This place has a fun and nice feeling atmosphere. They've got a lot of pizza choices and even gluten free options. Sometimes the crust is really burnt, but when it is, I just don't eat it. Always good service and a great place to meet up with friends and family to eat. read more

This place is just overpriced bs in my opinion. They don't offer any of taste or texture to justify the cost. I truly don't lime driving through alleys to get to a restaurant either. read more

One of our best meals on our trip! I'm not a huge pizza fan, but this was great! We had them made with cauliflower crust and you couldn't even tell. We also ordered the wings and they too were fantastic! Great service, great food! read more

Amarillo, this is a great place with great service. Stopped here while traveling. Pizza is awesome and sauce is just right. Salad was well done. Lasagna was a treat. large portion and great flavor. All takeout due to COVID. Friendly service and very helpful. Will repeat next trip. read more

The Wise Guy Pizza is so delicious!!! Homemade meatballs (sliced thin) with pepperoni and fresh garlic make this pizza my family's favorite! Great wine, craft beers, and creative desserts are a treat. Live music equals a nice atmosphere. Family friendly, date friendly, and single friendly. Locals frequent this locally-owned restaurant (entrance found behind the shopping strip) for a great dinner with friendly service. read more

Back alley location was a bit tricky to find, after dark. But, well worth it! Brick oven pizza with house-made sausage, a tasty Caesar salad, and house-made peppermint ice cream dessert. Great service and fresh brews on tap. We didn't try the wines but the extensive wine list is worth another visit. Truly a must try. read more

The pizza is fantastic. When we found that the restaurant is behind the mall (we should have read other reviews that mentioned this) we were greeted by the smoky smell of the brick oven. We also shared a panini sandwich that was very tasty. Since we were only passing through we won't be able to return but we really recommend this place. read more

Great customer service! Offered to bring the pizza out to my truck after offering me a complementary drink while I wait.

This is an excellent place for pizza! The mullet was fantastic, as was the Hot Mama. Delicious! Great atmosphere and ambiance. Definitely a must try for locals and for those traveling. Under new ownership, and is much better than the times we went before the restaurant changed hands. I forgot to take a photo for the review. read more

Had pizza and calzone delivered to the holiday inn it was cold and bland maybe better in restaurant but not for me

Can't say I even got to experience their food but the lack of service sent me elsewhere. I was going to try it for the first time, and let me first say that having to drive all the way around to the back of the shopping center is silly. How pretentious can you be? Then I finally find their entrance and sign, and park my car. The place looks closed up, from the outside. I almost hesitated there in the parking lot, and probably should have. I walked up to the door and surprisingly it was open. Then I walked in and assessed the place. Looked like it had a nice atmosphere, and at first glance was eager to try their food. No one was there at the host area and I was not greeted by anyone. I waited for several more minutes. No one passed by the front area or made any effort to greet me or seat me. Continued to wait, for over 5 minutes. I think at some point a staff member looked toward me but made no effort to engage me or apologize or anything. I had brought my appetite and had no desire to continue to wait. So I turned around, walked out, and found somewhere else to get my meal. read more

Best pizza in Amarillo! The meatball pizza was amazing, get it with fresh garlic. Save room for the smores calzone. Great draft beer and wine selection. Family owned and well run. Can't beat this wood-fired brick oven pizza, wish there was a Fireslice in Dallas! read more

Fire Slice Pizzeria - Smores Calzone! - Pizza Near Me - Amarillo, Texas

Best brick oven pizza I've eaten since I lived in Italy. Thin crust slightly charred by super heat in that oven adds special flavor that cannot be replicated any other way. Toppings are sparse, as are done in Italy and fresh. If you want greasy thick crust heavy pizza, this is NOT your place. Staff is friendly and knowledgeable. Only con is the location...hard to find. read more

