keeping their theme, but it smells very strongly of cleaning products. And dare I have the audacity to kindly make a suggestion to their business... Although the waitstaff is very friendly, the owners have an attitude! It makes me so sad when small business owners are rude, let alone to their regulars!!! Several friends of mine in the area too have reported less than friendly service. Unfortunately I have no reason to go back. read more

We had an excellent experience here. From the fish bowl margaritas, pina colada was rated "ok," definitely go for the margs. Mussels blanco were , followed by the taco salad with chicken, and chicken fajitas. We had a few birthdays to celebrate that evening, and the wait staff accommodated perfectly. Our birthday desserts came with Fiesta shirts! If you have a celebratory event or want excellent food, it's a must go-to. read more

See all

Hard to find this spot unless you know about it. The place is very cute and festive on the inside. Have some specials weekly and drink deals. I ordered the enchiladas which was my first time having one and I was very happy with my choice. The portion was perfect for the price and the taste and all the sauces and flavors were excellent. I will definitely come back and get this dish again soon. Give this place a try! read more

I don't know what happened to this place but it's not the same, I used to always bring friends who were visiting to Fiesta for great food and drinks but it's become mediocre at best. read more

DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY!!! Food was terrible and super low quality. The best part was the chips. Super overpriced and not worth it. The queso was nasty melted goat cheese. You don't get beans and rice or any other toppings. Worst Mexican food I've ever had. Edit: (Next Day) Everyone that ate food there had a lot of stomach issues the next day. read more

1) they do not take out of state IDs which to be in the Catskills and people come visit is outrageous. 2) they waitress was rude from the start 3) food sucks 4)salsa water down 5) Mexican restaurant. No speaks Spanish read more

The quality of the food has declined since they first opened. The food is bland. I recently got take out and found out theyn had given us the wrong order. My wife called to speak with manager who was not there. She explained the situatuion to whomever answered the phone. She was calling not to get a comp, but to let them know about the order. Receiving a wrong order is not new to us, we've had it done before. There is a Mexican resturant in the south side. They will have our business from now on. read more

We had the most awful experience ever. The waitress was lacking the basic skills of being efficient. We had a large party. Our dinner service was 2 1/2 hours long. It took over an hour to have our order taken, the dinners came out wrong. No rice or beans, when we asked for things like ketchup or extra salsa, that took 10 minutes. We asked the bus boy for drink refills. Then came dessert. Again was wrong. We asked for the check. The 18% percent gratuity was $36.00 was not deserved or earned. Not going back. read more

The food was as good as the service. Waitress did not know how to serve you don't pass food across the table you bring it to the customer. Food lacked taste. Asked for more sour cream was charged $3.50 no salsa!! There are better Mexican restaurants close by. read more

The drinks were good but the food was terrible. Plus we went in with a big party and got rushed out after spending hundreds of dollars.

This place isn't terrible but it's nothing special. I've come here a few times with friends on weekdays and during Cinco de Mayo. They're packed on Cinco de Mayo and you'll definitely need a reservation. The "Margarita Monday" deal is what we go there for. The sangria is apparently made fresh there but it tasted horrible to me. In terms of food, I usually get the beef quesadilla which is meh. Food comes in big portions. Very greasy. From my experience, staff there have always been very friendly. They check IDs, no out of state drivers license IDs allowed. Bathrooms are pretty clean. I would recommend this place if you wanted to try something new or different than what else is available on main st. This place wouldn't be my first choice for food though. read more

Gross canned food taste, fish was GREY. The place looks miserable. I dont even understand how anyone can eat here. I took one bite and was done. Waitress didn't even ask what was wrong. read more

It was ass service was terrible and didn't know what half of the Menu was. Took me over 45 minutes to get my food. Do not recommend it's dog. read more

Salsa..gross Enchilads.. meh Taco.. so dry i spit out feathers Tequila.. delish. A very good selection and a good Cadillac margarita Chocolate cake.. microwaved read more

I'd say two and a half stars. On their best day? Maybe a three. It's a small little Mexican restaurant in a small little plaza. Very Mexican environment which is a plus but on the downside it does seem like they try very hard to do so. Has a decent sized bar though. Marble tables, a little fireplace, Mexican music and so on... Onto the food. Our server seemed absolutely less than enthused to serve us. They brought us a complimentary basket of tortilla chips with salsa. The salsa was quite watery. And spicy which is to be expected but watery was kind of saddening. The menu consisted of what you'd expect; tortillas, enchiladas, burritos, lots of items involving jalapeño, churros, etc. Nothing too special. I personally got the "Vera Cruz" enchilada with chicken. Comes with a red sauce, peppers, sour cream, cheese, chicken on a soft tortilla grilled. The inside contained the shredded chicken which seemed over-cooked, rice, and lots of spices! The top contained a boat load of melted cheese and well decorated with sour cream and olive oil as shown in the picture. The appearance of all out dishes was very appealing to the eye but the taste wasn't all that great. My fiancé got the "Three Amigos" tacos with a choice of soft or hard taco. Going with soft, the dish came with three tacos of fish, steak and chicken. They were complimented with lettuce, cheese, and the fish taco came with a spicy cabbage slaw and salsa verde. They were over stuffed with meat, over-cooked, and they weren't up to par on taste. Our friend got the "Adobe Enchilada" with chicken. Also plated very nicely, taste did not meet expectation. With a hot-and-cold inside, this dish is a one time eat and not to be reheated. It had guacamole and sour cream insides. The guacamole was stuffed with onions and ruined the taste. We also got some churros which seemed to be the highlight of our meal. Overall, I wouldn't go out of my way to come here again especially for the cost of our meal of three coming to $60! read more

Fiesta Mexican Grill & Cantina - Our lunch for the afternoon. Results pending. - Mexican Near Me - Oneonta, New York

Worst restaurant I've ever been to! We didn't get half our food, the bill was all mixed up, and the servers acted like we were in the wrong. The food had no flavor, the specials were not technically specials, and the food portions were completely not adequate for the price we paid. read more

Server was very nice, food is edible but not any where close to Mexican cuisine. The food wasn't seasoned, I've had better tasting food at Taco Bell. I order the medium rare burger, it was over cooked with no seasoning. Great spot for a restaurant & it's nice inside but wouldn't return sadly read more

Wonderful dinner. Super affordable. Ate at the bar and the bartender was extremely polite and had quick service. Two adult meals with drinks for 2 adults was less than an appetizer and a beer at nearby Cooperstown All Star Village. read more

I didn't have a margarita (maybe I should have), so I can't comment on that, however, the enchilada was probably the worst I've ever had! It was absolutely tasteless, except for the chicken, and that tasted very odd . The enchilada sauce tasted like a jar of Ragu was opened and poured over it. And, I'm not sure if there was even cheese on it ‍ - if there was , that was tasteless as well read more

Our server Eileen was so wonderful! The food was great, the drinks were awesome. Try the drunken sauce with whatever you order! I got a side of it with the Tacos De Camarón. So delicious! read more