There are very few restaurants that are quaint, quiet, cozy and kid friendly. The perfect place for a family dinner where you can talk and connect over amazing food. Brick oven pizza is the best in town here. Our kids love the mullet! Sweet potato fries are a must and a great wine list! Live music was amazing as well and just added to the ambiance. This is our families fav pizza place and where we go to unwind, talk and relax. Staff is top notch and always makes you feel like family. Best hidden secret in Amarillo! read more

First time here visiting family and we were craving pizza and wanted someplace new. The pizza here is the best. We had chicken Florentine and it was very good. We had the Johnny amigo and that was sooo good. Little spicy kick but not hot, and who thought cilantro on a pizza? Thumbs up!!! Did I forget to mention wine is 1/2 off on Wednesday? Sweet! read more

Pizza and environment is awesome! The crust is amazing and you can tell it's hand made there! BRICK OVEN.... Is there another way! Nope! Great wine selection! The calzones appeared the same! Hand made even though I didn't get to try! Great place! Thought the price of the pizza was a little high but when I ate it! It was worth the few extra bucks! It's a hidden gem! Somewhat hard to find if you don't know exactly where it is, but all good after that! read more

I have to say this because it is true, and people should know about this. I have eaten a lot of pizza, and it seems normal to throw away the "pizza bones" But you cannot stop eating the crust! There is nothing else like it in Amarillo. They developed it and it is hand mixed in the store. I got this from one of the staff while I was sitting at the bar. They take a lot of pride in their craft. And they have very creative pizzas. read more

What else can you say but WOW. EXCELLENT server Tristan!!! Cold beer hot pizza. Homemade salad dressings and the craziest choices of toppings on their pizzas. We had a calzone, cheese burger with green chili pizza and a margarita pizza. And dessert of course was berry pound cake and bread pudding. read more

Stopped on our way through town and so glad we did! It's hard to find (down the back side of a strip mall) but worth the search. Everything we had was hot and fresh, arancinis were so yummy and the garlic wings were cooked to perfection. Authentic Caesar dressing, and the pizza dough was the perfect bite of a little crunch and a little chew. I know I'll be craving those wings in a couple weeks! read more

Ordered a grilled chicken salad and a pizza after a long drive to Amarillo. Not many places open that would deliver to the hotel. But they were still open so gave it a whirl. The pizza was great and the salad was better than I expected. The greens were actually fresh. Didn't seem to be from a bag. And the chicken had some extra flavor of awesomeness. The delivery guy had a smile and a little extra spring in his step. Just all around nice experience after a long day of travel. read more

Fucking phenomenal place! I loved the pizza and there was an interesting twist. A s'mores calzone! It wasn't that good, but I give them four stars for the effort. By the way, it was a relatively quick delivery time. Good on this business for thinking outside of the paradigm! read more

Worth the find! Yelp directions locates it next to McDonalds, it's actually north of the strip mall in the alley. Great pizza and service!!

Excellent food, we had pizza ravioli and lasagna. Portions were just right and flavors were on point. Fast delivery too!

So good. Friendly staff and amazing food. Honey bomb pizza was my favorite. Eat here if you haven't

I like the pizza... but I need to talk about the wings. They have wings, and they don't make a big deal about it... just hidden down there on the menu... but they are there... and let me tell you... they are the best wings in town. Being a wing lover, we were disappointed in Amarillo's lack of a decent wing place... until we found these by chance coming here for pizza. Yes, we like the pizza, but we come here for the wings. YUM! Love the atmosphere and service too. You can tell they love their customers. read more

We absolutely love going to Fire Slice. They have great beer, including True Blonde, my favorite. The pizza is great and we love the dessert calzone! Everything is really good and the staff is so personable and friendly! read more

I am a masochist. For those of you unfamiliar with the term, it is someone who gets their jollies from their own pain or humiliation. In my case it is the humiliation aspect. I used to pay hundreds of dollars to a dominatrix to yell at me and tell me how I am worthless and the scum of the earth. Sadly it got to expensive and I had to stop going to her. Luckily I found Fire Slice Pizza. I can go in and be ignored for what seems like hours. I can also order food and when the wrong food is brought to the table I can have the staff berate me and tell me how wrong I am. If I am really looking for some punishment I will send my flat beer from the bottom of the keg back and ask for one that is fresh and have the waitress lose her shit on me and tell me that it isn't a flat, stale beer. The best part is when you send the wrong food back and your waitress goes and gets the owner to come and yell at you. I do feel sorry for those who don't share my joy of humiliation and degradation because I imagine for them this place must suck balls. read more

We weren't disappointed! Was hard to find, but was awesome! Would definitely eat here again.

Was traveling through town for the night and found this place on yelp. Could not have been more impressed! The pizza was oh so yummy, and they had a great selection of beer and wine too! The service was very friendly. Too bad I live so far away. If I was in town I'd be here at least once a week! read more

We were passing through town and stopped in for a quick lunch based on the recommendations on Yelp. It was a bit difficult to find as the entrance is on the back side of a large shopping center but so glad we did! Staff was so friendly and we even got to speak to the owner for a bit. Had a Greek salad which was delicious! We couldn't decide between a wise guy or primavera pizza, our waitress suggested we do half and half. So darn good! Amazing pizza and great people. Highly recommend. read more

This place is incredible. Upon walking in we found the atmosphere very inviting. It was very busy but the wait was not long at all. Looking at the drink menu first you will imediately notice the beer selection is awesome! Great beers on tap and extensive bottle collection. Looking at the wine menu the prices were very affordable and a good list. Ok now let's get to the part that is making my mouth water as I type, the pizza. We ordered "the Rudy" and when it hit the table it was almost too hot to touch. I couldn't wait to dig in so my fingers are a little tender today. The pizza was insane! The mushrooms had the most incredible flavor, way different than you get from a chain like pizza hut. That pizza was gone and the other one we ordered had time to cool a little so my fingers were relieved. The pepperoni and bacon pizza was perfect. Tons of cheese and don't even get me started on the crust (it will make this review ten pages long). I wish we had saved room for the smore calzone, sounds damn good! Bottom line is this is the best pizza place I have ever been to. I wish there was one in Austin. I guess I have to make more trips up here! read more

Delicious salad. Everything else (we tried the lasagna and hula pizza) was totally unremarkable. Very bland.

Best pizza in town! Great food, service and atmosphere. Love the jazz nights!

I had read all of the great reviews and was looking forward to an exceptional pizza. This wasn't it. In all fairness, we probably should have ordered something more adventurous than the Fire Slice Combo. It was just. ... okay. Expensive for the amount of ingredients and underwhelming in flavor. The bill after Groupon was $7. Gave the waiter a $20 and he asked if I needed change. Yes please! The service didn't warrant a $13 tip. It was worth a try, but we won't be back. read more

Great pizza and friendly service !! Only bad thing is trying to find it. Gps try's to park you on a residential street. It is in the back of a strip mall behind all the shops near the loading docks. But once you find it you will be happy . Would have been 5 stars if it did take so long to fined. read more

Outstanding service! Yelp entered my order wrong and the girl at the store thought it looked odd and called us to verify the order. The pizza was outstanding and delicious. read more

OMG!!! Passing thru Amarillo from Colorado to College Station. Looked on Yelp and Fire Slice had a 4 1/2 star rating so we thought we'd try something other than Pizza Hut. SO GLAD WE DID!! Best pizza I've ever had. Highly recommend the Goodfellow, lots of meat and so good. Also had a Caesar salad which was awesome. Hard to find...behind a shopping center in the alley but well worth it!! Don't pass this place up. read more

Best pizza in Amarillo. Love the crust. Salad is a little expensive. But I just love the pizza!

Awesome! I work around the corner and phoned in a lunch calzone.... It was nothing short of amazing! Will be back!

One of the few restaurants that made Amarillo livable when I was there. Great food, great decor, good music. Thank you for helping me not go insane in a small city Fire Slice. read more